I'm undecided about whether Bitcoin had been intentionally designed as a scam, but it certainly appears to have the mechanics of a scam.
Of course, it might be just a very misguided attempt at creating a legitimately usable currency. Its design is certainly very clever, and a lot of sophisticated programming has gone into its implementation. The creators have put a lot of worthwhile effort into ensuring verification of the monetary units and the security of transactions within a wholly decentralized, distributed system, and that work is definitely useful.
But at the same time, there's no denying that the creators set it up in such a way that it grants a disproportionately large advantage to a very small number of the earliest adopters. That inequity alone is very suspicious, especially when you consider that those early adopters contributed none of their own actual money into the system, or any value at all, really.
At least a few of the earliest adopters may be developers and even venture capitalists who contributed to the creation of the system, but I don't have any evidence to support or refute that presumption. At any rate, the earliest adopters reaped their rewards simply by running a background process on their computers. Because they "earned" their stockpile of bitcoins at a time when there was very little active trading, the valuable service they contributed to the system was negligible.
As we know, bitcoin "mining" becomes less and less profitable over time as the difficulty ramps upward. The days of letting your computer earn your money for you are over; that's no longer practically viable unless you have access to something like a data center full of servers or a 3D graphics rendering farm. Anybody nowadays who wants to use bitcoins to purchase stuff has to buy them with his hard-earned money.
But an early adopter could shut down his mining operation now that it's no longer a viable venture, and quit contributing to the operation of the economy at large. There's no penalty incurred by this, and because the system is engineered to create artificial scarcity, his stock of bitcoins will increase in value as long as the hype machine keeps drawing new users into the system. That's*where Bitcoin most resembles a pyramid scheme.
Our theoretical early adopter could simply sit on his bitcoin stack and wait for the speculation bug to induce lots of overvaluation into the system, then begin cashing in his bitcoin in little chunks whenever the bitcoin-dollar exchange rate peaks. The sudden dumping of bitcoins will cause a market crash of course, but as long as the hype machine keeps running there will be plenty of new speculators rushing into the fold to pour their hard-earned cash into the system in hopes of getting rich. The miners get their free money, and the exchanges get their cut in the form of exchange fees.
It's true there's little or no real monetary value in the system at this point in time. But what value there is has been created by the speculation (and to a far lesser extent, consumers using Bitcoin for its nominal purpose as a currency) who have bought into the system with real money. Whenever somebody cashes in their bitcoins, those virtual tokens get snapped up by speculators just as quickly, keeping the market up.
We'll see how long it can last. It's certainly been quite interesting to follow.