How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
In addition to that work, the miner's machine is also applied to the task of working out the cryptography necessary to secure some Bitcoin transactions. The processing of monetary transactions is the community service that miners are expected to provide in exchange for the privilege of creating new bitcoins for themselves. "Miners" perform the crypto necessary to secure transactions that they're not a party to, avoid the conflict of interest of allowing that work to be performed by either party of the transaction.

Alright, I understand this. What I was getting at is how energy/performance intensive this secure transaction is? In 2008, Finland had a population of 5.3 million, and roughly two million credit card transactions daily (the per capita ratio is probably higher in USA). If bitcoin is to be thought as an alternative for national currencies, could it handle these transaction rates, and at what cost? Has this been calculated somewhere on the net?
 
Alright, I understand this. What I was getting at is how energy/performance intensive this secure transaction is? In 2008, Finland had a population of 5.3 million, and roughly two million credit card transactions daily (the per capita ratio is probably higher in USA). If bitcoin is to be thought as an alternative for national currencies, could it handle these transaction rates, and at what cost? Has this been calculated somewhere on the net?


That's an excellent question, that raises some other very important questions.

Considering the following questions might shed even more light on the bigger question of whether Bitcoin was truly engineered to function as a useful currency, or to simply masquerade as one while actually serving as an easily-monopolized bubble economy...

If the plan is for this thing to grow into a useful currency that supports a flourishing economy, then the securing of the transactions ought to be the top priority, correct?

In the Bitcoin model, the main purpose of rewarding "mining" with profits is to provide an incentive for users to voluntarily accept the computational burden of securing the transactions.

In a best-case scenario, Bitcoin's popularity grows, and many millions (or tens, or hundreds of millions) of users start adopting Bitcoin as a currency. With each user making multiple transactions per day, the transaction load will increase exponentially. So in that scenario, one would expect the system to provide greater and greater incentives for more miners to come online and handle the task of processing transactions, right?

But that's not how it works at all. In fact, it works the exact opposite way. Instead of lowering the "mining difficulty factor" to adjust for increased workload, and to balance the competition among the influx of new miners coming online, the Bitcoin system inexplicably ramps up the difficulty over time. As time goes on and the thing grows in popularity, while it ought to be making transaction processing easier and easier for miners, it instead burdens the individuals processing transactions with this useless, ever increasing resource drain of solving arbitrary, excessively difficult mathematical problems of no real benefit to the system.

So while the Bitcoin economy should be growing its infrastructure, it instead removes incentives to participate in the infrastructure, and wastes exponentially more and more computational resources of the remaining miners that would be better applied toward processing monetary transactions.

Wouldn't it make more sense to provide greater incentives for mining as more and more people start trading Bitcoin as a currency? One would certainly think so, if the genuine intention of the creators was to provide a useful currency. Instead, it makes "mining" less and less profitable over time, thus disincentivizing the all-important work of transaction processing when it should be rewarding it.

It's basically engineered to doom itself to failure as a useful currency, by taxing the miners out of existence.

So if the processing of transactions is so unimportant that it can just be pissed away in favor of ever-increasing "mining difficulty", then what's the purpose of "mining difficulty" in the first place?

Obviously, the mining difficulty factor exists for the sole purpose of engineering scarcity, thereby artificially inflating the value of this intrinsically valueless product that doesn't even serve the ostensible purpose for which it was created. Calling Bitcoin a "currency" appears to be a false pretense merely intended to lure investors to it in the first place.

That's why I say it appears to be engineered to operate as an investment bubble, and to be easily manipulated by the anonymous creators and early adopters who awarded themselves controlling shares right from the outset. An ingenious scam. Can you think of any better reason for it to have been set up to function in this way?
 
Last edited:
Ugh. When I first read about BTC in the OP of this very thread, my first thought was "ponzi scheme," but the more I read about it, the more insane it sounds. Couldn't they use computer processing to actually, you know, do something ?
You have probably been sucked in by the emotive language surrounding bitcoin. The bitcoin trade is no more a ponzi or pyramid scheme than the trade in a commodity like gold or silver or anything else that has "artificial scarcity". This is just a claim made by those who are jealous that somebody could get rich by introducing a new commodity. It's simply a case of buy at one price and sell at another. If you pick the price movement right, you make a profit.

The "mining" algorithm might not be all that satisfactory but ATM the only alternatives involve people deciding who gets the new bitcoins. Although bitcoins can be stolen by hackers, the algorithm hasn't been cracked so, with a few sensible precautions (like not storing your bitcoin wallet on any medium that can be accessed via the internet), it is a reasonably safe medium.

Of course, there are a number of limitations with bitcoin:
  • Few retailers accept bitcoins as payment so bitcoin has little value except for speculative purposes.
  • 1% of bitcoin holders hold 50% of bitcoins so bitcoin is susceptible to cartel like behaviour.
  • If your bitcoin wallet is stolen or a bitcoin exchange does the dirty on you then you have little legal recourse.
OTOH bitcoin has a big advantage over physical commodities: Since gold and silver can only be moved around physically, most people deal with the digital form (IOUs designated in gold or silver). Such IOUs can be rendered worthless even though the physical commodity they represent still has value. Since bitcoins are already virtual, there is no value in having a bitcoin designated IOU.
 
You have probably been sucked in by the emotive language surrounding bitcoin. The bitcoin trade is no more a ponzi or pyramid scheme than the trade in a commodity like gold or silver or anything else that has "artificial scarcity".

Uh? How is the scarcity of gold or silver "artificial"?

This is just a claim made by those who are jealous that somebody could get rich by introducing a new commodity. It's simply a case of buy at one price and sell at another. If you pick the price movement right, you make a profit.

Much as you could make a profit on tulip bulbs or dot-com stocks. That you can make money at something doesn't mean that it's not a speculative bubble: every speculative bubble has someone who makes a profit.
 
Uh? How is the scarcity of gold or silver "artificial"?
"Artificial scarcity" is a term invented by bitcoin opponents in a desperate bid to make bitcoin appear somehow crooked. Of course, this is just "double think" since the value of any commodity is related to its scarcity.

Much as you could make a profit on tulip bulbs or dot-com stocks. That you can make money at something doesn't mean that it's not a speculative bubble: every speculative bubble has someone who makes a profit.
Whether bitcoin is in a bubble or not remains to be seen but you invest in it at your own risk.
 
You have probably been sucked in by the emotive language surrounding bitcoin.

No. Try again.

The bitcoin trade is no more a ponzi or pyramid scheme than the trade in a commodity like gold or silver or anything else that has "artificial scarcity".

I'm having trouble believing you made this post while being unaware of what's been explained about bitcoins here. Or did you forget that other commodities don't reward those who implement the system in the first place, at the detriment of later adherents ?

This is just a claim made by those who are jealous that somebody could get rich by introducing a new commodity.

This is an appeal to emotion, and it's a pretty ridiculous one, considering how many people lost money because the bitcoin system is broken. It's also interesting to see that you think I am jealous of people who make money by conning others. Do you have an actual argument to make ?

It's simply a case of buy at one price and sell at another. If you pick the price movement right, you make a profit.

Except that, AGAIN as has been mentionned, there is no security whatsoever against theft of bugs. The mining algorithm is also very suspect.

Of course, there are a number of limitations with bitcoin:
  • Few retailers accept bitcoins as payment so bitcoin has little value except for speculative purposes.
  • 1% of bitcoin holders hold 50% of bitcoins so bitcoin is susceptible to cartel like behaviour.
  • If your bitcoin wallet is stolen or a bitcoin exchange does the dirty on you then you have little legal recourse.

Limitations ? I'd say those disadvantages are crippling. It's enough that almost no one would ever want to use them, so if those who propose bitcoin as a currency wish it to become appealing, they should absolutely solve those problems.

OTOH bitcoin has a big advantage over physical commodities: Since gold and silver can only be moved around physically, most people deal with the digital form (IOUs designated in gold or silver). Such IOUs can be rendered worthless even though the physical commodity they represent still has value. Since bitcoins are already virtual, there is no value in having a bitcoin designated IOU.

Wait, you think that the fact it has _no_ real-world equivalent to set its value is an advantage over commodities that do ?
 
"Artificial scarcity" is a term invented by bitcoin opponents in a desperate bid to make bitcoin appear somehow crooked. Of course, this is just "double think" since the value of any commodity is related to its scarcity.

You missed a spot, there. It's not the scarcity that's the problem, it's the algorithm that screws people over by modifying the scarcity contnuously.
 
It's also interesting to see that you think I am jealous of people who make money by conning others.
Calling bitcoin a "con job" is no different to calling it "The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man".

The facts don't lead to either conclusion.
 
it's the algorithm that screws people over by modifying the scarcity contnuously.
HOW AWFUL! That sounds like a major disaster and by using the word "screw" that proves that bitcoin is only used by criminals.

Of course if you word it as "limited amounts of bitcoins can be mined each year" it becomes a non-event.
 
Again the "jealousy" argument comes out... why do you feel we're so selectively jealous of bitcoin founders in particular, as opposed to anyone else that's in a position to make a lot of money?
 
Calling bitcoin a "con job" is no different to calling it "The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man".

The facts don't lead to either conclusion.

Have you been even reading this thread ?

HOW AWFUL! That sounds like a major disaster and by using the word "screw" that proves that bitcoin is only used by criminals.

Ah, I see your problem. You are confusing "proof" with "conclusion".

Of course if you word it as "limited amounts of bitcoins can be mined each year" it becomes a non-event.

No it doesn't. It changes nothing of the algorithm and how it punishes latecomers at the benefit of early adopters. Or do you deny that it does ?
 
. . .it punishes latecomers at the benefit of early adopters. . . .
Translation: "latecomers don't stand to make as much profit as early adopters".

BTW limited amounts of bitcoins are released each year. Saying that it is the result of this insidious algorithm adds nothing but spin.
 
Again the "jealousy" argument comes out... why do you feel we're so selectively jealous of bitcoin founders in particular, as opposed to anyone else that's in a position to make a lot of money?
I don't know if there is a motivation other than jealousy but it certainly is a big issue for some of the posters here. Just look at the noise that they constantly make about the founders/early adopters.

The other thing that makes me skeptical is that the amount of protesting about bitcoin is approaching Shakespearean levels. If you look only at the objective data, you are not going to get anything much worse than post #1083. You might well conclude that only a fool would consider bitcoin a safe investment and that is a valid inference that could be drawn from the data.

However, when we start reading about evil faceless people plotting to rip off the internet community through some fanciful scam? When limited supply becomes part of the plot to "punish latecomers"? Really?? Just add a few "NWO"s to the mix and you have a ready made post for the CT section.
 
Translation: "latecomers don't stand to make as much profit as early adopters".

"Translation" ? That's EXACTLY what I've been saying all along. Are you denying that it's a problem ? In fact, you haven't answered my previous question. You DO have arguments, right ?

BTW limited amounts of bitcoins are released each year. Saying that it is the result of this insidious algorithm adds nothing but spin.

Again you show your confusion, because I never said that.

Releasing new bitcoins insures that _some_ people will foolishly invest in the system, although they stand no chance of making a profit.
 
I don't know if there is a motivation other than jealousy but it certainly is a big issue for some of the posters here.

That is just your opinion. You have no way of knowing except an inflated trust in your own musings.

Just look at the noise that they constantly make about the founders/early adopters.

The mere fact that the system is constructed to reward them at the expense of others should raise a red flag for you. That it doesn't basically sets you up as just another victim.

Assuming it's a scam, and not just a horribly-designed system that just happens to work like a scam.
 
Last edited:
Why should that be a problem?

Well as someone who thinks everybody should be encouraged and able to have at least a shot at being successful, a system that makes you unable to be successful unless you're the one who made the system is decidedly unfair. Isn't that a problem ?
 
I don't know if there is a motivation other than jealousy but it certainly is a big issue for some of the posters here. Just look at the noise that they constantly make about the founders/early adopters.

The other thing that makes me skeptical is that the amount of protesting about bitcoin is approaching Shakespearean levels. If you look only at the objective data, you are not going to get anything much worse than post #1083. You might well conclude that only a fool would consider bitcoin a safe investment and that is a valid inference that could be drawn from the data.

However, when we start reading about evil faceless people plotting to rip off the internet community through some fanciful scam? When limited supply becomes part of the plot to "punish latecomers"? Really?? Just add a few "NWO"s to the mix and you have a ready made post for the CT section.

