HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

?? sorry I have to ask, but--what's 'dry sex'?

is it like 'dry beer'?

The women put herbs in their vaginas to reduce lubrication. (like the opposite of Astroglide).
I have no idea what herbs they are or how they work, but the idea is to increase friction, which results in small abrasions (blood, which is good for HIV transmission).
 


It seems that there are more people questioning stuff than you might think, from watching TV. I have to agree with the point about the Media not being skeptical. This isn't just about HIV, but lots of stuff.
 
And I could suffer from PCP and not have HIV/AIDS.

Yes if you had a different underlying cause of immunosuppression.
Little game: Name 10 or so reasons for immunosuppression.

-Lack of Sunlight
-Lack of a diet rich in fresh fruit
-Junk food (in general a crappy diet)
-Smoking
-Protein-rich diet
-Medication, in general
-Medication, cancer therapy
-Medication, HIV therapy
-Medication for transplant immunosuppression
-Not enough exercise
-Carcinogens
-clinical depression
-not enough sex
-genetic factors
-IV Drugs
-Nitrite inhalants
-Other drugs (see also: medication in general)
-HIV?

But if you've got HIV, and you PCP, you've got AIDS, by definition.

Not to mention that dying of PCP probably has been around in medieval times already. (Only the germ theory of disease and microscopes even allowed for PCP to be identified as a distinct cause/symptom of lung infection)

In spite of arguing with W for the fun of it, I've always thought heavy drug use probably accelerates HIV disease progression. At the very least, heavy drug use tends to be so all consuming that people forget to eat, or don't care, become malnourished, and that makes things fall apart. There aren't too many infectious diseases that aren't remarkable worse in the malnourished.
Do heroin. Clean needles, clean dope. Do it all the time, so you don't feel no hunger, you don't feel any pain. Wait. After a while you'll be suffering from gross malnutrition, lack of exercise, lack of sunlight, and probably a host of other things as well. You get PCP and go to a doctor.

Interestingly, only now you get tested for HIV (which has a good rate for returning a false positive in cases of an acute infection) and are now diagnosed with AIDS, as a result you receive antiretroviral treatment. Since you're addicted to heroin and HIV is identified as causing the PCP, you aren't stopping the heroin.

How long till you're another AIDS death statistic? Do the scientific thing and figure it out.

How many unnecessary deaths does the HIV/AIDS theory cause each year (as a counter argument to the "denialists murder/eat babies" argument)
 
Interestingly, only now you get tested for HIV (which has a good rate for returning a false positive in cases of an acute infection)
You've said this before, what is the figure you have for "a good rate"? If a test is positive a different confirmatory test is subsequently performed.
 
Western blot is false positive 5-10% of the time.

http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/280/12/1080

Antibody tests are wrong a lot more often.

Note that acute infections are a known cause for false positives, and people with AIDS-like symptoms are not going to be blood donors, so the actual figure of false positives in a subset of people who have AIDS-like symptoms may be far higher.

Not always is an HIV test required for the diagnosis of AIDS. If you've got PCP, KS or TB for example, you've got good chances of being diagnosed with AIDS and assumed/diagnosed HIV+ without any actual test. Hey, you're gay, and you've got KS/TB, so you MUST have HIV, why bother with a test?

According to this (denialist) site's sources, TB and KS (Herpes) can statistically significantly cause false positives anyways.

http://www.virusmyth.net/aids/data/cjtestfp.htm

Note that receptive anal sex also causes false positives. You call that a statistical fragment, its more likely that an accompanying factors cause this correlation, an alternative interpretation is that gay men are more likely to get a false-positive for whatever reason.
 
Western blot is false positive 5-10% of the time.

http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/280/12/1080

Antibody tests are wrong a lot more often.

Note that acute infections are a known cause for false positives, and people with AIDS-like symptoms are not going to be blood donors, so the actual figure of false positives in a subset of people who have AIDS-like symptoms may be far higher.

Not always is an HIV test required for the diagnosis of AIDS. If you've got PCP, KS or TB for example, you've got good chances of being diagnosed with AIDS and assumed/diagnosed HIV+ without any actual test. Hey, you're gay, and you've got KS/TB, so you MUST have HIV, why bother with a test?

According to this (denialist) site's sources, TB and KS (Herpes) can statistically significantly cause false positives anyways.

http://www.virusmyth.net/aids/data/cjtestfp.htm

Note that receptive anal sex also causes false positives. You call that a statistical fragment, its more likely that an accompanying factors cause this correlation, an alternative interpretation is that gay men are more likely to get a false-positive for whatever reason.
So you don't have any figures for the ELISA based diagnostic tests which are used for the initial screening? At least two different tests are done so the chance of getting two false positives is reduced.
 
Western blot is false positive 5-10% of the time.

http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/280/12/1080
You need a lesson in how to interpret what you are reading.

False-Positive HIV-1 Test Results in a Low-Risk Screening Setting of Voluntary Blood Donation; Steven Kleinman, [MD; et al]; JAMA.; 1998;280:1080-1085.

ABSTRACT
Context.— Persons at risk of human immunodeficiency virus 1 (HIV-1) infection have been classified incorrectly as HIV infected because of Western blot results, but the frequency of false-positive Western blot results is unknown.
Objectives.— To determine the frequency of false-positive HIV-1 Western blot results in US blood donors and to make projections to other screened populations. Secondarily, to validate an algorithm for evaluating possible false-positive cases.
Design.— A retrospective cohort study of HIV-1 enzyme immunoassay (EIA) and Western blot results from large blood donor screening programs in which donors with suspected false-positive Western blot results underwent HIV-1 RNA polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing and follow-up HIV-1 serology.
Setting.— Five US blood centers participating in the Retrovirus Epidemiology Donor Study.
Participants.— More than 5 million allogeneic and autologous blood donors who successfully donated blood at 1 of the 5 participating centers from 1991 through 1995.
Main Outcome Measures.— Rate of false positivity by Western blot and true HIV-1 infection status as determined by HIV-1 RNA PCR and by serologic follow-up of blood donors more than 5 weeks after donation.
Results.— Of 421 donors who were positive for HIV-1 by Western blot, 39 (9.3%) met the criteria of possible false positivity because they lacked reactivity to p31. Of these, 20 (51.3%) were proven by PCR not to be infected with HIV-1. The false-positive prevalence was 4.8% of Western blot–positive donors and 0.0004% (1 in 251000) of all donors (95% confidence interval, 1 in 173000 to 1 in 379000 donors).
Conclusions.— A false diagnosis of HIV-1 infection can result from the combination of EIA and Western blot testing in blood donor and other HIV-1 screening programs. Individuals with a positive Western blot result lacking the p31 band should be counseled that, although they may be HIV infected, there is uncertainty about this conclusion. These individuals should be further evaluated by RNA PCR testing (if feasible) and HIV serologic analysis on a follow-up sample.

Methodology
...A review of the 5.02 million donations in the 1991-1995 REDS donation database revealed that 4650 were anti-HIV EIA repeat-reactive and 421 were HIV-1 Western blot positive (0.008% of all donations; 9.0% of EIA repeat reactives) using the 1993 FDA interpretive criteria. Thirty-nine (9.3%) of the Western blots with positive results lacked the p31 band....
Out of more than 5 million blood donors 4650 tested positive by EIA and 421 of those tested positive for HIV by Western blot and only 39 of those lacked an additional marker for HIV which all 421 were tested for. (That's 3 different tests for HIV BTW and even that was not the final test.) Of the 39, 20 did not have HIV by PCR testing. So while a small percentage of Western Blots were false positive, only 20 people out of >5 million would have been falsely diagnosed with HIV if only the WB result was used. And no one relies on the WB in this country. All people being treated for HIV would be getting viral counts by PCR. So unless the patient with a positive WB failed to get further testing recommended, they would not be finally diagnosed until the PCR was done.

Antibody tests are wrong a lot more often.
What does this even mean? No provider uses the EIA for anything other than an initial screen.

Note that acute infections are a known cause for false positives, and people with AIDS-like symptoms are not going to be blood donors, so the actual figure of false positives in a subset of people who have AIDS-like symptoms may be far higher.
Actually, it is the opposite. There is a higher false positive rate in a low risk group simply as a function of statistics.

Say there is a 1% prevalence of a disease in a group. If 2% test positive, that is a 50% false positive rate.

If you take that same disease and test people with a risk factor for the disease making a 90% prevalence in your select group, and you use the same test, then 90% are going to test positive because they are positive. That leaves 1% of 10% testing falsely positive. Now your false positive rate is only .01%.

Not always is an HIV test required for the diagnosis of AIDS. If you've got PCP, KS or TB for example, you've got good chances of being diagnosed with AIDS and assumed/diagnosed HIV+ without any actual test. Hey, you're gay, and you've got KS/TB, so you MUST have HIV, why bother with a test?
Wrong again. You have to have HIV to be diagnosed with HIV-AIDS. The diseases you list only define the onset of AIDS in someone with HIV. Those infections do not define anything else except as an indication the person is immunosuppressed.

According to this (denialist) site's sources, TB and KS (Herpes) can statistically significantly cause false positives anyways.

http://www.virusmyth.net/aids/data/cjtestfp.htm

Note that receptive anal sex also causes false positives. You call that a statistical fragment, its more likely that an accompanying factors cause this correlation, an alternative interpretation is that gay men are more likely to get a false-positive for whatever reason.
You seem to think this is supposed to prove people with HIV are being falsely diagnosed. Yet in that 5 million + blood donor pool only a tiny fraction were falsely positive (20) and even they were detected as false positives with the final PCR test. So who cares what causes false positives except in a few situations?
 
The other day I worked out that if a HIV test has 98% sensitivity and specificity and the incidence of HIV in the population was 3% then:

Given a positive test result there is a 60.2% chance you are HIV+. (The positive predictive value, PPV)

Given a negative test result there is 99.9% chance you are HIV-. (The negative predictive value, NPV)

For those interested in the calculations:

The True Positive (TP) rate is given by the sensitivity of the test multiplied by the incidence in the population e.g.

TP = 0.98 * 0.03 = 0.0294

The False Positive (FP) rate is given by 1 - the sensitivity of the test multiplied by 1 - the incidence e.g.

FP = (1-0.98) * (1-0.03) = 0.02 * 0.97 = 0.0194

The PPV is then TP / (TP + FP) e.g.

PPV = 0.0294 / (0.0294 + 0.0194) = 0.602 = 60.2%

The True Negative (TN) rate is given by the specificity of the test multiplied by 1 - the incidence e.g.

TN = 0.98 * (1-0.03) = 0.98 * 0.97 = 0.9506

The False Negative (FN) rate is given by the 1 - the specificity of the test multiplied by the incidence e.g.

FN = (1-0.98) * 0.03 = 0.02 * 0.03 = 0.0006

The NPV is then TN / (TN + FN) e.g.

NPV = 0.9506 / (0.9506 + 0.0006) = 0.999 = 99.9%
 
Western blot is false positive 5-10% of the time.

http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/280/12/1080

Antibody tests are wrong a lot more often.

Note that acute infections are a known cause for false positives, and people with AIDS-like symptoms are not going to be blood donors, so the actual figure of false positives in a subset of people who have AIDS-like symptoms may be far higher.

Not always is an HIV test required for the diagnosis of AIDS. If you've got PCP, KS or TB for example, you've got good chances of being diagnosed with AIDS and assumed/diagnosed HIV+ without any actual test. Hey, you're gay, and you've got KS/TB, so you MUST have HIV, why bother with a test?

According to this (denialist) site's sources, TB and KS (Herpes) can statistically significantly cause false positives anyways.

http://www.virusmyth.net/aids/data/cjtestfp.htm

Note that receptive anal sex also causes false positives. You call that a statistical fragment, its more likely that an accompanying factors cause this correlation, an alternative interpretation is that gay men are more likely to get a false-positive for whatever reason.

Another way to say what Skeptigirl said...

Diagnostic tests are interpreted using dependent probabilities (Bayesian analysis). The question is "what is the probability that this person has this disease, given that this test is positive". The person isn't assumed to have the disease on the basis of the test. You start with the pre-test probability that the person has the disease - the prevalence of the disease in the population that the individual is drawn from. That is converted to odds and then multiplied by the Likelihood Ratio (LR) which is the likelihood of a positive test in someone with the disorder compared to the likelihood of a positive test in someone without the disorder. This gives you your post-test odds which can be converted to a post-test probability. As you can see, as the pre-test probability of the disease increases (the individual practices receptive anal sex without condoms), the probability that a positive test result is a true-positive increases.

However, the question of false-positives is irrelevant when you are talking about a screening test such as the ELISA. Nobody cares about false-positives when screening (well, they do, but for a different reason altogether). What they care about is false-negatives. The purpose of screening is not to identify those people with the disease, but to identify those people without the disease. This means that you purposely use an overly sensitive test and set the bar low, so that you pick up everyone who is HIV positive. You don't really care at that point that you've also picked up a whole bunch of people who are HIV negative, because the next step is to apply a test that is very specific for HIV, such as PCR, which tells you which of the positives were true positives. The purpose of doing the ELISA first is that it is a cheap, fast and easy test that eliminates a whole bunch of people from further testing. Then you only have to do the more expensive, slower PCR test on a handful of people. There are other ways to handle positives picked up on a screening test as well (as mentioned by Capsid).

Linda
 
...

However, the question of false-positives is irrelevant when you are talking about a screening test such as the ELISA. Nobody cares about false-positives when screening (well, they do, but for a different reason altogether). What they care about is false-negatives. The purpose of screening is not to identify those people with the disease, but to identify those people without the disease. This means that you purposely use an overly sensitive test and set the bar low, so that you pick up everyone who is HIV positive. You don't really care at that point that you've also picked up a whole bunch of people who are HIV negative, because the next step is to apply a test that is very specific for HIV, such as PCR, which tells you which of the positives were true positives. The purpose of doing the ELISA first is that it is a cheap, fast and easy test that eliminates a whole bunch of people from further testing. Then you only have to do the more expensive, slower PCR test on a handful of people. There are other ways to handle positives picked up on a screening test as well (as mentioned by Capsid).

Linda
Good point.
 
Getting back to the claim HIV didn't cause AIDS, Silly Green Monkey sent me this news article, Sex is prime cause of China's HIV
China's state media says unsafe sex has, for the first time, become the main means of transmission of HIV/Aids, overtaking intravenous drug use.

Infected blood transfusions also caused many of the early cases.

The news raises fresh concerns that HIV infections are moving from high risk groups to the mainstream population.

China estimates that about 650,000 people are HIV positive - but it is thought that widespread under-reporting makes accurate figures hard to come by.

...

An official report says China saw 70,000 new cases of HIV in 2005 - and almost half were contracted from sexual intercourse.
Obviously this is the pattern of an infectious disease, not of a drug or malnutrition problem. Don't know if 'W' is still reading the thread.
 
According to this (denialist) site's sources, TB and KS (Herpes) can statistically significantly cause false positives anyways.

http://www.virusmyth.net/aids/data/cjtestfp.htm


(Bump - Just back from being chased by hurricane Dean around the caribbean)

Dabljuh,
I'm interested in which sources of "evidence" you seem to trust. You have decried scientific "peer-reviewed" evidence provided for you on countless occasions in the past, giving only a poor explanation of why this should be. Yet time and time again, you quote whackjob web site dross like Virusmyth as though it is the gospel truth and gives us the definitive answer on the matter. Regarding its list of things that cause false-positive HIV results-
Can I ask why you "trust" it's opinion on the matter?
Where is your objectivity and critical thinking skills?
Did you bother trying to verify any of the claims?
Did you look up any of the source articles?

If you did you will find that most have been misinterpreted or distorted to promote the concept that false positive HIV tests are commonly found, the implication being the test is useless.

In addition, the person who made this list has stooped to multiple counting to try and boost the overall number of "things that cause a false positive HIV test". Some of this is clearly deliberate, but some of it is because of astounding medical ignorance, to a degree which makes their conclusions on anything medical quite suspect.

For example, we know that with (any) antibody test performed in a lab, high levels of pre-existing circulating nonspecific antibody in serum will interfere with attempts to perform accurate diagnostic antibody assays, lowering the threshold for test positivity. So conditions that induce high levels of these antibodies can lead to occasional false positive antibody tests (which by the way are easily identified as being falsely positive by the confirmatory assays performed as standard). One example is auto-immune disease, where conditions like Systemic Lupus Erythematosis (SLE), which is characterised by production of nonspecific antibody and high levels of auto-antibodies, can rarely throw up false positive tests for other infections, among them for HIV.

You will see that Virusmyth lists this single entity 4 separate times as a cause of false HIV positivity:
1. Systemic Lupus Erythematosis (SLE)
2. Autoimmune diseases
3. Serum-positive for antinuclear factor (the main antibody produced in excess in SLE)
4. Antinuclear antibodies (the same thing as 3 above)

(It also throws in around a good half dozen other auto-immune diseases/auto-antibodies as individual causes.) I guess this needless tautology on SLE is due to gross ignorance and inability to tell the difference between these 4 terminologies (but there again it could be deliberate deceit).

Several of the other entries on the list are only there because someone noticed an extremely uncommon coincidence of the problem (eg one case of HIV positivity after rabies vaccine) and decided to write it up in a journal because of it's rarity factor. So it gets put into the Virusmyth list, with the intention that medically ignorant readers like you will be horrified by the long list of conditions that could give you a false positive HIV tests result. Don't feel bad about being caught out, even famous science Professors can fall for this bait (as did Lynn Margulis when she famously said that most pregnant women are "nearly always HIV postive"). (See near the end of the responses for my comment as DT on March 20th)

In fact the false positive rate for HIV tests in a low prevalence setting is in the order of about 1:250thousand. And as you should now know, false positives are proportionately commoner in a low prevalence setting than a high prevalence one. The HIV testing protocol is actually extremely good, far better than for some other infections/illnesses.
 
Last edited:
Gallo RC. Testimony at appeal hearing of Andre Parenzee. Court of Criminal Appeal. 2007 Feb 12.

If a 1000 men had a pregnancy test, and in one of them it was positive because he had unusal[sic] hormone levels, and only a further "advanced" tets[sic] showed he was a true negative, would you say: "men can be pregnant using standard tests"?

Of course not. But if half of the men tested showed that they were pregnant, or worse, if half of the dogs tested showed human pregnancy, I would certainly consider the test invalid or flawed.

While the makers of the test do state that they are not to be used to diagnose, and that advanced testing is to be used if HIV shows positive, in many countries just one Western Blot test is used, with no validation from any accurate test. Pregnancy, of all things, can produce a false positive on both ELISA and Western Blot test.

“AIDS and AIDS-related conditions are clinical syndromes and their diagnosis can only be established clinically. EIA testing cannot be used to diagnose AIDS, even if the recommended investigation of reactive specimens suggests that the antibodies to HIV are present.”

Human immunodeficiency virus types 1 and 2: (E. coli, B. megaterium, recombinant antigen) HIVAB HIV-1/HIV-2 (rDNA) EIA. Abbott Laboratories. 2004.

“Western Blot assay should not be used as a screening test. WB should be viewed as a supplemental test which can be used to confirm positive results obtained from EIA. However: Specificity is less than that of EIA. A significant number of indeterminate blots are seen in low risk populations.”

Babu VR. HIV Testing Technologies: ELISA/Western Blot. CDC. 2004 Jan 19-23

This is wrong in the extreme. If pregnancy tests show that half the men you test are pregnant, despite the obvious, or half the dogs you test show up positive for HIV related antibodies, it only shows one very important thing. This would be that the tester is so sadly, incredibly dumb that they would use a pregnancy test on a man, or a test for human antibodies related to HIV on a dog.

If your Phillips screwdriver won't turn your flathead screws, there's nothing wrong with your screwdriver. It is a simple case of using the wrong tool for the wrong job.

The tests work fine within the parameters for which they were designed.
 
Skeptigirl says that for an HIV Diagnosis an HIV test has to be positive, and the others here say, an HIV test doesn't have anything to with diagnosis (except for differential diagnosis, i.e. ruling out HIV as a cause)

Make up your minds already.

Some tidbit I read about western blot. Basically, western blot detects the presence of a number of proteins, about a dozen or so which are attributed to the HIV virus. But only 3 marks (3 different proteins detected) are necessary for an HIV positive test. But oh wait, it gets better: Different country, different standards. Some countries require western blot to have 4 or 5 positive stripes to count as positive. Meaning by simply moving to another country, you no longer are HIV-positive. And: a number of those supposed virus particles will be found in any human.

And then the tests for HIV seropositivity, by what means are they going to be calibrated? You test 1000 people with ELISA and then double-check with western blot, and vice versa. Doing so, you're making sure that both ELISA and WB simply are false-positive on the same external factors.

This is wrong in the extreme. If pregnancy tests show that half the men you test are pregnant, despite the obvious, or half the dogs you test show up positive for HIV related antibodies, it only shows one very important thing. This would be that the tester is so sadly, incredibly dumb that they would use a pregnancy test on a man, or a test for human antibodies related to HIV on a dog.

If your Phillips screwdriver won't turn your flathead screws, there's nothing wrong with your screwdriver. It is a simple case of using the wrong tool for the wrong job.

The tests work fine within the parameters for which they were designed.
The analogy is flawed, this pregnancy test is, even when used on fertile females, false positive a lot of the time, especially in those cases when a non-test-based diagnosis would result in a false positive as well (enlarged breasts / distended belly / missing periods etc).

The HIV/AIDS advocates simply circumvent this issue by claiming the pregnancy could have a latency of 20 years or more, so a positive diagnosis and/or test doesn't lead to the predictable result of disease X within Y months.

And going further with the pregnancy test analogy, stuff like acne, headaches, nausea and vomiting would be counted as the pregnancy "breaking out", and no amount of period or subsequent negative pregnancy test would invalidate the first diagnosis.

And then, because its politically incorrect to only have one sex get this disease, you declare that now everyone can get pregnant. Remember GRIDS? The Gay-Related Immunodeficiency Syndrome?

Next thing, you go to africa, and diagnose everyone with a distended belly as being pregnant. Or rather, you examine one particularly starving community of 500 people, and then calculate that at least 50 million people in africa must be "pregnant"! Hilarity ensues...

But your point remains valid. We're testing for HIV with bad tests in the wrong people to detect a condition (HIV seropositivity) that may have nothing to do with immunodeficiency.
 
We're testing for HIV with bad tests in the wrong people to detect a condition (HIV seropositivity) that may have nothing to do with immunodeficiency.
On the contrary, we are testing for HIV with good tests that are among the most highly validated and reproducibly accurate serological assays ever devised for microbiological diagnosis.
They are detecting a condition (HIV infection) that has everything to do with immunodeficiency.

No-one has claimed any test ever invented has 100% accuracy.
Evidence that a test has less than 100% sensitivity or specificity is not evidence the disease does not exist.

You want a pregnancy analogy to HIV tests? - I'll give you this one I posted on another board some time ago.........
Report from The UK Sunday Times. 2010 September 6


The world of obstetrics was turned upside down on Friday after astonishing results were published in the New England Journal of Medicine from a survey on the accuracy of urinary dipstix pregnancy tests. These rely on the detection of a hormone, HCG, which appears in the urine about 14 days following conception. Shock waves reverberated through the medical world when it was revealed that these have only a 97% accuracy.

Professor James Low, from the London Hospital Maternity Unit, was astounded by the results. "The false positive rate for this test is even higher than that for conditions such as HIV, which as we know was shown not to exist when the innacuracy of the tests was revealed last month by HIV denialists. I have no idea what we can do. Pregnancy is clearly a lie, and our unit will have to close, rendering hundreds of midwives and doctors unemployed. I dread to think of the consequenses for colleagues elsewhere in the world, particularly in countries with high birth rates."

A retail pharmacy spokesperson, who declined to be named, said "The financial repercussions of this finding are immense. An entire baby industry exists, built upon the bald faced lie that pregnancy is real. Now we can see it is not, there will be financial meltdown in the relevant market sectors. Think infant care products, clothing, buggies, toys - you name it, it will all be over by Christmas. Sell your Mothercare shares now if you aren't to late!"

Globally, parents are expressing delight. "I don't have to bother with my kids now" said Irene, a relieved looking Mum who was waiting outside Dell Primary School for the school bell, at least until she heard the good news. "I'm off to the pub!" she waved cheerily, hurling her baby's pushchair into some bushes.

But others, particularly children, are distraught. "To think I never existed!" wailed Josie, a tearful 5 year old we found wandering the streets in Salford Keys. "And my mother didn't exist either!"

Pregnancy denialists are, however, jubilant. "We always knew this shoddy test would perish one day under the weight of overwhelming evidence that as many as 32 different conditions can influence results" rejoiced Alexander Bussell, an expert in anti-aging medicine and part-time artist and philosopher. "The whole obstetric house of cards has finally crashed to its knees!"
 
Last edited:
Are you willfully misinterpreting what's been posted here 'W'? Or are you really just not getting it?

Either way, it is your interpretation of what's been posted that is the problem, not what's actually been posted.

Your biggest problem is assuming health care practitioners are as ignorant as you are when diagnosing patients. We are not. Nor do we usually make any diagnosis based on a single test. Perhaps that is your problem. You keep looking for the single test which you can claim HIV diagnoses are flawed. There is no single flaw which fulfills your desire to deny the HIV pandemic.

Practitioners are more than capable of dealing with ambiguous test results. In addition, you are only referring to weakly positive results. In a patient with weakly positive results if other tests have not resolved the diagnosis is simply stuck having to wait a bit to see if the disease is revealed a few months later after having progressed. Results do not stay equivocal in HIV infected individuals. The virus replicates and the tests result in stronger reactions.

In a low prevalence group, false positives occur. These also are resolved over time and with additional tests.

Wide divergence of different HIV Western Blot (WB) interpretation standards in low-positive sera.
Schupbach J, Tomasik Z, Boni J.
Int Conf AIDS. 1990 Jun 20-23; 6: 133 (abstract no. S.C.215).

Swiss National Center for Retroviruses (SNCR), University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland

OBJECTIVE: The CDC has issued new guidelines for WB interpretation [MMWR 38/S7:1-7,1989]. We have seen increasing numbers of sera with faint antibodies against env+gag, env+pol, gag+pol, env+gag+pol, or pol or env alone. Study aims: (i) Comparison of different WB interpretation guidelines with such sera; (ii) determine the individuals truly infected with HIV. METHODS: Antibody tests: recomb. EIA, Envacor(R), and HIV-1/-2 WB (DuPont; sera dil. 1/25). Antigen, PCR, and viral culture were additionally done on follow-ups. WB interpretations included 5: Association of State & Territorial Public Health Laboratory Directors/CDC, Consortium for Retrovirus Serol Standardization, American Red Cross, FDA/DuPont, SNCR. RESULTS: Approx. 10% of the sera seen at the SNCR in 1989 had WB of the above patterns, some for greater than 2y. Of 220 such sera, 116 (52.7%) were positive by ASTPHLD/CDC, 96 (43.6%) by CRSS, 45 (20.5%) by ARC, but only 2 (0.9%) by FDA/DP). None was pos. for HIV-2. Envacor(R) was env-positive in 30 (13.6%) and gag-positive in 13 (5.9%). Serum antigen and virus cultures were negative in all instances. PCR results will be presented at the conference. WB analysis of 100 screening-negative, but otherwise unselected blood donors under analogous assay conditions showed p17 bands in 24%, p24 in 9%, and gp120/160 in 3%. The likelihood of a chance combination p24+gp120/160 (ASTPHLD/CDC- and CRSS-positive!) in a normal donor would thus be 0.09x0.03=0.0027, i.e. 1 out of 370. CONCLUSION: PCR results pending, our data suggest that the WB interpretation guidelines endorsed by the ASTPHLD/CDC or CRSS, while they may be good for sera from symptomatic patients with clearly-positive screening results, are not stringent enough for their use in the testing of populations with low prevalence of HIV infection. They are dangerous when used for sera with border-line screening results and should be reconsidered.

Your denial is obviously dangerous. I hope you are not practicing unsafe sex.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom