Leif Roar
Master Poster
- Joined
- Nov 27, 2002
- Messages
- 2,795
The failure is the 3rd party site...I guess it's lucky for the users of that site that was hacked can roll back the trades. I suppose of your ebay account was hacked that would be a failure in all online auctions?
Yes, this was a failure in one specific bitcoin exchange site and not a failure of the bitcoin concept or algorithms. However, what this failure does is to very aptly illustrate some of the non-technical problems with bitcoins as a practical currency: to wit how the monetary value of bitcoins is entirely speculation based, how a huge percentage of the available currency is controlled by a few individuals, the fragility of the infrastructure (a currency without developed banking and payment systems is pointless), the security concerns of moving money around across the Internet (there's some very good reasons why banks spend a lot of money running dedicated high-security networks for -- and they're not even sending any actual _money_ over the wires, just transaction details), the significant security risks surrounding the use of bitcoins and, last but not least, the Mickey Mouse nature and lack of professionalism or any kind of banking knowledge of the established "institutions" dealing the currency.
If you don't think all of this matters for bitcoins' viability as a currency, you've got another think coming.