HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

So in almost every country, except those in Africa, most HIV, most HIV that develops into AIDS, and HIV that results in AIDS that results in death, has been homobisexual men or I.V. drug users.

I think this is what you meant.
 
I guess one needs to be an M.D. and be in HIV/AIDS field to know all these things.
Teach a man/woman to fish and you feed them for a lifetime.

You can teach people/learn for yourself how to evaluate the information they are confronted with/exposed to/seek out for its validity. You can teach people/learn for yourself how to spot a con job and how to spot woo. Then you do not need to be anything other than a skeptic.
 
I think this is what you meant.

I appreciate that. I'm trying to gather sources and put it together in a coherent manner. Remember, I believe HIV/AIDS to be a real and deadly problem. I'm also trying to avoid the most blatant sources that would either have extreme bias, or sound like conspiracy theory.

I've never come across such an amazing amount of crap and conflicting data in my entire life. And I don't understand a lot of the advanced microbiology stuff, and a lot of leads end up in dead ends. And a lot of the data is classified or hidden.

This started because somebody started the thread AIDS(hah), claiming HIV wasn't dangerous, and that AIDS was made up or something. It got complicated, and I would love to just know the facts man. I lost friends to AIDS, and I spent a lot of time in the 80s on the issue, in a professional way. Sorry, I can't tell you more, it would violate the personal information rule. But it was to prevent HIV from spreading, and I saw people with late stage AIDS up close and personal, and some died before the project was finished.

I'm trying to put things in individual post to make it easy to debunk or add to each data point.

I have no doubt some of them are in error, or incomplete. I don't claim to be an expert, or know more than everybody. In fact, everything is from other sources, I have no direct experimentation or original research at all.
 
HIV is not allowed to be debated by the ruling class.

That one is obviously not true for us, because so far nobody has censored or tried to stop a debate here. But are we the ruling class? :)

I'm pretty sure nobody is debating it on TV right now. Or in mainstream Journals. It really might be just a minor factoid, it didn't need to be included in the list really.
 
OK that is enough out of me. I apologize if it seems like too many post in a row. I'm sure there will be debunking, other sources, conflicting information and commentary to come.

As long as it is educational, I have no problem with any of that. And, you never know, somebody might change their mind. If nothing else, I've already learned a lot of new stuff, based on links provided.

Fascinating stuff. I had no idea how much DNA we seem to be using that came from a retrovirus "invading" our Genetic code.

And then there is stuff like this:
Researchers Discover That Sheep Need Retroviruses For Reproduction

Science Daily — A team of scientists from Texas A&M University and The University of Glasgow Veterinary School in Scotland has discovered that naturally occurring endogenous retroviruses are required for pregnancy in sheep.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/09/060911233630.htm

Whoa. That is wild, just wild stuff.
 
Robinson,
I can only spare the time to post now and again, so I am a bit dismayed at the speed at which these threads move - as you say, some posts/threads require some relishing and research before responding, by which time there have been 3 more pages added, and no-one is paying attention any more.

Can I ask what made you compile your OP list?
Are these "facts" you wish to have confirmed/rebutted, or are they some of your own ideas on the subject?

HIV is complex, and "AIDS" more so. But I could compile a long list of misconceptions about almost anything - TB for example, or diabetes. I could extend your list over several pages if you wished, by including facts, theories and lies about the virus which have been presented in some way somewhere.

What does it achieve to produce such a list? Each point on your list could be tackled but at the risk of ballooning this thread enormously as people juggle back and forth between points. It will become very hard to follow.
 
Can I ask what made you compile your OP list?
Are these "facts" you wish to have confirmed/rebutted, or are they some of your own ideas on the subject?

If you follow the link, you can read how it came about. As I said, I want to know the truth. They are "facts" as reported on web pages and publications. Is it true or not? The group of diverse people here is much better than just my feeble mind at determining this.

And yes, the sheer volume is daunting. I'm not sure what the solution is. But I figure about two years and we could get a good idea of some of them.:D

HIV is complex, and "AIDS" more so. But I could compile a long list of misconceptions about almost anything - TB for example, or diabetes. I could extend your list over several pages if you wished, by including facts, theories and lies about the virus which have been presented in some way somewhere.

Please don't. I try to avoid the wilder claims and publications on this. I'm a skeptic after all. A thread on them could go in the Conspiracy section, or something.

What does it achieve to produce such a list? Each point on your list could be tackled but at the risk of ballooning this thread enormously as people juggle back and forth between points. It will become very hard to follow.

Yes, but that is the nature of the issue. At least one person has praised the distillation into a single post. As to what it achieves, that is up to each person to decide. My hope would be to help dismiss the most glaring errors in what is believed, based on either bad press, or propaganda, from both sides of the deabte.
 
Robinson: "We are people, they are people. people make mistakes, people can be wrong. In fact, it is certain we will be wrong at some point. Everybody can even be wrong."

Here is the crux of this thread. Do you get your information from someone you consider a good source? Is the information being presented by someone you have no clue about?

Science doesn't rely on any one person. Neither is it majority rule, though consensus does tend to indicate the evidence is being correctly interpreted. The essence of science is the evidence, not the people interpreting it. The evidence can be misinterpreted. Studies can be flawed. But the evidence is reality and it can eventually be determined in spite of false conclusions and poor study design and even random variation.

The bottom line is there is a reality out there. Since that is the case, when there is a controversy, it is not an insurmountable obstacle. It just means more research is needed to resolve the questions. Or it may mean that you simply need to sort out the evidence that is already available.

I'm not bothered by the fact people have, "gotten it wrong". That's a no brainer. What concerns me about the way robinson is presenting his view here is why does anyone rely on other people to get it right. I rely on me to know the principles of good science. I try to recognize the misleading persuasion techniques so I'm immunized against them. I always consider the bias of the person whose conclusions I am listening to when I evaluate their conclusions. And I can evaluate the reliability and expertise of someone I am listening to beyond their educational degree.

Robinson is pointing out all the scandals, all the woo headlines, all the conspiracy theories as if that means we cannot determine the truth. Or as if it means we need to argue about these less than credible versions of reality for which there will always be (in our lifetime anyway) human beings falsely claiming are the facts. Nonsense. Good science is all you need to look at. Who cares that people are making this claim or that claim. Since I can look at the evidence they based their conclusions on, at their biases which usually aren't hard to find, at how the other experts in the field view the conclusions, I'm not concerned about these supposed controversies.

If you can't tell the wheat from the chafe when you read all the clutter of information that is out there, if you can't tell who is right when you read about HIV conspiracy theories, then I guess you'd be in robinson's position. Relying on everyone else's interpretations of the evidence rather than on your evaluation of it.

Teach yourself to fish and you will not be relying on everyone else to tell you what reality is. It doesn't require expertise in every field. It merely requires a little expertise in recognizing BS when you see it.
 
Strandstrom HV, Higgins JR, Mossie K, et al. Studies with canine sera that contain antibodies which recognize human immunodeficiency virus structural proteins.

For the record, there is no evidence that dogs can get HIV or AIIDS.
Well, this is typical of how things are misinterpreted by the layperson. You said that HIV could be detected in the blood of dogs. That is wrong because it is not HIV that is detected but antibodies that can cross-react witn HIV proteins. A common problem with western blot tests. Yet somehow the interpretation is that dog's are infected with HIV.
 
May 11, 1987, The London Times
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/1105346a2fa6e417b4.jpg

I would link to the article, but I can't find it online. It had an interview with Gallo himself, as well as WHO information, and some really interesting statistics to back up the story.





Obviously, this story, and the resulting reaction to it, is going to be difficult to verify. As in, what is the truth?
It is entirely supposition not supported by facts.
 
Wait a minute. Are you saying HIV CAN be contracted from lab primates? By a needlestick? Bites? How?

Are you aware that over 10,000 Chimps have been used in research labs? And they have been used for a very long time? For all kinds of experiments, including cancer and vaccine trials? As well as used to culture vaccines? Do you have any idea how many needlesticks, bites and culture accidents occurred?

If you believe HIV came from Chimps, and the lab chimps came from Africa .... and you can get HIV from chimps ... well... do you want to open that door? Think about it.
Yes I am saying someone may be infected (not contracted) by an HIV+ lab chimps, through biting or when taking blood for example. But this is only restricted to those chimps that have been experimentally infected with HIV in the lab. So it is a very special scenario but a theoretical one none the less.

Where did you get the 10,000 figure from? Are you lumping chimps and monkeys together?
 
Remember how this topic starts off. HIV is different depending on where you are. There are multiple strains, types, and it spreads differently in different regions, populations and countries.

It helps to remember HIV is not just a retrovirus. It is multiple things. Once we get to AIDS it gets much more complex.
No it is just a retrovirus. HTLV-I and HTLV-II preceded its discovery, HIV-I (formerly HTLV-III) was just another T-lymphotropic retrovirus along with HIV-2.
 
May 11, 1987, The London Times
1105346a2fa6e417b4.jpg

...Obviously, this story, and the resulting reaction to it, is going to be difficult to verify. As in, what is the truth?
You are correct in that this is one harder for the layperson to sort out. A Google search for "aids smallpox vaccine the London times interview Dr Gallo" gets pages and pages of websites discussing and mostly promoting the false hypothesis that HIV is a man-made virus.

What I would recommend to someone trying to sift the truth out of this particular mass conspiracy bonanza is to recognize that genetic science maps the origin of species. So I would go to the genetic research data base to resolve this controversy. Every single genetic researcher is not going to be in on the government conspiracy or coverup. If HIV were truly the spawn of smallpox or bioweapons research, then the genetic fingerprints would be all over it.

Instead, the genetic research connects HIV to its natural origin.
 
Again, I have a problem with how this statement is misleading. The articles you linked to are about drug companies making profits from the anti-retrovirals. Your statement "HIV has made some people very very wealthy." implies that individual people have personally made a lot of money.
 
...

If you believe HIV came from Chimps, and the lab chimps came from Africa .... and you can get HIV from chimps ... well... do you want to open that door? Think about it.
This is faulty logic.

The genetic evidence indicates HIV crossed the species barrier at some point in the past. It could have been as recently as 50 years ago. But that doesn't mean an animal host has been identified and it certainly doesn't mean chimpanzees are that animal host. I believe the African Green monkey is suspected, not chimpanzees but anyone interested can find out on the Net I'm sure.

In addition, people are not sharing injection needles with lab chimps nor are they having sex with chimps. HIV is transmitted from person to person and an animal reservoir is not implicated as playing a major role in the current epidemiology of HIV. So all the infected lab animals in the world are not the source of HIV, nor do lab animals pose a significant risk of spread to humans as a whole. An individual lab worker may be at risk, but that's it. And, you'd have to see how much viral replication went on in chimpanzees since they do not exhibit symptoms of AIDS when infected with HIV to know if individual lab workers are at risk. Lab workers are at risk of herpes B virus from chimpanzees and it hasn't crossed the species barrier and become a human to human infection.
 
This is faulty logic.

The genetic evidence indicates HIV crossed the species barrier at some point in the past. It could have been as recently as 50 years ago. But that doesn't mean an animal host has been identified and it certainly doesn't mean chimpanzees are that animal host. I believe the African Green monkey is suspected, not chimpanzees but anyone interested can find out on the Net I'm sure.

In addition, people are not sharing injection needles with lab chimps nor are they having sex with chimps. HIV is transmitted from person to person and an animal reservoir is not implicated as playing a major role in the current epidemiology of HIV. So all the infected lab animals in the world are not the source of HIV, nor do lab animals pose a significant risk of spread to humans as a whole. An individual lab worker may be at risk, but that's it. And, you'd have to see how much viral replication went on in chimpanzees since they do not exhibit symptoms of AIDS when infected with HIV to know if individual lab workers are at risk. Lab workers are at risk of herpes B virus from chimpanzees and it hasn't crossed the species barrier and become a human to human infection.
Please see my posts #31 and #36.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom