How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
The failure is the 3rd party site...I guess it's lucky for the users of that site that was hacked can roll back the trades. I suppose of your ebay account was hacked that would be a failure in all online auctions?

Yes, this was a failure in one specific bitcoin exchange site and not a failure of the bitcoin concept or algorithms. However, what this failure does is to very aptly illustrate some of the non-technical problems with bitcoins as a practical currency: to wit how the monetary value of bitcoins is entirely speculation based, how a huge percentage of the available currency is controlled by a few individuals, the fragility of the infrastructure (a currency without developed banking and payment systems is pointless), the security concerns of moving money around across the Internet (there's some very good reasons why banks spend a lot of money running dedicated high-security networks for -- and they're not even sending any actual _money_ over the wires, just transaction details), the significant security risks surrounding the use of bitcoins and, last but not least, the Mickey Mouse nature and lack of professionalism or any kind of banking knowledge of the established "institutions" dealing the currency.

If you don't think all of this matters for bitcoins' viability as a currency, you've got another think coming.
 
Same thing to steal CC#s and peoples money from online accounts. Don't compare a digital currency to one that is physical.
I know most CC and other online accounts can't actually become unusable which is theoretically possible and quite probable with Bitcoins.
 
OK, so... Bitcoins can be lost and they can't be replaced. That seems like a pretty serious limitation. What good is a currency whose total availability can only diminish? Once all 21 million Bitcoins are unlocked, the pool can only shrink. Bitcoins have already been lost, so the system will never actually have 21 million Bitcoins in circulation.

Look at this...

(1) Bitcoins are divisible to 0.00000001, so this is not a problem. (2) If you lose your coins, all other coins will go up in value a little. Consider it a donation to all other bitcoin users.

Source: Myths - Lost coins can't be replaced and this is bad


1) That sentence isn't at all relevant to the myth they're attempting to dispel.

2) Oh, so... losing your Bitcoins isn't bad because everyone else benefits from your loss. That's like reverse Communism, or something.

No one sees a problem here? That would not only continue to encourage hoarding of Bitcoins, but also encourage the disappearance of others' Bitcoins in order to drive up the value of your own.
 
Last edited:
Yes, this was a failure in one specific bitcoin exchange site and not a failure of the bitcoin concept or algorithms. However, what this failure does is to very aptly illustrate some of the non-technical problems with bitcoins as a practical currency: to wit how the monetary value of bitcoins is entirely speculation based

How does this incident have anything to do with bitcoin's value being speculation based?

how a huge percentage of the available currency is controlled by a few individuals

Again, how does this incidence illustrate this? People's accounts were hacked and their stocked dumped for the lowest price. All this illustrates is that there is a low volume of overall trading on that site vs the accounts which were hacked.

the fragility of the infrastructure (a currency without developed banking and payment systems is pointless),

The security of the exchange site was fragile and the exchange site is part of the bitcoin infrastructure...is that your point? Solution: better security.

the security concerns of moving money around across the Internet (there's some very good reasons why banks spend a lot of money running dedicated high-security networks for -- and they're not even sending any actual _money_ over the wires, just transaction details),

And when CC databases get hacked, identity theft, other online fraud? These aren't problems specific to bitcoin, so how does this incident illustrate a bitcoin specific problem? If this was a poker site and the poker accounts got dumped would it be any different?

the significant security risks surrounding the use of bitcoins and

Such as what...and how does this incident illustrate them?

last but not least, the Mickey Mouse nature and lack of professionalism or any kind of banking knowledge of the established "institutions" dealing the currency.

So because one site had crap security all of the insitituions lack professionalism? At least this site can revert the trades.

If you don't think all of this matters for bitcoins' viability as a currency, you've got another think coming.

Some of it matters, but most of your list was nonsense.
 
Anybody who believes that bitcoin is just a flash in the pan is indulging in wishful thinking. As long as the algorithm is uncrackable, there will be a role for bitcoin. The role hasn't been clearly defined yet but that often happens when new technology is introduced.

EFF has thrown it under the bus. In a year it will be as much of a joke as freenet or barter clubs.
 
Which is what mt gox did, by reversing the fraudulent trades.

Correction. They have claimed that they will roll back, the exchange is still closed, and at least one sixth of the entire Bitcoin reserves are out of commission. Lots of theories flying around about why the rollback has not taken place.

But they hopefully would, if you obtained that $1000 through hacking a bank's website. Also, mt gox doesnt claim to issue currency either, so again mt gox and bitcoin are being conflated.

The hacking of the major exchange has sent ripples to the wider community, at least to anyone who is not a rabid pro-BTC supporter.
 
Which is what mt gox did, by reversing the fraudulent trades.

This is not what I understand did happen.

The rollback affects *all* trade over a specific time frame. That includes legitimate trades between users that simply had different opinions on whether the report about a larger number of stolen coins was accurate.
 
there will be a role for bitcoin. The role hasn't been clearly defined yet

The value of bitcoin will stabilize once people learn

And here we see exactly what the problem is. Even if you ignore all the other issues people have raised and assume that bitcoin really is perfectly good as a currency, there's still no reason for anyone to actually use it. We already have a whole bunch of perfectly serviceable currencies that are accepted across the world (I have yet to visit a country in which my credit card won't work). In order to have a chance of replacing something established, you have to offer very clear advantages over the existing thing. Cars, for example, are significantly faster and stronger than horses, so they quickly caught on and largely replaced them. Bitcoin, however, is attempting to replace currency with currency. Even if you could show that the exact details of how it works are objectively better, you're never going to be able to persuade ordinary people to switch to it because it offers no obvious advantages over what they're already using.

The quotes from psionl0 make it very clear - Bitcoin might be useful some time in the future, once people learn what it actually is and what it could be used for. But right now, people haven't done that and therefore it isn't actually useful. So obviously people aren't going to start using it. Which means that they're never going to learn what it is and what it could be used for. Which means it will never actually be useful.

Incidentally, this also makes clear just how silly the title is. At best, this is a minor upgrade to a long established system. Does the OP really want us to believe that making currency work slightly better is a more important discovery than the actual invention of currency itself? And that's before you even start thinking about the various other far more important discoveries like fire, the wheel, agriculture, sliced bread, and so on. Bitcoin could potentially be slightly interesting, but it's not some incredible, world changing idea, and even proponents seem to admit that it's not actually very useful, they just think it might be at some undefined time in the future.
 
Long story short: BItcoin is nothing but electronic counterfeiting, and everyone involved is a crook. I hope the Treasury Department nails each and every Bitcoin user and advocate's butts to the wall.
 
Hold on there. Advocating would just fall under free speech--especially with its purported "illegality" not at all established law so far. Even if it becomes that, I doubt someone participating before the law passes could be held criminally.
 
Last edited:
Long story short: BItcoin is nothing but electronic counterfeiting, and everyone involved is a crook. I hope the Treasury Department nails each and every Bitcoin user and advocate's butts to the wall.

Nah, Bitcoin is just what any other currency is, a medium of exchange in a barter economy. If people think it is valuable, then it is valuable. If people think it is worthless, then it is worthless. It's no different than US dollars, Canadian dollars, British Pounds, Rei Stones, or lumps of gold. Heck, if everyone woke up tomorrow and decided that all Pez dispensers were worth a million dollars, that would be fine if highly unlikely.

Of course, this also means that Bitcoin isn't really anything special either. It has no magical protection from market forces, and if people decide that they are worthless, then they are worthless.

(It certainly isn't the most important creation in the history of man. While a lot of people will vote for things like the club, fire, or spoken language, I think the most important single creation was the bag. The ability to carry several objects by holding just one enabled people to bring more tools, food and valuables with them at any given time while they travelled. Before that, you were limited to either having only one or two items that you carried with you, or using only the items that could be found in the area you were staying at the moment.)
 
Hold on there. Advocating would just fall under free speech--especially with its purported "illegality" not at all established law so far. Even if it becomes that, I doubt someone participating before the law passes could be held criminally.

Counterfeiting is already illegal. Bitcoin as currency has the legitimacy of a $3.50 bill, and anyone saying otherwise is aiding and abetting in counterfeiting. Advocacy of criminal acts is not protected speech.
 
Counterfeiting is already illegal. Bitcoin as currency has the legitimacy of a $3.50 bill, and anyone saying otherwise is aiding and abetting in counterfeiting. Advocacy of criminal acts is not protected speech.

People can buy and trade things and collect things as they want to, they can even trade them for other things in the same of different classes. The thing is that you can not make me accept your watch instead of paying the money you owe me. That is the unique thing about money the government forces people to accept it as payment for debts.
 
Counterfeiting is already illegal. Bitcoin as currency has the legitimacy of a $3.50 bill, and anyone saying otherwise is aiding and abetting in counterfeiting. Advocacy of criminal acts is not protected speech.

Nobody here seems to be counterfeiting anything. A bitcoin doesn't pretend to be a dollar, it only claims to be worth an amount of x dollars.

There's a strip club in hamburg (I am sure others follow the same scheme, but this happens to be the one i was in) that sells "doll house dollars" to the customers. Euros have no small denominations in notes, and few people are willing to hand over fivers to the performers it seems.

These pieces of papers are used to tip dancers and servers as well as buy food and drink. They will not be accepted anywhere as soon as you leave the premises.

Counterfeiting?
 
Bitcoin could potentially be slightly interesting, but it's not some incredible, world changing idea, and even proponents seem to admit that it's not actually very useful, they just think it might be at some undefined time in the future.

Paypal found a niche, I think bitcoin could as well. But you are right, even if it caught on in a big way, the world would not be that different.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom