wilsontown
Thinker
- Joined
- Aug 8, 2007
- Messages
- 127
Judging by what was written in a previous thread discussing the powerpoints, the figures in the paper are the same ones, showing UV-vis and Raman spectra. So, apart from all the things you folks have already pointed out about how rubbish this is, it seems they got their graphs mixed up as well.
As for review...well, it doesn't seem as though this stuff was reviewed by anyone with much of an understanding of science generally, never mind the methods used. It was presumably reviewed by homeopaths. I wouldn't expect a reviewer to play around with Corel Draw, to be fair, but there are plenty more problems that could be found.
As for the 'envelope of difference', well, who knows what it is. The thing with the two graphs is that in figure 1, the one of the curves is supposed to be Nux Vom and one Nat Mur, but in figure 2 they're both supposed to be Nat Mur. Who knows which of them, if either, is the correctly labelled one?
And no, I'm not Johnnie Scobie...
As for review...well, it doesn't seem as though this stuff was reviewed by anyone with much of an understanding of science generally, never mind the methods used. It was presumably reviewed by homeopaths. I wouldn't expect a reviewer to play around with Corel Draw, to be fair, but there are plenty more problems that could be found.
As for the 'envelope of difference', well, who knows what it is. The thing with the two graphs is that in figure 1, the one of the curves is supposed to be Nux Vom and one Nat Mur, but in figure 2 they're both supposed to be Nat Mur. Who knows which of them, if either, is the correctly labelled one?
And no, I'm not Johnnie Scobie...