Except for the parts about needing a vast conspiracy and being able to control the world, yeah, it's just like that.

You conclude jealousy, but it flies in the face of reality... few here show any evidence of being generally jealous of wealth derived from ingenuity... so if your conclusion is false, you must examine your premises.
 
"Artificial scarcity" is a term invented by bitcoin opponents


"Artificial scarcity" is a genuine term of art in the field of economics. It was not invented by Bitcoin opponents.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_scarcity

It is a valid term that accurately describes how the Bitcoin "mining difficulty" algorithm operates. There's no good reason for them to have designed it that way, except to artificially inflate the impression of value among investors.


Calling bitcoin a "con job" is no different to calling it "The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man".

The facts don't lead to either conclusion.


The facts most certainly do lead to the conclusion that it's a scam, especially all the people who've already been scammed through their involvement with it.

I have pointed that out exhaustively. Yet you still continue to argue that I'm wrong without proving the lie to any of the facts I've shown, or logically refuting any of my reasoning. Your entire position has been one big argument by assertion.



Translation: "latecomers don't stand to make as much profit as early adopters".

BTW limited amounts of bitcoins are released each year. Saying that it is the result of this insidious algorithm adds nothing but spin.


You're obviously not looking at this thing objectively or critically.

The algorithm that reduces availability over time is contrary to Bitcoin's alleged purpose of being a currency. That increasing restriction on availability and regressive hindrance of transaction processing resources is contrary to Bitcoin reaching its potential as a widespread, general-purpose medium of exchange.

I'd say that major feature of its engineering is pretty convincing evidence that Bitcoin was never really intended to function effectively as a currency. Its function as a currency is apparently secondary to its purpose as an ideology for financially ignorant ideologues to invest real money in, from which the creators can directly benefit.

Therefore, its use as a currency is just a pretense to garner interest from misguided investors. Its actual purpose is evident by the fact that it's engineered to artificially restrict availability to investors, in order to artificially inflate the price. It's a valueless thing being promoted on a false pretense, which "speculators" are paying money into for the benefit of its creators, who paid nothing.

Given all that, one would have to be a fool not to see that Bitcoin has been engineered as a fraudulent enterprise.


I don't know if there is a motivation other than jealousy but it certainly is a big issue for some of the posters here. Just look at the noise that they constantly make about the founders/early adopters.


"Jealousy" is not the issue.

The problem people have with the "founders/early adopters" of Bitcoin is that they've deliberately set up a false micro-economy entirely under their own control, whereby they are positioned to profit solely from the investment of others. In other words, they're the perpetrators and beneficiaries of a scam.


The other thing that makes me skeptical is that the amount of protesting about bitcoin is approaching Shakespearean levels.


"Shakespearean levels"?!?


If you look only at the objective data, you are not going to get anything much worse than post #1083. You might well conclude that only a fool would consider bitcoin a safe investment and that is a valid inference that could be drawn from the data.


Further "valid inferences" can be made about the purpose of the system by looking at how it has been designed to function.


However, when we start reading about evil faceless people plotting to rip off the internet community through some fanciful scam?


What do you suppose is the reason why "Satoshi" chooses to remain a "faceless" person/entity?

When you see an investment scheme whose primary purpose is obviously engineered to create an opportunity for its creators to profit entirely at the expense of others, why is it wrong to call that a scam?


When limited supply becomes part of the plot to "punish latecomers"? Really??


"Limited supply" of a nonexistent, imaginary thing created solely for the purpose of artificially inflating its value to attract investors so its creators can financially profit from the hype?

That's the definition of a scam.


Just add a few "NWO"s to the mix and you have a ready made post for the CT section.


But we haven't added any "NWO's," have we?

Nobody's alleging Bitcoin is a huge government plot to fleece the Internet.

I'm not saying it's necessarily any more than a handful of people who initially collaborated on this thing. Scams are nothing new, and are well known to propagate across the Internet. If you really examine the way this thing operates with a critical eye, it's apparent that it's ill-suited to function as a currency (as it purports to be), but in fact exhibits the mechanics of a certain class of financial scams.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom