fraorlando
New Blood
- Joined
- Jun 27, 2005
- Messages
- 16
Dabljuh, i'd like to remark that i have reviewed the dissident material (well, mainly duesbergs) to a certain degree and came to the conclusion that their theories regarding the etiology of aids cannot possibly hold against reality.
For example his theory that aids is a drug induced illness - as a matter of fact (if you havent read the paper google asher, winkelstein etc.), people who don't do any drugs and are hiv-positive do get clinical symptoms of aids, wheras those who are negative don't.(also those who are abusing drugs btw) - When challenged with this, duesbegs claimed that the data was fabricated, though he never made a formal scientific fraud complaint ....also, when drug-free HIV positive asymptomatic people he presented as evidence later died of aids he simply accused them of beeing covert drug users post mortem). Another claim is that there is aids in HIV-negative people, so hiv doesn't cause aids. This is not only logically wrong.
Of course there are symptoms similar to aids in hiv-negative people, but they are extremely rare, or they are easily reversible, wheras aids in hiv positive people takes a distinct course. Also, there are a lot of conditions that can appear without the pathogen most of the time causing it. (Ex.: You can have liver failure without the hepatitis virus, does that mean the herpes virus doesn't exist? or: only a small percentage of people infected with the hepatitis virus ever get ill, but this is not an argument for the non-existence of the virus)
Regarding the tests, there is a is a controversy in the dissident camp - perth vs. duesberg. Duesberg just doesn't claim that being positive doesn't mean that one is infected, he only claims that its harmless. He also claims, that hiv is not transmitted sexually, mainly because of the famous padian-paper. Although, in this paper 'seroconversion' hasnt took place, there are several other papers who have clearly shown that this is the not true (but they are -understandably for those infected- denied by the dissidents.)
See, i dont want to elaborate an extensive review here, because the literature on this topic is really vast, I only advise you to double check the dissident's notions, as i have done it. You ll be suprised!
Also, i'd like to clarify that i am not just believing the scientific consensus. There really is a splendid amount of anomalies in hiv research(that may lead to a completely different view, not only of hiv/aids but of the whole field of virology/pathology), but as it stands, their theories fit reality far more better than those of the dissidents. Check it out!
For example his theory that aids is a drug induced illness - as a matter of fact (if you havent read the paper google asher, winkelstein etc.), people who don't do any drugs and are hiv-positive do get clinical symptoms of aids, wheras those who are negative don't.(also those who are abusing drugs btw) - When challenged with this, duesbegs claimed that the data was fabricated, though he never made a formal scientific fraud complaint ....also, when drug-free HIV positive asymptomatic people he presented as evidence later died of aids he simply accused them of beeing covert drug users post mortem). Another claim is that there is aids in HIV-negative people, so hiv doesn't cause aids. This is not only logically wrong.
Of course there are symptoms similar to aids in hiv-negative people, but they are extremely rare, or they are easily reversible, wheras aids in hiv positive people takes a distinct course. Also, there are a lot of conditions that can appear without the pathogen most of the time causing it. (Ex.: You can have liver failure without the hepatitis virus, does that mean the herpes virus doesn't exist? or: only a small percentage of people infected with the hepatitis virus ever get ill, but this is not an argument for the non-existence of the virus)
Regarding the tests, there is a is a controversy in the dissident camp - perth vs. duesberg. Duesberg just doesn't claim that being positive doesn't mean that one is infected, he only claims that its harmless. He also claims, that hiv is not transmitted sexually, mainly because of the famous padian-paper. Although, in this paper 'seroconversion' hasnt took place, there are several other papers who have clearly shown that this is the not true (but they are -understandably for those infected- denied by the dissidents.)
See, i dont want to elaborate an extensive review here, because the literature on this topic is really vast, I only advise you to double check the dissident's notions, as i have done it. You ll be suprised!
Also, i'd like to clarify that i am not just believing the scientific consensus. There really is a splendid amount of anomalies in hiv research(that may lead to a completely different view, not only of hiv/aids but of the whole field of virology/pathology), but as it stands, their theories fit reality far more better than those of the dissidents. Check it out!