Take a close look at this comment (from "Caroline")
I was taught this method by Phyl Eyre and she never reported any remedy failures. If the energy truely does expand outside the bottle, then I cannot quite see why it would not be possible to continue to re fill bottles. I never doubted this method, until qualified homoepaths said that one of the reasons they prescribe a remedy, say 3 times over 3 hours, or morning and repeat at night, is because they "don't quite trust the remedy / not all the pills may have been medicated" (I guess this is also a working example of what some will call a "split dose"!!)
Julian, I accept the need to support the pharmacies, but whilst Nelsons etc. continue to print on their containers, "take 2 pillules..." I shall continue to educate those who will listen.
And also, often, just sheer economics force this choice of extending quantities of certain remedies...
I'm not sure I quite have her argument straight, or on which side of the argument she's actually coming down. However, there is a very valid point in here.
When I was trying that stupid Belladonna proving, I noticed that the bottle (bought in Boots) said on it that two pills should be taken twice daily. I asked at H'pathy what the point of the two-pill instruction was, because most of the posters there were taking the line that a dose was a dose was a dose, irrespective of the number of pills. (Apart from anything else, it's part of the stock homoeopath answer to the "I just scarfed this entire bottle of homoeopathic sleeping pills" stunt.) So, were Boots just trying to double their sales?
I was quite stunned by the reply, that maybe not all the pills in the bottle had been medicated, so taking two doubled your chance of getting a dose. This of course implies diabolical working practices and worse quality control, and frankly I simply don't believe it. Making sure that the entire batch does get medicated is so childishly simple that no manufacturer could possibly be allowing such poor practice. Then of course we got into the argument about how can you quality control a manufacturing process where you can't in any way whatsoever distinguish the finished product from the raw material, and relationships rather deteriorated from that point.
I just pegged the "unmedicated pills" excuse as yet another one from the lexicon of what we blame it on when for some reason the remedy doesn't appear to have done anything. Along with someone having touched the pill, airport security scanners, exposure to the close approach of Mars and drinking a cup of coffee (not to mention taking the contraceptive pill). I never did get an answer to why the twice-daily repetition of the remedy when Hahnemannian practice would seem to prohibit this, but that's a constant battle with these people anyway.
However, the excuse would seem to be completely blown out of the water by this "grafting" stunt. In fact, all Boots would have to do would be to ensure that there were one or two medicated pills in the bottle, and fill up with blanks. Hey, maybe they do that! The more I hear of the range of legitimate ways of producing homoeopathic products, the more of a money-spinner it seems to be.
So, either pills in the same bottle all take on the properties of the medicated ones, and so the grafting stunt is valid, or this doesn't happen, in which case precautions to avoid taking an inadvertently unmedicated pill may be advisable. They can't have it both ways. So which is it?
And they get all huffy when you complain that they themselves are full of internal contradictions!
Rolfe.