HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

HIV proviral DNA can be detected in infected persons; this means that the virus has integrated into the host DNA. To do that the virus must have infected the host.
Because you say so? Come on. READ the stats. HIV positive is a CONDITION affected by RACE, GENDER, and AGE. If it were a disease, especially a sexually transmitted disease, it would have hot spots like those that occur for syphilis or other STDs, BUT IT DOES NOT. Once you BELIEVE it is a disease, you MAKE UP reasons for all those anomalous details.
 
How does he explain the fact that, among HIV positive pregnant women, the ones in randomized trials who are given anti-hiv drugs (compared to vitamins) give birth to kids who are hiv negative and live, compared to the vitamin control group, who give birth to hiv positive babies who die disproportionately?

Look at the charts where HIV positive results decline quickly from birth to about age three or four. How do YOU explain that the MORE women breastfeed their babies, the LESS they are found HIV positive. There is so much crazyness as soon as you wrongly accept that HIV is infectious and that the test for it is accurate. Then you have to pile on complication after complication to explain the weird results. If you accept Bauer's statistics from the CDC and the Army and so forth, then his conclusion that it cannot be an infection follows.
 
HIV proviral DNA can be detected in infected persons; this means that the virus has integrated into the host DNA. To do that the virus must have infected the host.

Even if I accepted your premis, it could be explained, for example, by an endogenous virus that was there already in the genes from ancestors. But the stats differ so reliably by RACE, GENDER, and AGE that HIV positive is obviously not an infection. If if were an infection that cannot be defeated, then why does anyone ever go from positive to negative. That happens dramatically in the first three years of life and again after about age 50.
 
How is an infection supposed to behave?

Good question. How accurate have the predictions been about AIDS? I don't follow it, but the sense of doom and gloom doesn't seemed to have panned out, but that could simply be a result of press coverage that I happened to notice "back then" and happen to notice "these days" (a nice way of saying I have no clue).

I just searched Google News for AIDS Predictions from 1991-1993. The first article I looked at reads:
http://www.nytimes.com/1992/06/22/w...pulation-in-parts-of-africa.html?pagewanted=1
In Uganda, where 1.5 million people out of a population of 16 million are thought to be infected with H.I.V., the virus that causes AIDS, the current 3 percent population growth rate is likely to fall to below zero after 2002, with more people dying than being born, the projections say.

In 15 years [in 2007], Uganda would have 20 percent fewer people than if the AIDS epidemic had not occurred. The population would be 20.28 million, instead of 24 million. Tanzania, Malawi and Rwanda, all in the central and east African belt where AIDS has hit hardest, would be similarly affected, the results show.

According to this site, that seems to be way off the mark:

Uganda has had a steady population growth with a population of 30.6M in 2007. Same type of uninterrupted growth for Tanzania. Rwanda had a big dip around 1995 and then steady growth. Malawi had a little dip and then steady growth.

Is AIDS progressing as expected, assuming there's a way to predict its progress? I'm pretty sure it didn't spread via mosquitoes like the La Rouche people tried to tell me outside the local post office many years ago.

And before people get all touchy, I'm just asking a question. :D
 
Look at the charts where HIV positive results decline quickly from birth to about age three or four.

Can I get a link(s) to the original research demonstrating this?
This is a nuanced topic. In an area where HIV prevalence is very low, you'll get a lot of (most cases being, even) false positives which will later be ruled out by better diagnostics. In an area where HIV prevalence is relatively high, not so much. So to figure out what's going on, we have to know exactly what we're looking at, and be able to ask "why?"

How do YOU explain that the MORE women breastfeed their babies, the LESS they are found HIV positive.
Assuming this is true (and I need evidence to go with that) there are a few plausible mechanisms. The research to date implies that a lot of people are exposed to HIV in potentially infective quantities, but don't become chronically infected. Infection is part about the host, and part about the pathogen.
"Bad" HIV vaccines, for example, make people more likely to become chronically infected with hiv, probably through what's known as "antibody mediated enhancement".
And HIV, appears (to me, at least) to be especially adapted to immune systems compromised by extreme malnutrition. For example, it takes far fewer sex acts between HIV discordant couples in the conditions of malnutrition for a transmission to take place, compared to sex acts among the well nourished. (I'll look up the research if anyone cares.)
Which makes sense to me. HIV emerged in malnourished Africa. Of course it's adapted well to the African condition. Which leans towards near-starvation. Duh. And anywhere you get Africa-like conditions, it becomes more transmissible. Coke/meth-laden, no eating, gay buttsecks in the US , or unclean needles from underfunded medical projects in the developing world, whatever. HIV is not adapted to the developed world, and might not ever be.

Does it resemble in ways that matter, the Africa that HIV emerged in? That's where you see highly endemic HIV today, if the answer is "yes". Which makes sense.

You'd expect a zoonotic pathogen that emerged in conditions of extreme overcrowding with an endless supply of fresh bodies, dead or alive, well nourished, where extreme sickness didn't result in any form of quarantine (WWI war conditions), to become hyper-virulent for the young and healthy, too. And you'd expect it to become less deadly, if more transmissible, over time, too, as it spread across the more general population.

I realise I'm ranting here, off topic, but it's in every pathogen's best interest to be as endemic yet asymptomatic as possible.

I was meaning to tie this back into HIV, but I have to tend to a baby. :)
 
Last edited:
Even if I accepted your premis, it could be explained, for example, by an endogenous virus that was there already in the genes from ancestors. But the stats differ so reliably by RACE, GENDER, and AGE that HIV positive is obviously not an infection.

You have simply guessed wrong about how an infection is supposed to behave. Other infections vary by race, age and sex, why not HIV?

If if were an infection that cannot be defeated, then why does anyone ever go from positive to negative. That happens dramatically in the first three years of life and again after about age 50.

But since this happens with other antibody measurements as well, why not HIV?

Linda
 
Good question. How accurate have the predictions been about AIDS? I don't follow it, but the sense of doom and gloom doesn't seemed to have panned out, but that could simply be a result of press coverage that I happened to notice "back then" and happen to notice "these days" (a nice way of saying I have no clue).

It depends upon what you mean. Predictions depend upon a certain set of conditions and if those conditions change, then we'd expect the outcome to change as well. If you say, "if sexual practices remain unchanged, we can expect this pattern of disease prevalence" and sexual practices change with a resulting change in the prevalence, does that mean your prediction was inaccurate?

Is AIDS progressing as expected, assuming there's a way to predict its progress?

What part are you asking us to predict? We can predict that HIV transmission and HIV prevalence will decrease if efforts to reduce higher risk sex practices are effective. We can predict that progression to AIDS will decrease if we effectively modify those factors which lead to progression. Twenty years ago, what would have been more difficult to predict is whether we would find effective methods of reducing higher risk sex practices or whether we would find disease-modifying treatments.

Linda
 
Even if I accepted your premis, it could be explained, for example, by an endogenous virus that was there already in the genes from ancestors.
The method for detecting HIV DNA or RNA is specific for HIV since it is based on the nucleic acid sequence of the virus. This is different to that of endogenous viruses already present.
But the stats differ so reliably by RACE, GENDER, and AGE that HIV positive is obviously not an infection.
Why is it obvious? HIV can infect people in a number of ways; vertical and horizontal transmission; by blood contact, sexually; wouldn't this explain those differences.

If if were an infection that cannot be defeated, then why does anyone ever go from positive to negative. That happens dramatically in the first three years of life and again after about age 50.
Perhaps you are only considering the antibody test; the PCR test can detect proviral DNA. Once it's in the genome it can not be removed.
 
Last edited:
It depends upon what you mean. Predictions depend upon a certain set of conditions and if those conditions change, then we'd expect the outcome to change as well. If you say, "if sexual practices remain unchanged, we can expect this pattern of disease prevalence" and sexual practices change with a resulting change in the prevalence, does that mean your prediction was inaccurate?
Obviously not, because the prediction discussed changes in sexual practices. If other conditions change that were not anticipated, well, yeh, the prediction on the whole was wrong. That doesn't mean that the elements they did predict were done in error but simply that they did not anticipate something. Thus the incorrect numbers can be explained. I'm okay with that.

What I'm asking is if the AIDS predictions have panned out. Take the Rwanda example. The numbers were way off. Do they know why? I would hope so. It could be that they were wrong about how the disease spreads or the mortality rate. Or maybe they didn't anticipate a change in sexual practices or treatment. This is what I am asking.

What part are you asking us to predict? We can predict that HIV transmission and HIV prevalence will decrease if efforts to reduce higher risk sex practices are effective.
We can also predict that if we are wrong about HIV transmission that we might see increases or decreases if higher risk sex practices remain unchanged. In Rwanda it appears that condom use is still very low (http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/100615.php). So, as an average mope on the street pulling up the first couple of articles he sees, I wonder why population growth appeared to remain steady for 15 years when it was predicted to be reach zero or negative.

Problem is, the press in general doesn't cover stuff like this, so I'm asking here.

We can predict that progression to AIDS will decrease if we effectively modify those factors which lead to progression. Twenty years ago, what would have been more difficult to predict is whether we would find effective methods of reducing higher risk sex practices or whether we would find disease-modifying treatments.
Yes, I understand that. I'm asking what has happened because I don't know.
 
Obviously not, because the prediction discussed changes in sexual practices. If other conditions change that were not anticipated, well, yeh, the prediction on the whole was wrong. That doesn't mean that the elements they did predict were done in error but simply that they did not anticipate something. Thus the incorrect numbers can be explained. I'm okay with that.

What I'm asking is if the AIDS predictions have panned out. Take the Rwanda example. The numbers were way off. Do they know why? I would hope so. It could be that they were wrong about how the disease spreads or the mortality rate. Or maybe they didn't anticipate a change in sexual practices or treatment. This is what I am asking.

The WHO has publications outlining the demographics and evaluation of programme effectiveness.

http://www.afro.who.int/aids/publications/index.html

Epidemiological reports for individual countries are available here:

http://apps.who.int/globalatlas/default.asp

The report for Rwanda is here:

http://apps.who.int/globalatlas/predefinedReports/EFS2008/full/EFS2008_RW.pdf

We can also predict that if we are wrong about HIV transmission that we might see increases or decreases if higher risk sex practices remain unchanged. In Rwanda it appears that condom use is still very low (http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/100615.php). So, as an average mope on the street pulling up the first couple of articles he sees, I wonder why population growth appeared to remain steady for 15 years when it was predicted to be reach zero or negative.

Problem is, the press in general doesn't cover stuff like this, so I'm asking here.

I think the article you referenced answers that question for you. Prof. Anderson's numbers were gloomier than other researchers who predicted a slowing of the growth rate, but not for it to reach zero or negative. It appears that Prof. Anderson's assumptions were incorrect compared to others'.

Yes, I understand that. I'm asking what has happened because I don't know.

In that regard, it has behaved as predicted/expected.

Linda
 
Because you say so? Come on. READ the stats. HIV positive is a CONDITION affected by RACE, GENDER, and AGE. If it were a disease, especially a sexually transmitted disease, it would have hot spots like those that occur for syphilis or other STDs, BUT IT DOES NOT. Once you BELIEVE it is a disease, you MAKE UP reasons for all those anomalous details.

Gee, so its a total coincidence that gay fellows who have unprotected sex on a regular basis get it? Sorry, your assertion is insane.
 
Is it true there are a few people still alive who got AIDS a long time ago?

And if that is true, doesn't that mean the AIDS medication work?
 
HIV is not allowed to be debated by the ruling class.

That one is obviously not true for us, because so far nobody has censored or tried to stop a debate here. But are we the ruling class? :)

I'm pretty sure nobody is debating it on TV right now. Or in mainstream Journals. It really might be just a minor factoid, it didn't need to be included in the list really.

Well, at first, when Gallo shouted HIV causes AIDS the trials weren't really complete, but they rushed things because the virus explaination was good for the polls. To this day there are more unresolved issues than not, but it's easier to discard them than to revise 30 years of science.

No drugs that fight HIV have made money. If AZT had been good against cancer (what it was originaly meant to be able to do) I'm sure it would have made money like that.

Well, actually the antiretrovirals are a big market. Consider this: AZT was pretty useless, but for something like 10 years it was sold as a life saving madication. That's money with no effort.

PCR does.

PCR finds genetic sequences that have been associated with some strains of HIV. The test kit itself says that the test is not specific enough to base a diagnosis on.

Isolation and electron microscopy are pretty close.

Well, the denialists should whine about the "junk science" behind all viral and bacterial cultures, then, coz that's just the way it goes.

Actually, there have never been pictures of the HIV taken from AIDS patients. We have HIV cultures, but they are taken from other sources and immortalized through culture in lymphocites.

Nobody has done for HIV what has been done for every other pathogen.

:rolleyes:

No, but all the other data, research and studies do. That, and basic immunology.

The "overwhelming evidence" expression is quoted quite a lot when someone wants to dismiss the debate.

Because you say so? Come on. READ the stats. HIV positive is a CONDITION affected by RACE, GENDER, and AGE. If it were a disease, especially a sexually transmitted disease, it would have hot spots like those that occur for syphilis or other STDs, BUT IT DOES NOT. Once you BELIEVE it is a disease, you MAKE UP reasons for all those anomalous details.
There's a debate, so nobody is to be believed from say so. It is true that AIDS has never behaved in a way common to any sexually transmitted disease. STDs have a very specific behaviour, plus there are a number of studies that tested directly HIV's ability to be transmitted via sexual encounters and it seems that it is too low to be a viable mean of transmission.

Is it true there are a few people still alive who got AIDS a long time ago?
And if that is true, doesn't that mean the AIDS medication work?

This doesn't account for all the people who are diagnosed with HIV infection or AIDS and are alive today without taking the meds.


DISCLAIMER: I couldn't post any link in this reply because I'm operating from someone else's computer and I'm out of time. If you want I will shortly.
 
Good question. How accurate have the predictions been about AIDS? I don't follow it, but the sense of doom and gloom doesn't seemed to have panned out, but that could simply be a result of press coverage that I happened to notice "back then" and happen to notice "these days" (a nice way of saying I have no clue).

I just searched Google News for AIDS Predictions from 1991-1993. The first article I looked at reads:

"In Uganda, where 1.5 million people out of a population of 16 million are thought to be infected with H.I.V., the virus that causes AIDS, the current 3 percent population growth rate is likely to fall to below zero after 2002, with more people dying than being born, the projections say.

In 15 years [in 2007], Uganda would have 20 percent fewer people than if the AIDS epidemic had not occurred. The population would be 20.28 million, instead of 24 million. Tanzania, Malawi and Rwanda, all in the central and east African belt where AIDS has hit hardest, would be similarly affected, the results show."

Following directly after "A British scientist has predicted ...". (My emphasis, obviously.)

According to this site, that seems to be way off the mark:

Well that's egg-on-the-face for Dr Roy M. Anderson. That's a risk you take when you get your name in print.

Further on in the article :
"Professor Anderson's results are far gloomier than those of other mathematical modelers at the World Bank, the World Health Organization of the United Nations and the Population Council in New York. They have all concluded that population growth in Africa would be curbed by AIDS but would not turn negative."

No such problem for them, then :). Of course they didn't get their names in print ...
 
Well, at first, when Gallo shouted HIV causes AIDS the trials weren't really complete, but they rushed things because the virus explaination was good for the polls.

Not sure what you mean by "polls" there, but AIDS was a high-profile issue in its early US manifestation. Not that promiscuous homosexuals were a suympathetic group, but many people in the media counted them amongst their friends and acquaintances. So there were headlines and stories to rush out. I'm not sure Gallo was responsible for all the shouting.

The normal scientific process wasn't hurried, of course. It progressed marvellously quickly because of the money that was thrown at it, but it didn't cut corners.

To this day there are more unresolved issues than not ...

Every question answered simply introduces more, so this is unsurprising.

... but it's easier to discard them than to revise 30 years of science.

Thirty years of solid established science. And Science, from that base, is moving on to address these unresolved issues of which you speak.
 
Well, at first, when Gallo shouted HIV causes AIDS the trials weren't really complete, but they rushed things because the virus explaination was good for the polls. To this day there are more unresolved issues than not, but it's easier to discard them than to revise 30 years of science.

Well, actually the antiretrovirals are a big market. Consider this: AZT was pretty useless, but for something like 10 years it was sold as a life saving madication. That's money with no effort.

PCR finds genetic sequences that have been associated with some strains of HIV. The test kit itself says that the test is not specific enough to base a diagnosis on.

Actually, there have never been pictures of the HIV taken from AIDS patients. We have HIV cultures, but they are taken from other sources and immortalized through culture in lymphocites.

Nobody has done for HIV what has been done for every other pathogen.

The "overwhelming evidence" expression is quoted quite a lot when someone wants to dismiss the debate.

There's a debate, so nobody is to be believed from say so. It is true that AIDS has never behaved in a way common to any sexually transmitted disease. STDs have a very specific behaviour, plus there are a number of studies that tested directly HIV's ability to be transmitted via sexual encounters and it seems that it is too low to be a viable mean of transmission.

This doesn't account for all the people who are diagnosed with HIV infection or AIDS and are alive today without taking the meds.

DISCLAIMER: I couldn't post any link in this reply because I'm operating from someone else's computer and I'm out of time. If you want I will shortly.

So who told you that scientists cling to information they know to be wrong, that AZT is ineffective, that STD's behave in a common way, that people with HIV or AIDS die in short order without meds, that HIV has not been isolated from people with AIDS? Why did you believe them?

Linda
 
BTW, current combination antiretroviral therapies have cut the death rate markedly. This would point to a retrovirus cause even if nothing else did.

Following the science has indeed had a positive result, whereas sniping from the edges has produced nothing. It has got (and kept) some people's names in print, of course, but that's not actually productive.

The silver lining of AIDS is that without it we wouldn't know nearly as much about retroviruses and appropriate therapies as we now do. Had it been initially confined to Africans and the sort of intravenous drug-users who don't keep their own works in a designer case, we still wouldn't.
 
Must have been infected? Not hardly.

HIV proviral DNA can be detected in infected persons; this means that the virus has integrated into the host DNA. To do that the virus must have infected the host.

Even if the tests were actually specific, it could be that HIV is a HERV, a Human Endogenous Retro-Virus, contracted by an ancestor sometime in the last 20 or 30 million years. But the tests are not specific and the inserts say so. And they've never been adjusted to different races, so African women test positive many times as frequently as Caucasian or Asian women. The CDC is willing to say that's because of their sexual promiscuity, but that's a racial slur without real support.
 
How do infections behave?

How is an infection supposed to behave?

Linda

First, sexually transmitted infections happen in hot spots which vary somewhat over time. HIV is not concentrated in the places where syphilis and other STDs occur, together. Secondly, they spread among the population. I think the theory put forth by the CDC is that there are about a million "infected" people in this country, same as always.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom