Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Never mind the memory of water, what about the memory of sugar? Take oscillococcinum, it's a 200C (a 1 in 10^400) dilution of duck liver using water. So you get this water with a memory of duck liver, but no actual duck liver.

You then use this to moisten some sugar pellets, a single dose has 1g of these pellets. The water would evaporate, leaving sugar. Does the sugar have a memory?

Obviously the pill vehicle would make sense if there was some of the substance left in the water, which is what was originally thought. But now we know there is not, and the only possibility is this "memory", how does it get transferred to the sugar?

Obviously I'm not expecting a real explanation, but how do homeopaths explain this? I've looked around and could not find it explained anywhere.
 
Obviously I'm not expecting a real explanation, but how do homeopaths explain this? I've looked around and could not find it explained anywhere.


Likewise. Slippery fellows, these homeopaths.

They just say vague things like they put a drop of 'potentized' remedy or medicine on the pill. Of course if you put a drop of a real medicine on a sugar pill, it would leave some residue. By claiming equivalency to the real world by using words like 'medicine', they can infer that the remedy is transferred to the sugar pill.

The paper that is the subject of this thread "The defining role of structure (including epitaxy) in the plausibility of homeopathy" offers a nugget of speculation that may be relevant:

The nanoheterogenous structure of water can be determined by interactive phenomena such as epitaxy (the transmission of structural information from the surface of one material to another without the transfer of any matter), temperature–pressure processes during succussion, and formation of colloidal nanobubbles containing gaseous inclusions of oxygen, nitrogen, carbon dioxide, and possibly the remedy source material.


They don't go so far as to say that epitaxy is the means by which pills are 'potentized', but ten to one someone's thinking it.
 
Never mind the memory of water, what about the memory of sugar? Take oscillococcinum, it's a 200C (a 1 in 10^400) dilution of duck liver using water. So you get this water with a memory of duck liver, but no actual duck liver.

You then use this to moisten some sugar pellets, a single dose has 1g of these pellets. The water would evaporate, leaving sugar. Does the sugar have a memory?

Obviously the pill vehicle would make sense if there was some of the substance left in the water, which is what was originally thought. But now we know there is not, and the only possibility is this "memory", how does it get transferred to the sugar?

Obviously I'm not expecting a real explanation, but how do homeopaths explain this? I've looked around and could not find it explained anywhere.


Haven't seen them claiming this yet, but at the risk of giving the homoeopaths more wild ideas, there would be some water of crystallisation in the lactose. Not that this helps them, because any structure involving this water would be as a result of the lactose molecules, not whatever the remedy was supposed to have been.
 
They just say vague things like they put a drop of 'potentized' remedy or medicine on the pill. Of course if you put a drop of a real medicine on a sugar pill, it would leave some residue. By claiming equivalency to the real world by using words like 'medicine', they can infer that the remedy is transferred to the sugar pill.


In case anyone in the thread hasn't already heard of it, check out the concept of "grafting". You don't even need to drop the "medicine" on all the pills; some (most?) homoeopaths believe that if they take one potentised pill and put it with a bottleful of blanks it will transfer its medicinal properties to the rest of the pills.
 
Last edited:
In case anyone in the thread hasn't already heard of it, check out the concept of "grafting". You don't even need to drop the "medicine" on all the pills; some (most?) homoeopaths believe that take one potentised pill and put it with a bottleful of blanks it will transfer its medicinal properties to the rest of the pills.

And they're right. The blanks will have exactly the same medicinal properties as the potentised pill.
 
In case anyone in the thread hasn't already heard of it, check out the concept of "grafting". You don't even need to drop the "medicine" on all the pills; some (most?) homoeopaths believe that take one potentised pill and put it with a bottleful of blanks it will transfer its medicinal properties to the rest of the pills.


Yeah, that's just cheeky.

Any homeopaths want to defend grafting?
 
Any homeopaths want to defend grafting?
It has been a sore spot for the homoeopaths I have met: the problem for them is that grafting was supported by Hahnemann, and he could never be wrong.

The question is, how would they test if grafting works?
853.gif
 
I'd never heard of grafting, so I looked it up, check out this description of how they used to do it (and maybe still do, somewhere).
http://www.acampbell.ukfsn.org/homeopathy/homeopathy-html/chapter12.html

Whatever adds to the ritual serves to enhance its efficacy. At one time I used to practise homeopathy privately in the rooms of a colleague who had a lot of remedies that were about fifty years old. They had been prepared long ago by a homeopathic doctor who had made them by hand, and they had been preserved by a process known as grafting. The medicines consisted of lactose powders, contained in bottles with handwritten labels and neatly stacked in rows on the shelves of cabinets.

The "grafting" consisted essentially in adding fresh lactose to the almost empty bottle, perhaps with a little alcohol-water mixture, and shaking it for a short time. This procedure was supposed to transmit the energy of the medicine to the added lactose - to potentise it, in fact.

The funny thing was, the slapdash 50 year old powder actually worked better than modern carefully prepared homeopathic remedies. It seems that powders carefully extracted from dusty jars have a more powerful placebo effect than tables in a plastic tube.
 
I couldn't find it in the Organon. Lots of other nonsense in there, but not that particular tidbit.
 
OK, I looked it up, and I found this description:
In 1832, Korsakov described the method of 'dry grafting'. A single dry globule of a potentized remedy is put in a bottle half-filled with sugar globules. The bottle is shaken for five minutes, and this way all the globuli should be able to exert the influence of the initial remedy, "as if by contagion". Hahnemann approved of the idea, saying that it "is a sort of infection, bearing a strong resemblance to the infection of healthy persons by a contagion brought near or in contact with them".

(I also noticed this titbit, which really made me laugh: "Another technique involves a 'paper remedy' - "finds out what they need, writes the remedy down on a piece of paper, they put it in their pocket and it works." Well, I am sure it works just as well!)

Closer to home, we have had a discussion of grafting in this thread.
 
I suspect if you challenged Rustum Roy or any of his mates with that lot, he'd probably declare it to be complete BS. But of course the problem they have is that the evidence of efficacy for grafted remedies is just as good as for the conventionally-prepared things - anecdote and supposition. And if you pressed them on that point, you'd probably get something like, well, this phenomenon may be even stranger than we realise....

Rolfe.
 
Thought you lot might be interested in this...

Over at Ben Goldacre's site, I was looking at the graphs in figures 1 and 2 for this paper. I played around in Corel Draw, resizing and stretching figures so the scales match. When you superimpose the part of figure 2 that supposedly represents the 'envelope of difference' for 30C Nat Mur, onto the first graph in figure 1, which shows a comparison between 30C Nat Mur and 30C Nux Vom...the graphs are identical. So the same graph is supposedly representing two different things.

Apart from that, the curves in figure 1 are all from figure 2 (the envelope of differences figure), suggesting they are comparing extreme examples rather than 'representative' ones.

Of course, that's in addition to all the other basic errors that have previously been pointed out.
 
I'm new here, so I can't post URLs. That's quite annoying. If you put three w's in front of the following, I've posted the images there.

hawk-handsaw.blogspot.com/2007/08/very-bad-science.html

Not the best quality, but I hope you can see that they're the same.
 
Thought you lot might be interested in this...

Over at Ben Goldacre's site, I was looking at the graphs in figures 1 and 2 for this paper. I played around in Corel Draw, resizing and stretching figures so the scales match. When you superimpose the part of figure 2 that supposedly represents the 'envelope of difference' for 30C Nat Mur, onto the first graph in figure 1, which shows a comparison between 30C Nat Mur and 30C Nux Vom...the graphs are identical. So the same graph is supposedly representing two different things.

Apart from that, the curves in figure 1 are all from figure 2 (the envelope of differences figure), suggesting they are comparing extreme examples rather than 'representative' ones.

Of course, that's in addition to all the other basic errors that have previously been pointed out.


Thanks, Wilsontown (your real name's not Johnnie Scobie by any chance, is it?). I thought some of these spectra looked a bit similar!

I went over the PowerPoint slides of the data which have been available on his own web site for some time, and concluded that the alleged "ethanol blank" was such a big no-no that the whole set of UV spectra were so much waste paper. I really must try to read the whole of the actual paper, but I get the very strong impression that it's no more informative.

How can anyone with any sort of scientific expertise bring themselves to present such shoddy data?

Rolfe.
 
I've been at a loss to understand the point of Figure 2. "Envelope of differences within a series of 10 preparations supplied of each Homeopathic medicine: Nat mur and Nux vom."

They were supplied with 10 preparations of two 'medicines', from which they present six graphs, with no indication of what the closed or open circles mean, each graph showing two curves. Baffling.

At least we know that Nux vom is probably the open circles, seeing as one of the graphs is a copy of Figure 1. Well spotted!

Wouldn't it be interesting to know which member of the circle jerk of irrelevancy that is Homeopathy's review board, actually approved this paper? What really bothers me is that Elsevier keeps the journal behind a pay wall. One might expect some standard of review for the money that one pays.

Eh, maybe it was 'super peer reviewed'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom