How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
But it is still a scheme designed to reward early adopters, and "Ponzi" is often shorthand for that. :)

Yes, but personally I can buy that that's more by accident than by intent. That might be slightly naive of me, but bitcoins is an intriguing system with some nice ideas when considered as a cryptological proof of concept. It fails completely from an economics point of view, of course, but I can see it being designed by a well-meaning crypto-geek rather than a nefarious scammer.
 
Maybe, but it seems doubtful, to me. It's a system that's designed to fail, in my opinion, and I don't think that its creators could've missed that.

You know what they say, "Never attribute to malice..."
 
Ahh, but does that commute to "Never attribute to greed..."?
 
I'm undecided about whether Bitcoin had been intentionally designed as a scam, but it certainly appears to have the mechanics of a scam.

Of course, it might be just a very misguided attempt at creating a legitimately usable currency. Its design is certainly very clever, and a lot of sophisticated programming has gone into its implementation. The creators have put a lot of worthwhile effort into ensuring verification of the monetary units and the security of transactions within a wholly decentralized, distributed system, and that work is definitely useful.

But at the same time, there's no denying that the creators set it up in such a way that it grants a disproportionately large advantage to a very small number of the earliest adopters. That inequity alone is very suspicious, especially when you consider that those early adopters contributed none of their own actual money into the system, or any value at all, really.

At least a few of the earliest adopters may be developers and even venture capitalists who contributed to the creation of the system, but I don't have any evidence to support or refute that presumption. At any rate, the earliest adopters reaped their rewards simply by running a background process on their computers. Because they "earned" their stockpile of bitcoins at a time when there was very little active trading, the valuable service they contributed to the system was negligible.

As we know, bitcoin "mining" becomes less and less profitable over time as the difficulty ramps upward. The days of letting your computer earn your money for you are over; that's no longer practically viable unless you have access to something like a data center full of servers or a 3D graphics rendering farm. Anybody nowadays who wants to use bitcoins to purchase stuff has to buy them with his hard-earned money.

But an early adopter could shut down his mining operation now that it's no longer a viable venture, and quit contributing to the operation of the economy at large. There's no penalty incurred by this, and because the system is engineered to create artificial scarcity, his stock of bitcoins will increase in value as long as the hype machine keeps drawing new users into the system. That's*where Bitcoin most resembles a pyramid scheme.

Our theoretical early adopter could simply sit on his bitcoin stack and wait for the speculation bug to induce lots of overvaluation into the system, then begin cashing in his bitcoin in little chunks whenever the bitcoin-dollar exchange rate peaks. The sudden dumping of bitcoins will cause a market crash of course, but as long as the hype machine keeps running there will be plenty of new speculators rushing into the fold to pour their hard-earned cash into the system in hopes of getting rich. The miners get their free money, and the exchanges get their cut in the form of exchange fees.

It's true there's little or no real monetary value in the system at this point in time. But what value there is has been created by the speculation (and to a far lesser extent, consumers using Bitcoin for its nominal purpose as a currency) who have bought into the system with real money. Whenever somebody cashes in their bitcoins, those virtual tokens get snapped up by speculators just as quickly, keeping the market up.

We'll see how long it can last. It's certainly been quite interesting to follow.
 
Last edited:
The other (in my opinion, far more likely) scenario would be a race to the bottom, with one or more greedy speculators or miners trying to cash out too big all at once, crashing the market and causing a panic among speculators and the subsequent failure of exchanges as the system collapses under its own weight.

I consider this not only likely but inevitable... aside from the remaining alternative of bitcoin demand staying somewhat anemic to the point that nobody decides it's time to start cashing in.

But if it ever reaches "critical mass" so to speak--the Tragedy of the Commons will see to precisely what you suggest here.
 
I just edited my post to remove the predictions!

But yeah, I also suspect that's the inevitable outcome. The thing has some obvious problems as a currency, so I'm afraid its novelty will eventually wear off and that will unfortunately lead to a very bad day for some investors.
 
Well, the Bitcoin counter to that is that a single BTC can be divided... one hundred million times, or something like that? If Bitcoin takes off, individuals will be dealing in miniscule fractions of a BTC. Can you imagine how unwieldy that would be?
Well, sure, but then you aren't limited to 21 million, you have an infinite supply of coins. It's one or the other - you (you=bitcoin, not you Cl1mh4224rd) either have a finite, fixed supply, or you don't. You can't claim the former as a benefit, yet implement the latter.

I would have to agree that, theoretically (in a system such as this), there is no difference between creating more and sub-dividing the ones that already exist.
 
I'm undecided about whether Bitcoin had been intentionally designed as a scam, but it certainly appears to have the mechanics of a scam.

Of course, it might be just a very misguided attempt at creating a legitimately usable currency. Its design is certainly very clever, and a lot of sophisticated programming has gone into its implementation. The creators have put a lot of worthwhile effort into ensuring verification of the monetary units and the security of transactions within a wholly decentralized, distributed system, and that work is definitely useful.

But at the same time, there's no denying that the creators set it up in such a way that it grants a disproportionately large advantage to a very small number of the earliest adopters. That inequity alone is very suspicious, especially when you consider that those early adopters contributed none of their own actual money into the system, or any value at all, really.

At least a few of the earliest adopters may be developers and even venture capitalists who contributed to the creation of the system, but I don't have any evidence to support or refute that presumption. At any rate, the earliest adopters reaped their rewards simply by running a background process on their computers. Because they "earned" their stockpile of bitcoins at a time when there was very little active trading, the valuable service they contributed to the system was negligible.

As we know, bitcoin "mining" becomes less and less profitable over time as the difficulty ramps upward. The days of letting your computer earn your money for you are over; that's no longer practically viable unless you have access to something like a data center full of servers or a 3D graphics rendering farm. Anybody nowadays who wants to use bitcoins to purchase stuff has to buy them with his hard-earned money.

But an early adopter could shut down his mining operation now that it's no longer a viable venture, and quit contributing to the operation of the economy at large. There's no penalty incurred by this, and because the system is engineered to create artificial scarcity, his stock of bitcoins will increase in value as long as the hype machine keeps drawing new users into the system. That's*where Bitcoin most resembles a pyramid scheme.

Our theoretical early adopter could simply sit on his bitcoin stack and wait for the speculation bug to induce lots of overvaluation into the system, then begin cashing in his bitcoin in little chunks whenever the bitcoin-dollar exchange rate peaks. The sudden dumping of bitcoins will cause a market crash of course, but as long as the hype machine keeps running there will be plenty of new speculators rushing into the fold to pour their hard-earned cash into the system in hopes of getting rich. The miners get their free money, and the exchanges get their cut in the form of exchange fees.

It's true there's little or no real monetary value in the system at this point in time. But what value there is has been created by the speculation (and to a far lesser extent, consumers using Bitcoin for its nominal purpose as a currency) who have bought into the system with real money. Whenever somebody cashes in their bitcoins, those virtual tokens get snapped up by speculators just as quickly, keeping the market up.

We'll see how long it can last. It's certainly been quite interesting to follow.

I believe you're correct.

This may not be a designed from the ground up scam, but the possibility is certainly there for manipulation.
 
I would have to agree that, theoretically (in a system such as this), there is no difference between creating more and sub-dividing the ones that already exist.

Actually, there is a difference. With a hard limit on the number of bitcoins that can be introduced, bitcoins are by necessity deflationary -- which is not a good thing.
 
As we know, bitcoin "mining" becomes less and less profitable over time as the difficulty ramps upward. The days of letting your computer earn your money for you are over; that's no longer practically viable unless you have access to something like a data center full of servers or a 3D graphics rendering farm. Anybody nowadays who wants to use bitcoins to purchase stuff has to buy them with his hard-earned money.

That was never the point of bitcoin. Bitcoin is not a get rich quick scheme. The early adopter incentive was probably designed to get the system started...and it seems to have worked. There may be a speculative bubble, but the point of bitcoin was only to have currency free from central authority. If freedom from central authority is desired enough, people will happily convert real money into bitcoin to make purchases.
 
The early adopter incentive was probably designed to get the system started...and it seems to have worked.

It might have helped kickstart the system, but unfortunately it also guarantees the system is inviable in the long term. The concentration of bitcoins among the early adopters is as if the manager and staff of the US mint would keep 80% of all money printed for themselves and only distribute the remaining 20% for general circulation. It's a recipe for disaster.
 
That was never the point of bitcoin.

Assuming this is true: So what? It still is what bitcoin is.


Bitcoin is not a get rich quick scheme.

It is essentially just that, regardless of what people were thinking when they build it.


The early adopter incentive was probably designed to get the system started...and it seems to have worked. There may be a speculative bubble, but the point of bitcoin was only to have currency free from central authority. If freedom from central authority is desired enough, people will happily convert real money into bitcoin to make purchases.

... and thereby making the early adopters stinking rich.

You could initially get a single bitcoin virtually for free. As I understand it, this is no longer possible or practical. The early adopters have free and whole bitcoins.

If the currency should ever take off, one bitcoin will be worth a lot. The value the early adopters got for free will be paid by everyone who came to the game late.
 
I find it impossible to believe they were smart enough to design the Bitcoin system, yet not smart enough to know it amounted to a scam.

Though I'm willing to be shown to be wrong. :)
 
That was never the point of bitcoin. Bitcoin is not a get rich quick scheme. The early adopter incentive was probably designed to get the system started...and it seems to have worked. There may be a speculative bubble, but the point of bitcoin was only to have currency free from central authority. If freedom from central authority is desired enough, people will happily convert real money into bitcoin to make purchases.

But first they'd have to actually be able to make a purchase. I'm still less than impressed with this amazing currency of the future's inability to actually be used to buy anything. That's a really important aspect of a currency that they've apparently overlooked.

BTC Millionaire: Good morning economic slav..I mean fine sir! I'd like to purchase a cheeseburger with everything. Also I'll be paying in bitcoins!

Food Jockey: I don't know what that is but we only take cash or plastic.

BTC Millionaire: Funny, I get that everywhere I go. It's like you cursed tax merchants have no idea you're speaking to a millionaire here! I'd curse you out more but I really don't have the strength. Seems that I haven't eaten in days....

A sandwich! A sandwich! My Bitcoin kingdom for a sandwich!
 
It seems that both our resident AnCap proponent and our resident Libertarian have run away from this thread. Apparently they´ve run out of ideological soundbites to throw at us.
 
I would have to agree that, theoretically (in a system such as this), there is no difference between creating more and sub-dividing the ones that already exist.

The people who began bitcoin will not lose any value in their stockpiles while new miners will gain less and less as time goes by.

If they were adding new coins, everyone's value would decrease by the same proportion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom