John Albert
Illuminator
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2010
- Messages
- 3,425
There never was any pretense of intrinsic value.
I never said there was.
The value of bitcoin is derived from a combination of their voluntary acceptance, and cryptographically limited scarcity.
The value derives from a lot of people paying their real, hard-earned money into the Bitcoin market and there not being quite enough bitcoins in existence to meet the demand due to engineered scarcity. Most of these people appear to be foolishly trying to make a fast buck by play-trading in this essentially worthless, fake commodity.
Bitcoins have no intrinsic value whatsoever, because bitcoins have no substance and are backed by no substance. They are nothing more than line items in a digital ledger. If something untoward happens and your bitcoin wallet gets erased or an exchange gets hacked, they just vanish into nothingness, because they never really existed in the first place except as an imaginary fiction.
In addition, if this is the standard for a "pyramid" scheme, then the US dollar itself is the biggest pyramid scheme of all time.
I knew this discussion was going to veer back into "currency-crank" territory again sooner or later.
Yet again, you demonstrate a woeful misunderstanding of basic economics. The US dollar is not a "pyramid scheme."
The US dollar is a national currency, backed by the strength of the US economy, by US laws, by the full faith and credit of the US government, by all the gold in Fort Knox, all the real estate and material assets of the US government, by the force of the police agencies, the US Treasury Department, the FBI, and the US Armed Forces if need be.
Moreover, it has value because it has a history of consistent and reliable functioning in the purpose for which it was created:
- It is universally accepted
- Its acceptance is guaranteed by law
- Its value is stabilized through a system of active management in response to changes in economic conditions
- It is universally fungible
- There is a robust and reliable infrastructure (The US banking system) that supports its use
- The US banking system is regulated by Federal laws to prevent fraud and theft
- The US banking system is ensured by the US government against financial losses by private and commercial holders of US dollars
- There are laws protecting consumers and merchants in case of theft and fraud, and a system of courts to offer recourse for recovery of lost money due to crime or civil disputes
Bitcoin offers none of these features that add value to the US Dollar.
- It is not universally accepted. Only a handful of small-time merchants actually conduct business in Bitcoin.
- Its acceptance is not guaranteed by any law
- Exchanging even relatively minor amounts of BTC into other currencies has a tendency to throw the Bitcoin economy into as tail-spin, which negatively affects its fungibility
- Bitcoin has no reliable infrastructure for exchanging or storing funds. Users are left to their own devices or the mercy of the extremely sketchy and unreliable exchanges which regularly fail
- Its value is not stabilized in any way. Instead of stability, the system has been expressly set up to reward the earliest adopters at the direct financial expense of the latecomers, not unlike a pyramid scheme
- Bitcoin exchanges are not regulated in any way to ensure they don't swindle or steal consumers' money
- Bitcoin offers no protection or surety whatsoever in case an exchange goes under financial losses
- There are no laws protecting consumers in case of theft and fraud, no laws to bring Bitcoin thieves to justice, and no recourse to recover lost funds due to crime or civil disputes
- The scheme is hyped as a "revolutionary new system," with promises of financial independence in exchange for little or no actual work.
This is a bogus claim, a complete lie.
No, it is not.
Bitcoin is widely promoted as an investment opportunity.
There's also a huge community of bitcoin "miners" who try to attract investors to their "miner's pools" with promises of free money.
1. Bitcoin is a technologically sound project.
Not sure of your definition of "technologically sound," but I certainly would not characterize it as such.
Call me crazy, but it's my opinion that any software designed specifically to consume resources, maxing out the entire processing capability of the host hardware 24 hours per day, 7 days a week in exchange for diminishing returns is an poorly-designed, abusive piece of crapware.
The Bitcoin exchanges seem to have some serious problems with information security, and I would say that makes them significantly "unsound" also.
2. Bitcoin is unstoppable without end-user prosecution.
So is child pornography, human trafficking, and all kinds of other horrible things including investment scams. What's your point?
3. Bitcoin is the most dangerous open-source project ever created.
Wait, are you trying to defend Bitcoin, or defame it?
Dangerous? This is a selling point?
I have to agree that it's extremely dangerous to the financial well-being of anyone foolish enough to get mixed up in it by this point.
Just the fact that it operates extra-legally should be a huge red flag to anyone seriously considering sinking money into it.
4. Bitcoin may be the most dangerous technological project since the internet itself.
Do you realize you're starting to sound like a real kook with this kind of talk?
It's certainly dangerous to anyone who invests their own hard-earned money into it. I'll agree with you on that.
See my last 20 or so posts for a rundown of all the ways in which it harbors and perpetuates a variety of financial scams.
5. Bitcoin is a political statement by technotarians (technological libertarians).*
I'm not sure I know exactly what that means, but I can tell you that it's also designed to operate as a scam.
So what happens when the Bitcoin exchange gets "hacked" and a lot of people lose a lot of money but no investigation follows and nobody ever gets caught? I guess those poor suckers are just S.O.L. and "the market will correct itself." In other words, the lost coins just vanish from existence and the remaining BTC holders just become that much richer. How convenient for them!
Anyone would be a fool to get mixed up with this Bitcoin nonsense.
6. Bitcoins will change the world unless governments ban them with harsh penalties.
Bitcoin has already wiped out quite a few life savings, so I suppose it could be argued that it already has "changed the world" from somebody's point of view.
The demand for bitcoins exists because there is a demand to transfer value over the internet quickly and anonymously, using a unit which cannot be arbitrarily devalued.
If there's such a demand, then how come only a handful of small-time merchants accept Bitcoin as payment?
How come it's mostly gambling, porn, amateur webdesign, illicit drug dealerships, kiddie-porn outlets, hippy-dippy macrame, and vintage videogame consoles being sold for bitcoins?
Why doesn't the grocery store accept it? They accept my PayPal card and even Green Dot MoneyPaks, so why not Bitcoin?
It certainly does not appear that there's any particular need for a "decentralized cryptocurrency." Where's the demand, outside of illegal businesses and tax evasion? If there's such a demand, then why will no major retailers anywhere in the world even deign to touch it?
I believe the demand for bitcoins exists because a lot of people are speculating in the market, using Bitcoin as a trading commodity as opposed to a medium of exchange.
The vast majority of people using bitcoin, use it for those reasons.
Do you have any evidence to back up that assertion? Because looking at the charts, the trading volume of Mt. Gox alone seems to account for a significant percentage of all BTC transactions wordwide. That to me says that people are primarily using it to play investment games, not to pay for stuff.
In fact, as I've said before, out of all the Bitcoin promoters I've spoken to on the Internet (and that's a lot), not a single one of them has admitted to using Bitcoin to purchase goods and services on a regular basis.
I would venture to speculate that your economic ignorance on display here trumps virtually all bitcoin users, in spades.
You "venture to speculate" on my degree of understanding of basic economics? That's amusing. You haven't even bothered to refute anything I've said from an economics perspective.
The only reason you don't believe what I'm saying is because you don't like being told that Bitcoin is not a magical golden bullet that will destroy evil gubmints.
There is no "system".
Bitcoin is a system just as much any other computer program is a system, just as the US Federal Reserve System is a system, just like even the Internet itself is a system. It has been conceived, designed, and implemented for a purpose.
Like any system, examining its operational qualities reveals details about its function.
By examining the way Bitcoin operates, it's clear that it was set up to award its originators controlling shares of a virtual economy that would eventually attract an influx of real dollars, which could then be tapped for their own financial gain. Smart, savvy people don't go to all the trouble of creating this kind of thing on accident. Just by examining how it operates, any intelligent person with a passing knowledge of economics and a basic familiarity with the history of confidence games and investment scams will recognize that this thing was obviously created for the primary purpose of enriching its creators at the expense of investors.
Bitcoin is a de-centralized crypto-currency.
So I've heard.
You keep calling it a currency, but I can't help noticing that it fails to behave as a proper currency in any useful regard. In fact, it's far less stable, reliable or secure than any conventional currency in the industrialized world.
Maybe that's because its usefulness as a currency was not the primary concern of its creators?
The originators had and have to mine bitcoin just like everyone else, or exchange something else of value for it.
Yeah, see you're trying to make it out like they had to do actual work for their bitcoins. But anyone who understands how Bitcoin operates could see how disingenuous that argument really is.
All they had to do was "mine" for it, right at the beginning when it was first created, when the "difficulty" was low and there was little competition because hardly anybody had even heard of it. All they had to do was run a background process on their computers for a few hours a day and they could rack up millions of BTC in just a few months.
The Bitcoin blockchain was started on January 3, 2009, about a week before the first beta version had even been posted to Sourceforge and announced on the cryptography mailing list at metzdowd.com on January 9, 2009.
In that announcement, the titular Bitcoin "creator" (an anonymous person or persons using the handle "Satoshi") wrote:
I made the proof-of-work difficulty ridiculously easy to start with, so for a little while in the beginning a typical PC will be able to generate coins in just a few hours. It'll get a lot harder when competition makes the automatic adjustment drive up the difficulty.
So at that time only a handful of people even knew about Bitcoin, and the BTC had absolutely no monetary value. But with such a small pool of miners and the difficulty set to "ridiculously easy," those initial adopters were able to "mine" themselves huge, worthless "fortunes" of BTC in very short time.
Later, as the project gained steam through word of mouth (and later, promotion through professional marketing) more miners came online and the difficulty of mining BTC increased sharply, making new coins harder to come by. Concurrently, people started actually paying real money into the system in exchange for bitcoins, and it was than that the system actually started to have real monetary value. But by then, the originators and their friends on the cryptography mailing list already possessed the vast majority of bitcoins in existence.
In other words, a large percentage of the value of every dollar paid into the market became theirs by default, and they can cash in on that equity whenever they want. Even more important is the degree of control they're able to wield over the market. Simply by dumping a large number of BTC from their hoard, they can cause an immediate crash and then immediately buy back in at a lower rate, making money and even strengthening their position in the market.
There is no redistribution.
Yes, Bitcoin does indeed redistribute monetary value. If you don't understand how that works, I'd be happy to explain it to you using really easy-to-understand metaphors and everything.
Last edited: