HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

Did it say in the fulltext if SIVcpz induced apoptosis in human cells? Did they look at anything beyond susceptibility to infection?

Is this the kind of thing people are doing research on right now, and we might have to wait a few years to get in depth answers on?...lol.. (I noticed the dates on the articles you're posting keep getting more and more recent :)).

I checked to see if anyone had cited that paper yet, and not much else has been done since then so far, it doesn't look like.
The abstract does say that there was no difference in susceptibility to apoptosis. :)

I doesn't appear that much research is being done on this at the present. I found this one published this year though.
 
If you personally had to guess, would you say SIVcpz, as it exists in chimps in Africa, causes AIDS in humans?

What would you rate the probability as, or is not enough known to really even make a guess?
 
If you personally had to guess, would you say SIVcpz, as it exists in chimps in Africa, causes AIDS in humans? What would you rate the probability as, or is not enough known to really even make a guess?
I think there was a interaction between the human host and SIVcpz that caused it to become pathogenic. But it seems that this interaction is rare or unique.
 
I think there was a interaction between the human host and SIVcpz that caused it to become pathogenic. But it seems that this interaction is rare or unique.

What sort of rare or unique interactions do you consider the most likely?
 
What sort of rare or unique interactions do you consider the most likely?
I don't know enough about coreceptor usage by SIV/HIV, but as I said above there may have been unique sequence changes in the coreceptor(s) and virus that allowed the zoonotic infection to take hold and become pathogenic. How that happens I don't know, viral pathogenesis is complex. Maybe there are clues in how viruses are attenuated, for example a 12 base pair deletion in the nef gene in SIVmac is enough to make it fully apathogenic.
 
All quotes from skeptigirl in my response are in blue text, to make it easy to slice and dice, and respond.
Here is the crux of this thread.

I'm backing up here for a minute, probably due to the slack in the thread, sort of letting anyone who cares to catch up, and because I'm getting ready to drop a whole bunch of information from good sources, regarding HIV.

And we haven't even got to AIDS yet, which is far more controversial.

But back to that statement, Here is the crux of this thread. It isn't the crux of course, but one of the more salient points. How do you know who to trust? How can you know a source is valid? Honest? Open? Accurate?

To continue..

Do you get your information from someone you consider a good source? Is the information being presented by someone you have no clue about?

Interesting questions. Notice that rather than focusing on the information, how it was obtained, was it validated? Has the research been repeated? Can it stand up to scrutiny? Does it match other research? Has it passed peer review? Can you trust the data? Where did it come from? How was it obtained? Was there contamination? Cheating? What safe gaurds and checks were used? Does the firm, company, lab or researcher have bias? Vested interest? Was the funding from a source with a financial stake in the results? Etc etc.

Instead we are asked, Do you get your information from someone ... Is the information being presented by someone ..

So rather than look to the method, the resources, the technology, we focus on people. A person, or group of people. But then, the next thing is:

Science doesn't rely on any one person. Neither is it majority rule, though consensus does tend to indicate the evidence is being correctly interpreted.

So "science" doesn't rely on a person, but a consensus, sort of. Then we get to:

The essence of science is the evidence, not the people interpreting it. The evidence can be misinterpreted. Studies can be flawed. But the evidence is reality and it can eventually be determined in spite of false conclusions and poor study design and even random variation.

The evidence is reality. Like data, evidence, information, reports, like they exist in the Universe without bias, without error, with no problems, pure science, evidence, free of any chance of being wrong.

The bottom line is there is a reality out there. Since that is the case, when there is a controversy, it is not an insurmountable obstacle. It just means more research is needed to resolve the questions. Or it may mean that you simply need to sort out the evidence that is already available.

Now what is strange, is that I tend to agree with that last paragraph. In fact, that is just what I am doing. I tend to give weight to certain sources, and distrust others, based on obvious bias, prejudice, and vested interest involved. And because this is a skeptic forum, I tend to ignore the more woo sounding or conspiracy theory sort of stuff, for no other reason than it can't be verified, and those sights don't cite sources, or show the research they used to reach conclusion. Even if somebody is right, like Einstein, without research, testing of theories, or evidence to review, it is just theory. It might sound good, it may seem obvious that it is true, but it still needs to be validated, to have meaning.

I'm not bothered by the fact people have, "gotten it wrong". That's a no brainer. What concerns me about the way robinson is presenting his view here is why does anyone rely on other people to get it right.

I will admit I don't understand that statement.

I rely on me to know the principles of good science. I try to recognize the misleading persuasion techniques so I'm immunized against them. I always consider the bias of the person whose conclusions I am listening to when I evaluate their conclusions.

Again, I agree with that. I am the same way.

And I can evaluate the reliability and expertise of someone I am listening to beyond their educational degree.

I don't understand that claim at all. Especially considering the nature of this communication. If you want to be anonymous, your claim has no validity, other than what your words express. And you know little or nothing about others degree of learning. So it doesn't make any sense at all.

Robinson is pointing out all the scandals, all the woo headlines, all the conspiracy theories as if that means we cannot determine the truth.

That is your claim, your view. Thing is, nobody needs you to tell them what somebody is "doing", when they type words on your screen, or present information, research, data, and questions. That you think you know what I am pointing out, and why, is arrogance, and ignorance, especially considering your utter lack of stepping up and making any statement about what you believe, or what you know to be true about the subject.

But back to your post:
Or as if it means we need to argue about these less than credible versions of reality for which there will always be (in our lifetime anyway) human beings falsely claiming are the facts.

Again, that is your claim, your statement about what is. I tend to just ignore most of your lengthy responses, because the rarely contain anything of value, or add any new information to the topic. Case in point, this one I am responding to.

Nonsense. Good science is all you need to look at. Who cares that people are making this claim or that claim.

While I agree about good science, I certainly think who is making a claim matters. Especially when the issues are as vast and important as million of people dead, millions more to die, and billions of dollars at stake.

People will twist things, hide evidence, lie, steal, cheat and distort over a lot less than what is on the table when it comes to HIV and AIDS. Scientist have been known to cheat, lie and fudge things, just to keep a research grant, or to get ahead in their field. It happens, it has happened, it isn't something we like to think about, but we all know it. Scientist are people, they have feelings, egos, desires and flaws. While it is nice to imagine Science as being some great Holy pure thing, science is done by people, and people are flawed.

Since I can look at the evidence they based their conclusions on, at their biases which usually aren't hard to find, at how the other experts in the field view the conclusions, I'm not concerned about these supposed controversies.

Since I can look at the evidence they based their conclusions on

Now that I agree with you about. If I can see the evidence, the research, the peer reviewed experiments, tests and trust the source, it makes a difference.

If you can't tell the wheat from the chafe when you read all the clutter of information that is out there, if you can't tell who is right when you read about HIV conspiracy theories, then I guess you'd be in robinson's position. Relying on everyone else's interpretations of the evidence rather than on your evaluation of it.

Here you leave reality behind. I don't trust other peoples interpretation, that is exactly why I question things, do my own research, look at lots of sources, read the original papers, rather than take somebodies word for something. And even then, I am skeptical that they are perfect in their opinion about what it means. For example, I don't buy your brand of reality, or accept what you say, based on a complete lack of evidence that you are a credible source. And based on your faulty logic, your abundant fallacies, and your dismissal of information, before you have a clue what it is, makes me consider anything you say suspect.

Teach yourself to fish and you will not be relying on everyone else to tell you what reality is. It doesn't require expertise in every field. It merely requires a little expertise in recognizing BS when you see it.

While that sounds good, I think, what the hell does it really mean? The amount of expertise and advanced research techniques involved, make it impossible to know how to interpret everything you read in this matter. One has to accept at some level, that researchers and scientist are being as honest as they can, when they report findings. If you doubt everything, or try to validate everything in a field this rich and wide, you can't get anywhere.

If a scientific paper, published and indexed and stored in a reputable website, if you can't trust that data, all is lost.

Teach yourself to fish and you will not be relying on everyone else to tell you what reality is.

I tend to agree with that, to a point. But I also tend to accept that an article in the New England Journal, or Lancet, or Nature, has a great deal of credibility. I'm not expecting the author to tell me what reality is, but I trust the research is valid, as far as we can tell.

Your stuff, on the other hand, has no value at all. Based on the same criteria for sifting out the bull from the crap.

I have a pretty good built in BS detector. And I am quite capable of reading what has been published. I don't depend on you, or anyone else, to make up my mind for me.

:wackywink:
 
OK, after that long screed, which I already regret wasting 5 minutes of my life on, I feel the need to contribute, to mix it up, throw some facts around, post some links, and ask, seriously ask, because I really do value the skeptic mind, what you think of this.

Until these damn JREF topics involving AIDS on trial and does AIDS exist and AIDS(hah), whcih really got me going again, I really didn't give much thought or time to HIV/AIDS, mostly because it never became an epidemic in MY country, the US.

Sure I hear now and then about the horrible Pandemic that is destroying entire countries, civilizations are collapsing, populations falling, yadda yadda yadda, the sky is falling, whatever.

Thing is, you can't see it from my house. It was pretty much drug addicts and homobisexuals in my neck of the woods, very rare for anyone else to even get HIV+, much less develop AIDS.

Of all the people I know who got AIDS and died, or are still alive, (and on medications), everyone of them was an IV drug addict or homobisexual. Way more people have died from heart attacks, cancer and accidents. So I know I'm supposed to feel all terrible about the millions of kids orphaned, the millions dead from AIDS, show some fear and concern about the pandemic sweeping across the world, the horror, the horror... but frankly, drug addiction and drunk driving is way more problematic where I live.

But now I've been sucked back into looking at this topic, damn you troll, damn you to hell, and it has become interesting again. Mostly because of the claims a few people have made, that just don't make any sense.

Sure it might be I'm dumb, don't know a Virulence plasmid from a Polymerase chain reaction, wouldn't know a virus-inhibitory peptide if it walked up and infected me.

But I know how to read, my Google Fu is strong, and my computer fast. And I can smell BS a mile away. When I start running into dead ends, and the obvious stuff that should be there, just isn't there, it gets my curiosity up, and my fingers flying, and as usual, probably going to piss some people off.

Tough. Life is hard, wear a helmet.

Now way back in the day, before HIV was HIV, it was called other stuff. This leads to some serious confusion, since one of the things it was called, something else is now called that same name. But the old papers, the old research, hasn't been updated,, or edited, so the old stuff shows up under the old name, and the stuff they published, and researched, and thought about, is damn interesting.

Especially since nobody has gone back and edited any of it, much less thought to hide it and stuff. In fact, any attempt to change history, when it comes to published Journals and such, would be met with more than a little curiosity, from no less than the Publisher, as well as the people whose name is on it.

And what did I find? Well, I wish I could just tell you, but there is damn much of it, and it is confusing, because they changed names and techniques and even changed how it is talked about, but one thing didn't change. The people sniffing around and finding stuff out, they were hot on the trail of it, and they published everything they found, and were pretty damn open about what it might mean.

This was long before it became a political issue, a Gay issue, or an economic issue. It was then, a health and a science issue, and there is all kinds of information just sitting there. Maybe all the new stuff is just keeping everybody so busy, maybe it doesn't seem important, after all, if you have been told something is settled, its over, what reason would there be to do research on anything?

So after that long winded wind up, (yeah, yeah I know, just cut to the chase robinson, quit building the damn suspense already), just what can one find if one puts a little time into it?

And knows the right terms to look for?

And should I just post the links? Every time I do that, it is obvious nobody bothers to read them. I can tell, from the complete lack of input, and also because sometimes I know, that if somebody followed the link, they would have come back on may ass about it, for no other reason than to smack me silly over it. Because I am so well liked and stuff. You know, like a festering boil on the backside,

So here it is in a nutshell, and after skeptichick or somebody tries to hammer me about it, then I will do the quote and paste thing, and you can decide for yourself what is what.

Facts, as I understand them based on research published.

Primates have a bunch of retroviruses.
Some of them, when they cross species, cause a buttload of problems, the biggest one being death, but not without a great deal of suffering first.
This can happen from one Primate hunting and eating another. These retroviruses, (as well as other nasty surprises), seem to be able to mutate like sons of bitches, and either kill you or you develop immunity to them.
And science, science don't know much about them.
Well, a crapload more now than 40 years ago, but still, some of them haven;t even been NAMED yet, much less does anybody have any idea of what they do, or don't do.
What we do know, is that monkeys, baboons, chimps and humans can infect each other.
And we know how to screw with these interesting little molecules.
We use them to try and insert DNA into cells, we use them to experiment, we use them to Bio-engineer stuff, and we have combined them, and spread them, both knowingly, and unknowingly, all over the planet.
And some of them can kill you. They kill monkeys too.
We know an awful lot about certain ones.
What we don't know much about, is how to experiment with them, because of the damn Chimp/Monkey problem.
(Oh, and I looked it up, there have been a LOT of chimps used in research. For AIDS research alone they bred a thousand Chimps, all of whom ended up worthless for research, and have cost a lot of money taking care of them.

Note: One thing that is really hard to hide. Money. It cost money to raise and care for Chimps. Somebody has to pay. Records are kept. You can find out about almost every chimp ever used because somebody had to pay for them somebody had to care for them, and they cost money. And when money is involved, records are kept.

Usually. Except in Africa, where you just go out and catch some when you need em. Those records are hard to come by. Pity.

So here is the thing, it looks like way back before they knew what it was, but they damn sure knew what it was doing, and what it was made of, a lot of research was done. While we tend to remember Gallo and the French, because they "discovered" HIV, and claimed it was the cause of "AIDS", it is easy to forget all the other research that was being done at the same time.

Lots and lots of research. And while they didn't call it HIV, they certainly reported on it. A lot. And, because at the time research wasn't dictated by HIV/AIDS, or theories that Africans ate Chimps, got AIDS, and corn holed a virus across the planet, the research tends to be very interesting, and very open.

What is true? Well, I tend to trust this research, especially the published stuff, because it was so innocent and open. Nobody was worried about anything but finding out WHAT it was, HOW it was doing stuff, and what it was doing.

Now it might seem unbelievable that after all the time and money spent, that nobody has published a paper that explains exactly how HIV kills you, that does seem to be the case right now. As far as I know. Maye somebody is hiding that research paper, I dunno.

We got theories galore, but when it comes down to it, nobody knows. Or they are not telling.

Nobody knows where HIV came from, how it spread, how many times did it jump species, how it mutated, or what to do to stop it. Not for lack of trying for sure.

So having caused you such great suffering, all that dam reading, lest look at a few choice items, culled from the mass of research, back when HIV wasn't HIV, but was called lymphadenopathy-associated virus, or HTLV-III/LAV. Got that?

It is important to remember that HIV used to be HTLV-III/LAV, or HTLV-IV, or just HTLV-III, or perhaps HTLV-IIIAGM. But read the damn articles and you can figure it out.

The etiologic agent of AIDS is believed to be the virus HTLV-III/LAV, which has been proposed as having originated from a recent simian-human transmission in Africa. This report describes the isolation of a designated STLV-IIIAGM retrovirus closely related to HTLV-III/LAV from seven healthy wild-caught African Green monkeys (Cercopithecus aethiops) that showed the presence of antibodies designated STLV-IIIAGM. In vitro growth characteristics, ultrastructural morphology, and major proteins of 160,000 kilodaltons (kD), 120 kD, 55 kD, and 24 kD are similar to and cross-reactive with the analogous antigens of HTLV-III/LAV. The use of these serologic markers in the detection of STLV-IIIAGM-infected monkeys may be important in assuring the continued safety of a variety of biologic reagents that are derived from these primate species. The existence of a retrovirus closely related to HTLV-III/LAV that naturally infects an African nonhuman primate in the apparent absence of disease may provide a unique model for the study of human AIDS and the development of an effective vaccine.
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/230/4728/951

This report describes serologic evidence for a virus similar to that known as simian T-lymphotropic virus type III of African Green monkeys (STLV-IIIAGM) infecting apparently healthy people in Senegal, West Africa, and the isolation of virus from these individuals. Serum samples from selected healthy West African people showed unusual serologic profiles when tested with antigens of HTLV-III/LAV, the etiologic agent of AIDS, and of STLV-IIIAGM. The samples reacted strongly with all of the major viral antigens of STLV-IIIAGM but showed variable or no reactivity with the major viral antigens of HTLV-III/LAV by radioimmunoprecipitation and sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. A new human T-lymphotropic virus (HTLV-IV) isolated from these people was grown in vitro and shown to have retroviral type particles, growth characteristics, and major viral proteins similar to those of the STLV-III and HTLV-III/LAV group of retroviruses. The gp120/160, gp32, p64, p55, p53, p24, and p15 proteins precipitated were the same size as and reactive with STLV-IIIAGM proteins. The serologic data suggest that this virus shares more common epitopes with STLV-IIIAGM than with the prototype HTLV-III/LAV that infects people in the United States and Europe. Further study of this virus and of the origin of the HTLV-III/LAV group of viruses may expand our understanding of the human AIDS virus.
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/232/4747/238

The T-cell tropic retrovirus of macaque monkeys STLV-III has morphologic, growth, and antigenic properties indicating that it is related to HTLV-III/LAV, the etiologic agent of the acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS) in humans. Four of six rhesus monkeys died within 160 days of STLV-III inoculation with a wasting syndrome, opportunistic infections, a primary retroviral encephalitis, and immunologic abnormalities including a decrease in T4+ peripheral blood lymphocytes. These data show that an immunodeficiency syndrome can be produced experimentally in a nonhuman primate by an agent from the HTLV-III/LAV group of retroviruses. The STLV-III-macaque system will thus provide a useful model for the study of antiviral agents and vaccine development for human AIDS.
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/230/4721/71



HTLV-III/LAV-like retrovirus particles in the brains of patients with AIDS encephalopathy.

Epstein LG, Sharer LR, Cho ES, Myenhofer M, Navia B, Price RW.

It has been postulated that the retrovirus HTLV-III/LAV thought to be the etiologic agent of AIDS also infects the central nervous system and directly causes AIDS encephalopathy. Electron microscopical studies performed on brain sections from three patients with AIDS complicated by progressive encephalopathy revealed structures morphologically consistent with HTLV-III/LAV retrovirus particles. The particles were located principally within multinucleated giant cells but were also present in astrocytes. Many particles were also noted in the extracellular space.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=6100783&dopt=Citation

The complete 9193-nucleotide sequence of the probable causative agent of AIDS, lymphadenopathy-associated virus (LAV), has been determined. The deduced genetic structure is unique: it shows, in addition to the retroviral gag, pol, and env genes, two novel open reading frames we call O and F Remarkably, Q is located between pol and env and F is half-encoded by the U3 element of the LTR. These data place LAV apart from the previously characterized family of human T cell leukemia/lymphoma viruses.
http://www.cell.com/content/article/abstract?uid=PII0092867485903034
Genetic analysis of a new subgroup of human and simian T-lymphotropic retroviruses: HTLV-IV, LAV-2, SBL-6669, and STLV-IIIAGM.

AIDS Res Hum Retroviruses. 1987 Spring;3(1):11-7. Unique Identifier : AIDSLINE MED/87299191
Franchini G; Collalti E; Arya SK; Fenyo EM; Biberfeld G; Zagury JF; Kanki PJ; Wong-Staal F; Gallo RC
Abstract: A new primate retrovirus, STLV-IIIAGM, has been recently isolated from healthy African green monkeys and is apparently nonpathogenic in its natural host. However, spontaneous infection as well as inoculation of STLV-IIIAGM into macaques induces a disease with clinical features that resemble human AIDS. Independent isolates of human retroviruses, serologically closely related to STLV-IIIAGM, have been obtained from healthy individuals (HTLV-IV) and patients with immunodeficiency (LAV-2FG and SBL 6669) from West Africa. The latter have also been referred to as HIV-2 because, like HTLV-III/HIV-1, they may be associated with immune deficiency, or as West African human retroviruses because of their prevalence and probable origin from that region. We have molecularly cloned the STLV-IIIAGM genome and have generated probes from the gag-pol and envelope genes to analyze the genetic relatedness of these simian and human retroviruses. Our results indicate that all these retroviruses are genetically closely related to each other, HTLV-IV and STLV-IIIAGM differing only by a few restriction enzyme sites while LAV-2FG and SBL 6669 exhibit greater polymorphism from HTLV-IV/STLV-IIIAGM. These data mirror the variable degree of relatedness among members of the first subgroup of human retroviruses, HTLV-III/HIV.
http://www.aegis.com/aidsline/1987/dec/M87C0097.html

Oh trust me, there is a whole lot more than that.

Barré-Sinoussi, F. et al. Science 220, 868–871 (1983).

Montagnier, L. et al. in Human T-Cell Leukemia/Lymphoma Virus (eds Gallo, R. C., Essex, M. & Gross, L.) 363–379 (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, New York, 1984).

Feorino, P. M. et al. Science 225, 69–72 (1984).

Levy, J. A. et al. Science 225, 840–842 (1984).|

Gallo, R. C., Essex, M. & Gross, L. (eds) Human T-Cell Leukemia/Lymphoma Virus (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, New York, 1984).

Watanabe, T., Seiki, M. & Yoshida, M. Science 222, 1178 (1983)|

Hirt, B. J. molec. Biol. 26, 365–369 (1967).


There are THOUSANDS of studies, papers and published articles on lymphadenopathy-associated virus, HTLV-III, HTLV-III/LAV, and all the supposed Primate versions of it. And guess what? If you skimmed over the quoted articles, here is a phrase from one of them that might get your attention.
The use of these serologic markers in the detection of STLV-IIIAGM-infected monkeys may be important in assuring the continued safety of a variety of biologic reagents that are derived from these primate species.
Science 22 November 1985:
Vol. 230. no. 4728, pp. 951 - 954
DOI: 10.1126/science.2997923


Lets edit the name, (which is now called SIV), to help understand what it says.

The use of these serologic markers in the detection of SIV-infected monkeys may be important in assuring the continued safety of a variety of biologic reagents that are derived from these primate species.
 
Last edited:
And if you can debunk that smoking gun, please do. Because there are a hundred more just like it. Not from some woo site, (I found none of this on any denialist/conspiracy site), but in respectable journals.

You can be assured, that I am not making any of this up. I always try to link to the source, so you can debunk it, dismiss it, or read it. I think you should decide for yourself, not take my word for it.

These data show that an immunodeficiency syndrome can be produced experimentally in a nonhuman primate by an agent from the HTLV-III/LAV group of retroviruses.

If you update the name, it makes more sense.
These data show that an immunodeficiency syndrome can be produced experimentally in a nonhuman primate by an agent from the HIV group of retroviruses.

Funny thing is, there is recent research on this, and indeed, Monkeys can get AIDS if you give them the right HIV.
 
Last edited:
The use of these serologic markers in the detection of STLV-IIIAGM-infected monkeys may be important in assuring the continued safety of a variety of biologic reagents that are derived from these primate species.
After all that, you appear to implying that HIV could have begun from infected viral vaccines? Remember, that SIVcpz not SIVagm is the zoonotic infection of humans that causes AIDS, this was derived from chimpanzees NOT African green monkeys. The early polio vaccines were prepared on monkey kidney cells, if HIV came from monkeys via SIVagm then there would have been a huge epidemic in the late '50s, don't you think?
 

After all that, you appear to implying that HIV could have begun from infected viral vaccines? Remember, that SIVcpz not SIVagm is the zoonotic infection of humans that causes AIDS, this was derived from chimpanzees NOT African green monkeys. The early polio vaccines were prepared on monkey kidney cells, if HIV came from monkeys via SIVagm then there would have been a huge epidemic in the late '50s, don't you think?
You are implying this hasn't been the case. Why? Consider the following possibilities:
-SIVagm didn't turn virulent until the 70-80ies
-SIVagm has a latency of 30 years and caused the AIDS cases in the 80ies and produced false positives on HIV tests
-SIVagm caused an AIDS-like epidemic in the 60-70ies, but this wasn't recognized as such
-SIVagm is harmless, never turned virulent, and the same is true for HIV

Any statement of the type that something can't be is almost always wrong.
 
Another claim with no evidence, reasoning, or data to help the interested mind see what, why or how the claim came to be a belief. I'm not dissin a one line reply with no value, (I've made my share :)), but in a thread about facts, myth, and knowing what is true, it isn't advancing either skepticism, or knowledge.
Nonono you got it all wrong. Skepticism isn't about questioning stuff that everybody knows is true. Skepticism is about unquestioningly accepting whatever the majority of scientists subscribe to, while making fun of and/or agressing the intellectual minorities such as Creationists, Homeopaths, HIV-Reappraisers etc.
 
Nonono you got it all wrong. Skepticism isn't about questioning stuff that everybody knows is true. Skepticism is about unquestioningly accepting whatever the majority of scientists subscribe to, while making fun of and/or agressing the intellectual minorities such as Creationists, Homeopaths, HIV-Reappraisers etc.

Well, that is part of it, but certainly not all of it. I agree that it seems that way at times, but there are a lot of very interesting scientific discussions about other stuff. I consider skepticism a philosophy that question anything that seems questionable.


After all that, you appear to implying that HIV could have begun from infected viral vaccines? Remember, that SIVcpz not SIVagm is the zoonotic infection of humans that causes AIDS, this was derived from chimpanzees NOT African green monkeys.

I hope I have been open and honest enough so that you believe me when I tell you this: I don't know. There are way too many factors involved. And the name changes makes it almost impossible to follow the threads back then. If you, or anyone else, could post a set of facts as you understand them, it would make it much easier to understand.

And links to sources where I can see why you said it, for example
Remember, that SIVcpz not SIVagm is the zoonotic infection of humans that causes AIDS, this was derived from chimpanzees NOT African green monkeys

Where did that come from? This is how I work. I see something claimed as fact, I go check it. Almost instantly it becomes obvious that there is a lot of questions raised by your statement. It's not that I dismiss it, I check it out instead.

Here is the first couple of things I see-

At last year's Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections, Dr. David Ho and others from the Aaron Diamond AIDS Research Center at Rockefeller University presented evidence that the virus probably first infected people around 50 years ago.

At the opening of this year's meeting, Hahn made the case that this event almost certainly occurred in west equatorial Africa when someone caught the virus from a chimp, perhaps after killing the ape for food.

Hahn said her team confirmed the connection by analyzing frozen tissue saved from Marilyn, who died in 1984 at age 26 from childbirth complications at a U.S. Air Force primate center.

The chimp version of the AIDS virus, thought to be the grandfather of HIV, is called SIVcpz. It is extremely rare among chimps in U.S. lab colonies, apparently because they are removed from the wild at a young age and never exposed to the virus sexually.
http://www.cnn.com/HEALTH/9901/31/aids.origin/

The '99 story about how HIV came from chimps. Fact added to the datastream, the chimp came from an Air Force Lab, which I didn't know until now. (The Air Force and NASA used a lot of chimps, in case you didn't know.) Then I check the fact that it is rare. How about in wild chimps?

Working in Côte d’Ivoire, Uganda and Tanzania, Hahn’s team collected urine in upturned umbrellas left beneath chimp nests. They tested this for antibodies against SIVcpz (simian immunodeficiency virus). They then tested the faeces of SIVcpz -positive animals to identify which virus strain they had. Three strains of SIVcpz are closely related to HIV-1, which causes the majority of AIDS deaths in the West.

Of 58 animals tested, just one had SIVcpz. This figure has HIV experts intrigued: SIV rates can reach 90% in other primates such as African green monkeys. Many expected similar levels of infection in wild chimps.
http://www.innovations-report.com/html/reports/life_sciences/report-7082.html

See? The reason I always try to quote sources, is so anyone can follow the information, and do their own checking. So I learn from that a few things:

Three strains of SIVcpz are closely related to HIV-1
SIV rates can reach 90% in other primates such as African green monkeys.
SIVcpz seems to be rare in wild Chimps too.

See? Based on a lot of studies and published data, strains of SIVcpz are found in chimps, and monkeys, but while common in monkeys, it is rare in chimps.

But obviously, lab chimps somehow are found to have the exact strain believed to have jumped species to become HIV.

This may seem disjointed, because I haven't posted the other links to sources, all of which are about this very issue. What are the facts? Can we trust all these documents from the sixties, seventies and eighties? Do you trust a publication from Nature or the Lancet? New England Journal of Medicine? Science?

Because there is a wealth of evidence from back then.

What does it mean?

The early polio vaccines were prepared on monkey kidney cells, if HIV came from monkeys via SIVagm then there would have been a huge epidemic in the late '50s, don't you think?

That is bad reasoning. It isn't that simple. There is also a time lag from exposure, to mutation, to transmission, to development of disease. If a disease was spread by vaccine, it would have a time lag, and show up in clusters, because it is obvious that all vaccines were not contaminated, nobody believes that.

It also does not explain the evidence of AIDS showing up in the US and Europe in clusters, all at the same time. And it certainly doesn't explain a few other facts.
 
And links to sources where I can see why you said it, for example
Remember, that SIVcpz not SIVagm is the zoonotic infection of humans that causes AIDS, this was derived from chimpanzees NOT African green monkeys

Where did that come from?
Please read my posts earlier in this thread. I linked to several papers that reported this.
Here is the first couple of things I see-


http://www.cnn.com/HEALTH/9901/31/aids.origin/

The '99 story about how HIV came from chimps. Fact added to the datastream, the chimp came from an Air Force Lab, which I didn't know until now. (The Air Force and NASA used a lot of chimps, in case you didn't know.) Then I check the fact that it is rare. How about in wild chimps?
Again I cited papers that showed that SIVcpz has an infection rate around 30% in chimps in regions of Africa where the related HIV-1 strains are also present.

That is bad reasoning. It isn't that simple. There is also a time lag from exposure, to mutation, to transmission, to development of disease. If a disease was spread by vaccine, it would have a time lag, and show up in clusters, because it is obvious that all vaccines were not contaminated, nobody believes that.
How do you know the chronology of how HIV-1 spreads?

It also does not explain the evidence of AIDS showing up in the US and Europe in clusters, all at the same time. And it certainly doesn't explain a few other facts.
Why can't it be spread in clusters because it was brought back form Afirca by international travellers who then spread it further in their locale?
 
No time to play today, but for anyone who doubts that a retrovirus can cause disease, here are a few facts. No doubt about it at all.

This is another reason that most people accept that HIV causes AIDS.

The SIV strains, endemic in African monkeys, which are almost exactly the same as HIV, doesn't make them sick, but causes AIDS in Asian
species of primates, such as the stump tailed macaque, and the
rhesus macaque.

The two kinds of HIV causing people to become ill, look almost exactly like SIV, and HIV-2 is very similar to a SIV. If it had been found in Monkeys first, it would be called a SIV. (In fact, it was, several times)

SIV viruses infect macrophages and CD4 cells
selectively, just as the HIV strains do. The syndrome they cause
in Asian monkeys includes lymphadenopathy, wasting, lymphoma,
lymphocyte depletion, and many opportunistic infections such as
Pneumocystis pneumonia, CMV retinitis, chronic cryptosporidia
diarrhea, and invasive candidiasis. They also cause encephalitis
and brain dysfunction.

This experiment has been done over and over. There is no doubt that a new SIV introduced into a primate that has no resistance to it, can cause AIDS like symptoms.
 
No time to play today, but for anyone who doubts that a retrovirus can cause disease, here are a few facts. No doubt about it at all.

This is another reason that most people accept that HIV causes AIDS.

The SIV strains, endemic in African monkeys, which are almost exactly the same as HIV, doesn't make them sick, but causes AIDS in Asian
species of primates, such as the stump tailed macaque, and the
rhesus macaque.

The two kinds of HIV causing people to become ill, look almost exactly like SIV, and HIV-2 is very similar to a SIV. If it had been found in Monkeys first, it would be called a SIV. (In fact, it was, several times)



This experiment has been done over and over. There is no doubt that a new SIV introduced into a primate that has no resistance to it, can cause AIDS like symptoms.
With respect robinson, but we have already stated this (not sure if it's in this thread or the AIDS(hah) one).
 
robinson:

Um, it said SIV rates are up to 90% in other primates, not specifically SIVcpz. I suspect they were discussing other strains of SIV particular to the individual species. The article never clarifies this point.

I know, I have a wealth of data on this, but no time today to answer you with a detailed and linked response.

You could do some research yourself. There are thousands of papers on this. It is not simple. There are LOTS of strains of SIVs, and they are different.


The results indicated that West African green monkeys are naturally infected with SIVs which are closely related to East African SIVagm isolates. However, structural, antigenic, and genetic differences were observed which strongly suggest that the West African green monkey viruses comprise a phylogenetically distinct subgroup of SIVagm.
http://jvi.asm.org/cgi/content/abstract/65/6/2816

The variability among SIVagm isolates exceeded the variability among any other group of primate lentiviruses. Our data suggest that SIVagm has been in the African green monkey population for a long time and may be the oldest primate lentivirus group in existence.
http://jvi.asm.org/cgi/content/abst...FIRSTINDEX=0&minscore=4000&resourcetype=HWCIT
Genetic distances indicated that SIVagm isolates from tantalus monkeys are the most divergent among SIVagm in feral AGMs in Africa. The fact that AGMs are infected by four distinct lentiviruses, each specific for a single AGM species, supports the hypothesis of a coevolution of these viruses and their natural hosts and suggests that SIV transmission is a rare event among separated AGM species in the wild.
http://jvi.asm.org/cgi/content/abst...FIRSTINDEX=0&minscore=4000&resourcetype=HWCIT

See? That is just the tip of the iceberg.
 
Last edited:
With respect robinson, but we have already stated this (not sure if it's in this thread or the AIDS(hah) one).

I know, but sometimes it doesn't hurt to repeat stuff.

ETA: As I posted before SIV from african monkeys is not harmless in Asian macaques.

It might help to point out, that the SIV mentioned, is almost exactly the same as HIV-2. HIV-2 could be labeled SIV, if it is found in Monkeys. In people, it is HIV-2.
 
Last edited:
robinson:

I was just saying that to point out the error in your earlier statement:
Based on a lot of studies and published data, strains of SIVcpz are found in chimps, and monkeys, but while common in monkeys, it is rare in chimps.

That statement, as it stands, is incorrect. It should read:

Based on a lot of studies and published data, strains of SIVcpz are found in chimps while other strains are found in monkeys. But while other SIV strains are common in monkeys, SIVcpz is rare in chimps.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom