HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

May 11, 1987, The London Times
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/1105346a2fa6e417b4.jpg[/qimg]

I would link to the article, but I can't find it online. It had an interview with Gallo himself, as well as WHO information, and some really interesting statistics to back up the story.

Obviously, this story, and the resulting reaction to it, is going to be difficult to verify. As in, what is the truth?

The story was wrong:

http://www.mapinc.org/drugnews/v06/n759/a05.html?116
 
HIV is a new retrovirus.
HIV resembles very old retroviruses.

Yes so?

HIV damages the immune system in some people.

Ebola kills some people

HIV is harmless in some people.

No just in some cases something else kills them first.

HIV mutates all the time, and there are multiple types.

Same true for Influenza.

HIV is spread by, sex, blood, and organ transplants.

Pretty much.

HIV has shown up in isolated Indian Tribes that have had no contact ever with the outside world.

No such tribes exist.

HIV has been fought about since it was "discovered".

Um same true for ebola

HIV is not allowed to be debated by the ruling class.

Thabo Mbeki would appear to be a member of any reasonable defintion of ruleing class.

HIV is a political, economic, social issue, as well as medical.

No it is a virus.

HIV does not act like any known retrovirus.

Evidences?

HIV is different in Africa than it is in America and Europe.

HIV-1 vs HIV-2 yes?

HIV statistics for many countries are estimates, and they have been shown to be wrong.

Not really.

HIV is known to damage CD4 receptor cells, and invade other tissue. How this happens is still not known.

Fairly well known. Mostly due to the gp160 spike interacting with various surface structures on the cell.

HIV is a Pandemic.
HIV, by causing AIDS, is a minor cause of death.

Life expactancy in a number of african countires has crashed.

HIV is the source of a lot of death.

Yes

HIV is a harmless passenger virus.

No

HIV is spread by heterosexual sex.

Yes

HIV is mostly spread by homobisexual sex and drug use.

Not for the last few years in britian.

HIV was spread through the blood supply before it was known about.

See the rates in hemophiliacs

HIV can be spread by infected vaccines.

Doesn't appear to have happened.

HIV has been found in tissue samples from a long time ago.
HIV was unknown before 1979.

50000 Quaoar was discovered in 2002. Prediscovery images go back to 1954

HIV is found in dogs, cats, pigs and rats, and in mosquito guts.

No it isn't

HIV is not spread by eating it.

Finding a way to eat viable virus would be tricky

HIV is spread by mothers milk.

Spread by brestfeeding. may be due to blood contact.

HIV is spread by needlestick accidents.

Killed a few researchers.

HIV was around for years before it was detected.
HIV has almost never infected a Surgeon or Doctor, except by sex or I.V. drug use.

Yes so? they take precations against any form of infection.

HIV can survive in blood stored for use, for a long time.
HIV can't survive outside the body for long.

Neither can RBCs normaly.

HIV is found in sperm and seminal fluid.
HIV is very hard to detect in sperm or seminal fluid.

Lots of things are hard to detect (extrasolar platents say) what of it?

HIV is spread through oral sex.

Again risk of blood contact.

HIV is in saliva.

At insanely low levels

HIV can't reproduce without human DNA.
HIV reproduces in Chimps and Monkeys.

HIV related stuff appears in chimps.

HIV infections began in New York City and San Fransisco.
HIV was late in infecting Africa.

First documented infection was 1959 in what is now DRC.


HIV isn't the same as SIV, SV40, or any other retrovirus.

Simular to SIV.

HIV couldn't be created by science.

Doubtful it's too darn big for current tech.
 
Two moments of clarity

I guess one needs to be an M.D. and be in HIV/AIDS field to know all these things.

Teach a man/woman to fish and you feed them for a lifetime.

You can teach people/learn for yourself how to evaluate the information they are confronted with/exposed to/seek out for its validity. You can teach people/learn for yourself how to spot a con job and how to spot woo. Then you do not need to be anything other than a skeptic.

--

Robinson: "We are people, they are people. people make mistakes, people can be wrong. In fact, it is certain we will be wrong at some point. Everybody can even be wrong."

Here is the crux of this thread. Do you get your information from someone you consider a good source? Is the information being presented by someone you have no clue about?

Science doesn't rely on any one person. Neither is it majority rule, though consensus does tend to indicate the evidence is being correctly interpreted. The essence of science is the evidence, not the people interpreting it. The evidence can be misinterpreted. Studies can be flawed. But the evidence is reality and it can eventually be determined in spite of false conclusions and poor study design and even random variation.

The bottom line is there is a reality out there. Since that is the case, when there is a controversy, it is not an insurmountable obstacle. It just means more research is needed to resolve the questions. Or it may mean that you simply need to sort out the evidence that is already available.

I'm not bothered by the fact people have, "gotten it wrong". That's a no brainer. What concerns me about the way robinson is presenting his view here is why does anyone rely on other people to get it right. I rely on me to know the principles of good science. I try to recognize the misleading persuasion techniques so I'm immunized against them. I always consider the bias of the person whose conclusions I am listening to when I evaluate their conclusions. And I can evaluate the reliability and expertise of someone I am listening to beyond their educational degree.

Robinson is pointing out all the scandals, all the woo headlines, all the conspiracy theories as if that means we cannot determine the truth. Or as if it means we need to argue about these less than credible versions of reality for which there will always be (in our lifetime anyway) human beings falsely claiming are the facts. Nonsense. Good science is all you need to look at. Who cares that people are making this claim or that claim. Since I can look at the evidence they based their conclusions on, at their biases which usually aren't hard to find, at how the other experts in the field view the conclusions, I'm not concerned about these supposed controversies.

If you can't tell the wheat from the chafe when you read all the clutter of information that is out there, if you can't tell who is right when you read about HIV conspiracy theories, then I guess you'd be in robinson's position. Relying on everyone else's interpretations of the evidence rather than on your evaluation of it.

Teach yourself to fish and you will not be relying on everyone else to tell you what reality is. It doesn't require expertise in every field. It merely requires a little expertise in recognizing BS when you see it.

Thanks, skeptigirl. Very well put.
 
Re types of HIV:
There are 2 types- HIV-1 and HIV-2
There are 3 subtypes of HIV-1 (M, N and O)
There are at least 9 subgroups of M, plus all recombinants.
Here is a useful guide.


ETA
Here is an article on the phylogeny of HIV
Here is some new data on Green monkeys and SIV
 
Last edited:
HIV comes from monkeys and chimps. Myth? Fact? Theory?

Wertheim and Worobey suggest various SIVs arose because SIVs were transmitted horizontally, between primate species, and evolved into a new host-specific form only after transmission.

HIV arose from chimpanzee SIV that was transmitted to humans, probably when people had contact with chimpanzee blood from hunting and butchering the animals, Worobey said.
http://www.scientificblogging.com/news/african_green_monkeys_and_the_evolution_of_hiv
 
"You can teach people/learn for yourself how to evaluate the information they are confronted with/exposed to/seek out for its validity. You can teach people/learn for yourself how to spot a con job and how to spot woo. Then you do not need to be anything other than a skeptic."

I'm not sure who said that, because it is nested in two quotes, but it illustrates a good point. An anonymous person on the Internet is telling me I can teach people -" how to evaluate the information they are confronted with", and "how to spot a con job and how to spot woo".

Where is the information on how to do that? In this case? Considering the topic, and the OP, what is this anonymous person telling me, you, to do? And how do you verify a source is correct?

How do you determine data is valid, and how do you interpret it? The thing that is obvious to me, is that some people do nothing but counter statements, try and debunk what they already believe is wrong, or something, but they never add anything to the list.

If you know the facts about HIV, post your list. It would be interesting to see what you think are the facts about HIV.

Well, this is typical of how things are misinterpreted by the layperson. You said that HIV could be detected in the blood of dogs. That is wrong because it is not HIV that is detected but antibodies that can cross-react witn HIV proteins. A common problem with western blot tests. Yet somehow the interpretation is that dog's are infected with HIV.

Nope. The data was clear. HIV test don't detect HIV, they detect anti-bodies, and they are not to be trusted. If you hear somebody claim you have HIV based on a Western blot, they are full of it.

No test detects HIV. Even the most advanced testing doesn't detect HIV. The manufacturers own literature tells you this.

It's not HIV in wild chimps. It's SIVcpz that is the source.

It certainly makes for livelier stories than the scientific consensus: that the AIDS virus crossed from African chimpanzees into local tribesmen who ate their meat.
http://www.mapinc.org/drugnews/v06/n759/a05.html?116

This is one of the most persistent and annoying bit in the muddled data stream. Some sources say HIV came from monkeys to chimps to tribesmen to America. Some sources say it can't be transmitted from wild or captive Chimps used in research labs to lab workers, or from tame chimps used in movies and Circus acts and zoos. Remember, we are talking about in the 100 years before HIV was discovered.

No live Chimp (that all came from Africa), ever had HIV or could have transmitted it to Western workers, only in Africa could dead chimps transmit it to hunters. Now, rather than spew some nonsense about ... well .. whatever, why not try and address the obvious point here.

Can both those "facts" be true? In 1998 it was reported that when a new experiment was being started to test a HIV vaccine on Chimps, the lab tested all the Chimps first, for HIV, to make sure they didn't have it.

The experiment was canceled when it was found they test animals all had HIV already, even though they were all lab raised, sterile chimps, bred and raised for a lab test. The story caused a bit of a stir, then quietly vanished.

Do you remember that story? Can you find that story online?
 
While it may seem dumb to harp on one single factoid, a minor thing, like the source of HIV, the Pandemic virus killing millions worldwide, but call me silly then. I get like that.

Somebody claims HIV came from chimps to hunters then spread worldwide through sex. You might think something that huge, a statement like that, would require extraordinary proof. Would you accept a whopper like that without vast amounts of evidence? Well, if the Media tells you so, I guess it is so.

What do scientist working in the HIV fields say about it? What do top researchers, top Doctors who know stuff say? Does everybody buy that story?
 
Can both those "facts" be true? In 1998 it was reported that when a new experiment was being started to test a HIV vaccine on Chimps, the lab tested all the Chimps first, for HIV, to make sure they didn't have it.

The experiment was canceled when it was found they test animals all had HIV already, even though they were all lab raised, sterile chimps, bred and raised for a lab test. The story caused a bit of a stir, then quietly vanished.

Do you remember that story? Can you find that story online?

You are the one makeing the claim you find it.
 
Please see my posts #31 and #36.
I knew I should have checked my facts. It was even in a link I posted in the other thread on this topic.

The origin of AIDS and HIV.
...Until 1999, the closest counterpart that had been identified was SIVcpz, the SIV found in chimpanzees. However, this virus still had certain significant differences from HIV.
What happened in 1999?

In February 1999 a group of researchers from the University of Alabama1 announced that they had found a type of SIVcpz that was almost identical to HIV-1. This particular strain was identified in a frozen sample taken from a captive member of the sub-group of chimpanzees known as Pan troglodytes troglodytes (P. t. troglodytes), which were once common in west-central Africa.

The researchers (led by Paul Sharp of Nottingham University and Beatrice Hahn of the University of Alabama) made the discovery during the course of a 10-year long study into the origins of the virus. They claimed that this sample proved that chimpanzees were the source of HIV-1, and that the virus had at some point crossed species from chimps to humans.

Their final findings were published two years later in Nature magazine2. In this article, they concluded that wild chimps had been infected simultaneously with two different simian immunodeficiency viruses which had "viral sex" to form a third virus that could be passed on to other chimps and, more significantly, was capable of infecting humans and causing AIDS.

These two different viruses were traced back to a SIV that infected red-capped mangabeys and one found in greater spot-nosed monkeys. They believe that the hybridisation took place inside chimps that had become infected with both strains of SIV after they hunted and killed the two smaller species of monkey.

They also concluded that all three 'groups' of HIV-1 - namely Group M, N and O (see our strains and subtypes page for more information on these) - came from the SIV found in P. t. troglodytes, and that each group represented a separate crossover 'event' from chimps to humans....

...WHEN?

During the last few years it has become possible not only to determine whether HIV is present in a blood or plasma sample, but also to determine the particular subtype of the virus. Studying the subtype of virus of some of the earliest known instances of HIV infection can help to provide clues about the time it first appeared in humans and its subsequent evolution.

Three of the earliest known instances of HIV infection are as follows:

1. A plasma sample taken in 1959 from an adult male living in what is now the Democratic Republic of Congo.
2. HIV found in tissue samples from an American teenager who died in St. Louis in 1969.
3. HIV found in tissue samples from a Norwegian sailor who died around 1976.

A 1998 analysis of the plasma sample from 1959 has suggested8 that HIV-1 was introduced into humans around the 1940s or the early 1950s; much earlier than previously thought. Other scientists have dated the sample to an even earlier period - perhaps as far back as the end of the 19th century.

In January 2000 however, the results of a new study presented at the 7th Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections, suggested that the first case of HIV-1 infection occurred around 1930 in West Africa . The study was carried out by Dr Bette Korber of the Los Alamos National Laboratory. The estimate of 1930 (which does have a 15 year margin of error) was based on a complicated computer model of HIV's evolution. If accurate, it means that HIV was in existence before many scenarios (such as the OPV and conspiracy theories) suggest.

What about HIV-2? When did that get passed to humans?

Until recently, the origins of the HIV-2 virus had remained relatively unexplored. HIV-2 is thought to come from the SIV in Sooty Mangabeys rather than chimpanzees, but the crossover to humans is believed to have happened in a similar way (i.e. through the butchering and consumption of monkey meat). It is far rarer, significantly less infectious and progresses more slowly to AIDS than HIV-1. As a result, it infects far fewer people, and is mainly confined to a few countries in West Africa.

In May 2003, a group of Belgian researchers led by Dr. Anne-Mieke Vandamme, published a report9 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Science. By analysing samples of the two different subtypes of HIV-2 (A and B) taken from infected individuals and SIV samples taken from sooty mangabeys, Dr Vannedamme concluded that subtype A had passed into humans around 1940 and subtype B in 1945 (plus or minus 16 years or so). Her team of researchers also discovered that the virus had originated in Guinea-Bissau and that its spread was most likely precipitated by the independence war that took place in the country between 1963 and 1974 (Guinea-Bissau is a former Portuguese colony). Her theory was backed up by the fact that the first European cases of HIV-2 were discovered among Portuguese veterans of the war, many of whom had received blood transfusions or unsterile injections following injury, or had possibly frequented local prostitutes.
The genome and genetic sequences of all life on Earth contain information which reveals a map you can trace backward to the origin of any organism. We may not have all the data on every organism, but it is available once we get around to looking.
 
Last edited:
"You can teach people/learn for yourself how to evaluate the information they are confronted with/exposed to/seek out for its validity. You can teach people/learn for yourself how to spot a con job and how to spot woo. Then you do not need to be anything other than a skeptic."

I'm not sure who said that, because it is nested in two quotes, but it illustrates a good point. An anonymous person on the Internet is telling me I can teach people -" how to evaluate the information they are confronted with", and "how to spot a con job and how to spot woo".

Where is the information on how to do that? In this case? Considering the topic, and the OP, what is this anonymous person telling me, you, to do? And how do you verify a source is correct?

How do you determine data is valid, and how do you interpret it? The thing that is obvious to me, is that some people do nothing but counter statements, try and debunk what they already believe is wrong, or something, but they never add anything to the list.
I'll address this in a bit, it will be a long post. In fact, I think I'll just start a new thread. It's a very important topic.

If you know the facts about HIV, post your list. It would be interesting to see what you think are the facts about HIV.
In 25 words or less??????? I'll just continue along with the other thread posters debunking your false claims of facts. If you have a specific question, I'd be happy to answer it, including supporting evidence.

Nope. The data was clear. HIV test don't detect HIV, they detect anti-bodies, and they are not to be trusted. If you hear somebody claim you have HIV based on a Western blot, they are full of it.

No test detects HIV. Even the most advanced testing doesn't detect HIV. The manufacturers own literature tells you this.
You make the false assumption that tests are not subject to means of verifying that they do indeed reveal what they claim to reveal. Not to mention there are direct tests for the HIVirus along with antibody tests.

If you want to claim that the vast amount of research into the antibody antigen function of immune systems or the development of thousands of pathogen specific antibody tests are useless, worthless, unreliable or whatever other nonsense you are claiming here, I suggest you never bother seeing a doctor or health practitioner again. Since we all just practice junk medicine using bogus tests why waste your time?

I think the majority of people recognize the successes of modern medicine even if you don't.

...This is one of the most persistent and annoying bit in the muddled data stream. Some sources say HIV came from monkeys to chimps to tribesmen to America. Some sources say it can't be transmitted from wild or captive Chimps used in research labs to lab workers, or from tame chimps used in movies and Circus acts and zoos. Remember, we are talking about in the 100 years before HIV was discovered.

No live Chimp (that all came from Africa), ever had HIV or could have transmitted it to Western workers, only in Africa could dead chimps transmit it to hunters. Now, rather than spew some nonsense about ... well .. whatever, why not try and address the obvious point here.

Can both those "facts" be true? In 1998 it was reported that when a new experiment was being started to test a HIV vaccine on Chimps, the lab tested all the Chimps first, for HIV, to make sure they didn't have it.

The experiment was canceled when it was found they test animals all had HIV already, even though they were all lab raised, sterile chimps, bred and raised for a lab test. The story caused a bit of a stir, then quietly vanished.

Do you remember that story? Can you find that story online?
See my above post. Like I said, genes are a record of evolution and as such can be used to look backward to find the origin or approximate origin of any living organisms. We are only limited by the fact all the genomes are not yet recorded.
 
I think the majority of people recognize the successes of modern medicine even if you don't.

That's what it all boils down to for me: basic common sense. The HIV/AIDS pseudoskeptics make claims that seem to come down to an assertion that the entire scientific and medical community uses a set of standards and procedures for 99.99999% of what they do, that has resulted in enormous advances in knowledge about disease and treatment...

... and then they threw out all of it and just made stuff up when it comes to HIV, defrauded the entire world, and they are all in on the conspiracy. It is, of course, possible... but with the pathetic "evidence" provided by the woo side of this, it can be safely filed away alongside all the other conspiracy theory stuff.
 
While it may seem dumb to harp on one single factoid, a minor thing, like the source of HIV, the Pandemic virus killing millions worldwide, but call me silly then. I get like that.

Somebody claims HIV came from chimps to hunters then spread worldwide through sex. You might think something that huge, a statement like that, would require extraordinary proof. Would you accept a whopper like that without vast amounts of evidence? Well, if the Media tells you so, I guess it is so.

What do scientist working in the HIV fields say about it? What do top researchers, top Doctors who know stuff say? Does everybody buy that story?
The article I linked to above discussing the origin of HIV does a thorough job of addressing the theories from the conspiracy theorists to some of the most recent research.

The way science works is answers to questions such as where did HIV originate start out with a lot of hypotheses. And when it involves human tragedy, politics, big events, and such you also get wild conspiracy theories.

As research continues, theories begin to get ruled out. Scientists don't automatically dismiss conspiracy theories but if there is no evidence supporting them they tend to get rejected early on. Some of them warrant investigation and scientists will usually pursue viable hypotheses regardless of how crazy. But the key is 'viability'.

Eventually the evidence gets more and more focused and refined as only the studies pursuing the actual correct hypothesis remains. That can be a short time as with SARS, or it can take years as with HIV. The difference is the tools to investigate HIV were just coming on the scene in the late 70s. Tracing the genetic roots of HIV wasn't possible until more refined laboratory procedures were developed. When SARS emerged, the tools to investigate existed.

In the investigation of HIV, enough evidence has now accumulated to rule out most of the junk you bring up in this thread. You are taking decades old hypotheses and presenting them as if nothing further has been discovered which rules those ideas out. And if you read the origin of HIV information in my previous post, you can look into the genetic trail and confirm that it is much closer to if not arrived at a definitive answer.

That's what science does, robinson. Research accumulates until definitive answers are arrived at.
 
From the OP-
HIV is a new retrovirus.
HIV resembles very old retroviruses.
HIV is found in chimps and monkeys.
HIV doesn't make chimps and monkeys sick.
HIV has been found in tissue samples from a long time ago.
HIV was around for years before it was detected.
HIV reproduces in Chimps and Monkeys.
HIV is theorized to have started in Africa.
HIV can't be contracted from lab monkeys or chimps.
HIV is believed to have started from monkeys and chimps infecting Africans.
HIV isn't the same as SIV, SV40, or any other retrovirus.
HIV was not made in a lab, or spread by medical procedures.


All of those could have come from the article linked to

http://www.avert.org/origins.htm

In February 1999 a group of researchers from the University of Alabama1 announced that they had found a type of SIVcpz that was almost identical to HIV-1. This particular strain was identified in a frozen sample taken from a captive member of the sub-group of chimpanzees known as Pan troglodytes troglodytes (P. t. troglodytes), which were once common in west-central Africa.

So, if we accept this article as Gospel, we can state a number of facts based on it.

To add to the original list,
HIV can be tested for in frozen tissue, or stored tissue samples, and the Genetic code can be determined.

The researchers (led by Paul Sharp of Nottingham University and Beatrice Hahn of the University of Alabama) made the discovery during the course of a 10-year long study into the origins of the virus. They claimed that this sample proved that chimpanzees were the source of HIV-1, and that the virus had at some point crossed species from chimps to humans.

HIV came from Chimps
HIV crossed species.
SIV mutated into HIV.

Their final findings were published two years later in Nature magazine2. In this article, they concluded that wild chimps had been infected simultaneously with two different simian immunodeficiency viruses which had "viral sex" to form a third virus that could be passed on to other chimps and, more significantly, was capable of infecting humans and causing AIDS.

Retroviruses can be combined to form new retroviruses, without any help from science.
Does this mean it can be done in the lab as well?

These two different viruses were traced back to a SIV that infected red-capped mangabeys and one found in greater spot-nosed monkeys. They believe that the hybridisation took place inside chimps that had become infected with both strains of SIV after they hunted and killed the two smaller species of monkey.

HIV came from monkeys and chimps. Retroviruses can from new retroviruses, all on their own.
They also concluded that all three 'groups' of HIV-1 - namely Group M, N and O (see our strains and subtypes page for more information on these) - came from the SIV found in P. t. troglodytes, and that each group represented a separate crossover 'event' from chimps to humans....

HIV isn't just one retrovirus. It is a combination of retroviruses.
HIV has spontaneously been created multiple times'
HIV isn't just one retrovirus.

During the last few years it has become possible not only to determine whether HIV is present in a blood or plasma sample, but also to determine the particular subtype of the virus. Studying the subtype of virus of some of the earliest known instances of HIV infection can help to provide clues about the time it first appeared in humans and its subsequent evolution.

All tissue and blood samples can be tested for HIV now.
The subtype allows theorizing about where it came from.

Three of the earliest known instances of HIV infection are as follows:

1. A plasma sample taken in 1959 from an adult male living in what is now the Democratic Republic of Congo.
2. HIV found in tissue samples from an American teenager who died in St. Louis in 1969.
3. HIV found in tissue samples from a Norwegian sailor who died around 1976.

Any tissue sample can be tested for HIV.

A 1998 analysis of the plasma sample from 1959 has suggested8 that HIV-1 was introduced into humans around the 1940s or the early 1950s; much earlier than previously thought. Other scientists have dated the sample to an even earlier period - perhaps as far back as the end of the 19th century.

HIV does not act like any known retrovirus.
It was present many years ago, but never spread like an STD, much less the current Pandemic HIV.

In January 2000 however, the results of a new study presented at the 7th Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections, suggested that the first case of HIV-1 infection occurred around 1930 in West Africa . The study was carried out by Dr Bette Korber of the Los Alamos National Laboratory. The estimate of 1930 (which does have a 15 year margin of error) was based on a complicated computer model of HIV's evolution. If accurate, it means that HIV was in existence before many scenarios (such as the OPV and conspiracy theories) suggest.

A computer model replaced actually testing old tissue samples.
HIV is theorized to have started longer ago.
What about HIV-2? When did that get passed to humans?

Until recently, the origins of the HIV-2 virus had remained relatively unexplored. HIV-2 is thought to come from the SIV in Sooty Mangabeys rather than chimpanzees, but the crossover to humans is believed to have happened in a similar way (i.e. through the butchering and consumption of monkey meat). It is far rarer, significantly less infectious and progresses more slowly to AIDS than HIV-1. As a result, it infects far fewer people, and is mainly confined to a few countries in West Africa.

HIV came from monkeys.
HIV isn't just one retrovirus.

In May 2003, a group of Belgian researchers led by Dr. Anne-Mieke Vandamme, published a report9 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Science. By analysing samples of the two different subtypes of HIV-2 (A and B) taken from infected individuals and SIV samples taken from sooty mangabeys, Dr Vannedamme concluded that subtype A had passed into humans around 1940 and subtype B in 1945 (plus or minus 16 years or so).

HIV came from monkeys.
HIV doesn't make monkeys sick.
SIV isn't HIV, except that it becomes HIV, somehow.
HIV doesn't make monkeys sick.

Her team of researchers also discovered that the virus had originated in Guinea-Bissau and that its spread was most likely precipitated by the independence war that took place in the country between 1963 and 1974 (Guinea-Bissau is a former Portuguese colony). Her theory was backed up by the fact that the first European cases of HIV-2 were discovered among Portuguese veterans of the war, many of whom had received blood transfusions or unsterile injections following injury, or had possibly frequented local prostitutes.

HIV came from monkeys. Except for the kind that came from Chimps.
HIV is spread by medical procedures, (Blood and shared needles)
HIV is transmitted by sex, sometimes.

So based on this paper, SIV becomes HIV, but only in Africa, from monkeys and Chimps, never in Labs or research centers, that use monkeys and Chimps from Africa.

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) group N from Cameroon is phylogenetically close, in env, to the simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) cpz-gab from Gabon and SIVcpz-US of unknown geographic origin. We screened 29 wild-born Cameroonian chimpanzees and found that three (Cam3, Cam4, and Cam5) were positive for HIV-1 by Western blotting.
http://jvi.asm.org/cgi/content/abstract/74/1/529

"were positive for HIV-1 by Western blotting"
HIV is found in chimps and monkeys.
HIV doesn't make chimps and monkeys sick.

No no! It isn't HIV, it is SIV! It somehow becomes HIV!
The most plausible origin of HIV-1 group M is an SIV lineage currently represented by SIVcpz isolated from the chimpanzee subspecies Pan troglodytes troglodytes.
http://mbe.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/20/12/1986

HIV isn't the same as SIV, SV40, or any other retrovirus.

Now wait a minute. Nobody challenged that fact in the OP. HIV is almost the same as SIV? And with rapid mutation (by using our DNA), it turned into HIV?

To better study HIV/AIDS in animal models, researchers have created various HIV-SIV chimeras, viruses whose genome partly comes from HIV and partly from SIV. These are often referred to as SHIV.

HIV can be joined with other organisms, (Chimeras), and many kinds of HIV have been created for research.
HIV is easy to modify in a lab.
HIV strains are created by scientist to study it.


In case anyone feels their head might explode at this point, I understand.

Language is important.

Precedent for this has been set in our laboratory in the past by creation of neutralization-sensitive strains of SIV239 with elimination of carbohydrates in the first and second variable loops of the env spike. My focus has been to remove glycosylation sites that are located in the better-conserved core of the spike proximal to the receptor binding sites. The mutant strains we have created, missing glycans in the env core either singly or in combination, demonstrate the remarkable tolerance that SIV has to removal of conserved glycans within its core.
http://www.childrenshospital.org/cfapps/research/data_admin/Site366/mainpageS366P0.html

HIV is easy to modify in a lab.
HIV strains are created by scientist to study it
 
Last edited:
Regarding the tests
ELISA detects antibodies to HI-Proteins. Not infectious HI-Virions
Western Blot detects proteins. Not infectious HI-Virions.
PCR detects DNA. Not infectious HI-Virions.

So, there's no test that detects infectious HI-Virions. No infectious HI-Virions have been extracted from human tissue/blood (But some could be procured after growing the blood in the laboratory) which is of course a complaint of some denialists.
 
PCR detects DNA. Not infectious HI-Virions.
You can't have the DNA without the virons, though.

So, there's no test that detects infectious HI-Virions.
Isolation and electron microscopy are pretty close.

No infectious HI-Virions have been extracted from human tissue/blood (But some could be procured after growing the blood in the laboratory) which is of course a complaint of some denialists.

Well, the denialists should whine about the "junk science" behind all viral and bacterial cultures, then, coz that's just the way it goes.
 
Regarding the tests
ELISA detects antibodies to HI-Proteins. Not infectious HI-Virions
Western Blot detects proteins. Not infectious HI-Virions.
PCR detects DNA. Not infectious HI-Virions.

So, there's no test that detects infectious HI-Virions. No infectious HI-Virions have been extracted from human tissue/blood (But some could be procured after growing the blood in the laboratory) which is of course a complaint of some denialists.
Regarding your lack of knowledge regarding HIV detection tests, first, there are both HIV RNA and HIV DNA tests. One looks at the virus genetic material and the other looks at viral presence by finding the DNA which the HIV makes. Second, there are 2 ways in which RNA is detected so PCR is not the only way. And third, are you going to argue in ignorance that a fingerprint or someone's DNA is not evidence either?

...DNA and RNA PCR as being complimentary. After acute infection, one sees a massive amount of replication within the lymph glands. This produces lots of infected cells, which in turn are producing lots of viral particles that are put out into the plasma. Within a few days to a couple of weeks, one can detect infected cells (HIV DNA PCR) and cell free plasma virus (HIV RNA PCR) in the blood. The levels are usually so high, that it is relatively easy to find infection by either test. Once antibodies are produced, the amount of infected cells (DNA) and plasma viral load (RNA) goes down by some amount (different in every person).

HIV1 RNA & DNA PCR TEST(Viral Load)
Amplicor HIV-1 Monitor
In PCR-based assays, HIV RNA is converted into DNA by reverse transcription followed by PCR amplification of the DNA. The PCR product is detected by hybridization with an enzyme-conjugated probe specific for HIV-1, and quantified by reacting bound probe with a substrate that undergoes a color change, as in an ELISA.
At present the Roche Amplicor HIV-1 Monitor (RT-PCR) assay is the only one approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, and is the most widely used in clinical practice.

Quantiplex
HIV-1 RNA The branched DNA assay uses non-enzymatic means to amplify the signal from HIV RNA. In this assay, viral RNA is "captured" by hybridization to complementary oligonucleotides that are bound to the wells of a microtiter plate. The captured viral RNA target is then hybridized to branched oligonucleotides (hence the name "branched" DNA assay), which in turn are hybridized to enzyme-conjugated oligonucleotides that can be quantified as above.

HIV-1 RNA QT
The NASBA assay is similar in concept to the RT-PCR assay except that reactions occur at one temperature.
------
Results of the three commercially available quantitative HIV-1 RNA assays are highly correlated but not interchangeable so it is important that the same method be used each time.

You are making stupid arguments and they only serve reinforce your own beliefs. They are not convincing to anyone else. So if you want to tell us which mistakes in logic you are using to fabricate your fantasy, then post away. If on the other hand, you were actually interested in why people with HIV actually have a chance now with modern medical science, research and care, then stop with the nonsensical distortions and get a clue.

The lab tests are not made in someone's garage and then marketed. Manufacturers must present evidence the labs test what they say they test. If they didn't work there are thousands of people all over the world from physicians to competing lab test manufacturers who are going to notice and say something.

You never answered how many people were in on this conspiracy fantasy you have?
 
I'm not sure what your point is robinson? Are you trying to resolve which of your beliefs are valid and which aren't?
 
HIV infections didn't begin in USA, HIV started in Africa where it was called slim disease.

Bad link. I fixed it for you in the quote above.

http://magazine.jhsph.edu/2006/Spring/africa/temporary_miracle/slim_disease.cfm?subsection_id=17

Fascinating stuff. I hope we haven't forgot who started this discussion. You know, the person who claimed HIV wasn't causing AIDS and that stuff. One could hope that an educational experience may have occurred by now, if one could actually slog through this ever growing pile of, well, evidence of sorts.

HIV is pretty well understood, even if we don't know yet exactly how it damages the immune system. There is little doubt among Medical experts that it is a dangerous thing to contract, and that it can make you sick, by decreasing your ability to fight off diseases, and that for some, it is going to lead to death.

I think it would be folly, and perhaps dangerous to try and convince anyone otherwise, based on what we know.

And yet, at the same time, it isn't a death sentence anymore, and with good medical care and nutrition and other important factors, you may not even get sick. At least in the next twenty years. Time will tell.

Each year HIV+ people make it with no symptoms, the knowledge grows. Some people appear to be immune, (HIV IS A HARMLESS PASSENGER VIRUS), some people die, (HIV LEADS TO AIDS WHICH LEADS TO DEATH), some people don't even become infected, (HIV is almost never spread by female to female sex.), and I'm sure there is more to come.

I'm not sure what your point is robinson? Are you trying to resolve which of your beliefs are valid and which aren't?

I'm actually making a lot of points, and with the help of a few people I've learned a bunch of new stuff.

I never said I believed everything, in fact I said in the OP,
If these are the facts, then everybody is correct. A big if, and one that should be determined, in my view.

I also said
I would like to know if those statements are true. I'm sure most of them are. Even the ones that don't make sense.

Of course some of them can't be true, because they seem to directly contradict each other.

Yet, the facts show one thing clearly.

There are multiple problems under the heading HIV/AIDS. Obviously there are two main HIV strains, or types, with sub groups. And there is, and has been, different symptoms associated with different populations, especially when it comes to transmission and suffering.

If you compare Cuba with Botswana, you find HIV/AIDS to be a different problem.

And note that we haven't even started on the AIDS part of the thread yet.
What spawned this dubious topic was the thought that maybe two people can be right, even when it seems impossible.

To a patient with twenty years of HIV infection, no symptoms, no medications being used, who enjoys good health, HIV is different, than to a malnourished, malaria infested, starving child, with HIV and AIDS, who is going to die in a few years, from an immune system that can't keep up.

One could see HIV as harmless, another it is a Pandemic incurable disease. Even if it is a related retrovirus that is detected in both people.

This is what I meant by HIV isn't just one thing, it is many. Language is important, especially when attempting to gently coax somebody to think about things. Insults, derision, spewing forth emotional or psychological evaluations, while it might make you feel good, does little to advance science or education.

We have also learned that some of the old claims and beliefs about HIV may just be myths, kept alive by confusion or other factors. Some of the new beliefs about HIV may also be myths. As somebody said, theories change to fit new information. The more valid, verifiable data you can look at, the better chance an intelligent person can be free of faulty logic, bad reasoning, or just emotional responses.

The problems with HIV test and the criminal use of infected blood supplies should have been dealt with right from the start, but that is rarely the case when it comes to huge amounts of money, and a political hot potato.

The vaccine issue should have been investigated in an open fashion, and the information from research labs that is classified would have laid to rest many of the fears people had, and some still have.

But it would also have incriminated the guilty, and cost some people profits.

The fears generated by bad science and religious nutjobs created doubt and distrust when current announcements are made. Especially to those with HIV.

And I wanted to focus on Cuba, the best source of hard science and real success in dealing with HIV on the entire planet.

Is it long and complicated? Of course. Can you explain it all in a post or two? Of course not. Is it easy to understand? No way. But every real input from a smart person here, every explanation and link adds just a little bit. Remember this, the people who post are the minority. The reader, the lurker, the curious and the ignorant, they gain more from one reasonable post, with real data and a good explanation of how to understand it, than they do from a thousand insipid insults.

I'm about ready to post a new HIV list, myths VS facts, but knowing how many people won't log in until Monday, and how much there is to wade trough, it might be best to wait a few days. Let some other people input and debunk or support the questionable points.

What do ya say to that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom