Homeopathy -grafts

Kumar said:
From where energy comes to iron on which maget is rubbed to make it permanent magnet?
From another magnetic field. In the hypothetical case of a magnetic tape that I described above, the magnetic fields of the two pieces of tape both affect the other tape. The original recording is made with a magnetic field produced by a coil, where the energy comes from a current and an electromotive force, which was produced by an amplifier operating on batteries or line power.

We can only talk all these rubbish, when we shall be able to know & test 'quantums' fundamental, elementry particles etc. in full. Till then that is sufficiens, as I recently concluded.
I'm not sure what you think you're raving about here, but the evidence for quantum mechanics is very very strong. And I didn't just read it in a book, I've done some of the actual experiments myself. (it's fun!)

You don't get to cite quantum mechanics in support of some crazy notion, and then when I object because quantum mechanics doesn't imply what you think it does, say that we don't really understand quantum mechanics so it might happen anyway. Decide whether you agree with quantum mechanics or not, and then use it consistently or don't.
 
Zombified,

It was discussed in Elecromagnetic...topic that, on rubbing... photons can be produced & photons can cause permanent effects on any substance. I think these can also be got propagated if a carrier media is provided to these. On applying Kinetic energy by rubbing magnet on iron, it can be converted & stored as PE or/and propagated energy in iron piece. What is the confusion now? This concept can somewhat be applicable on other substances. However, when we say it can't be applicable on other substances--then only I say that science may not yet be able to understand this other's substances concept in full because very minute in nature.

Hope I am clear to you now.

-------

Since, I concluded & exausted a bit & it is TOO MUCH BY SO MANY REPEATIONS, I may not be able/capable to attend in FULL. Sorry & thanks.
 
Barb, please come and tell us about grafting - who discovered it, and when, and what evidence he presented that the grafted product was active? Are grafted remedies just as active as the original? If so, why should anyone (homoeopath or pharmacist) ever bother to do the diluting and succussing more than once? If not, what is the evidence for any lack of efficacy? How can any homoeopath justify using the procedure if it doesn't produce quality remedies? Why do those referring to the procedure not state more clearly what the dangers are?

And if grafting is a real effect, and if (as you've often told us) a dose is a dose is a dose irrespective of the number of pills, why do the bottles of OTC remedies tell people to take two pills as a single dose?

Rolfe.
 
OK, I had a closer look at the text file, and Warmly-Maria does answer some of these questions to some extent.
best to buy a remedy from a reputable pharmacy.
Grafting does work, but remember there is a chance of contamination, a chance that the remedy you tried to graft was inactive, or not good.
So in a way it's back again to the impossible quality control question. There is no agreement regarding expiry dates of remedies, or storage conditions, or conditions which might inactivate remedies (security scanners, daylight, touching the pills etc.). So nobody can be at all confident that any remedy is in good condition, because there are no clear guidelines about how it should be handled.

Some have suggested that remedies gradually lose their potency with time. Some have said that this will not happen if they are protected from sunlight. Some have said that airport security scanners will inactivate remedies. Some have said that touching a pill with the bare fingers will inactivate it. Some have said that storing remedies close to perfumed toiletries or other "aromatic" substances will inactivate them.

And then, for all these suggestions, there are other homoeopaths who hotly deny that this is the case.

The one thing you will never see is any suggestion for a means of testing to see who is right. Because they all know that there is no way at all to conduct such a test. Homoeopathic remedies have no properties that can be measured in any way at all that will demonstrate whether they are "good" or "active", or not.

It's quite funny to hear some of them going on about the "energies" as if it's an accepted and proven fact that these energies exist. No, physics, that can measure the spin on a single electron (or so I am reliably informed), denies that these things have any energy at all, different from the ordinary energies of the blank carrier material.

So, we have no quality guarantee at all regarding homoeopathic remedies. Any of them. Because a grafted remedy might inadvertently have been prepared from an inactive remedy. So by the same token any remedy might be inactive. And we have no way of knowing, no way to test. In spite of Warmly-Maria asserting
Our pharmacies spend a lot of time, effort and money guaranteeing the quality of what they sell. The remedies are worth the cost.
there is no way to be assured of this.

However, one question still hasn't been adequately addressed at all. Why do Boots tell people to take two pills as a single dose?

Rolfe.
 
Hello, Barb...[taps on inside of computer screen]...are you out there? Bring Sarah back as well, please.
 
Rolfe said:
... Some have said that storing remedies close to perfumed toiletries or other "aromatic" substances will inactivate them.

And then, for all these suggestions, there are other homoeopaths who hotly deny that this is the case.
To rephrase the point I made earlier, if information can be "grafted" in one direction then it ought be grafted the other way. What prevents an inactive pill from grafting the state of inactiveness onto an active pill? What prevents, say, a nearby tube of Immodium (for non-USians, a OTC diarreah medication) from imprinting itself on your remedies and stopping up the works?

Another question is, how is grafting any different than normal dilution, especially if its some mystical energy pattern and not actual atoms that are the key. How is contamination prevented? How do you make sure it's the "right" pattern that takes? I think all the same questions about grafting may be asked of regular dilutions.

And to reiterate Rolfe's excellent point, how could you ever tell?

It's quite funny to hear some of them going on about the "energies" as if it's an accepted and proven fact that these energies exist. No, physics, that can measure the spin on a single electron (or so I am reliably informed), denies that these things have any energy at all, different from the ordinary energies of the blank carrier material.
Indeed, very precisely. It is a very rigorous test of quantum electrodynamics, I think it's to something like 20 decimals. (I assume you meant the electron's magnetic moment, which is the product of spin and gyromagnetic ratio. ;) )

The word "energy" means something very specific in physics. Confusion invariable results when you conflate the technical meaning of a word with a looser, colloquial meaning. It's only energy if you can use it (hypothetically at least) to boil water or shove weights around.

Of course, replacing the misused "energy" with any other term won't help matters much...
 
Zombified,

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the information "transferred" due to the tapes being in close proximity is not coherent. The sets of magetised particles do have interfering magnetic fields but there's no way that half of the Bing Crosby song will suddenly appear in the middle of a Korn track in a way that's intelligible.

In the same way, the energy and particles that are released from a nucleus cannot be reassembled into the same nucleus. This contasts sharply with homoeopathy in which it's supposed that the "energy" released into the solvent somehow retains the same characteristics as the original substance.

(forgive any cognative dissonance, Czech lager has that effect on a chap)
 
The Don said:
Zombified,

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the information "transferred" due to the tapes being in close proximity is not coherent. The sets of magetised particles do have interfering magnetic fields but there's no way that half of the Bing Crosby song will suddenly appear in the middle of a Korn track in a way that's intelligible.
Well, if one of the tapes is blank you'd hear a very faint, noisy version of the signal on it after a long time. There's no spooky quantum stuff going on there, that's just classical magnetism - you've got a ferromagnet in the field produced by another ferromagnet (that is, small regions of tape sandwiched close together). If both had a program that signal would likely swamp the signal imposed by the other. Given long enough time everything would average out to unintelligable noise, though.

In the same way, the energy and particles that are released from a nucleus cannot be reassembled into the same nucleus. This contasts sharply with homoeopathy in which it's supposed that the "energy" released into the solvent somehow retains the same characteristics as the original substance.
Yes, a problem with homeopathy (whether in normal succussion or grafting) is that there's a specific, chosen piece of information that supposedly gets copied a lot without any extra energy being added, without destroying the original, and without copying the other "signals" present.
 
I've got a tape somewhere of something that begins with a noisy fanfare, and the blank bit at the beginning actually plays a faint version of the opening fanfare. But to be honest I'm not sure if it's the tape picking up its own signal from the winding, or the grooves of the original record I pirated being too close together and the needle picking up the fanfare on its previous revolution. I guess timing the effect would answer the question.
Badly Shaved Monkey said:
Hello, Barb...[taps on inside of computer screen]...are you out there? Bring Sarah back as well, please.
Deafening silence on this thread, even though I took the trouble to copy Barb's relevant post over here. They can spend plenty of time arguing about the legitimacy of the term "allopathy", or objecting to the same sort of insults they dish out all the time, and even posting useless posts that evade all questions, but get involved in a slightly tricky area - where aaaarrrrrreeeeeee yyyyyyooooooouuuuuuuuu.......

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
I've got a tape somewhere of something that begins with a noisy fanfare, and the blank bit at the beginning actually plays a faint version of the opening fanfare. But to be honest I'm not sure if it's the tape picking up its own signal from the winding, or the grooves of the original record I pirated being too close together and the needle picking up the fanfare on its previous revolution. I guess timing the effect would answer the question.
Tape wound on a spool can certainly have this happen, its a limit to the longevity of magnetic tape recordings, particularly in such applications as data backups. If it the spiral of the original LP, the delay should be 33-1/3 RPM / 60 seconds, or 555 ms or whatever. :)

Now, to be on-topic: I am getting more and more curious how the signal of interest (or the "energy pattern of the remedy" or however you want to describe it) gets amplified, and why no other signals do.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:
Hello, Barb...[taps on inside of computer screen]...are you out there? Bring Sarah back as well, please.

Oh dear - so sorry I wasn't sitting at my computer all day to address you. Sorry I was at my daughters 5th birthday party, gee, I shoul've told her I couldn't go because then I would be accused of avoiding you very important folks here.
 
Rolfe said:
They can spend plenty of time arguing about the legitimacy of the term "allopathy", or objecting to the same sort of insults they dish out all the time, and even posting useless posts that evade all questions, but get involved in a slightly tricky area - where aaaarrrrrreeeeeee yyyyyyooooooouuuuuuuuu.......

Rolfe.

AT my daughters birthday parrrrrtyyyyyyyyyyy.

Boots tells people to take 2 pills because it has become the general standard.
 
Barbrae said:


Boots tells people to take 2 pills because it has become the general standard.

Really. The product is that unreliable that the standards have to reflect that? Nevermind that, but why bother? It won't matter if you take two or fifty.
 
Rolfe said:
This was Barb's post on one of the other threads where she was challenged about not having responded on this thread. (She said she'd tried to post here but the post didn't show up.)

OK, Barb, this is the place for this discussion.

Do you believe grafting works? You seem to say yes, by agreeing that you have on occasion (rarely) used that method. But then you seem to admit to doubt, by declaring that you would only do this "if necessity dictates".

I have found this to work with liquid potencies, I have no experience in using the dry gr]fting.


I'm genuinely interested here. What is the evidence for the efficacy of grafting? Who first "discovered" it, and what evidence did he present to support his discovery? If it is perfectly effective, why should any homoeopath ever buy a remedy again? If it has problems, then again I would like to know about the evidence for these. Who has reported that a grafted remedy didn't work as expected? And under what circumstances?

I don't know, I have my strong doubts that grafting is as effective as traditional remedy production.

If there is real doubt about the quality or efficacy of a grafted remedy, then how can anyone ever justify using the procedure? I suppose I can just about understand "better than nothing" if nothing else is obtainable (though really, only as a stop-gap), but many homoeopaths are presenting it as a perfectly viable alternative, without any warnings about possible disadvantages. Is this an ethical way to behave with people's health?

if they have evidence to support it's efficacy

And "support the pharmacies" sounds extraordinarily protectionist. Why not just send them a charitable donation and be done with it?

Not sure what you are talking about

Rolfe.
 
Eos of the Eons said:
Really. The product is that unreliable that the standards have to reflect that? Nevermind that, but why bother? It won't matter if you take two or fifty.

In the US they have to put a dosing requirment and a indication on the remedy bottle - BOTH are totally against classical homeopathic principles but it is the law. 2 pellets works well for the vast majority of people, (by the way Rolfe - I never EVER said a dose is a dose is a dose - try listening sometime) however, as with all things about homeopathy dosing needs to be individualized so indeed a very sensitive person could need only one pellet -- yet aggravate on 2 and indeed, grafting could come in handy at this point for these individuals that are so sensitive.
 
Barbrae said:
I don't know, I have my strong doubts that grafting is as effective as traditional remedy production.


How can you tell? It looks like you would want to use "it doesn't" work as your defence against the patent lunacy of "dry grafting". Well, that's OK, of course it doesn't work, but why are there homeopaths out there saying it works perfectly? How can they be so wrong

Barbrae said:

if they have evidence to support it's efficacy

That's a big "if". You say, "I have my strong doubts that grafting is as effective as traditional remedy production", so you must have evidence to the contrary. So, away you go, marshall your evidence against and their evidence for the efficacy of grafted remedies.
 
Sarah-I said:
I have never used grafting at all. If I run out of any remedy I go to Helios in London and buy some more.
We're not really asking whether you yourself use this method. We want to know if you agree that it's a valid practice, and a useful way of getting remedies.

If not, do you have any comment about the generally favourable reception the idea received at H'pathy? What about all these eminent homoeopaths who are reported to have used the practice routinely and reported just as good results as you report for your classical remedies? What about Barb, who has used the method occasionally, for want of anything else? Was this reasonable under the circumstances, or might she as well have given a blank pill?

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe,

Just for purposes of clarity, what Barb said was that she had used grafting with LM potencies. She has not used dry grafting with the centesimal potencies, if what I can gather from her post is correct.

There is a difference here. I have seen grafting work well for the LM's. At times, if a patient at the clinic has run out of their LM potency before a follow up consultation and they need to continue it, they will be told to fill the bottle up with water.

For the other potencies, I have never seen this done and I would suspect that grafting in this way results in a weaker potency of the remedy. The thing is that it is so easy just to go along to Helios and purchase the remedy freshly made up. It is easy to medicate yourself too. If you have a bottle of sac lac, then you can buy a medicating potency from Helios and just medicate it yourself.

I really cannot comment properly on grafting, as I have never done it except with LM's, but I do wonder about the efficacy of it.
 
That is a reasonable reply, thank you.

However, do you have any comment about the practice of "questionable" methods? You see, this is just another one of the list of things homoeopaths can't seem to agree on that we find so frustrating. Other things included....

Do remedies have an expiry date?
Does light inactivate remedies?
(Does the approach of Mars inactivate remedies, as was claimed on the old HH board?!)
Do airport security scanners inactivate remedies?
Does drinking coffee inactivate any (or all) remedies?
Does the contraceptive pill inactivate remedies?
Does touching the pills inactivate remedies?
Why do labels on commercial remedies say to take two pills?

And I think there were more but I can't remember right now.

You see, it's all about testing and quality control. Real medicines are tested all round the houses. It's possible to tell when a product is good and when it has deteriorated. Thus, objective expiry dates and storage and handling conditions can be defined.

If there were a suspicion that something like drinking coffee inactivated a medicine, pharmacologists wouldn't just argue about it in the abstract, they'd design and perform experiments to test what the true situation was. Ditto security scanners or whatever.

And if anyone was seriously claiming that it was possible for blank pills to be put into a bottle of aspirin or something and take on the properties of aspirin, it wouldn't just be debated, they'd be invited to prove it, and their evidence would be put to the test.

So, we'd learn something.

Why do you have such faith in homoeopathy when such testing is neither possible nor attempted?

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom