How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
When MtGox got hacked way back in 2011, the price of bitcoin plummeted over the following 6 months and everybody was writing its epitaph then too.

Once MtGox is out of the way, it will be back to business as usual until another major attack is waged against bitcoin. This is going to be a very instructive lesson on how the market copes without the hand of "big brother" government.

How many "major attacks against bitcoin" will it take before people realize that it's not nearly as safe and secure as its proponents would have us believe? After all the difficulties with exchanges, how long before people begin to wonder if any exchange is truly safe?
 
How many "major attacks against bitcoin" will it take before people realize that it's not nearly as safe and secure as its proponents would have us believe? After all the difficulties with exchanges, how long before people begin to wonder if any exchange is truly safe?

In other news, banks occasionally get robbed, hackers occasionally steal credit/debit/bank account information, and financial giants manipulate all manner of markets. Some question if these are as safe and secure as believed and wonder if any storage/transfer of value is truly safe.
 
How many "major attacks against bitcoin" will it take before people realize that it's not nearly as safe and secure as its proponents would have us believe?

How do attacks against bitcoin prove bitcoin is not safe and secure? That simply does not follow.

Bitcoin's security problems are well known, so I'm not sure what you're talking about and I suspect you aren't either. Transaction malleability?

And for the record, how secure and safe are the proponents saying it is? I'm wondering who you're reading or where you get your information.

After all the difficulties with exchanges, how long before people begin to wonder if any exchange is truly safe?

I think any rational person wonders that all the time with any third party they hand their money over to. Ever since my mother lost quite a lot of money when one of our local banks went belly up, I'm wondering how secure are the banks.

And it's already been mentioned, but there are p2p exchanges on the horizon.
 
Last edited:
I think any rational person wonders that all the time with any third party they hand their money over to. Ever since my mother lost quite a lot of money when one of our local banks went belly up, I'm wondering how secure are the banks.

FDIC says my first $250k in any given account is secure. Should I accumulate $500k worth of liquid cash at some point, I will be willing to overlook the small extra effort required to maintain two (or more) accounts with two different banks.

Was the local bank not FDIC-insured?
 
In other news, banks occasionally get robbed, hackers occasionally steal credit/debit/bank account information, and financial giants manipulate all manner of markets. Some question if these are as safe and secure as believed and wonder if any storage/transfer of value is truly safe.

Seems that with BTC it's a bit more than occasional.
 
FDIC says my first $250k in any given account is secure. Should I accumulate $500k worth of liquid cash at some point, I will be willing to overlook the small extra effort required to maintain two (or more) accounts with two different banks.

Was the local bank not FDIC-insured?

That was in 1998 when the bank declared bankruptcy, just 2 years after it was founded. Honestly I have no idea whether or how it might have been insured, all I know is that my mother lost somewhere around 30-40% of her savings. She wasn't the only one and certainly not the one with the biggest loss. The bank already owed around 60 000 000 EUR to the government, and whoever was in charge of the liquidation decided depositors would be given 80% of their deposit, but no more than 7670 EUR.
Estonia had freshly regained independence and remnants of soviet corruption plagued finance and political sectors. AFAIK, the amount they gave back wasn't precontractual, but some seemingly arbitrary sum from liquidation of the bank's assets.
 
That was in 1998 when the bank declared bankruptcy, just 2 years after it was founded. Honestly I have no idea whether or how it might have been insured, all I know is that my mother lost somewhere around 30-40% of her savings. She wasn't the only one and certainly not the one with the biggest loss. The bank already owed around 60 000 000 EUR to the government, and whoever was in charge of the liquidation decided depositors would be given 80% of their deposit, but no more than 7670 EUR.
Estonia had freshly regained independence and remnants of soviet corruption plagued finance and political sectors. AFAIK, the amount they gave back wasn't precontractual, but some seemingly arbitrary sum from liquidation of the bank's assets.

Oops, that's right -- you're not in the US, so FDIC doesn't apply to you. I would indeed be a lot more cautious about bank failures if that particular guarantee wasn't available. And yeah, it sounds like that was a big ol' corrupt payoff :/

The international support from more-corrupt countries might be one of the biggest reasons Bitcoin is hanging in there, thinking about it; Cypriots obviously would have much preferred to have their money in Bitcoin, volatility be damned. Unfortunately I can't see any way the price can become stable enough to serve as an actual store of value, which makes it only 'sort of' useful on that front.
 
..If the BTC on Gox are allowed to leave, why wouldn't they be sold on the other exchanges and thus, drive the price down to $130 on those exchanges as well? The bid stacks on BtC-e and Bitstamp couldn't support a wave of 500k bitcoins being liquidated over even a month. The prices would simply collapse.

I'd guess that MtGox would put a limit on Bitcoin withdrawals to limit the effects of such an action. But if you don't believe it'll collapse dramatically if that happens a patient person could make a lot of money anyway.
 
I'd guess that MtGox would put a limit on Bitcoin withdrawals to limit the effects of such an action.
Yes, probably so.


But if you don't believe it'll collapse dramatically if that happens a patient and lucky person could make a lot of money anyway.

FTFY

I think MtGox is toast but that is just my opinion. This has gone on for too long without any decent explanation. Now they are just a PO box and numbers on a screen. No telling who is even trading on the exchange and it's odd that without being able to get anything out, trading is allowed to continue.
 
I think MtGox is toast but that is just my opinion.
It is not just your opinion. The demise of MtGox will probably has a long lasting effect on bitcoin prices and confidence in bitcoin exchanges in general.

What would be worse is if MtGox were bailed out and allowed to continue to be a burden on all and sundry. Thank goodness MtGox doesn't have the same political clout that banks do.
 
What would be worse is if MtGox were bailed out and allowed to continue to be a burden on all and sundry. Thank goodness MtGox doesn't have the same political clout that banks do.

This statement displays a profound ignorance of how the FDIC works. In the future, please educate yourself before posting.

http://money.howstuffworks.com/personal-finance/banking/fdic.htm

FTFL said:
The FDIC's depositor insurance is, in principle, no different from any other insurance. Instead of insuring cars and workers, however, the FDIC insures people who hold deposit accounts with U.S. banking institutions. What's different is that bank account holders don't have to pay a penny for FDIC coverage or even fill out an application; it's free and automatic.

The FDIC is a corporation set up by the United States government to help regulate the U.S. banking system, and is not funded by federal income tax dollars. It is funded by insurance premiums of member banks and by its own investments [source: FDIC].

From that subsource:

FDIC said:
The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) preserves and promotes public confidence in the U.S. financial system by insuring deposits in banks and thrift institutions for at least $250,000; by identifying, monitoring and addressing risks to the deposit insurance funds; and by limiting the effect on the economy and the financial system when a bank or thrift institution fails.

An independent agency of the federal government, the FDIC was created in 1933 in response to the thousands of bank failures that occurred in the 1920s and early 1930s. Since the start of FDIC insurance on January 1, 1934, no depositor has lost a single cent of insured funds as a result of a failure.

The FDIC receives no Congressional appropriations - it is funded by premiums that banks and thrift institutions pay for deposit insurance coverage and from earnings on investments in U.S. Treasury securities. The FDIC insures approximately $9 trillion of deposits in U.S. banks and thrifts - deposits in virtually every bank and thrift in the country.
 
This statement displays a profound ignorance of how the FDIC works. ..........................
The FDIC insures approximately $9 trillion of deposits in U.S. banks and thrifts - deposits in virtually every bank and thrift in the country.
The ignorance is yours if you think that the FDIC has sufficient funds to pay out a major claim (and where do they keep it - in the banks?).

Of course, the US isn't the only economy in the world. Many governments have guaranteed bank deposits without setting up an FDIC style insurance scheme.

And setting up an FDIC style scheme for bitcoin exchanges would be sheer lunacy.
 
Last edited:
The ignorance is yours if you think that the FDIC has sufficient funds to pay out a major claim

[unsupported assertion -- citation needed]

FDIC said:
An independent agency of the federal government, the FDIC was created in 1933 in response to the thousands of bank failures that occurred in the 1920s and early 1930s. Since the start of FDIC insurance on January 1, 1934, no depositor has lost a single cent of insured funds as a result of a failure.

That was in the prior message, in case you missed it.

And setting up an FDIC style scheme for bitcoin exchanges would be sheer lunacy.
Well, of course. The exchanges aren't banks; there's no point trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. Their purpose is to facilitate transactions, not hold people's money for them. But that has nothing to do with your inaccurate anti-FDIC/bank/whatever screeds; it just demonstrates your own lack of understanding.
 
Seems that with BTC it's a bit more than occasional.

As compared to what? When banks, credit cards, currency exchanges, etc first existed or now after how many decades of problems and continual improvements to address them?

Besides it seems like every other month there is some data breach that affects millions.
 
That was in the prior message, in case you missed it.
There is no need for me to repeat my recent posts on bank insurance. You can read them for yourself. You should also research "moral hazard".

Well, of course. The exchanges aren't banks; there's no point trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. Their purpose is to facilitate transactions, not hold people's money for them.
Wow. That's not even a non-sequitur. Not only do you imply that bitcoin exchanges can't be insured because they are not banks but you also imply that they don't hold people's money.
 
As compared to what? When banks, credit cards, currency exchanges, etc first existed or now after how many decades of problems and continual improvements to address them?

Besides it seems like every other month there is some data breach that affects millions.

You mean in the US ? Because up here things seem relatively stable.
 
As compared to what? When banks, credit cards, currency exchanges, etc first existed or now after how many decades of problems and continual improvements to address them?

Besides it seems like every other month there is some data breach that affects millions.

When a major bank has a data breach, millions of people are affected, yes, but any losses are reimbursed by the bank. There are legal protections in place for the bank's depositors.

When a Bitcoin exchange gets hacked, the thieves bugger off with the money, and depositors may not get their money back. There is no legal protection for the depositors whatsoever.

See the difference?
 
When a major bank has a data breach, millions of people are affected, yes, but any losses are reimbursed by the bank. There are legal protections in place for the bank's depositors.

When a Bitcoin exchange gets hacked, the thieves bugger off with the money, and depositors may not get their money back. There is no legal protection for the depositors whatsoever.

See the difference?
Are you suggesting that bitcoin exchange customers should have the same sort of protection as bank customers?
 
Are you suggesting that bitcoin exchange customers should have the same sort of protection as bank customers?

No, he's suggesting that without this kind of protection BTC will never be the most important creation in our history.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom