Homeopathy -grafts

When, out of curiousity, I tried OTC Arnica Montana by Boiron (sp?) for acute, not chronic, muscle pain relief last year, their clear written instructions were to use THREE to FIVE "pellets" at each dosage. Now I have to wonder WHY 3? Or maybe 4? Or how about 5??

BTW, no result of any kind, good or bad, though I took at least 50 of those little suckers over a several day period. Not to mention concurrently using the Arnica Gel.
 
HELLO,

Another similar subject PREPARING SANJEEVINI REFILLS(Grafting of healing remedy) for your scrutnizing:-

"A sample of the combination you have originally dispensed. You can either make it a practice to keep samples of everything you give out or ask your patients to bring back a few globules (6 to 8 globules are more than adequate) of the original combination given to them.
The Multiplication and Broadcasting Card - Exhibit 2 is the Multiplication and Broadcasting Card. If you need more copies of this card, feel free to make photocopies from Exhibit 2. Photocopies are as good as the original!
Place the "sample" in the small circle marked "sample" on the Multiplication and Broadcasting card.
Place the bottle containing fresh pills or vibhuthi in the circle marked "Output" on the Multiplication and Broadcasting card.
Leave for half a minute. Remember, chanting a prayer, mantra or affirmation while the Sanjeevinis are being prepared is good for the patient and the healer.
The medium in the "Output" circle is now ready, having been charged with all the vibrations that were in the original sample."
http://www.saisanjeevini.org/frames.htm(Go to Introduction & Instructions>>PREPARING SANJEEVINI REFILLS
for patients, with the Multiplication and Broadcasting Card

Looks to be a Gift for you---probably.;)
 
KFCA said:
When, out of curiousity, I tried OTC Arnica Montana by Boiron (sp?) for acute, not chronic, muscle pain relief last year, their clear written instructions were to use THREE to FIVE "pellets" at each dosage. Now I have to wonder WHY 3? Or maybe 4? Or how about 5??

BTW, no result of any kind, good or bad, though I took at least 50 of those little suckers over a several day period. Not to mention concurrently using the Arnica Gel.

Well of course dependin on the homeopath you speak to the commen resopnce will be one of tyhew following:

It was not the indicated remedy

You overdosed (allthough they probably will not use that word) and agrivated

You ate/drank something wich antidoted it

You are clearly insencertive to the remedy.
 
Kumar said:
Another similar subject PREPARING SANJEEVINI REFILLS(Grafting of healing remedy) for your scrutnizing:-
OK, sometimes clicking on "view this post" has its points.

Is any homoeopath prepared to criticise this method?

Rolfe.
 
Geni, you missed "you didn't have a full homoeopathic hour-and-a-half case-taking, and the remedy was not individualised."

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
OK, sometimes clicking on "view this post" has its points.

Is any homoeopath prepared to criticise this method?

Rolfe.
Thanks. I think, it may be difficult to criticise it?
 
Kumar said:
Thanks. I think, it may be difficult to criticise it?
Yes, it's difficult to say anything coherent when you're convulsed by uncontrollable laughter!

Do you still believe that the close(r than usual) approach of Mars inactivated homoeopathic remedies, Kumar?

Rolfe.
 
The bloke at Otherhealth is still banging on about how perfectly it works.
http://www.otherhealth.com/showthread.php?t=3412&page=3&pp=10&highlight=grafting

"Just because it has not been written about, does not mean it does not have value. As I said, I have seen a number of "old-time" homeopaths, using grafting on a regular basis. Where did they learn? From THEIR teachers-- Julia M. Green, Elizabeth Wright Hubbard, Eugene Underhill, etc. And where did *they* learn? From the earlier generation-- Austin, Grimmer, Tomhagen-- all pupils of Kent. The practice of grafting goes back to the early 1830s when Korsakov suggested it to Hahnemann.

It is used generally out of necessity-- to extend a potency that is no longer available.

If someone asked me for a DM (500,000) of a remedy that I had in an old bottle from some long-gone pharmacy, I would not hesitate to make a graft for them."

Now then, Barb, what's he got wrong? He's speaking from his experience and citing lots of lovely old authorities, but you don't believe in it. Why?
 
Rolfe said:
Do you still believe that the close(r than usual) approach of Mars inactivated homoeopathic remedies, Kumar?

Rolfe.
Frankly, I doubt it. But these are all related unseen fields. Do you think any scientific changes which may effect on earth--are possible by this or not?
 
Kumar said:
Frankly, I doubt it.
Wow, we've found one piece of arrant woo Kumar is prepared to doubt!

But why, Kumar? It's no less reasonable than the rest of this fictitious fantasy-world.

Rolfe.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:
If someone asked me for a DM (500,000) of a remedy that I had in an old bottle from some long-gone pharmacy, I would not hesitate to make a graft for them.
Does this not bring the question of expiry dates into play again? Are there any? How are they determined? How would you know if "an old bottle from some long-gone pharmacy" was any good or not?

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
Wow, we've found one piece of arrant woo Kumar is prepared to doubt!

But why, Kumar? It's no less reasonable than the rest of this fictitious fantasy-world.

Rolfe.
I know, you will discuss & oppose on every point--this way or that way. :D

Anyway, because I couldn't experiance it accordingly.
 
Rolfe said:
Does this not bring the question of expiry dates into play again? Are there any? How are they determined? How would you know if "an old bottle from some long-gone pharmacy" was any good or not?

Rolfe.


Barb just told us they last forever. So some dusty bottle found in an old trunk of Hahnemann's still contains that homeopathic dynamite.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:
The bloke at Otherhealth is still banging on about how perfectly it works.
http://www.otherhealth.com/showthread.php?t=3412&page=3&pp=10&highlight=grafting

"Just because it has not been written about, does not mean it does not have value. As I said, I have seen a number of "old-time" homeopaths, using grafting on a regular basis. Where did they learn? From THEIR teachers-- Julia M. Green, Elizabeth Wright Hubbard, Eugene Underhill, etc. And where did *they* learn? From the earlier generation-- Austin, Grimmer, Tomhagen-- all pupils of Kent. The practice of grafting goes back to the early 1830s when Korsakov suggested it to Hahnemann.

It is used generally out of necessity-- to extend a potency that is no longer available.

If someone asked me for a DM (500,000) of a remedy that I had in an old bottle from some long-gone pharmacy, I would not hesitate to make a graft for them."

Now then, Barb, what's he got wrong? He's speaking from his experience and citing lots of lovely old authorities, but you don't believe in it. Why?

It's hard to comment on this because as I said I am not ever on at otherhealth so haven't read any of the thread except what you just posted. Based on that however, I don't see why you would think I would say he has anything wrong. All I said about grafting was 1. I use it in liquid form occassionaly 2. I don't dry graft 3. I doubt it is AS EFFECTIVE... Thant does not mean I don't be bleieve it is effective at all, and it doesn't mean I think it is bunk or useless. I have my doubts but have no experience wiht it.
 
Barbrae said:
It's hard to comment on this because as I said I am not ever on at otherhealth so haven't read any of the thread except what you just posted. Based on that however, I don't see why you would think I would say he has anything wrong. All I said about grafting was 1. I use it in liquid form occassionaly 2. I don't dry graft 3. I doubt it is AS EFFECTIVE... Thant does not mean I don't be bleieve it is effective at all, and it doesn't mean I think it is bunk or useless. I have my doubts but have no experience wiht it.

Just savouring it. Thanks for that.
 
Look guys, we are wasting our time. All this thread is doing is stroking our collective egos. Those who might have different views are unlikely to ever look at it. Indeed, they are unlikely to have even heard of the JREF or the criticisms of homeopathy anyway.

Realists (some would call cynics) like us (hoi oligoi) ain’t never going to regard homeopathy as anything other than self-delusion foisted on gullible hoi poloi (including themselves) – along with other such lunacies as acupuncture, Reiki “healing”, feng shui, and a thousand others. In the town (in the UK) where I live we have a shop flogging Chinese “remedies”. If you read the posters in the window, they can cure anything from dandruff to a nasty case of death. Well, maybe not advanced dandruff. Whilst I don’t recollect ever seeing anyone in there, they have been around for a goodly number of years, probably more than 10. Perhaps they have cracked the secret of Breathanarism and don’t need to make money to eat – or pay the rent etc.

Just down the road, several times a week I walk past an outfit offering all manner of woo, including homeopathy. The trouble is that they offer “counselling” and “hypnotherapy”: one day I’ll go in and ask what kind of qualifications they have for either. A degree in psychology would be a good start. (As a matter of interest, I was a long time a member of the British Society for Experimental and Clinical Hypnosis: the minimum entry qualification was a degree in psychology.) They also offer chiropractic treatment. My sister-in-law spent a fortune on chiropractic “treatment” over a number of years until eventually she went to a NHS osteopath, who cured her problem in one visit. For free. Urinated off she was. Muchly.

We ain’t not never ever not knowhow no way going to convince hoi poloi that they are deluded. At best they will nod and smile and pity our “ignorance”. When challenged they will simply invent new rationalizations and justifications to support their delusions. So – is it worth bothering? Sometimes I just feel that the only pleasant thing about banging my head against a brick wall is that the pain stops when I stop doing it.

I appreciate that fixation on deluded “treatment” stops people from getting reliable treatment for real medical conditions, but perhaps that is what personal choice is all about. Maybe it’s Darwinian after all. Not so much the survival of the fittest, but more the non-survival of the unfittest. I can think of a number of other situations to which that applies. I can think of a number of people to which it also applies – mainly politicians. The trouble is that they have a habit of reproducing before the grim reaper gets to them.

So, why don’t we just reserve our efforts for areas in which we could win. OK, if we get one person to get real medical advice and treatment it will have been worth it. But is that going to happen?
 
And you revived an 8-year-old thread for this rant?

Fred
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom