HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

Dabljuh, i'd like to remark that i have reviewed the dissident material (well, mainly duesbergs) to a certain degree and came to the conclusion that their theories regarding the etiology of aids cannot possibly hold against reality.

For example his theory that aids is a drug induced illness - as a matter of fact (if you havent read the paper google asher, winkelstein etc.), people who don't do any drugs and are hiv-positive do get clinical symptoms of aids, wheras those who are negative don't.(also those who are abusing drugs btw) - When challenged with this, duesbegs claimed that the data was fabricated, though he never made a formal scientific fraud complaint ....also, when drug-free HIV positive asymptomatic people he presented as evidence later died of aids he simply accused them of beeing covert drug users post mortem). Another claim is that there is aids in HIV-negative people, so hiv doesn't cause aids. This is not only logically wrong.
Of course there are symptoms similar to aids in hiv-negative people, but they are extremely rare, or they are easily reversible, wheras aids in hiv positive people takes a distinct course. Also, there are a lot of conditions that can appear without the pathogen most of the time causing it. (Ex.: You can have liver failure without the hepatitis virus, does that mean the herpes virus doesn't exist? or: only a small percentage of people infected with the hepatitis virus ever get ill, but this is not an argument for the non-existence of the virus)
Regarding the tests, there is a is a controversy in the dissident camp - perth vs. duesberg. Duesberg just doesn't claim that being positive doesn't mean that one is infected, he only claims that its harmless. He also claims, that hiv is not transmitted sexually, mainly because of the famous padian-paper. Although, in this paper 'seroconversion' hasnt took place, there are several other papers who have clearly shown that this is the not true (but they are -understandably for those infected- denied by the dissidents.)

See, i dont want to elaborate an extensive review here, because the literature on this topic is really vast, I only advise you to double check the dissident's notions, as i have done it. You ll be suprised!

Also, i'd like to clarify that i am not just believing the scientific consensus. There really is a splendid amount of anomalies in hiv research(that may lead to a completely different view, not only of hiv/aids but of the whole field of virology/pathology), but as it stands, their theories fit reality far more better than those of the dissidents. Check it out!
 
Thank you for your input fraorlando. The problem I'm having with your argument is that you make duesberg look like a fraud. He isn't. I haven't seen the slightest evidence whatsoever of him committing fraud, or being scientifically dishonest, or even merely crazy. The arguably little work I have seen from him seemed very careful, trying not to make any statements too outrageous.

The perth group? Crazies. Well, some at least.

But what I have observed is a disorganized effort to discredit duesberg. Instead of trying to convince this very respectable scientist, I've see attempts to smear his reputation for no other reason than his stance on HIV. Duesberg shouldn't be easily dismissed.

My personal opinion is that HIV may cause a immune depression, but it hasn't been established in how many people and how severe, on average, the depression may be. It may be less than smoking, or eating from teflon pans.
 
Thank you for your input fraorlando. The problem I'm having with your argument is that you make duesberg look like a fraud. He isn't. I haven't seen the slightest evidence whatsoever of him committing fraud, or being scientifically dishonest, or even merely crazy. The arguably little work I have seen from him seemed very careful, trying not to make any statements too outrageous.

I doubt Duesberg is wilfully dishonest. He is just very misguided, and assumes because he knows something about laboratory retrovirology that he is an epidemiologist, microbiologist and clinician as well. His pronouncements on epidemiology of HIV are particularly bizarre and have no basis in fact. What he is guilty of is trying to dress up weak evidence to look significant and consistently ignoring strong evidence that goes against his hypotheses. In other words he deploys the scientific method very poorly. That does not however make him a fraud.

The perth group? Crazies. Well, some at least.
No argument from me there.

But what I have observed is a disorganized effort to discredit duesberg. Instead of trying to convince this very respectable scientist, I've see attempts to smear his reputation for no other reason than his stance on HIV. Duesberg shouldn't be easily dismissed.
If this has happened it is unfortunate, and not the way things should happen. I am aware of many people who have discredited his ideas, not him personally.

My personal opinion is that HIV may cause a immune depression, but it hasn't been established in how many people and how severe, on average, the depression may be. It may be less than smoking, or eating from teflon pans.
It has been established. Your inability to look at the many papers we have directed you to on this point smacks of some carelessness (may I say dishonesty?) on your part.
If you have any evidence that smoking, or eating from teflon pans is more immunosuppressive than HIV infection, I would love to see it. If you are unable to cite references for these claims, may I ask why you even mention them?


A few papers on the clinical natural history of HIV-immunodeficiency before the advent of potent antiretroviral drug therapy:

In the San Francisco City Clinical Cohort of men infected from 1977 to 1980, an 11 year follow-up revealed that 54 percent progressed to AIDS and 19 percent remained asymptomatic.
Rutherford GW et al, BMJ 1990 Nov 24;301(6762):1183-8

The percentage of patients developing AIDS (according to the 1987 definition) following seroconversion was 0 at one year, 3% at three years, 12% at five years, 36% at eight years, 53% at ten years, and 68% at 14 years.
MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 1987.

Mean survival time following a reduction of CD4 count below 200 was 38 to 40 months.
Osmond D, et al. JAMA 1994 Apr 13;271(14):1083-7.
 
No, Dabljuh, i dont think Duesberg is a fraud. His latest work on aneuploidy and cancer is a good example for how brilliant this man can be. In fact, I like him - i believe he knew quite well that he stood all but on the loose by rejecting the theory that hiv causes aids, but did so relentlessly, and subsequently lost all of his by the late '80 well established reputation. The problem i see is not in his reasoning with the facts he presents, but those he omits. And i dont think this is deliberate obfuscation, but a not uncommon theory caused bias taken to the extreme - maybe because of some underlying personal issues, the rejection by his peers, who knows. He just happens to ignore all information that don't fit into his drug aids-hypothesis. For example, if drugs where to culprit for what is seen in aids, how did all those kids in the pre-AZT(before late 1987) era develop aids? Did they die by definition? (nature.com/nature/journal/v328/n6132/abs/328719a0.html;jsessionid=4B2E1D1F87E3B7ECE225684FE2A5699C)
and
(bmj.com/cgi/content/full/311/7019/1534)
(add www to the links to mak it work)
 
Nature

BMJ

PS. Here is a refutation of the "drugs cause AIDS" hypothesis. This was conclusively shown 14 years ago, but the denialists still view the hypothesis as being as fresh as though it was announced yesterday, and as unchallenged as the theory that the world is not flat.
 
I was impressed by Henry Bauer's book, The Origin, Persistance and Failings of HIV/AIDS Theory. Google will show you his blog and also the many folks who attack him, while ignoring what he says. He uses official statistics on HIV test results to show that HIV does not behave like an infectious agent at all.

In particular, sexually transmitted diseases have hot spots in geography and time which differ from where HIV positive results occur. Indeed, one can predict the likelihood of a positive test result from merely the age, gender, race, and population density of location of the tested person. Thus what the test discovers, whether it is HIV or not, is not an infectious agent.

This does not mean that AIDS (that is serious immune deficiency likely to lead to infections and death) is not real, but only that HIV cannot be an infectious agent that causes AIDS.

Still AZT and HAART kill people. Most deaths via HAART are for organ failure, not AIDS defining diseases.
 
He uses official statistics on HIV test results to show that HIV does not behave like an infectious agent at all.
How does he explain the fact that, among HIV positive pregnant women, the ones in randomized trials who are given anti-hiv drugs (compared to vitamins) give birth to kids who are hiv negative and live, compared to the vitamin control group, who give birth to hiv positive babies who die disproportionately?
 
How does he explain the fact that, among HIV positive pregnant women, the ones in randomized trials who are given anti-hiv drugs (compared to vitamins) give birth to kids who are hiv negative and live, compared to the vitamin control group, who give birth to hiv positive babies who die disproportionately?
I don't question what you say, but there was a control group where babies died???
 
I was impressed by Henry Bauer's book, The Origin, Persistance and Failings of HIV/AIDS Theory. Google will show you his blog and also the many folks who attack him, while ignoring what he says. He uses official statistics on HIV test results to show that HIV does not behave like an infectious agent at all.

In particular, sexually transmitted diseases have hot spots in geography and time which differ from where HIV positive results occur. Indeed, one can predict the likelihood of a positive test result from merely the age, gender, race, and population density of location of the tested person. Thus what the test discovers, whether it is HIV or not, is not an infectious agent.

This does not mean that AIDS (that is serious immune deficiency likely to lead to infections and death) is not real, but only that HIV cannot be an infectious agent that causes AIDS.

Still AZT and HAART kill people. Most deaths via HAART are for organ failure, not AIDS defining diseases.
HIV proviral DNA can be detected in infected persons; this means that the virus has integrated into the host DNA. To do that the virus must have infected the host.
 
I don't question what you say, but there was a control group where babies died???
Yes. Anti-hiv drugs have actually been tested against vitamins in pregnant women, and lots of dead kids was the result. We went over this in a different thread here.
 
I was impressed by Henry Bauer's book, The Origin, Persistance and Failings of HIV/AIDS Theory. Google will show you his blog and also the many folks who attack him, while ignoring what he says. He uses official statistics on HIV test results to show that HIV does not behave like an infectious agent at all.

In particular, sexually transmitted diseases have hot spots in geography and time which differ from where HIV positive results occur. Indeed, one can predict the likelihood of a positive test result from merely the age, gender, race, and population density of location of the tested person. Thus what the test discovers, whether it is HIV or not, is not an infectious agent.

This does not mean that AIDS (that is serious immune deficiency likely to lead to infections and death) is not real, but only that HIV cannot be an infectious agent that causes AIDS.

Still AZT and HAART kill people. Most deaths via HAART are for organ failure, not AIDS defining diseases.
I haven't read his book.
However in some of his articles, it is clear he misrepresents and misinterprets data, twisting it to suit his own preconceptions.

Take this article here, which supposes that the official data on deaths are not compatible with a sexually transmitted/other infection and that HIV therapies have had no impact on delaying deaths as they would if they actually worked.

Firstly he fails to appreciate that when someone is diagnosed with HIV is inherently very variable - they might be diagnosed the month after infection, or 10 years afterwards. Date of notification of infection cannot be used as a surrogate of date of infection. He also fails to appreciate that incubation period to "AIDS" is very variable, being anything from a couple of years up to 20 or 30 years (or never in a tiny percentage of people). Using crude mortality data is a very dodgy thing to do, epidemiologically speaking.

He asserts: "Progressively improved treatments have supposedly extended the latent period for asymptomatic HIV positive persons as well as the lifespan of AIDS patients. However, neither the age distribution of first HIV-positive test nor that of death from AIDS changed between 1987 and 2004. Both distributions still peak between ages 35 and 44. These data are incompatible with the conventional view of HIV/AIDS."

In fact the data sets he uses do not indicate this (and even if they did his conclusions about what they show are not valid)​

Let's look at his chart about deaths in HIV (Table 1). The data are fairly normally distributed for each year analysed. Look at 1995 (just before effective treatment was introduced) and the last data set for 2004. A quick "Bauer" analysis reveals that the "decade" in which the highest death rates are recorded is the same (35-44 years).​

But in fact the mean age at which the deaths peaked was 37 in the 1995 cohort as opposed to 42 in the 2004 cohort. This means that already there was a crude "prolongation" effect of 5 years following the introduction of therapy. Patients were dying when they were on average 5 years older than they did the decade before. Throw in a lot of other variables (like how only about half of eligible patients were actually on HAART in the early years when it became available, and how around 20% are still not on any treatment) and you can see that there is an apparently significant treatment effect. Bauer ignores this completely.​

The best way to assess mortality is to do a cohort analysis rather than looking at these crude deaths rates. This has been done, particularly in Eurosida, and demonstrates a major survival impact for HIV therapy.​

I haven't bothered to comment about the numerous other idiocies in his paper, but if you are really interested in my opinion I will be happy to do further debunking.
 
Still AZT and HAART kill people. Most deaths via HAART are for organ failure, not AIDS defining diseases.

Only in relative terms.

Answer me this.
Hypothetical situation (based on real data)

You have a 20% chance of dying this year. (You have a 5% chance of dying from disease X, and a 15% chance of dying from disease Y).

You are now offered treatment that will mean you have a 10% chance of dying (6% chance of dying from disease X and a 4% chance of dying from disease Y).

What would you do?

Do you take treatment, knowing that treatment halves your overall risk of dying (but seems to increase your real risk of dying from disease X, and you are now more likely to die from disease X than disease Y)?
I figure from your post that you would refuse treatment.

More fool you.

(Substitute AIDS for disease Y, and non-AIDS diseases/organ failure for X and you get my drift.)
 
Last edited:
Wait. Let's not debunk lots and lots of stuff. I pointed out one fundamental fact which Bauer makes clear in his book. HIV is not behaving like an infection. If that one fact is true, the rest is called into question. The predictions made by the HIV orthodoxy over two and a half decades based on infectious HIV have FAILED. One reason is that HIV is NOT AN INFECTION. It might be just a curiosity that the HIV test does not detect HIV or that when the viral load is said to be overwhelming, there are no HIV viral particles to be found.

Back up. If HIV is not an infection then none of the other conclusions matter.
 
Wait. Let's not debunk lots and lots of stuff. I pointed out one fundamental fact which Bauer makes clear in his book. HIV is not behaving like an infection. If that one fact is true, the rest is called into question. The predictions made by the HIV orthodoxy over two and a half decades based on infectious HIV have FAILED. One reason is that HIV is NOT AN INFECTION. It might be just a curiosity that the HIV test does not detect HIV or that when the viral load is said to be overwhelming, there are no HIV viral particles to be found.

Back up. If HIV is not an infection then none of the other conclusions matter.
Unfortunately for Bauer that fact is true as I pointed out above, did you not read what I wrote?
 
HIV is an infection.

Human agent identified by multiple laboratory methods? Check.
Solid animal and laboratory experimental data for similar transmissable retroviruses? Check.
Tests available to indicate who and who is not infected? Check.
Clinical correlates exist for laboratory parameters? Check.
Transmissable experimentally and by observational studies? Check.
Can cause similar clinical features in the new hosts? Check.
Variable prevalence in different populations depending on their risk behaviours? Check.
Like other infections, clinical manifestations variable in the host? Check.
etc etc
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom