How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
A wild guess on my part here, but perhaps in order to exchange them?
Wrong.

Bitcoins are a peerless mechanism. You don't need an exchange or any other intermediary in order to exchange them. They can be transferred directly from wallet to wallet.
 
Wrong.

Bitcoins are a peerless mechanism. You don't need an exchange or any other intermediary in order to exchange them. They can be transferred directly from wallet to wallet.

Exchange, as against US dollars. Not transfer.
 
I have never used bitcoins, never been curious enough to find out about them, and haven't even read more than a couple dozen posts in this thread. I don't understand what they are or how they work. But.

I was in a chat the other day, and someone dropped by who claimed to be "mining" bitcoins. Apparently this involves decrypting something or other, similar to the way those LinkedIn password hashes were decrypted. I don't know how the miner makes money.

The reason I bring it up here is because he said it will only be profitable for another month or so. Some kind of new technology is going to be introduced which will either mean the end of bitcoins or the end of his ability to mine them.

Yes, I know, this is all incredibly vague and unhelpful. Someone who is as ignorant as I am on the subject should probably not be attempting to add anything to the conversation, because I don't understand what I heard, I'm unclear on the details, etc.

But what the hell, I thought I'd toss it out there anyway, so sue me. For ALL the bitcoins.

ETA: Did a little research. Looks like bitcoin mining is not decrypting, it's actually generating new bitcoins. The "one or two months" is because of a change in how much bitcoin blocks will be worth. Read more here.
 
Last edited:
Any scarcity of bitcoins is artificial. The market perks along, rising slowly until one of the early adopters decides to cash out and dumps some huge number of bitcoins on the market. A system as easily manipulated as that isn't a system I'm going to be putting any money into, thank you very much.
In what you're describing, the surplus would be artificial, not the scarcity.
 
Gold tends to be so valuable because it is a physical element with historical, cultural, religious and aesthetic significance.
Why is it more valuable than other elements that have these things? Why did it become valuable before it had historical and cultural significance? Why is it used as money far more than, say, diamonds?

This argument is a red herring though. As I pointed out in my last post, bitcoins are not gold. It's a comparison that Bitcoin boosters keep repeating, but it's completely inapt.
No it isn't.

Gold is a real commodity with physical substance with universal demand and a wide variety of uses, whereas Bitcoins are not.
Why does gold have universal demand in the first place? Oil and diamonds are far more useful in the modern world. But we don't trade in vials of oil. Why?

You may have "answered" my claims, but you certainly have not countered them with any real facts or evidence.
Your arguments are not fact-based, they're logic-based, and holes in that logic were shown long ago.

Vortigern99 said:
John Albert is convincing me with a careful line of reasoned argumentation. The Bitcoin supporters are losing me with non-rebuttals that amount to "nuh-UH!"

If the BC supporters hope to gain some ground in this debate, I suggest offering up some evidence to support your contentions.
Take your mouse and click back several pages, until you see all the replies from me and others exposing the holes in his claims. He's getting ignored because he's repeating the same things ad nauseam and it's not interesting anymore to us. If you want to see the answers, then you'll have to be arsed to move your mouse across the screen and click a few times.
 
ETA: Did a little research. Looks like bitcoin mining is not decrypting, it's actually generating new bitcoins. The "one or two months" is because of a change in how much bitcoin blocks will be worth. Read more here.

That's right. The changes in mining difficulty will make it more difficult to mine bitcoins at a profit, but it will make existing bitcoins more valuable, to the extent that the demand for them remains constant, and/or grows.
 
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/09/05/bitfloor_heist

My guess is that this "Most Important Creation in The History Of Man" is now DOA, or at best crippled.

Your guess is wrong. The security of bitcoin exchanges, while it does affect the overall demand of bitcoin, doesn't have much to do with the security of the bitcoin protocol itself.

The problems with trust in the exchanges is out of the scope of the problem that bitcoin itself was designed to solve. You can expect more exchange hackers, and bitcoin denominated ponzi schemes, but these are in all likelihood just growing pains for bitcoin, the currency.

I think the idea of a non-state currency is meritorious. The implementation seems to be inadequate.

The implementation is fine. Saying bitcoin is inadequate because an exchange was hacked is like saying the US Dollar is inadequate because a foreign exchange bank was robbed.
 
I think the idea of a non-state currency is meritorious. The implementation seems to be inadequate.
That is the last statement I would have expected you to make (gold could be an example of a non-state currency).

I would argue the opposite. If state currencies could be transferred peer-to-peer bitcoin style then you wouldn't need taxpayers to guarantee "demand deposit" accounts.
 
In other news, this is the Bitcoin Google Trends graph as of the time I made this post.

viz


I wish I knew how to set it to cut out the years before it was invented, but you can note the steady rise of references to it beyond the bubble/spike in mid-2011. It has continued to grow in prominence at a steady rate, similar to the way the price has grown at a steady upward curve beyond the mid-2011 spike.

This is to be expected, as the only true threat to the value of Bitcoins is a hacking of the actual cryptography in the client itself, which is nearly impossible given current knowledge of computers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom