Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Judging by what was written in a previous thread discussing the powerpoints, the figures in the paper are the same ones, showing UV-vis and Raman spectra. So, apart from all the things you folks have already pointed out about how rubbish this is, it seems they got their graphs mixed up as well.

As for review...well, it doesn't seem as though this stuff was reviewed by anyone with much of an understanding of science generally, never mind the methods used. It was presumably reviewed by homeopaths. I wouldn't expect a reviewer to play around with Corel Draw, to be fair, but there are plenty more problems that could be found.

As for the 'envelope of difference', well, who knows what it is. The thing with the two graphs is that in figure 1, the one of the curves is supposed to be Nux Vom and one Nat Mur, but in figure 2 they're both supposed to be Nat Mur. Who knows which of them, if either, is the correctly labelled one?

And no, I'm not Johnnie Scobie...
 
As for the 'envelope of difference', well, who knows what it is. The thing with the two graphs is that in figure 1, the one of the curves is supposed to be Nux Vom and one Nat Mur, but in figure 2 they're both supposed to be Nat Mur. Who knows which of them, if either, is the correctly labelled one?


Good point. Hence, very embarrassing that it's the same graph in Figure 1 and 2.... maybe it's quantum?

;)
 
I wonder if there's any point in sending a comment to Homeopathy, pointing out the basic errors in this paper? Surely they would have to at least issue an erratum, or even withdraw the paper?
 
Send in a comment? Not a bad idea.

I wrote to the lead author a few weeks back asking for clarification on the ethanol experiment, but never got a reply. Heck, maybe I shouldn't have indicated that I was but a lowly PhD student.

Anyway, reusing the same graph for two different things should at least merit an erratum.

Worth a try.
 
Over the past 7 months I and 3 colleagues have complied a definitive document which debunks all Homeopathy totally - amounting to some 100,000 words it is a comprehensive tome of the very lasted scientific proofs that finally lay rest to this nonsense.

In order that these charlatans fully understand just how much I and my colleagues deplore their blatant disregard for pharmaceutical solutions we have decided to put our full documented claim to them in the strongest form at our disposal....

This is what we sent them.......

.


You may be shocked that we sent . which is a 10c dilution, however we felt a 4c paragraph, or 6c letter was not sufficient to state our case! We alas were not able to find a 0.0000000001 font size for a 20c tirade which was our initial aim.



(apologies if this has been done before, I'm a noob)
 
Figure 2 is slide 29 in the PowerPoint. That is captioned "Nat Mur (open circles) and Nux Vomica (closed circles)". This makes no sense to me as the lefthand set of graphs is labelled Nat Mur and the righthand set Nux vomica. I thought each set of axes was one preparation as described, with the open and closed circles representing the two most extreme spectra, but that doesn't really explain why the lines cross in some of the sets, as already discussed.

What I can't understand is the obsessive interest in measuring so many points right along the spectrum for every preparation. The shape of the spectra might be interesting if you were going to assign bond energies to the peaks or anything so rational. However, if you're just going to say, look at the difference, the way to do it would be to pick the wavelength at which the difference was greatest and do lots of measurements at that wavelength.

Geni estimated the lambda-max at about 324nm, which was a reasonable match for a possible contamination by acetone if I remember correctly! Anyway, if 324nm is the interesting wavelength, and it does appear that wherever there is a hint of a peak that's where it is, then just do lots of measurements of different preparations, with lots of repeats of each preparation, and do the statistics. Either there is a significant difference in absorbance at this wavelength or there isn't. If in fact there isn't due to poor precision, then there isn't a snowball's chance in hell you'll find it at any other wavelength.

It just beggars belief that anyone who knows anything about UV spectroscopy could accidentally produce such sloppy work. I know Roy is 84, but that doesn't mean he's ga-ga and if he's ga-ga then he shouldn't be publishing. Anyone at all involved with this who has the remotest idea about the subject whould be able to tell him this isn't the way to go about it.

I think he's run relatively few spectra, just with lots and lots of different wavelength-points for each run, and is then waving these spectra at us with no statistical treatment, as "different". Wilsontown seems to have spotted that he's run rather fewer spectra than one might at first sight assume. I just don't wholly understand the reference to the "series of 10" preparations, and if he's really done that, why aren't we seeing all the data for that. You know, means and standard deviations for each point and so on.

How much of this is incompetence and how much deliberate obfuscation, deliberately intended to provide an impressive-looking paper to be referred to be homoeopaths, realising that most people won't even bother to look to see if it's garbage or not? I have trouble going with the incompetence theory, given that actual possession of a spectrophotometer rather implies some degree of competence somewhere among the personnel. I have to suspect deliberate obfuscation.

But having said that, I'm rabbiting, and I haven't really looked at the thing in great detail yet.

Rolfe.
 
I wonder if there's any point in sending a comment to Homeopathy, pointing out the basic errors in this paper? Surely they would have to at least issue an erratum, or even withdraw the paper?


You jest! These guys take even the slightest critical look at what they've printed? I don't see it happening.

(Sorry about the "Johnnie Scobie" joke, just the local version of "For we're no awa tae bide awa" - "As I cam doon by Wilsontown, I met wee Johnnie Scobie....". It's the only thing my tone-deaf father could sing, and I got to hear it often as a kid.)

Rolfe.
 
Over the past 7 months I and 3 colleagues have complied a definitive document which debunks all Homeopathy totally - amounting to some 100,000 words it is a comprehensive tome of the very lasted scientific proofs that finally lay rest to this nonsense.

In order that these charlatans fully understand just how much I and my colleagues deplore their blatant disregard for pharmaceutical solutions we have decided to put our full documented claim to them in the strongest form at our disposal....

This is what we sent them.......

.


You may be shocked that we sent . which is a 10c dilution, however we felt a 4c paragraph, or 6c letter was not sufficient to state our case! We alas were not able to find a 0.0000000001 font size for a 20c tirade which was our initial aim.



(apologies if this has been done before, I'm a noob)


Someone from Manchester uni (I think) actually did this. They sent a load of blank pages to Peter Fisher, with suitable covering letter and so on. They put all this on the internet, including the po-faced, offended reply they got. It was so funny. But the last time I looked for it, the link was broken.

Rolfe.
 
You jest! These guys take even the slightest critical look at what they've printed? I don't see it happening.


Do you think Elsevier would have an interest in the credibility of it's journals? I'd like to think so.

But having said that, they don't make any claims to provide quality research, not that I could find.
 
Trouble is, you'd have to contact the authors and/or the journal first, and get the brush-off from them, before Elsevier might be interested. And as I'm pretty sure there's deliberate obfuscation going on here, it might be difficult to get any reply.

The criticisms go deeper than mixed-up graphs anyway. I wonder if it's worth taking our time about this, putting it all together - ethanol spectrum, methodological problems (lack of statistics, repeatability and data for the ten repetitions and so on) plus the duplicated graphs, and presenting it all wrapped up in a nice parcel with a bow round it?

Rolfe.
 
How much of this is incompetence and how much deliberate obfuscation, deliberately intended to provide an impressive-looking paper to be referred to be homoeopaths, realising that most people won't even bother to look to see if it's garbage or not? I have trouble going with the incompetence theory, given that actual possession of a spectrophotometer rather implies some degree of competence somewhere among the personnel. I have to suspect deliberate obfuscation.


This does not look like the publication list of an incompetent individual; the lady does appear to have done some good work in materials science.
 
This does not look like the publication list of an incompetent individual; the lady does appear to have done some good work in materials science.


Right. And Roy has a pedigree too (pointed out to me after I queried his credentials on the back of the obvious incompetence of the slide show).

So what the hell are they up to?

Rolfe.
 
What indeed. Pushing a belief despite the lack of supporting evidence. It looks like an attempt at obfuscation, and nobody called them on it.
 
Right. And Roy has a pedigree too (pointed out to me after I queried his credentials on the back of the obvious incompetence of the slide show).

So what the hell are they up to?

Rolfe.

This reminds me of an article published in Skeptic magazine by Marshall Deutsch called "The Truth About Cholesterol", that was so misguided that I seriously expected it to be revealed as a joke. I really appreciate that those of you with specific knowledge have taken the time to uncover this mystery. I suspect that this would benefit from being taken to a wider audience (wrapped up with a bow, as you put it) so that it comes to the attention of the peers of those involved. Being forced to answer or lose face may clear up just what they thought they were doing. Perhaps they were hoping that those in the know are unlikely to be regular readers of Homeopathy?

Linda
 
I've been scheming. And trying to read the paper!

I think a reasonably short letter to the editor (Peter Fisher himself!) BUT copied to Elsevier (and maybe to the authors) might be constructive. Or at least instructive. Signed (real names, pack drill the lot) by whoever understands spectrophotometry enough to feel able to, and has enough alphabet soup after their names to confer suitable gravitas. I'm certainly prepared to do it, but I think it will have more weight if there are several signatories.

I'm off sailing for the weekend, but I can start to put something together. My idea is to make it very factual, just pointing out the basic data problems, nothing contentious about why are you supporting this rubbish, not even any criticism of the pro-homoeopathy rhetoric, and maybe just finish it with a comment that if the authors are interested in addressing the plausibility of homoeopathy they should perhaps look to the plausibility of their own results in the first instance.

We've got the bogus ethanol spectrum, and the lack of any provenance for the source of the ethanol, and the lack of any data on repetitions, particularly the lack of any statistical treatment, maybe the nonsense-sentence where repeatability and precision are declared to be different things, and the duplicated graphs. I personally wouldn't touch the Raman spectra with a bargepole, but I know enough about UV spectroscopy to make it both technically convincing and right.

Wilsontown, can you pretty, pretty please post a list of which of these UV graphs are identical to which? It would make it so much easier.

Rolfe.
 
I think a reasonably short letter to the editor (Peter Fisher himself!) BUT copied to Elsevier (and maybe to the authors) might be constructive. Or at least instructive. Signed (real names, pack drill the lot) by whoever understands spectrophotometry enough to feel able to, and has enough alphabet soup after their names to confer suitable gravitas. I'm certainly prepared to do it, but I think it will have more weight if there are several signatories.


Good idea. I'm sure there's a chemistry professor around here somewhere who can add some weight to a letter (although the letters MPH! carry weight with these guys).

Just a PhD student myself. I'll pm you my email to the author so you can see what didn't work. ;)
 
Given these guys' level, I think a first degree in a science subject will look quite good enough. I've got a BSc (in biochemistry) and a PhD and I'm FIBiol too. So there's enough gravitas there to head up a reasonable list. Also, I'm used to refereeing papers.

I need Wilsontown to tell me which traces are identical though.

Rolfe.
 
Before any letter gets sent, I strongly recommend finding a published spectrum of ethanol to compare it to this one. Either that or getting your own spectrum of ethanol. If you want to question the spectrum (and I think you can legitimately do that) there should be more basis for it.

If you can say, "Roy's spectrum of ethanol does not match that published by XXX). How do the authors account for the discrepancy?" it will add significant weight.
 
Do you think Elsevier would have an interest in the credibility of it's journals? I'd like to think so. {snip}
Elsevier prints and markets good journals and fanzines, alike, if they can make money doing so. The quality of a publication lies in the hands of the sponsoring organization, in this case "The Faculty of Homeopathy" which is recognized by the British Parliament.

The quality of Roy's publication is in line with the quality of regular articles in this fanzine. Therefore, there is no point in complaining.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom