But no "description" of a UV spectrum is going to mention a minor bump at 320 nm, even if it is there. Note that this supposed feature is claimed to be minimally detectable, which means that the extinction coefficient is probably less than 1/1000th of that at lambda max, if that. You can't find this in a general description of the spectrum (just as a description of the vibrational spectrum won't mention every single bump, either)
You'd really need to see the spectrum to examine it properly.
Where did you get this idea? Look at the "standard" spectrum in Roy's paper, it is not a minor bump at 324 nm. And the absorbance below that is way above the reported spectrum. You need considerable experience with spectra before you can argue with us about them. If you know what you are doing, you can get a lot of information from the published descriptions of spectra; otherwise it would be pointless to publish them.
Also, comparing your own spectra to his is a meaningless exercise since you don't know what impurities are causing his results. We know he is not using "spectral grade" ethanol. All you could say is yours look like his, or not.
Here is the Aldrich description of the spectrum of spectro grade ethanol
UV absorption λ: 205 nm Amax: 1.00
λ: 210 nm Amax: 0.65
λ: 220 nm Amax: 0.35
λ: 255 nm Amax: 0.04
λ: 300-400 nm Amax: 0.01
The stuff from 300 - 400 nm is 1% of the intensity at the 205 max. That IS a minor bump in the spectum.
Boys, just calm down a minute. I don't entirely see where the disagreement is. Pgwenthold, as far as I can make it out, the data you quote absolutely back up what JJM is saying.
Remember, this isn't a spectrum of a solute we're looking at here - it's the spectrum of the
solvent. Thus, concentration isn't a variable. Thus, the actual absorbance readings themselves are absolute values and can be compared.
The absorbance at 205, 210 and even 220 isn't the issue. These aren't
peaks Aldritch are defining, they're just points on a curve, and they're giving the maximum absorbance you can expect from their pure product at those wavelengths. Below 250 everything is just shooting up towards opacity, as all these solvents do - they transmit pretty minimally at low-UV wavelengths. What Aldritch are showing is what level of background absorbance you're going to get from this solvent at these wavelengths, and how this increases steeply as you get into the low-UV wavelengths.
JJM pointed this out here, which is the post that caused the penny to drop with me.
Maybe this page makes it clearer. Look at the table (about half way down) in the section headed "solvent cut-off wavelengths", which quotes wavelengths above which the solvents are considered to be suitable for UV spectroscopy, because they don't absorb too much.
In this table, approximate wavelengths (nm) are specified below which the solvent absorbance may be unacceptable. For quantitative work, the cut-off may be set at a wavelength (L0) where the absorbance for 10 mm pathlength of the solvent exceeds 0.05 absorbance unit (relative to water), i.e. A1 cm > 0.05. For qualitative work, it may still be feasible to work at significantly lower wavelengths and most analysts accept a cut-off based on the wavelength (L1) for A1 cm > 1.0. However, if the UV absorption curve rises steeply, the accessible wavelength range may not be greatly extended.
In this context they quote 240nm as the lowest useful wavelength for ethanol for quantitative work, but say it may be practical down to 205nm for qualitative work. Note how very steep that rise is - from pretty minimal to a high absorbance reading (usually, 1.2 to 1.5 absorbance units is considered to be as high as you can practically go without diluting the solution, as the logarithmic scale makes anything above that very imprecise - basically, you're tending towards opacity) in only 35nm. It's this rise that Aldritch's data are describing more exactly.
In effect, the part of the spectrum we're actually interested in is the 250 to 400nm range. Above that (in the visible region) nothing seems to be absorbing significantly, and below that anything in ethanol and certainly all of Roy's samples are in the "rising steeply" phase where no useful information is going to be obtained.
What we do know for sure from the Aldritch data (and from the NPL page) is that ethanol
does not absorb significantly in this range. The NPL table shows <0.05 units for everything above 240nm, and the Aldritch data records that we're down to 0.04 by 255nm, for spectroscopic grade ethanol. Frankly, considering that we're operating on a scale of 0 to about 1.2 units for a standard spectrophotometer, 0.05 is the backside of bugger-all.
Now compare that to the spectrum Roy presents for "plain ethanol". Yes, the shooting up towards opacity begins at a much higher wavelength (in fact just below 400nm), but also, in that context, the lambda-max blip (if you want to call it that) at about 325nm is also significant. (I wonder if it is closer to 330nm in the printed paper? - that would make it even more likely to be acetone, no?) Anyway, there is an absorbance there of about 0.65 units - just a tad more than 0.05, no? (Actually, 0.01 by 325nm, from the Aldritch data.)
I think we can be pretty sure that Roy did not get his "plain ethanol" from Hahnemann laboratories. I think it's pretty obvious he's picked up something in his own lab, presumably labelled "ethanol", but this something has had a very significant level of impurities in it, probably including acetone.
Now if we turn to his figure 3, we see in the top graph a huge difference between this "plain ethanol" and the "succussed ethanol". That's also showing a bit of a shoulder at 325, and another at about 280, but in the region we're looking at, the absorbance is overall very much less.
Anyone want to believe that shaking and diluting ethanol with itself removes UV absorbance from the compound? No, I didn't think so. And where do we think he got his "succussed ethanol"? Given that his astoundingly selective M&M section makes great play about the samples being "hand-succussed by trained experts", I think we know where - especially as three "potencies" are also shown for that substance. It's clear that Hahnemann Laboratories supplied the succussed ethanol samples, prepared by their "trained experts", in the same way as the Nux Vom and the Nat Mur, but without the addition of the mother tinctures.
Actually, this is good design. When we were discussing the slide show, which didn't have that figure, I said that was one of the things he should have done. However it all depends on proper provenance of the solvent for
all measurements, and this is where it completely falls down. He should have insisted that
all preparations came from the
same stock bottle, and also used that same stock bottle for his unsuccussed spectrum. But he didn't.
So, I believe he got all the succussed and diluted samples from Hahnemann Laboratories. And he got the plain ethanol from somewhere else, and that was filthy dirty.
So far so good.
Now what about these succussed and diluted samples?
In the previous thread about this, after JJM linked to the Aldritch data, Murthy posted rather more of it.
There are nine types of ethanols mentioned on this site.
http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/catalog/search/TablePage/14577624
See the data for 493546 Ethanol.
UV absorption λ: 240 nm Amax: 0.40
λ: 250 nm Amax: 0.30
λ: 260 nm Amax: 0.30
λ: 270 nm Amax: 0.10
λ: 340 nm Amax: 0.10
*************
This is the data for specroscopic grade
UV absorption λ: 210 nm Amax: 0.40
λ: 220 nm Amax: 0.25
λ: 230 nm Amax: 0.15
λ: 240 nm Amax: 0.05
λ: 270-400 nm Amax: 0.01
The difference of absorbance between the two grades is self explanatory.
Quite fortuitously, he seems to have spotted something. JJM picked up on it.
The "493546" Ethanol is potable, anhydrous ethanol. It is not as clean as the spectroscopic grade. No matter, neither corresponds to the spectrum of pure ethanol shown on p. 28 of the lecture you are promoting. Most particularly, and this is very important (so- pay attention), the slide on p. 28 shows an absorption max. at 325 nm which does not belong to pure ethanol.
The "nux vomica" spectra could simply be potable alcohol.
Indeedy, he has a point. If we were to plot the Aldritch data for the "493546" ethanol, it wouldn't be exactly the same as Roy's spectra for the succussed and diluted stuff. In fact these traces (the Hahnemann-supplied material) actualy absorb rather less than the quoted figures around 250-260nm. However, we're in the same general ball park.
Pipirr sent me a graph he'd done including the Aldritch spectroscopic and 493546-grade data for comparison with the Roy data from the slide show. I don't know why he didn't just post it here, but Pipirr - could you? Or would you mind if I did? It makes the point beautifully.
Also, the succussed stuff does vary itself. The Nat Mur traces are generally low-absorbance, and almost identical between the three potencies, while the Nux Vom absorbs rather more than the succussed ethanol, especially around 250nm, and there is more variability between the potencies.
So what I'm thinking is, first, as we concluded, the unsuccussed ethanol has a completely different provenance. However, we also have no guarantee that everything coming from Hahnemann laboratories all originated in the same stock bottle. So second, I think we're looking at slightly different sources of ethanol for each of the three hand-succussed preparations - no mother tincture, Nat Mur and Nux Vom respectively.
I've checked
the web page Roy quotes in his M&M section, and there's no mention of the source or grade of the "alcohol". But I know what many homoeopaths say they use and recommend. Could we possibly be looking at slight differences in the UV spectrum of different
bottles of vodka?
This is of course speculation, and I wouldn't dream of putting it in the letter we're discussing, but I'm suspicious the answer is close to this.
I still haven't digested everything in that paper, but I need to go to bed now! However, I'd like to know just how certain Wilsontown is that Roy has actually duplicated traces, rather than that we're just looking at almost-identical traces of the same basic stuff. If it's possible they're just similar then perhaps we shouldn't pursue that line too forcefully.
Nighty-night.
Rolfe.