Homeopathy -grafts

"Then please go stand next to an intelligent person for us, Kumar. About 10 years should do it."

Zep, probably, I am standing here next to you people & getting my energy propagate & spreaded.;)

titel_your-asean.gif
 
Kumar said:
"Then please go stand next to an intelligent person for us, Kumar. About 10 years should do it."

Zep, probably, I am standing here next to you people & getting my energy propagate & spreaded.;)
If this means what I think it means, forget it.

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
If this means what I think it means, forget it.

Rolfe.
Do you tell lie also? Ignore list do not work. Thanks. ;)

--------

Although anything can be possible in sub-atomic/Quantum WORLD, But I had great fight with my homeopathic pharmacy over this 'graft' issue. He was not agreeing about any such possibility. Either it is bit trade secret for him or HE is not knowing. I am bit doubtful about second possibility because he is a well experianced & studied homeopath.
 
MRC_Hans said:
Uhh, no. It appears not to be supposed to increase the effect. And your statement is not correct; homeopathy does not claim that the more dilute, the stronger. It must be potentized, which means diluted and succussed.

Hans

Correct, I forgot the shake'n'bake. (Did I just admit to a mistake? Gee, sorry to disappoint so many people...)

So, if you shake the glass, it becomes potentized? Don't travel by air, then!!
 
Kumar said:
Chewing the food or digestion may be somewhat alike it. More you dilute, grind, shake, triturate... the more efficient it gets.;)

What if you swallow the pills, and then get the hiccups?? :D
 
Zep said:
Then please go stand next to an intelligent person for us, Kumar. About 10 years should do it.

He must also be succussed. That is, jump up and down for ten years... :D
 
sodakboy93 said:
Sometimes, I wonder if homeopaths think they're magicians, or have some kind of special power that "normal" humans don't have. That's the only way I can explain why they believe all this stuff - because they think they have the power to violate rules of science of logic.
Oh, but they do!

WALACH, H. (2000) Magic of signs: a non-local interpretation of homeopathy. Br. Hom. J. 89, 127-140.

Rolfe.
 
Kumar said:


Although anything can be possible in sub-atomic/Quantum WORLD.

No it can't. with elcteron shell n can only be an integer and l can only equal whole number values between 0 and n-1.
 
Rolfe said:

So does it include pre-selected remedies to treat "allopathic" diagnoses, with no consideration of what the individual's presenting signs happen to be (Mark again, and Wim)? Mixing two or more remedies in one preparation, and/or giving them together (Mark)? Giving two or more remedies to the patient, alternated throughout the day (Wim, for example his take on Mark's hyperthyroidism treatment, each of the three remedies given t.i.d., but staggered, so that - allowing at least some time for sleep - you'd be giving a remedy every two hours)?

And now I'm particularly keen to hear her take on "grafting". Especially as (though I'm not sure about this) I think it was her who suggested to me that some pills being unmedicated was the reason for taking two at once.

I think you'll find that BHMS Mumbai was the only one at Hpathy who came even close to following Hahnemann's true homeopathy, and look what happened to him?

Barb? Hello, Barb? We don't believe you're not reading this stuff.
 
Kumar said:

p.s. Yes, Kumar, I had already heard of ASEAN, thanks, and had once thought it was a cleverly vague reference to your location rather than your mis-spelling of Asian. Now, I don't care.
 
Kumar said:
Although anything can be possible in sub-atomic/Quantum WORLD
NO! QUANTUM MECHANICS IS NOT A MAGICAL GET-OUT-OF-SCIENCE-FREE CARD COMMA DAMMIT FULL STOP

You want to make a claim about quantum mechanics, you'd better be prepared to either (a) show some math and/or (b) describe an experiment. But since you can't even do that for something as simple as a blind test of a disease treatment, I'm not gonna hold my breath.
But I had great fight with my homeopathic pharmacy over this 'graft' issue. He was not agreeing about any such possibility. Either it is bit trade secret for him or HE is not knowing. I am bit doubtful about second possibility because he is a well experianced & studied homeopath.
If you can graft remedies, he doesn't make any money. It's that simple.
 
Well, this is just as bad as chiros suggesting they can cure the blind by cracking some backs. All the mystical energy must be aligned and all.

All this "energy" that has no presence. All this magical invisible energy...

People are so goshdarn freakin asininely gullible.

By the way, I'm invisible, and I watch you all day long. If you believe homeopathy, then you can believe that no problem.
 
Kumar

Lothian asked,
"Can one CD transfer information to another by placing them together. Can one individual learn from another by standing next to them."

and Kumar replied.
"Yes, this can be first step towards "Energy Propagation"(EP)."

Wow, this was enough for me to go to my CP, learn about Ignore for the first time, and proudly add Kumar as my first - and only - entry.
 
Furthermore, on those occasions when you *can* transfer information from one part of a system to another, thermodynamics limits how much information you've got without putting more energy into the system. (and I mean real work-equivalent physics energy, not made-up woowoo mystical energy.)

Example: put two pieces of magnetic tape next to one another. Imagine one is a recording of, oh, say, Bing Crosby, and the other is blank. Leave them there for a loooooong time. So, if you listen to the second piece of tape, and sure enough, you're going to hear a faint recording of, guess what, Bing Crosby. But guess what else: the original recording has degraded by at least as much. The information transfer is two way, and while one tape is impressing Bing Crosby on the other, the other is *erasing* the first! (This actually happens, BTW, it's a hazard of magnetic tape stored on reels for a long time.)

To make a copy of a tape without destroying the original, you have to use an amplifier, and an amplifier requires energy. That's not just an engineering problem, it's fundamental to the nature of information.

So *even if there was* a mechanism to exchange information about therapeutic substances from one sugar pill to another (and there isn't any coherent explanation that I've ever heard of), the originally inactive pills would be impressing the state-of-not-being-active onto those pills that are activated (whatever the hell that means in homeopathy). The originals would degrade. If you're talking information theory (as some homeopathy "theorists" attempt to do), this isn't additional dilution, its a degradation in the quality of the "signal" and would therefore be expected to eventually destroy the effectiveness of those pills.

Now, one could argue that this is why homeopaths are encouraged to go to the supplier to get fresh remedies, but this does not explain why homeopaths seem to feel its ok to use grafting, or why its ok for the supplier to use grafting themselves. Rolfe's point is very relevant and bears repeating: either grafting works, and you can always do it, or it degrades, and you cannot rely on the effectiveness of a grafted remedy (or indeed the original remedy you grafted it from!) and therefore shouldn't graft.
 
Did no-one else find it funny that they call this particular homeopathic spell "grafting"?

Graft can also mean (Encarta Dictionary):

2. cheating by a corrupt individual: the use of dishonest or illegal means to gain money or property by somebody in a position of power or in elected office
3. money obtained corruptly: something obtained illegally by taking advantage of high position or office


:)
 
Rolfe said:
....snip...

And now I'm particularly keen to hear her take on "grafting". Especially as (though I'm not sure about this) I think it was her who suggested to me that some pills being unmedicated was the reason for taking two at once.

Rolfe.

Be interesting to see if any supporters of this magic do state the reason for "take two" is because some tablets aren't effective. Could you imagine the outcry if a real medicine was manufactured to such terrible standards?

e.g.

Doctor: Take two of these beta-blockers twice a day… just in case some of the tablets don’t contain any of the active ingredient.”
 
Originally posted by Barbrae
Do I believe grafting works? Do I graft my remedies?

I have never grafted a dry remedy, unless necessity dictates (ie - I run out). I will occasionaly use the principle to continue a water potency but even that is very rare.
This was Barb's post on one of the other threads where she was challenged about not having responded on this thread. (She said she'd tried to post here but the post didn't show up.)

OK, Barb, this is the place for this discussion.

Do you believe grafting works? You seem to say yes, by agreeing that you have on occasion (rarely) used that method. But then you seem to admit to doubt, by declaring that you would only do this "if necessity dictates".

I'm genuinely interested here. What is the evidence for the efficacy of grafting? Who first "discovered" it, and what evidence did he present to support his discovery? If it is perfectly effective, why should any homoeopath ever buy a remedy again? If it has problems, then again I would like to know about the evidence for these. Who has reported that a grafted remedy didn't work as expected? And under what circumstances?

If there is real doubt about the quality or efficacy of a grafted remedy, then how can anyone ever justify using the procedure? I suppose I can just about understand "better than nothing" if nothing else is obtainable (though really, only as a stop-gap), but many homoeopaths are presenting it as a perfectly viable alternative, without any warnings about possible disadvantages. Is this an ethical way to behave with people's health?

And "support the pharmacies" sounds extraordinarily protectionist. Why not just send them a charitable donation and be done with it?

Rolfe.
 
Zombified

From where energy comes to iron on which maget is rubbed to make it permanent magnet?
-----
We can only talk all these rubbish, when we shall be able to know & test 'quantums' fundamental, elementry particles etc. in full. Till then that is sufficient, as I recently concluded.

:p
 
CFLarsen said:
What if you swallow the pills, and then get the hiccups?? :D
May be hyperacidity--means over digestion--so excess absorption. Body may not be interested in more as swallowed pill, so made the sucking pills in mouth--probably. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom