HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

I'm still wondering what happened between SIVcpz and human HIV.
 
I remember the chinese being outraged by Bill or that other lunatic reportedly saying something to the end, that they wanted MS products to be widespread before they'd start cashing in, and that was why the rights weren't enforced in china in particular.

the chinese were outraged because they said something like "addict them", and the chinese have a long history of being addicted to western monopolies (e.g. opium) and reacted harshly.

Copyrights were enforced in europe and patents were used to keep other countries' fledgling software industry down. Microsoft is loathed by lots of IT folks for a reason.

Software patents hard enough to enforce in the US not seen them being enforced anywhere else. There are a number of non use software industries around. India for example.

China is free to use Macs or linux or BSD rather than windows. Microsoft wants fairly solid copyrights but that has little to do with drugs (where protection is patent and trademark based).

In any case a lot of third world countries are basicaly running the copyright law the former colonial powers left them with with limited modification. It seriously needs updateing in many cases.
 
In any case a lot of third world countries are basicaly running the copyright law the former colonial powers left them with with limited modification. It seriously needs updateing in many cases.
The WTO's general trade agreement and the WIPO treaties pretty much enforce conformity from every third world country in the world. If you think they're running colonial law in third world countries, you're very wrong. Only china is still reluctant to implement all the IP stuff.

And I think IP - the concept of IP as legislated - is an invention by satan in order to enslave humanity.
 
I'm late to the thread, but I heard you can get AIDS from a toilet seat.
Alright, back to topic. Gonna create an IP thread some other time.

Basically we don't know why people get AIDS, or rather, we know too many factors that depress the immune system. HIV is one theory, or one factor and not a particularly promising one.

Can you causally get AIDS by sitting on a toilet seat? Unless the toilet seat is spiked with needles, which inject drugs and HIV and foreign proteins into your blood stream, I'd doubt it. Even for regular (real) diseases, toilet seats are poor vectors. The skin just isn't that great a place to live for bacteria, much less a cold, dry toilet seat.
 
Basically we don't know why people get AIDS, or rather, we know too many factors that depress the immune system. HIV is one theory, or one factor and not a particularly promising one.

Correction - YOU don't know why people get AIDS (despite numerous of attempts to improve your knowledge on the topic, including pointing you to plenty of sources of factual information). Not everyone on this forum is as intellectually challenged on this topic as you are, so don't presume to speak for them (or the general public or scientists or anyone else you include in your statement).

The skin just isn't that great a place to live for bacteria.
Firstly, the Central Scrut was being facetious, not earnest.
Secondly, HIV is not a bacterium.
Thirdly, there are hundreds of billions of bacteria on the skin (even yours!) - Its a wonderful place for them to have a picnic.
 
Last edited:
Correction - YOU don't know why people get AIDS (despite numerous of attempts to improve your knowledge on the topic, including pointing you to plenty of sources of factual information). Not everyone on this forum is as intellectually challenged on this topic as you are, so don't presume to speak for them (or the general public or scientists or anyone else you include in your statement).
Refusing to subscribe to a theory that one investigated and considers flawed is not intellectual disability. Your ad hominem attacks are.
Firstly, the Central Scrut was being facetious, not earnest.
Secondly, HIV is not a bacterium.
Thirdly, there are hundreds of billions of bacteria on the skin (even yours!) - Its a wonderful place for them to have a picnic.
We weren't talking about HIV, though, but AIDS and bacteria. And no, the skin isn't a wonderful place for *most* bacteria, a petri dish is. The skin produces several substances (fatty acids) that make it a deadly place for most bacteria. There are a few bacteria, that are adapted to the human skin (and not pathogenous) that can survive in this environment and also destroy other bacteria. There is also little food for unadapted bacteria, as only the adapted ones can digest the ceratine, the dermatophytes.

So basically, you're half right. Bacteria do live on the skin, but not the dangerous types that are unadapted to the human body, the pathogenous ones he probably thought about when asking.
 
Refusing to subscribe to a theory that one investigated and considers flawed is not intellectual disability. Your ad hominem attacks are.
I am saying that if YOU are the one refusing to subscribe to a theory, do not assume the rest of humanity agrees with you.
If I do not think the earth rotates around the sun, I do not declare to the world that "WE do not know if the earth rotates around the sun"

We have spent a long time showing you the conclusive and unequivocal evidence that HIV causes AIDS. The fact that you dispute this does not mean that the scientific establishment agrees with you. Yours is an (almost) lone voice in the wilderness concerning this, I'm afraid. Are there things that science does not yet understand about HIV? Yes - of course there are. But that in no way lends credence to the HIV denialist crackpot theories, any more than a debate between astrophysicists about whether a proto-solar cloud gave rise to the planets indicates that scientists do not know if the earth rotates around the sun.

We weren't talking about HIV, though, but AIDS and bacteria. And no, the skin isn't a wonderful place for *most* bacteria, a petri dish is. The skin produces several substances (fatty acids) that make it a deadly place for most bacteria. There are a few bacteria, that are adapted to the human skin (and not pathogenous) that can survive in this environment and also destroy other bacteria. There is also little food for unadapted bacteria, as only the adapted ones can digest the ceratine, the dermatophytes.

So basically, you're half right. Bacteria do live on the skin, but not the dangerous types that are unadapted to the human body, the pathogenous ones he probably thought about when asking.


You said:
Can you causally get AIDS by sitting on a toilet seat? Unless the toilet seat is spiked with needles, which inject drugs and HIV and foreign proteins into your blood stream, I'd doubt it. Even for regular (real) diseases, toilet seats are poor vectors. The skin just isn't that great a place to live for bacteria, much less a cold, dry toilet seat.
You said the skin is not a great place for bacteria to live, and I corrected you by pointing out plenty of bacteria live on the skin. Please note you just said "bacteria", and not "most bacteria" which you now try and pretend you said.

You then try and say I am half right, because you only really meant "dangerous types" of bacteria. The skin is host to staphylococci (including MRSA) and streptococci which believe you me, are extremely pathogenic when they gain entry into part of the body they normally do not colonise. Other types of bacteria can be even more pathogenic, I agree, but then you were only talking about "skin bacteria". Evolution has led to some strains of bacteria finding a very nice ecological niche on human skin. Other bacteria cannot survive well - they are poorly adapted for it, as you say.

Innacuracies in statements will lead to misunderstanding, and get people talking at cross purposes.
 
Refusing to subscribe to a theory that one investigated and considers flawed is not intellectual disability. Your ad hominem attacks are.
No 'W', using your fantasy evidence and not understanding scientific evidence, is what you are doing here. You aren't arguing evidence v evidence, you are arguing your misunderstandings v scientific evidence.

Just like your unscientific conclusion bacteria prefer petri dishes to skin. That is absurd. Dead skin cells make a wonderful feast for all kinds of critters from dust mites to bacteria. Yes, bacteria are specialized. There are billions of different kinds and they prefer billions of different environments. But there are not merely "a few" on skin as you seem to think.

The word is pathogenic, not pathogenous, BTW and nowhere in Deetee's post did she specify pathogenic vs nonpathogenic bacteria were on one's skin. I will however specify that both inhabit skin. People are often colonized with pathogens which are not causing disease. Staphylococcus aureus and Streptococcus pyogenes are both potential pathogens commonly found on skin. And there are a number of pathogens which grow all too well on skin. Just look in any dermatology or infectious disease reference.

Bacterial Skin Infections
Different species of micro flora resides normally on the skin surface without causing harmful effects under the optimum conditions of the skin. Some of this resident flora may change their behavior and become pathogenic under certain circumstances.

Normal resident flora of the skin includes the following species.

Aerobic Gram positive cocci:
Staphylococci, Micrococci, Gram-positive rods and diphtheroids.

Anaerobes
Propionibacterium species: in the deeper part of the hair follicles, aerobic cocci and Pityrosporum sp. yeast present on the surface of the hair follicles and sebaceous glands.
P. Acnes, P.granulosum reside on the face and upper trunk at the pubertal age, having a role in the pathogenesis of acne.
Streptococcus pyogenes carriers in the throat are about 10% of the normal population, while carriers in the anterior nares are less.

Natural antibiotic production by some other members of the throat flora may contribute to resistance to colonization by Strep. Pyogenes, but carriage is often not eradicated by therapeutic antibiotics.

...

1. There are no resident bacteria usually in the sweat glands.
2. The normal flora of skin has probably a defense mechanism against bacterial infection. P. Acne and Gram positive cocci cause split of fatty acids into free fatty acids and triglycerides, which cause skin irritation and inflammation as the case in Acne.
3. Sebum alone or the acidic pH is not the defense mechanism as was previously considered.
4. Some strains of normal skin flora can produce antibiotics capable of inhibiting other micro-organisms.
The link has details of an array of pathogens which readily inhabit the skin can also cause disease when given the opportunity.

Perhaps the following might also increase your knowledge about skin flora and pathogens, 'W'.

How To Differentiate Between Infected Wounds And Colonized Wounds
Defining Colonization And Infection
Recent literature has begun to differentiate between colonization and infection. There is much discussion as to when colonization stops and infection begins. Colonization is defined as the presence of proliferating bacteria without a host response.2,3 These bacteria may be present due to the natural flora, environmental or endogenous factors. Colonization generally does not impede healing and has been shown in small amounts to accelerate healing.6 Identifying and measuring host response is still difficult.

Infection is the invasion of proliferating bacteria not only on the surface of the wound but into deeper, healthy viable tissue on the periphery of the wound. Infection will elicit a host response. In the presence of infection, the host’s immune response is not sufficient to eliminate or overcome the effect of the bacteria.2 At this point, the equilibrium now favors bacterial proliferation and infection will impede healing.

Recently, researchers have postulated that there is a critical point between colonization and infection, which is termed critical colonization.2,6 Again, critical colonization is more of a theoretical concept at this point as it has not yet been established in the scientific literature. The ability to differentiate clinically between colonization and critical colonization is nearly impossible in today’s environment. Future tests and research may improve the practitioner’s ability to make this important distinction. For now, however, critical colonization has yet to be quantified
 
Last edited:
4. Some strains of normal skin flora can produce antibiotics capable of inhibiting other micro-organisms.

Fascinating. The stuff you learn on the Internets.

The human body harbors over 200 species of bacteria on the skin.2 At any time, one of these bacteria can be inoculated into the wound. Once the skin is injured, the body is vulnerable to contamination from the environment, surrounding skin and mucous membranes.1 The longer the wound is exposed, especially if it is devitalized or compromised, the easier it is for bacteria to colonize.1
In fact, wounds are an ideal place for bacteria to colonize and proliferate since they have a warm, moist nutritive environment. The type of bacteria present and whether the bacteria has infected the wound depends on the type, depth, location, level of perfusion and the efficacy of the host response.1
http://www.podiatrytoday.com/article/4306

The reference for that is
2. Ovington L. 2003. Bacterial Toxins and Wound Healing. Ostomy Wound Management, 49.7A:8-12. of which I can find no other reference anywhere.

Are there really 200 species of bacteria on the skin?

And I don't buy this line at all,
In fact, wounds are an ideal place for bacteria to colonize and proliferate since they have a warm, moist nutritive environment

Yeah, and a host of really nasty defense mechanisms. If bacteria are moving in because you have a wound, there is some serious problem with the immune system, or the wound isn't clean or something.

On a related note, did you know your tears are antibiotic? Which makes sense, because the eyes are a warm moist enviroment open most of the time. If your tears were not super antibiotic, you would have nasty stuff growing in your eyes all the time.

Life is so cool.
 
That reference is "for real".
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&lr=&safe=off&cluster=2909519464282757772
http://www.o-wm.com/article/1842

robinson said:
And I don't buy this line at all,



Yeah, and a host of really nasty defense mechanisms. If bacteria are moving in because you have a wound, there is some serious problem with the immune system, or the wound isn't clean or something.

I think we probably have a bunch of "mini infections" every day that don't make it far. Every time you cut yourself, I bet bacteria start to colonize. They just get wiped out before you know anything of the sort started to happen.
Why some rare folks who are otherwise healthy end up getting some infections is mysterious. Really, a lot of stuff about the human immune response to various bacteria under various circumstances is still quite mysterious. If you're into "real" mysteries, you could spend months or years reading about the host immune response to bacteria. There are lots and lots of unknowns there. It's really interesting stuff. :)
 
Last edited:

I didn't doubt it was real, but that they identified 200 species of bacteria on healthy skin. Nothing at those links to support that claim. I doubt there is anything close to that number of species on healthy skin. Maybe somebody can provide some evidence.

I think we probably have a bunch of "mini infections" every day that don't make it far. Every time you cut yourself, I bet bacteria start to colonize. They just get wiped out before you know anything of the sort started to happen.

I'm sure there is a constant and to-the-death battle at every moment between us and them. The interface between us and out-there, is the battle ground, and it is in earnest. The eyes, the nose, sinuses, the mouth, throat and lungs, the stomach and gut, everywhere we meet with "not us" it is a battle, and one we are very good at winning. Most of us.

Unless it is a hospital strain, or some mutant, infectious new beast, there is very little that can cause an infection in an ordinary cut, that a healthy immune system can't kill. Even mutant Staph isn't that dangerous to a healthy person, (which is obvious, by the lack of people with flesh eating bacteria running around with rotting skin and sores and stuff).

As you say,

Why some rare folks who are otherwise healthy end up getting some infections is mysterious. Really, a lot of stuff about the human immune response to various bacteria under various circumstances is still quite mysterious. If you're into "real" mysteries, you could spend months or years reading about the host immune response to bacteria. There are lots and lots of unknowns there. It's really interesting stuff. :)

Yes, yes it is. In fact, the HIV/AIDS stuff has led to a lot of research and understanding of how our body works, especially the lymph system and the Thymus. As science and medicine evolves, it becomes clearer that every theory about disease is just a theory, and the reality is always far more interesting.

I'm sure somebody will disagree. :wackywink:
 
Continuing Medical education sites are generally reliable. The accrediting bodies are a form of peer review. There is an approval process either for the individual material in the CE or you can become an approved CE provider by establishing your credentials.

Here is a more extensive review with a free full text: Wound Microbiology and Associated Approaches to Wound Management
Exposed subcutaneous tissue provides a favourable substratum for a wide variety of microorganisms to contaminate and colonize, and if the involved tissue is devitalized (e.g., ischemic, hypoxic, or necrotic) and the host immune response is compromised, the conditions become optimal for microbial growth. Wound contaminants are likely to originate from three main sources: (i) the environment (exogenous microorganisms in the air or those introduced by traumatic injury), (ii) the surrounding skin (involving members of the normal skin microflora such as Staphylococcus epidermidis, micrococci, skin diphtheroids, and propionibacteria), and (iii) endogenous sources involving mucous membranes (primarily the gastrointestinal, oropharyngeal, and genitourinary mucosae) (65). The normal microfloras of the gut, the oral cavity, and the vagina are both diverse and abundant, and these sources (particularly the oral and gastrointestinal mucosae) supply the vast majority of microorganisms that colonize wounds. Detailed microbiological analyses of wounds demonstrate close correlations between the species found in the normal flora of the gut or oral cavity and microorganisms present in wounds in close proximity to those sites (33-35, 43, 46). Whereas a minor, healing wound may allow sufficient time for a only relatively small number of skin contaminants to take residence, the continued exposure of devitalized tissue associated with a slowly healing chronic wound is likely to facilitate the colonization and establishment of a wide variety of endogenous microorganisms. Dental plaque, the gingival crevice, and the contents of the colon contain approximately 1011 to 1012 microorganisms/g of tissue, of which, up to 90% of the oral microflora (16) and up to 99.9% of the colonic microflora (105) are anaerobes. In view of this situation, it is reasonable to predict that wounds with a sufficiently hypoxic and reduced environment are susceptible to colonization by a wide variety of endogenous anaerobic bacteria. However, to date, widespread opinion among wound care practitioners is that aerobic or facultative pathogens such as Staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and beta-hemolytic streptococci are the primary causes of delayed healing and infection in both acute and chronic wounds. Such opinion has been formed on the basis of referenced comments and studies performed largely during the last two decades that have investigated the role of microorganisms in wound healing (58, 59, 81, 94, 146, 182, 216, 217, 238; D. J. Leaper, Editorial, J. Wound Care 7:373, 1998). A common oversight in these and other studies and opinions is that the culture and isolation of anaerobic bacteria was minimal or omitted, whereas when wounds are investigated by appropriate microbiological techniques anaerobes are found to form a significant proportion of the microbial population in both acute and chronic wounds (25, 27, 28, 33-38, 41-45, 64, 80, 98, 143, 166, 185, 213, 226). On the basis of the studies reviewed in Table 1, which involved detailed microbiological analyses of clinically noninfected (i.e., colonized) wounds of varied etiology, anaerobes constituted, on average, 38% of the total number of microbial isolates per study. It should be emphasized that the studies reported did not investigate specifically the effect of microorganisms on wound healing.
We tend to have a very oversimplified view of the microbial world if not reading detailed material in the science of infectious disease or the science of microbiology. As far as, "200 species of bacteria on healthy skin", the reference is to bacteria which do not predominate as well as those which do. We typically only see the dominant species listed in textbooks and on culture reports. There are many many other bacteria living in smaller numbers on skin. And bacteria come and go as well.
 
Last edited:
I wonder how many of them are beneficial?

I'd guess that the answer to that question is unknown at this point. Most of those bacteria we don't know a lot about, period. And even with the ones we know a lot about, we still don't know a lot about all the ways they interact with a lot of other bacteria.

About the "200 species on the skin" thing...
The reference "Bacterial Toxins and Wound Healing" gave for that statment was the Online Textbook of Bacteriology.

Which can be found here:
http://www.textbookofbacteriology.net/

It's searchable, and here's all I could find:

http://www.textbookofbacteriology.net/normalflora.html

In a healthy animal, the internal tissues, e.g. blood, brain, muscle, etc., are normally free of microorganisms. On the other hand, the surface tissues, e.g. skin and mucous membranes, are constantly in contact with environmental organisms and become readily colonized by certain microbial species. The mixture of organisms regularly found at any anatomical site is referred to as the normal flora.

The normal flora of humans is exceedingly complex and consists of more than 200 species of bacteria. The makeup of the normal flora depends upon various factors, including genetics, age, sex, stress, nutrition and diet of the individual. The normal flora of humans consists of a few eukaryotic fungi and protists, and some methanogenic Archaea that colonize the lower intestinal tract, but the Bacteria are the most numerous and obvious microbial components of the normal flora. The distribution of the bacterial flora of humans is shown in Table 1. This table lists only a fraction of the total bacterial species that occur as normal flora of humans, and it does not express the total number or concentration of bacteria at any site.

That's normal flora for the whole body, though. So maybe the "200 species on the skin" was inaccurate?

Another search:

http://www.google.com/search?q=200+...ogy.net&sitesearch=textbookofbacteriology.net

Hmm...
 
It could be they are talking about the varied species of the few bacteria than manage to live on the skin.

We got the Staph and Strep, Staphylococcus epidermidis, Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus pyogenes, thats 3, maybe there are 197 species of Corynebacteria and Mycobacteria? There might be 200 possible species in all of the body, but I doubt a clean healthy person has anywhere close to that number of bacteria species growing on their skin.
 
It could be they are talking about the varied species of the few bacteria than manage to live on the skin.

We got the Staph and Strep, Staphylococcus epidermidis, Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus pyogenes, thats 3, maybe there are 197 species of Corynebacteria and Mycobacteria? There might be 200 possible species in all of the body, but I doubt a clean healthy person has anywhere close to that number of bacteria species growing on their skin.
You are confusing the fact that these microbes are found on skin without causing disease with what you seem to be thinking, they are all found on all of us all the time. That has not been claimed.

But if you read the sources I posted, you will find many many more species noted than the ones you posted.

The other thing you seem to disbelieve is the number of different bacterial species, I tried to tell you this was typical of people who have not been exposed to much microbiology. They assume that such things a staphylococci are all the same species with different clothes on. But you wouldn't assume all felines are the same species because you are familiar with lions and tigers and house cats. Staphylo- is a prefix meaning clusters and cocci are round. Strep means the bacteria form chains, and diplococci are pairs but they are also considered strep. So streptococci pneumoniae is actually a diplococci.

Some Major Groups within the Bacteria
Some major phylogenetic divisions within the eubacteria and representative genera are listed below. Additional divisions continue to be found. The groups (and some of the genera) can be seen in the last page of the handout. To illustrate the scattered distribution of some physiological characteristics, they are marked on the corresponding genera: photosynthetic with an asterisk (*); gliding motility with a bar (|), lack of a cell wall with a paragraph mark (¶), and thermophilicity by a section mark (§).


Hydrogen oxidizers
(oxygen reducers) Aquifex§
Thermotogales Thermotoga§, Fervidobacterium§
Thermodesulfobacterium group Thermodesulfobacterium§
Green nonsulfur Chloroflexus*|, Herpetosiphon, Thermomicrobium§
Deinococcus group Deinococcus, Thermus§
Thermodesulfovibrio group Thermodesulfovibrio§
Synergistes group Synergistes
Low G+C Gram positive Bacillus, Clostridium, Eubacterium, Heliobacterium*, Lactobacillus, Mycoplasma¶, Spiroplasma¶
High G+C Gram positive Bifidobacterium, Mycobacterium, Propionibacterium, Streptomyces
Cyanobacteria Oscillatoria*|, Prochlorococcus*, Synechococcus*, chloroplasts*
Planctomycetales Planctomyces
Chlamydiales Chlamydia
Green sulfur Chlorobium*
Cytophaga group Bacteriodes, Cytophaga|, Flexibacter|, Flavobacterium, Rhodothermus§
Fibrobacter group Fibrobacter
Spirochetes Borrelia, Leptonema, Spirochaeta (including Spirochaeta sp. str. Antarctic¶), Treponema
Proteobacteria (Purple bacteria):
alpha subdivision Agrobacterium, Anaplasma¶, Rhodobacter*, Rhodospirillum*, Rickettsia, mitochondria
beta subdivision Neisseria, Rhodocyclus*
gamma subdivision Beggiatoa|, Chromatium*, Escherichia, Haemophilus, Legionella, Pseudomonas, Salmonella, Vibrio, Yersinia
delta/epsilon subdivision Bdellovibrio, Campylobacter, Desulfovibrio, Helicobacter, Myxococcus|, Wolinella

Insights into the origin and evolution of other properties can be gained by similarly examining their distribution among the groups (preferably directly on a tree, as discussed below).
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom