HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

Robinson, if you replace the word HIV (I know, it's actually an acronym, and now I've spent more time explaining that I am aware of the difference than I would have spent just typing "acronym") in your post #60 with the word "flu", you would be correct as well. A malnourished child with the Flu is a different patient than a wealthy, first-world child with the flu. HIV, however, while responding to intense medical intervention, is very different because it never goes away. HIV is not a passing infection that may be warded off for a while, ever after defeated. HIV has not been shown to ever be defeated (that boxer dude is an interesting case, but parsimony suggests that he is simply using fraudulent samples), and if not kept in check, HIV will always eventually cause AIDS. Yes, radical drug regimens have restored a life of sorts to many HIV+ people, but like metastatic cancer, every time a person decides that a temporary return to normalcy implies their overall welness and suspends medical care, that person soon dies.
One more point, as you are not one of the truly insane "HIV treatment causes AIDS" crowd, the greatly increased life-expectancy of HIV+ people is due exclusively to the assumption that HIV is the virus that causes AIDS.
 
Nope. The data was clear. HIV test don't detect HIV, they detect anti-bodies, and they are not to be trusted. If you hear somebody claim you have HIV based on a Western blot, they are full of it.

No test detects HIV. Even the most advanced testing doesn't detect HIV. The manufacturers own literature tells you this.
I think the problem here is a lack of understanding of the terminology. It is very precise. Robinson, you said in your OP "HIV can be detected in the blood of dogs" HIV refers to the virion itself specifically. So that statement is wrong. What is correct is that "anti-HIV antibodies can be detected in dog's blood"

And as skeptigirl has pointed out, there are two PCR tests which detect HIV. One detects the RNA inside virions and other detects the integrated DNA (the provirus) inside the host cells.
 
Robinson, your conclusions seem to sum up the situation pretty well. I think it is wrong to get too hung up on which subtype of retrovirus is similar to another - if one thing, the research done in the last 10 years shows that this is a complex and evolving field. Assumptions made 10 years ago may not hold true when looked at with today's technology for looking at molecular viral epidemiology. The retroviruses are certainly a bit schitzoid, if nothing else.
And we haven't even got onto the topic of other mammalian retroviruses (FIV, BIV etc) or the thorny issue of endogenous retroviruses and what they mean, what they do and how they arose. (no - please don't go there...)

http://jvi.asm.org/cgi/content/abstract/74/1/529

"were positive for HIV-1 by Western blotting"
HIV is found in chimps and monkeys.
HIV doesn't make chimps and monkeys sick.

No no! It isn't HIV, it is SIV! It somehow becomes HIV!

An interesting paper. I need not remind you that "were positive for HIV-1 by Western blotting" is not the same as saying "were HIV-1 infected"
The closer related the viruses are, the more cross reactivity on tests for antibody. The exact relatedness depends on studying the molecular genetics, which is what they have tried to do in this paper.

This paper also shows how analysing the genotypic information in just 4 chimps can yield lots of new info (and generate publications!). What on earth might they find if they could sequence 100 chimps? Something that would make their conclusions here seem invalid? Possibly. Someone will eventually sort things out I guess.

I am afraid I do not know enough of the field of retroviruses to know if this paper's results are of low significance on the wow scale, highly significant or even if it has been confirmed or refuted since it was published (2000). That is one of the problems picking out individual papers that are thrown up form long ago on pubmed. One lacks the context.

This paper is only one of thousands. A search in just this one journal (Journal of Virology) for both SIV and HIV in the title or abstract within the last 10 years throws up over 200 papers, all available in full text. Enjoy, (and I'll catch your next post in 2009!)

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) groups
M, N, and O are considered to result from at least three independent
introductions of simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) cpz
from chimpanzees into the human population (23). Four subspecies
of chimpanzees are currently recognized: Pan troglodytes
verus and P. t. vellerosus in West Africa, P. t. troglodytes in
Central Africa, and P. t. schweinfurthii in East Africa (6, 17).
The three SIVcpz viruses so far fully characterized originate
either from P. t. troglodytes (SIVcpz-gab1 and SIVcpz-US) or
from P. t. schweinfurthii (SIVcpz-ant) (4). SIVcpz-ant was isolated
in former Zaire (19) and does not cluster within HIV-1
group M, N, or O (4). The closest relatives of HIV-1 have been
found in P. t. troglodytes, and it has been suggested that this
subspecies is the primary reservoir of HIV-1 (4). SIVcpz-gab1
was thus isolated from a wild P. t. troglodytes chimpanzee
caught in Gabon (20), and is particularly related to HIV-1 N in
env (23). The more recently characterized SIVcpz-US, from a
P. t. troglodytes born in 1959 in an unknown Central African
country, is even more closely related to HIV-1 N in env (4). It
has been suggested that HIV-1 N arose through ancient recombination
events between SIVcpz-US-related viruses and
other SIVcpz strains in P. t. troglodytes, and subsequent transmission
to humans (4). If this is so, SIVcpz viruses phylogenetically
strongly related to HIV-1 group N might circulate in
the same geographic area as group N viruses. All HIV-1 N
viruses so far isolated originate from Cameroon (23). However,
it is not known whether chimpanzees from Cameroon
harbor SIVcpz viruses or whether these viruses are related to
HIV-1. In addition, Cameroon is a major epidemiological center
of group O viruses, but SIV clustering with group O (or
group M) has not been identified yet. This prompted us to
screen wild-born chimpanzees from Cameroon in order to look
for HIV-1-related viruses in these apes.
Phylogenetic analysis of mtDNA from the three source
chimpanzees in our study showed that two animals (Cam3 and
Cam5) belonged to P. t. troglodytes (Fig. 3). The third seropositive
chimpanzee (Cam4) did not cluster with P. t. troglodytes
but with the P. t. vellerosus lineage (Fig. 3). This classification
of Cam4 based on the mtDNA sequence fits with the geographic
origin of the chimpanzee (Southwest Cameroon). This
is the first time that a West African chimpanzee has been
shown to be infected by SIVcpz. Serological and genetic analysis
suggest that Cam4 was infected by Cam3 in captivity,
although we cannot totally exclude that the virus crossed from
Cam4 to Cam3. It is the first documented case of cross-subspecies
transmission of SIVcpz in captivity. As both apes were
males, transmission might have occurred through biting, a
common route of lentivirus transmission in animals (18),
and not by sexual contact. (but then you never know...!)
These data also confirm
that P. t. troglodytes is a natural host of HIV-1-related viruses,
since Cam5, and maybe also Cam3, was infected in the wild.
Although HIV-1 group M- and O-related viruses have not
been identified yet in chimpanzees (or in any other nonhuman
primate species), these African apes are clearly the best candidates
for explaining the origin of HIV-1. HIV-2, as is generally
agreed, originates from SIVsm present in a West African
nonhuman primate, the sooty mangabey (5). The ancestors of
SIVcpz and SIVsm, in contrast, are still totally unknown. The
reservoir of SIVcpz and SIVsm (if it still exists) would be a
further key to understanding the origin of these primate lentiviruses.
In conclusion, we demonstrate that SIVcpz and closely related
HIV-1 viruses currently cocirculate in both wild chimpanzees
and humans from the same geographic area, providing
a further step towards the missing link between HIV-1 and
related viruses in nonhuman primates.
 
HIV is spread by mothers milk.
Spread by brestfeeding. may be due to blood contact.

Maybe. But actually, it may be more because the baby's stomach is not that impervious to viruses during the first 12 hours or so after birth, which allows the mother to pass him/her antibodies through a special kind of milk called collostrum. This way the baby is protected for the first few months of life, during which its immune system is not fully operational. Antibodies for HIV may also be passed this way of course, which makes the Western Blot test unreliable for some time on infants born of HIV+ mothers.

the Kemist
 
Revisiting...

These are wrong.

Your words in italics, my additional commentary in Bold.

HIV is found in chimps and monkeys. You mean SIV. Although HIV can infect chimps.
Nope. Both chimps and monkeys have been injected with many HIV strains.
HIV doesn't make chimps and monkeys sick. You mean SIV, see above.
Nope. HIV injected into any primate has not caused them to develop AIDS. HIV is found after infection, it just doesn't cause AIDS.
HIV isn't just one retrovirus. Maybe you are confusing with HIV-2, HTLV-I and HTLV-II? For most purposes people mean HIV-1 when they say HIV.
Nope. Evidence shows there are multitudes of HIV retroviruses. Just the ones created for research alone number in the hundreds.
HIV can be detected in healthy dogs blood, using standard tests.
Yep, because the test are fooled. Only very advanced test can detect that no HIV actually exist.
HIV has made some people very very wealthy.
Yep. Gallo for one, but there are many others.
HIV is not allowed to be debated by the ruling class.
Questionable.
HIV does not act like any known retrovirus.
Unless you count SIV, which is very similar, and believed to be the source of HIV.
HIV is a harmless passenger virus.
In primates and people who are immune, it a harmless passenger virus
HIV can be spread by infected vaccines.
Yep. So can SV40 and Primate Foamy virus.
HIV resembles retroviruses used in cancer research. Which viruses specifically?
Good question. Ask Gallo, he knows all about it, having worked with retroviruses since 1960, including ones from primates, modified for research. Source:
HISTORICAL ESSAY: The Early Years of HIV/AIDS
Gallo
Science 29 November 2002: 1728
Retroviruses are found in every mammal species, and cats have their own FIV, which behaves almost exactly like HIV, except in cats only.

HIV is found in dogs, cats, pigs and rats, and in mosquito guts.
Again, it is because the test show false positives. Except Mosquitoes, if they suck infected blood, HIV is found in their guts.
HIV reproduces in Chimps and Monkeys. Chimps only.
Questionable.
HIV infections began in New York City and San Fransisco.
That one appears to be a myth.
HIV was late in infecting Africa.
Technically, not true. AIDS was late in showing up, but HIV is claimed to have infected Africans long ago.
HIV can't be contracted from lab monkeys or chimps.
False. HIV can be contracted from lab animals.
HIV was not made in a lab, or spread by medical procedures. It was spread by infected factor VIII clotting factors in haemophiliacs.
And blood transfusion, and shared needles, and organ transplants, and medicines made from infected organs or blood.
HIV can be joined with other organisms, (Chimeras), and many kinds of HIV strains are created by scientist to study it. Only parts of HIV can be genetically engineered with other viruses/bacteria.
That is what a Chimera is, part HIV, part SIV, or part E. coli. Pure HIV is however modified in the lab for research purposes.
 
Last edited:
Capsid- "These are wrong"
And my comments in blue.
Your words in italics, my additional commentary in Bold.

HIV is found in chimps and monkeys. You mean SIV. Although HIV can infect chimps.
Nope. Both chimps and monkeys have been injected with many HIV strains.
I think Capsid is referring to natural infections. I can inject HIV into a potato, that doesn't mean HIV "is found" in potatoes.

HIV doesn't make chimps and monkeys sick. You mean SIV, see above.
Nope. HIV injected into any primate has not caused them to develop AIDS. HIV is found after infection, it just doesn't cause AIDS.
You seem to both be in agreement here really - HIV doesn't make chimps sick usually, although there have been reports of a couple of lab animals in one study getting "AIDS". SIV of course does not make African primates ill, but will cause SAIDS in Asian rhesus macaques to whom it is a quite "foreign" virus.

HIV isn't just one retrovirus. Maybe you are confusing with HIV-2, HTLV-I and HTLV-II? For most purposes people mean HIV-1 when they say HIV.
Nope. Evidence shows there are multitudes of HIV retroviruses. Just the ones created for research alone number in the hundreds.
HIV is one retrovirus with numerous subtypes and in phylogenetic terms it is very closely related to SIVs so as to make this a question of semantics.

HIV can be detected in healthy dogs blood, using standard tests.
Yep, because the test are fooled. Only very advanced test can detect that no HIV actually exist.
What you mean is HIV antibody tests can be falsely positive in dogs - there is a difference. If a 1000 men had a pregnancy test, and in one of them it was positive because he had unusal hormone levels, and only a further "advanced" tets showed he was a true negative, would you say: "men can be pregnant using standard tests"?

HIV has made some people very very wealthy.
Yep. Gallo for one, but there are many others.
I agree there are a few people whose careers have flourished, and some whose patents on tests have meant large incomes. It is this way with everything.
I reckon Duesberg has benefitted greatly from HIV and taking the stance he did. He was a retrovirologist in a potentially great field of oncogenetics, but it was in decline when along came the HTLV/HIV story. He kinda missed the boat on this one, so turned to denial. He should have faded into the background, yet since then he has become infamous/famous, courted publicity, notoriety, is feted in many parts of the world for his stance (Wakefield-like).

HIV is not allowed to be debated by the ruling class.
Questionable.
It does not make it onto the agendas of many. Blame folk like Reagan, who didn't even want to think about it. But it is pretty high profile now. I regard Bill Gates as one of the ruling class, and you couldn't be more involved than him really.

HIV does not act like any known retrovirus.
Unless you count SIV, which is very similar, and believed to be the source of HIV.
And other mamalian retroviruses such as FIV mentioned below.

HIV is a harmless passenger virus.
In primates and people who are immune, it a harmless passenger virus
In those not naturally resistant to its effects, it's not such good news. All infections have natural variance in their impact. Some kids get exposed to chickenpox and it doesn't even cause spots, yet we know they have been infected. Other kids it might kill. That's life.

HIV can be spread by infected vaccines.
Yep. So can SV40 and Primate Foamy virus.
Rabies can be spread by infected vaccines too, if someone puts it in the vials. But its rather unlikely this would happen. Some have suggested HIV spread through contaminated vaccines, but there is no credible evidence for this, and the theory that contaminated polio vaccine was responsible has been conclusively refuted.

HIV resembles retroviruses used in cancer research. Which viruses specifically?
Good question. Ask Gallo, he knows all about it, having worked with retroviruses since 1960, including ones from primates, modified for research. Source:

Retroviruses are found in every mammal species, and cats have their own FIV, which behaves almost exactly like HIV, except in cats only.

HIV is found in dogs, cats, pigs and rats, and in mosquito guts.
Again, it is because the test show false positives. Except Mosquitoes, if they suck infected blood, HIV is found in their guts.
It's true! :)

HIV reproduces in Chimps and Monkeys. Chimps only.
Questionable.

HIV infections began in New York City and San Fransisco.
That one appears to be a myth.

HIV was late in infecting Africa.
Technically, not true. AIDS was late in showing up, but HIV is claimed to have infected Africans long ago.

HIV can't be contracted from lab monkeys or chimps.
False. HIV can be contracted from lab animals.
Only if the lab workers were exceedingly sloppy. We know that occupational HIV is very unusual in health care workers generally.

HIV was not made in a lab, or spread by medical procedures. It was spread by infected factor VIII clotting factors in haemophiliacs.
And blood transfusion, and shared needles, and organ transplants, and medicines made from infected organs or blood.

HIV can be joined with other organisms, (Chimeras), and many kinds of HIV strains are created by scientist to study it. Only parts of HIV can be genetically engineered with other viruses/bacteria.
That is what a Chimera is, part HIV, part SIV, or part E. coli. Pure HIV is however modified in the lab for research purposes.
 
Yes…that's why we added the western blot to the ELISA. The ELISA is very sensitive, it gives too much false positives…we in our papers told the scientific world screen with the ELISA but confirm with the western blot…there would be too many false positives with ELISA alone. Very sensitive. So yes, you get some cellular debris and you make it from antibodies reacting and you think that person is positive when the person won't be positive.
Gallo RC. Testimony at appeal hearing of Andre Parenzee. Court of Criminal Appeal. 2007 Feb 12.

If a 1000 men had a pregnancy test, and in one of them it was positive because he had unusal[sic] hormone levels, and only a further "advanced" tets[sic] showed he was a true negative, would you say: "men can be pregnant using standard tests"?

Of course not. But if half of the men tested showed that they were pregnant, or worse, if half of the dogs tested showed human pregnancy, I would certainly consider the test invalid or flawed.

While the makers of the test do state that they are not to be used to diagnose, and that advanced testing is to be used if HIV shows positive, in many countries just one Western Blot test is used, with no validation from any accurate test. Pregnancy, of all things, can produce a false positive on both ELISA and Western Blot test.

“AIDS and AIDS-related conditions are clinical syndromes and their diagnosis can only be established clinically. EIA testing cannot be used to diagnose AIDS, even if the recommended investigation of reactive specimens suggests that the antibodies to HIV are present.”

Human immunodeficiency virus types 1 and 2: (E. coli, B. megaterium, recombinant antigen) HIVAB HIV-1/HIV-2 (rDNA) EIA. Abbott Laboratories. 2004.

“Western Blot assay should not be used as a screening test. WB should be viewed as a supplemental test which can be used to confirm positive results obtained from EIA. However: Specificity is less than that of EIA. A significant number of indeterminate blots are seen in low risk populations.”

Babu VR. HIV Testing Technologies: ELISA/Western Blot. CDC. 2004 Jan 19-23
 
Last edited:
Rabies can be spread by infected vaccines too, if someone puts it in the vials. But its rather unlikely this would happen. Some have suggested HIV spread through contaminated vaccines, but there is no credible evidence for this, and the theory that contaminated polio vaccine was responsible has been conclusively refuted.

You know, after I read the link that claimed all chances of contamination of vaccines has been ruled out, I did some checking. Because they didn't link to any published papers or studies that showed any evidence for that claim. (I was also under the impression that all vaccine linked theories had been abandoned)

What I found, and it wasn't easy, is astonishing. I'm not sure if I want to even open that can of worms.
 
For Pete's sake, "what [you] found"? Garbage, I'm sure. HIV is not linked to vaccines and it was thoroughly looked at. So what ever you found if it was in the way of legit research or discussion is probably a decade or more old. We all know about it, the kidney cells and all.

As far as the testing goes, no one reports an HIV positive result based on an ELISA test unless they are incompetent. The blood bank may toss the blood, I'm not sure. My lab won't even report and HIV ELISA. If the test is reactive, they do a mandatory Western Blot. I don't have a choice.

And believe it or not, health care providers actually know what sensitivity and specificity mean and you don't run lab tests without knowing how reliable they are and incorporating that into your decision making process. You post as if we are all stupid or something.
 
Last edited:
For Pete's sake, "what [you] found"? Garbage, I'm sure.

Gee, should I read Medical Journals, Nature, Lancet, etc, or listen to some anonymous bonehead, who doesn't even know what is being talked about, but will declare everything garbage? Tough question ...

I think I will stick with science. You learn stuff that way.

Geissler E. SV40 and human brain tumors. Progress in Medical Virology, 1990;37:211–22.

Bergsagel DJ, et al. DNA sequences similar to those of simian virus 40 in ependymomas and choroid plexus tumors of childhood. New England Journal of Medicine, 1992;326:988–93.

Martini, M., et al. Human brain tumors and simian virus 40. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 1995;87(17):1331.

Lednicky JA, et al. Natural Simian Virus 40 Strains are Present in Human Choroid Plexus and Ependymoma Tumors. Virology, 1995;212(2):710–7.

Tognon M, et al. Large T Antigen Coding Sequence of Two DNA Tumor Viruses, BK and SV-40, and Nonrandom Chromosome Changes in Two Gioblastoma Cell Lines. Cancer Genetics and Cytogenics, 1996;90(1): 17–23.

Vilchez RA, et al. Association between simian virus 40 and non-hodgkin lymphoma. Lancet, (March 9, 2002), 359: 817–23.

Carbone, M., et al. SV-40 Like Sequences in Human Bone Tumors. Onco-gene, 1996;13(3):527–35.

Pass, HI, Carbone, M., et al. Evidence For and Implications of SV-40 Like Sequences in Human Mesotheliomas. Important Advances in Oncology, 1996:89-108.

Ohta Y, et al. No evidence for the contamination of live oral poliomyelitis vaccines with simian immunodeficiency virus. AIDS, 1989; 3:183–5.

Huet T, et al. Genetic organization of a chimpanzee lentivirus related to HIV-1. Nature, 1990; 345:356–9.

Desrosiers RC. HIV-1 origins: A finger on the missing link. Nature, 1990;345:288–9.

Sabin AB. Properties and behavior of orally administered attenuated polio-virus vaccine. Journal of the American Medical Association, 1957; 164:1216–23.

Plotkin SA, Koprowski H, et al. Clinical trials in infants of orally adminis-tered poliomyelitis viruses. Pediatrics 1959;23:1041–62.

Barin F, et al. Serological evidence for virus related to simian T-lymphotropic retrovirus III in residents of West Africa. Lancet 1985; ii:1387–9.

Hirsch VM, Zack PM, Vogel AP, Johnson PR. Simian immunodeficiency virus infection of macaques: End-stage disease is characterized by wide-spread distribution of proviral DNA in tissues. Journal of Infectious Dis-ease, 1991; 163(5):976–88.

Bohannon RC, et al. Isolation of a Type D retrovirus from B-cell lympho-mas of a patient with AIDS. Journal of Virology, 1991;65(11):5663–72.

Khabbaz RF, et al. Simian immunodeficiency virus needlestick accident in a laboratory worker. Lancet, 1992;340:271–3.

Gao F, et al. Human infection by genetically diverse SIVsm-related HIV-2 in West Africa. Nature, 1992;358:495–9.

Giunta S, et al. The primate trade and the origin of AIDS viruses. Nature, 1987;329:22.

Fascinating stuff.
 
The stuff from the fifties and early sixties is fascinating. Seems they knew there was some virus being spread, that came from monkeys, but didn't know what it was. There is a huge amount of data on this.
 
Robinson, you posted about the origin of HIV in vaccines and you said something about not opening a can of worms. Nothing in your reply is relative and it doesn't change mine which was specifically about your claim of finding some old garbage on HIV originating in vaccines.
 
robinson, have you gained any insight on where "HIV" comes from in these papers? I'm not talking about the designation, but the genetic information that makes up the retrovirus ultimately.

30-70 retroviruses are in every human. That's what originally made cancer research look for retroviruses as a cause: They simply found retroviruses in all tumors.

That's why: Just finding a retrovirus in a sick patient does not, in any way, show that he was made sick *by* the retrovirus.
 
robinson, have you gained any insight on where "HIV" comes from in these papers? I'm not talking about the designation, but the genetic information that makes up the retrovirus ultimately.

30-70 retroviruses are in every human. That's what originally made cancer research look for retroviruses as a cause: They simply found retroviruses in all tumors.

That's why: Just finding a retrovirus in a sick patient does not, in any way, show that he was made sick *by* the retrovirus.

:rolleyes:

No, but all the other data, research and studies do. That, and basic immunology.
 
I'm pretty sure nobody is debating it on TV right now. Or in mainstream Journals. It really might be just a minor factoid, it didn't need to be included in the list really.

Gee, I wonder why that is...
 
robinson, have you gained any insight on where "HIV" comes from in these papers? I'm not talking about the designation, but the genetic information that makes up the retrovirus ultimately.

30-70 retroviruses are in every human. That's what originally made cancer research look for retroviruses as a cause: They simply found retroviruses in all tumors.

That's why: Just finding a retrovirus in a sick patient does not, in any way, show that he was made sick *by* the retrovirus.

Got your second wind, huh?
 
:rolleyes:No, but all the other data, research and studies do. That, and basic immunology.

Another claim with no evidence, reasoning, or data to help the interested mind see what, why or how the claim came to be a belief. I'm not dissin a one line reply with no value, (I've made my share :)), but in a thread about facts, myth, and knowing what is true, it isn't advancing either skepticism, or knowledge.

robinson, have you gained any insight on where "HIV" comes from in these papers? I'm not talking about the designation, but the genetic information that makes up the retrovirus ultimately.

The data is almost overwhelming, but right now I am looking at, right on my computer, the actual data on HIV-I, HIV-II, HTVL-III, SIV, SV40, and SFV and HFV, all of which have been studied extensively, and are still being examined. It isn't easy to find, and some of it was expensive to come by, and can't be copied here, due to extensive legal restrictions.

I also found the smoking gun, in regards to several issues. I hope you realize by now, that retroviruses jumping primate species can cause illness, due to no immunity to a new retrovirus. This is true in all primates. While some either mutate a harmless version, or somehow resist the infection, many more suffer immune disorders from a foreign RNA retrovirus. Nobody who studies the issue doubts this.

This is why HIV kills people. How did it spread like wildfire worldwide in a matter of a few decades? And why did it not spread like an STD? To me, those are interesting questions. I know, I know, some people believe that is all said and done, and everybody knows how this happened. But if you do some research, that story falls apart real fast.

30-70 retroviruses are in every human. That's what originally made cancer research look for retroviruses as a cause: They simply found retroviruses in all tumors.

And they also found that a retrovirus is a good way to modify DNA. You can actually engineer retroviruses, to insert new code into the DNA. Very cool little trick. It is used all the time.

That's why: Just finding a retrovirus in a sick patient does not, in any way, show that he was made sick *by* the retrovirus.

They also found that just infecting an organism with a retrovirus that was believed to cause an illness, doesn't always cause an illness. In fact, there was much surprise when the "cause" was found to either already exist in the test animal, or immunity was already in place. A LOT of research has been done on this.

It is very interesting. Especially Gallo's early work from 'the sixties. As well as Sabin's warnings about the unknown Simian retroviruses, (they didn't know what they were then), that appeared in people after the Polio vaccines had spread them large.

Thank Heaven SV40 doesn't cause any problems in people, or SFV, or any of the other retroviruses that were accidentally contaminating the vaccines. Well, we don't know if they can cause problems, but that minor issue is going to be looked into soon.

I was surprised to find that there still exist samples of every vaccine ever used in Africa, Europe, India, Sout America, and America. The original vials of what was either injected or squirted into millions of people in the fifties and sixties.

How cool is that? Which means, with current technology, they could be tested to see if anything was actually in them, to know, without any doubt, if they were contaminated, if there were any problems.

Immunologist are licking their lips to get at them, knowing that with what we can do now, any SIV or other retrovirus that they find, can be put into the ever growing database, and they might be able to actually trace the origin of HIV, or any other viruses, as well as learn how to prevent any future problems.

Someday, maybe scientist will get to test them. Wouldn't that be cool? To know the facts? :wackywink:

I think so.
 
Last edited:
robinson said:
This is why HIV kills people. How did it spread like wildfire worldwide in a matter of a few decades? And why did it not spread like an STD? To me, those are interesting questions. I know, I know, some people believe that is all said and done, and everybody knows how this happened. But if you do some research, that story falls apart real fast.

I can kind of see in my head how, between IV drug use and needle sharing, contaminated blood supplies for transfusions, and other unhygienic medical practices, it took off.
The epidemiology in Africa is different because of different sex practices over there, of course.

Where do you see it falling apart, robinson?

Also...the lab workers who were infected...does anyone have another link on that or know if it was "wild, original SIV" they became infected with, or if it was the human HIV or some kind of hybrid?
 
Well, this is the thing. With modern technology, you can go back and actually tell what strain of HIV somebody had, died from, or has, and you can trace it by mutation, get an idea of the lineage almost, so that HIV, even with its rapid mutation, has a history. Using computers, they can deduce how far away in time a strain is from another strain, and tell if strains are related, and how closely they are related.

This is how they know so much already about the origins. If this is true, and I don't doubt it, we have the tools to actually discover where and when the jumps were made from SIV to HIV, where and when they happened.

The current theory is that it happened multiple times. And with both monkeys and chimps.

Where do you see it falling apart,

It is obvious if you read the actual studies, reports and publications, as well as look at the data. It wasn't any wild error or fantasy that led to the theories that people came up with, about HIV and how it spread.

We know it spread by blood, organs, and products made from blood. We know it spread through drug users, homobisexuals, and anal sex. We know it spread by heterosexual contacts, and we know it spread through accidents and pregnancy.

What is not known, is how it spread from the original mutations from SIV, and how it spread in certain populations, especially geographical clusters, Gays in New York, San Fransisco, and to isolated tribes, that had no social or sexual contact with anyone.

According to the Genetic trails, SIV jumped species multiple times, and at multiple time periods.

You don't have to be a genius to figure out the big problems with certain aspects of the dominant theory. The thing is, we have the ability to actually know what happened now. If all the data, and all the resources were open to research, if everything could be viewed and tested, the answer would become clearer.

What has happened, and it is no surprise of course, is certain sources either hid evidence, or have refused to allow testing and research. The reasons are obvious. Even the most hardened cynic that blindly accepts everything they are told, knows deep down that something is missing in this mystery.

The emotional response from such people, rather than a rational and reasonable refutation, using hard science and data, shows the nature of the hidden problem.

What is messed up, is that the multitude of theories, facts, data, and research, brings up more mysteries than it reveals. While I started off asking, "What if everybody is right?", one could just as well ask, "What if everybody is wrong?".
 
Last edited:
What is not known, is how it spread from the original mutations from SIV, and how it spread in certain populations, especially geographical clusters, Gays in New York, San Fransisco, and to isolated tribes, that had no social or sexual contact with anyone.
I can see contaminated medical stuff spreading it to various tribes.
With NY etc, I can see it being a few international travelers who had encounters with African prostitutes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom