Deetee
Illuminator
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2003
- Messages
- 3,789
Dubya, I find your objection to the evidence in these studies extremely specious. Basically it consists of wild handflapping and invalid excuses - the sort of reaction we have come to expect from HIV/AIDS rethinkers. Have you bothered to even read these abstracts, or just skim them in a predetermined fashion with nothing but confirmation bias in your mind?
(Originally Posted by Deetee in blue)
Incidence in Africa pre and post AIDS:
Comparison with data from the era of AIDS indicates 20-fold increases in the occurrence of Kaposi's sarcoma in Uganda and Zimbabwe.
Difference of epidemic KS from classical/endemic KS:
These data demonstrate the indolent nature of classic Kaposi sarcoma which usually requires a less aggressive therapeutic approach than in the African and AIDS-related types of Kaposi sarcoma.
Papers demonstrating some of the differences[in KS types] - Study 1 (endemic african KS) Study 2 (Classical KS in caucasians) and Study 3 (epidemic AIDS-related KS) from the same centre.
Again, this was an obviously misguided attempt by me to demonstrate what is the exact difference between the types of KS. Completely lost on you, as I feared. The authors have analysed in great detail all the KS types seen in their centre, and produced 3 papers, each one dealing with each variant of KS . And you complain they are "different studies"? Sheesh!
Thoughts about cause of KS before aetiological agent discovered:
In the United States Kaposi's sarcoma is at least 20,000 times more common in persons with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) than in the general population and 300 times more common than in other immunosuppressed groups. Among persons with the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) reported to Centers for Disease Control by March 31, 1989, 15% (13,616) had Kaposi's sarcoma. Kaposi's sarcoma was commoner among those who had acquired the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) by sexual contact than parenterally./
/Thus Kaposi's sarcoma in persons with AIDS may be caused by an as yet unidentified infectious agent, transmitted mainly by sexual contact.
Transmission of HHV-8 in US cohorts:
The prevalence of HHV-8 infection is high among homosexual men, correlates with the number of homosexual partners, and is temporally and independently associated with Kaposi's sarcoma. These observations are further evidence that HHV-8 has an etiologic role in Kaposi's sarcoma and is sexually transmitted among men.
Perhaps you missed the bit where "Base-line anti-LANA [HHV-8]seropositivity preceded and was independently associated with subsequent Kaposi's sarcoma, even after adjustment for CD4 cell counts and the number of homosexual partners."
BTW - Fun Fact #2: Contraceptive coil usage increases with promiscuity. So when do we get to hear your "Kaposi is caused by the Copper 7" hypothesis?
Regression Of KS coincides with restoration of immunity from HAART:
The findings indicate that antiretroviral therapy with protease inhibitors is effective for AIDS-related KS; the clinical response was correlated with a decrease in plasma HIV-1 RNA levels and an increase in CD4(+) lymphocytes, whereas antibody levels to the lytic-phase HHV8 protein were influenced by the extent of tumor involvement
You read almost right - aggressive, visceral KS were a contributing factor in 30% of deaths. You've never seen a case of KS, have you? You see, in AIDS it's not quite like the benign, indolent skin tumour you would have us believe (see the studies above to learn the difference between types).
I posted this case report for Robinson, since it was the first record of severe pulmonary KS regressing with HIV therapy. Here it is again, since you weren't paying attention first time around:
"This report represents the first documented case of pulmonary KS regression after the initiation of HAART. Although this finding is preliminary, if confirmed by other clinicians, the effect of potent antiretrovirals on KS growth and development will have important implications on the manner in which KS is staged and treated."
Guess what? - It has been confirmed, like all good science, and it is now well established that HIV therapy alone to restore immunfunction is the best way to treat KS.
The Mayo Clinic is a world famous institution with a very prestgious journal. The fact that you have not heard of it merely speaks of your gross ignorance in all things medical. It's impact factor is 4. This is higher than journals such as the American Journal of Medicine, the British Journal of Cancer, to name only two.
Another paper on this - EuroSIDA study
CONCLUSIONS: The current incidence of KS among patients with HIV is less than 10% of the incidence reported in 1994; the proportion of AIDS diagnoses made on the basis of KS diagnoses remains near 6%.
So after complaining about one "anecdote" you now have trouble accepting a cohort of 10 thousand cases? You stated below that you were "willing to believe that HHV-8 is the cause of KS, and that it does not usually cause KS in people that are not immunosuppressed".
I present a 10 thousand strong cohort, who with HIV therapy actually restore their immunity and become less immunosuppressed. By your own admission this should lessen the chance of KS, yet you still call the paper bunk???
If you are going to talk rubbish, at least let it be consisitent rubbish and stop contradicting yourself.
(my bold)
As a hypothesis, I'd like to see some (any?) supporting evidence. The competing hypothesis of HIV/HHV-8 is well supported however. It also explains the KS epidemic in Africa, which nitrites cannot explain (unless you are now willing to reveal the gay sauna address in Lusaka where all these thousands of people are meant to have gone to sniff poppers).
Your hypothesis is pretty vague. Substitute the words "anal lube" for "amyl nitrites" and I can generate another hypothesis that is of equal merit to yours. Now, as an intellectual exercise, why don't you prove to me that my anal lube hypothesis is incorrect.
(Originally Posted by Deetee in blue)
Incidence in Africa pre and post AIDS:
Comparison with data from the era of AIDS indicates 20-fold increases in the occurrence of Kaposi's sarcoma in Uganda and Zimbabwe.
Handflapping in an attempt to explain away a phenomenon you say did not exist.Does not correct for the 200 fold increase of scientists and their dogs diagnosing. Overruled.
Difference of epidemic KS from classical/endemic KS:
These data demonstrate the indolent nature of classic Kaposi sarcoma which usually requires a less aggressive therapeutic approach than in the African and AIDS-related types of Kaposi sarcoma.
What's to speculate? This is a study describing exactly what "classical" KS is, so that idiots like you will not confuse it with the aggressive epidemic form of KS seen with AIDS.The argument you are drawing here is of speculative nature.
Papers demonstrating some of the differences[in KS types] - Study 1 (endemic african KS) Study 2 (Classical KS in caucasians) and Study 3 (epidemic AIDS-related KS) from the same centre.
Still, completely different studies, and with ludicrously small samples at that.
Again, this was an obviously misguided attempt by me to demonstrate what is the exact difference between the types of KS. Completely lost on you, as I feared. The authors have analysed in great detail all the KS types seen in their centre, and produced 3 papers, each one dealing with each variant of KS . And you complain they are "different studies"? Sheesh!
Thoughts about cause of KS before aetiological agent discovered:
In the United States Kaposi's sarcoma is at least 20,000 times more common in persons with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) than in the general population and 300 times more common than in other immunosuppressed groups. Among persons with the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) reported to Centers for Disease Control by March 31, 1989, 15% (13,616) had Kaposi's sarcoma. Kaposi's sarcoma was commoner among those who had acquired the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) by sexual contact than parenterally./
/Thus Kaposi's sarcoma in persons with AIDS may be caused by an as yet unidentified infectious agent, transmitted mainly by sexual contact.
Firstly you must realise that I cited this early paper to show that a sexually-transmitted agent was thought to be a possible cause of KS very early on. There is no "misleading conclusion", because there is no conclusion. It is only an hypothesis, one which explained the observed evidence (and one that has been subsequently shown to hold true, unlike your nitrite theory)1 in 66 people is estimated as immunosuppressed. Interesting. Plus the final sentence's conclusion is misleading: It could still be amyl nitrites.
Transmission of HHV-8 in US cohorts:
The prevalence of HHV-8 infection is high among homosexual men, correlates with the number of homosexual partners, and is temporally and independently associated with Kaposi's sarcoma. These observations are further evidence that HHV-8 has an etiologic role in Kaposi's sarcoma and is sexually transmitted among men.
Fun fact: Nitrite inhalant usage also increases dramatically with promiscuity.
Perhaps you missed the bit where "Base-line anti-LANA [HHV-8]seropositivity preceded and was independently associated with subsequent Kaposi's sarcoma, even after adjustment for CD4 cell counts and the number of homosexual partners."
BTW - Fun Fact #2: Contraceptive coil usage increases with promiscuity. So when do we get to hear your "Kaposi is caused by the Copper 7" hypothesis?
Regression Of KS coincides with restoration of immunity from HAART:
The findings indicate that antiretroviral therapy with protease inhibitors is effective for AIDS-related KS; the clinical response was correlated with a decrease in plasma HIV-1 RNA levels and an increase in CD4(+) lymphocytes, whereas antibody levels to the lytic-phase HHV8 protein were influenced by the extent of tumor involvement
What the truck, 30% of AIDS deaths are caused by KS? Plus, with one sample, this is at the very best an anecdote. Can't imagine that "Mayo Clin Proc" is a very reknown journal. Bunk.
You read almost right - aggressive, visceral KS were a contributing factor in 30% of deaths. You've never seen a case of KS, have you? You see, in AIDS it's not quite like the benign, indolent skin tumour you would have us believe (see the studies above to learn the difference between types).
I posted this case report for Robinson, since it was the first record of severe pulmonary KS regressing with HIV therapy. Here it is again, since you weren't paying attention first time around:
"This report represents the first documented case of pulmonary KS regression after the initiation of HAART. Although this finding is preliminary, if confirmed by other clinicians, the effect of potent antiretrovirals on KS growth and development will have important implications on the manner in which KS is staged and treated."
Guess what? - It has been confirmed, like all good science, and it is now well established that HIV therapy alone to restore immunfunction is the best way to treat KS.
The Mayo Clinic is a world famous institution with a very prestgious journal. The fact that you have not heard of it merely speaks of your gross ignorance in all things medical. It's impact factor is 4. This is higher than journals such as the American Journal of Medicine, the British Journal of Cancer, to name only two.
Another paper on this - EuroSIDA study
CONCLUSIONS: The current incidence of KS among patients with HIV is less than 10% of the incidence reported in 1994; the proportion of AIDS diagnoses made on the basis of KS diagnoses remains near 6%.
And this uncontrolled, population based study attributes this to HAART which was introduced in 1997, when KS incidence was already going way down in 1993 (source) , and HAART is not usually supplied to people who haven't developed KS AIDS yet. As such it is pretty much impossible for HAART to be the causal agent that reduced the KS incidence - The whole paper is complete and utter bunk.
So after complaining about one "anecdote" you now have trouble accepting a cohort of 10 thousand cases? You stated below that you were "willing to believe that HHV-8 is the cause of KS, and that it does not usually cause KS in people that are not immunosuppressed".
I present a 10 thousand strong cohort, who with HIV therapy actually restore their immunity and become less immunosuppressed. By your own admission this should lessen the chance of KS, yet you still call the paper bunk???
If you are going to talk rubbish, at least let it be consisitent rubbish and stop contradicting yourself.
I'm willing to believe the following statements:
- HHV8 is the cause for KS
- HHV8 is an infectious agent, that can be spread through sex
- HHV8 does not usually develop KS in people that are not immunosuppressed
I'm willing to discuss the following statements:
- HIV *may* cause immunosuppression in *some* people, although there have never been any good studies on that
I'd like you to take a position this hypothesis:
- Amyl nitrites cause general immunosuppression when inhaled, and damage the skin's immunological defense, facilitating the developement of KS in an HHV8-infected host. This may explain the high KS incidence in homosexual men, not only in relation to population, but also in relation to HHV8 infections and in relation to HIV infections.
As a hypothesis, I'd like to see some (any?) supporting evidence. The competing hypothesis of HIV/HHV-8 is well supported however. It also explains the KS epidemic in Africa, which nitrites cannot explain (unless you are now willing to reveal the gay sauna address in Lusaka where all these thousands of people are meant to have gone to sniff poppers).
Your hypothesis is pretty vague. Substitute the words "anal lube" for "amyl nitrites" and I can generate another hypothesis that is of equal merit to yours. Now, as an intellectual exercise, why don't you prove to me that my anal lube hypothesis is incorrect.