Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Dana Ullmann posted once and ran, in the thread in "General Scepticism", wanting to know when we were all going to start on our supersized portions of humble pie, now that these great scientists had proved homoeopathy works.

On the basis of a special edition of Homeopathy? I don't think so. Get it into Nature, and get it independently replicated, then we'll see.

Rolfe.
 
How long must homeopathy fail to produce results before you throw in the towel and say "it doesn't work"?


To me, homeopathy, with regard to ingestible substances, is just the extracting of compounds from some plant source to enrich the body when ingested. You could, and they do, do that with 'regular' food. (Proper diet - and this isn't a 'one kind fits all' thing - is instrumental in good physical and mental* health.) The products of some companies definitively enrich. Some probably don't. Some don't. Some don't for some people, the same way some foods don't work for some people. Within the standard definition of homeopathy, I'm not saying either way. With regard to crystals and electronic gadgets, etc: (as with physical training) I'm always about less or no artifice; even if those things work, I don't think they're necessary.

What I'm getting at - and this will answer the above, as well as wollery and malbui - is apparently the majority of those in the homeopathic circle have a flawed conception of something that is actual; this would be a mitigating factor in 'scientists' replicating any experimental data; and, in general, those in the standard camp pick things to study, and conduct in such a manner, that will suit their needs - which are often industrial and from a conservative perspective. (Conservative, as in outlook - vs in operational practice.)


As to the ethical nature of this (or anything), that's irrelevant. People make ** bad decisions, encountre bad information, and people die. One can offer or make available information they think is beneficial, but helping to instate a conflict is, to put in relatively vague terms, distractive.

BSM: that's what it is to most involved here. Which is fine.


*I had a girlfriend who supposedely had ADHD. When it occurred, it was pretty unnerving, as she'd just bounce around, even if sitting. I gave her an environment that wasn't hectic, where she could relax, and even sleep through the night (without TV, even), and normalised her diet. She exclaims to this day that it was instrumental in her being so much more functional than before. But maybe I'm wrong...perhaps it was just the nazi environment that straightened her out.


**However, I'm not advocating free will. This is rather a reference of convenience.
 
To me, homeopathy, with regard to ingestible substances, is just the extracting of compounds from some plant source to enrich the body when ingested.

That isn't homeopathy. That would generaly be regarded as herbal medicine.


Within the standard definition of homeopathy, I'm not saying either way.

Generaly makeing up completely new defintions of words is unhelpful.
 
Ya all have a lot of knowledge on this, and are spending a lot of time discussing the topic. Perhaps that energy would be better spent assisting these folks, arranging and conducting the experiments yourselves, or doing something else.

I would like to assist these folks with a 2x4. They are so wrong there is no place to even start to correct them. The time an individual water molecule spends in a solvation shell around a typical water-soluble biomolecule is on the order of femtoseconds. That is the timescale on which water could have any sort of "memory".

Just answer me this question. The biotechnology industry spends billions to develop marketable drugs, 99% of which are water-soluble. Some of the developmental chemistry, most of the analyses, and virtually all of the end stage testing is done in aqueous systems. Don't you think if water had any such property, it would be obvious to these folk? Yet they never seem to take it into consideration.
 
To me, homeopathy, with regard to ingestible substances, is just the extracting of compounds from some plant source to enrich the body when ingested. You could, and they do, do that with 'regular' food. (Proper diet - and this isn't a 'one kind fits all' thing - is instrumental in good physical and mental* health.) The products of some companies definitively enrich. Some probably don't. Some don't. Some don't for some people, the same way some foods don't work for some people. Within the standard definition of homeopathy, I'm not saying either way. With regard to crystals and electronic gadgets, etc: (as with physical training) I'm always about less or no artifice; even if those things work, I don't think they're necessary.

What I'm getting at - and this will answer the above, as well as wollery and malbui - is apparently the majority of those in the homeopathic circle have a flawed conception of something that is actual; this would be a mitigating factor in 'scientists' replicating any experimental data; and, in general, those in the standard camp pick things to study, and conduct in such a manner, that will suit their needs - which are often industrial and from a conservative perspective. (Conservative, as in outlook - vs in operational practice.)


Where do you stand with regard to the basic principles of homoeopathy:

a) "like cures like"?

b) the dilutions used, and in particular the idea that the more dilute a remedy is, the more powerful it is?

ETA: And how about "miasms" and "psora"?
 
Last edited:
yes

Can now probably run FTIRs in my sleep.


Congratulations!!! Is this my fault for not keeping up with TRSOTTTWND, or for buggering off for nine months? Was it this year or last?

Sorry, what I really meant to say was, I do wish some people, particularly people who don't even have the first notion of what homoeopathy is and seem to think it's sort of herbal like, would stop butting in in threads about specific topics and go and play in a general thread somewhere.

So I'll take my congratulations to Community, and get back to studying Roy's dismal spectra.

Rolfe.
 
Sorry, what I really meant to say was, I do wish some people, particularly people who don't even have the first notion of what homoeopathy is and seem to think it's sort of herbal like, would stop butting in in threads about specific topics and go and play in a general thread somewhere.


Rolfe.

Hahahhaah. Rolfe doesn't seem to like tangents in these circumstances. Though, thank you, geni, I'll amend my classifications list. However, I adopt (and create) definitions within my own auspice. This applies often in regard to 'new age' stuff (it is rather generally hokey), but can also include more mainstream things. I don't play favorites.

pauite: I commented on it indirectly.

Mojo: I already generally commented on that. I don't bother myself with it any further. I have no idea what those last two things are, and in a brief search have found no definitions. I'll say again, much in new age is not, with regard to name and nomenclature, well-conceived; as well, standard medicine is flawed in its approach: it is largely about treating, rather than curing, things, and is only gradually becoming about prevention. Economics you know.
 
Last edited:
Hahahhaah. Rolfe doesn't seem to like tangents in these circumstances.


Hahahahahahahahha, you've been here for what, five minutes? And you've flitted from one homoeopathy thread to another, posting inane stream-of-consciousness garbage all over the place, even though these threads were created for very specific purposes. Thanks a bundle.

The problem with any discussion of homoeopathy round here, is that the actual point of the thread becomes lost as random homoeopaths just jump in and start declaring that "it works", and then all sense goes under the weight of requests for actual evidence. Even worse when it's a thread specifically about a specific technical paper that people want to discuss, you know, technically. Even worse when the poster doesn't even have the first clue what homoeopathy actually is, but couldn't care less because he just makes words mean anything he wants them to mean.

You want to muse about homoeopathy? Or maybe herbalism? Fine. Maybe get it straightened out which you mean, first. Then find a general thread, and post to it. Or even better, start one all of your own. Following the discussion about the UV spectra of grades of ethanol through your witterings is getting trying.

Rolfe. In a bad mood. See other thread for details.
 
Rolfe. In a bad mood. See other thread for details.

It's late - Get some sleep?
We'll all feel chirpier in the morning maybe.


ETA:
Well done Geni.
I didn't know, and I've not been away like Rolfe, so no excuses.
 
Yeah, you're right, but I'm fed up with homoeopaths spamming threads about specific subjects and completely derailing them. There's no bar to newbies starting their own threads, and I'm sure he'll get plenty replies.

I need to read Roy's paper more carefully. It's junk science, but I need to be clear exactly where the errors are. The problem then is that for media-type conversations it doesn't matter. The homoeopaths just declare that this great paper with these magnificent conclusions was published in a peer-reviewed journal, hey, we're vindicated. And it's the rest of us who are the wet blanket nitpicking naysayers.

Wake me up when Roy gets a paper in Nature on this. Because either it's groundbreaking enough to merit it, or he's doing it wrong.

Since he's obviously doing it wrong, to anyone who did basic undergraduate spectroscopy, and it's published in a woo-woo fanzine with scrutineering standards the Daily Mail would be ashamed of, then I expect to rival Rip van Winkle.

Rolfe.
 
Yeah, you're right, but I'm fed up with homoeopaths spamming threads about specific subjects and completely derailing them. There's no bar to newbies starting their own threads, and I'm sure he'll get plenty replies.

Um, I'll make consideration of that fragility and refrain from further disturbance.
 
Where do you stand with regard to the basic principles of homoeopathy:

a) "like cures like"?

b) the dilutions used, and in particular the idea that the more dilute a remedy is, the more powerful it is?

ETA: And how about "miasms" and "psora"?

Mojo: I already generally commented on that. I don't bother myself with it any further.


You have not said anything about either the principle of "like cures like" or the dilutions used in homoeopathy (you had only posted 14 times when you posted that, so it was a matter of only a few minutes work to check).

I have no idea what those last two things are, and in a brief search have found no definitions.


I'm not surprised: homoeopaths seem to have great trouble giving coherent definitions of these (and they don't really like talking about "psora" at all).

I'll say again, much in new age is not, with regard to name and nomenclature, well-conceived; as well, standard medicine is flawed in its approach: it is largely about treating, rather than curing, things, and is only gradually becoming about prevention. Economics you know.


And then we have the usual strawman attack on medicine (standard homoeopath approach #4, I believe).
 
Last edited:
To me, homeopathy, with regard to ingestible substances, is just the extracting of compounds from some plant source to enrich the body when ingested.
As others have noted, this isn't what is generally regarded as homeopathy, isn't what Rustum Roy and Dana Ullman are proposing, and isn't what is being discussed in this thread.

You could be talking about herbal medicine or dietary supplements here. Both have some degree of validity but are unfortunately tainted by quackery.

Fundamental to homeopathy is the idea that dilute solutions of a substance have a stronger effect than concentrated ones. Homeopathic remedies are often so dilute that not a single molecule of the substance remains.
 
To me, homeopathy, with regard to ingestible substances, is just the extracting of compounds from some plant source to enrich the body when ingested. You could, and they do, do that with 'regular' food.
(snip)

Question for you. What is the major difference between homeopathic remedies prepared at 6C, 12C, and 30C? Which preparation do you recommend for people to use when sick?
 
Thanks to Rolfe (and Pipirr) I have had the thrill of reading Roy's paper. There is no more information in the paper than in the slide show. We have already discussed it sufficiently- it is a collection of spectra of ethanol with varied contamination and, possibly, carelessly handled samples.

A lot of the references are to quack sources; some are spurious- referring to dilute solutions still containing solute.

Others have pointed out that, after introductory discussion of water properties and vague discussion of supramolecular "structure," there is an abrupt switch to spectra of ethanol. For the non-chemists here, the difference is quite large. The ethyl (CH3CH2-) group in ethanol cuts down on the ability to donate a hydrogen for bonding, and increases the congestion around the oxygen, making it difficult for another molecule to get close-enough for H-bonding. In similar molecules, the boiling point roughly tracks molecular weight. Although ethanol is more than twice the weight of water, it boils 22 degrees lower because intramolcular associations are inhibited.

Lack of critical explanations of the spectra and the abrupt switch from water to ethanol are such major flaws that this would not be accepted in even the worst technical journals. This is why I usually simply reject references to quack magazines.
 
So succussion and dilution can significantly alter the absorption properties of ethanol, and the experiment can be easily replicated by anyone with a spectrophotometer and a leather bound book. ;)

With that in mind, I wrote to Rao, the lead author of the paper, asking for clarification of a number of issues: the ethanol grade that was used, an explanation for the peak at 320nm, who supplied the samples and performed the succussions etc.

It's been a week and two days now and still no answer. Anyone else want a go?
 
So succussion and dilution can significantly alter the absorption properties of ethanol, and the experiment can be easily replicated by anyone with a spectrophotometer and a leather bound book. ;)
Actually, homeopathetics say you need extensive training to succuss with success. Whether hahnemann was clever, or lucky, that is their first line of defense against many critics. It anticipates "put an aspirin in a reservoir and the community it serves should never get headaches" or, "I did it myself and it didn't work."
With that in mind, I wrote to Rao, the lead author of the paper, asking for clarification of a number of issues: the ethanol grade that was used, an explanation for the peak at 320nm, who supplied the samples and performed the succussions etc.
On page 4, they go into great detail about the source of the homeo preps:
A Food and Drug Administration-regulated homeopathic
pharmacy (Hahnemann Laboratories, San
Rafel, CA) prepared samples of two different test
solutions in 16 ounce (450g), clear glass bottles [Type I
borosilicate glass] previously annealed at temperatures
between 600–700 1C for 15 minutes. One of the
solutions, [FONT=AdvMc_Times-i]Nat mur [/FONT](mineral: Sodium Chloride) and
the other [FONT=AdvMc_Times-i]Nux vom [/FONT](plant remedy, purchased as
tincture from Boiron) were diluted by the standard
Hahnemannian techniques in 95% ethanol and succussed:
a 30c potency is diluted (1/100)30 or 1060 from
the original material. They were hand-succussed by
trained experts [http://www.hahnemannlabs.com/preparation.
html] 3020 ¼ 600 times during the manufacturing
process. Each bottle was coded with an
unique number, the bottles were shipped together by overnight courier in the same box, with temperature sensor.​

However, they do not say where they got their succussed, pure ethanol Figure 3a, p. 5. It is typical for crappy research to go into exquisite detail where it is easy, and safe, and to overlook significant details in other cases.​

For example, I cannot figure out what Figure 2 means. On the one hand, they had two test solutions (see above) on the other hand, they seem to summarize 10 sample spectra. Huh? My best interpretation is that they sampled each prep 10 times, and they are showing how poor their reproducibility is with respect to the spectra.​

It's been a week and two days now and still no answer. Anyone else want a go?
I think your experience is instructive. BTW, thanks for helping get the paper.​
 
Actually, homeopathetics say you need extensive training to succuss with success. Whether hahnemann was clever, or lucky, that is their first line of defense against many critics. It anticipates "put an aspirin in a reservoir and the community it serves should never get headaches" or, "I did it myself and it didn't work."

It's such an irritating argument to use...

Still, on the face of it, it does appear to be a simple experiment. In contrast to basophil granulation or 77K thermoluminescence, it's very basic. As they said:

"The absorption spectra for unsuccussed ethanol is significantly different from: (a) the succussed ethanol and (b) succussed homeopathic remedies, Nat mur and Nux vom." Rao et al.

That sounds so refreshingly simple and clear-cut.

On page 4, they go into great detail about the source of the homeo preps:

But like you said, not about the ethanol controls. Did they get EtOH, EtOH 6C, 12C and 30C all from Hahnemann Labs? They only state that the Nux vom and Nat mur came from the supplier. If they succussed an ethanol sample that they themselves had, and used a different grade of ethanol for the diluting, it might explain the odd results in Fig. 3... I figured it was worth the asking.


It is typical for crappy research to go into exquisite detail where it is easy, and safe, and to overlook significant details in other cases.

Yes, essential that we know this nugget of information: "Each bottle was coded with an unique number, the bottles were shipped together by overnight courier in the same box, with temperature sensor."

And not the essential details that one would need to actually repeat the experiment.

For example, I cannot figure out what Figure 2 means. On the one hand, they had two test solutions (see above) on the other hand, they seem to summarize 10 sample spectra. Huh? My best interpretation is that they sampled each prep 10 times, and they are showing how poor their reproducibility is with respect to the spectra.

They say ten, I counted six. I have no idea what they meant with that figure...

I think your experience is instructive. BTW, thanks for helping get the paper.


Happy to help :)
 
Actually, homeopathetics say you need extensive training to succuss with success. Whether hahnemann was clever, or lucky, that is their first line of defense against many critics.


I'm pretty certain that Sam just said to bang it on a Bible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom