HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

Dubya, I find your objection to the evidence in these studies extremely specious. Basically it consists of wild handflapping and invalid excuses - the sort of reaction we have come to expect from HIV/AIDS rethinkers. Have you bothered to even read these abstracts, or just skim them in a predetermined fashion with nothing but confirmation bias in your mind?

(Originally Posted by Deetee in blue)
Incidence in Africa pre and post AIDS:
Comparison with data from the era of AIDS indicates 20-fold increases in the occurrence of Kaposi's sarcoma in Uganda and Zimbabwe.
Does not correct for the 200 fold increase of scientists and their dogs diagnosing. Overruled.
Handflapping in an attempt to explain away a phenomenon you say did not exist.

Difference of epidemic KS from classical/endemic KS:
These data demonstrate the indolent nature of classic Kaposi sarcoma which usually requires a less aggressive therapeutic approach than in the African and AIDS-related types of Kaposi sarcoma.
The argument you are drawing here is of speculative nature.
What's to speculate? This is a study describing exactly what "classical" KS is, so that idiots like you will not confuse it with the aggressive epidemic form of KS seen with AIDS.

Papers demonstrating some of the differences[in KS types] - Study 1 (endemic african KS) Study 2 (Classical KS in caucasians) and Study 3 (epidemic AIDS-related KS) from the same centre.
Still, completely different studies, and with ludicrously small samples at that.

Again, this was an obviously misguided attempt by me to demonstrate what is the exact difference between the types of KS. Completely lost on you, as I feared. The authors have analysed in great detail all the KS types seen in their centre, and produced 3 papers, each one dealing with each variant of KS . And you complain they are "different studies"? Sheesh!

Thoughts about cause of KS before aetiological agent discovered:
In the United States Kaposi's sarcoma is at least 20,000 times more common in persons with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) than in the general population and 300 times more common than in other immunosuppressed groups. Among persons with the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) reported to Centers for Disease Control by March 31, 1989, 15% (13,616) had Kaposi's sarcoma. Kaposi's sarcoma was commoner among those who had acquired the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) by sexual contact than parenterally./
/Thus Kaposi's sarcoma in persons with AIDS may be caused by an as yet unidentified infectious agent, transmitted mainly by sexual contact.
1 in 66 people is estimated as immunosuppressed. Interesting. Plus the final sentence's conclusion is misleading: It could still be amyl nitrites.
Firstly you must realise that I cited this early paper to show that a sexually-transmitted agent was thought to be a possible cause of KS very early on. There is no "misleading conclusion", because there is no conclusion. It is only an hypothesis, one which explained the observed evidence (and one that has been subsequently shown to hold true, unlike your nitrite theory)

Transmission of HHV-8 in US cohorts:
The prevalence of HHV-8 infection is high among homosexual men, correlates with the number of homosexual partners, and is temporally and independently associated with Kaposi's sarcoma. These observations are further evidence that HHV-8 has an etiologic role in Kaposi's sarcoma and is sexually transmitted among men.
Fun fact: Nitrite inhalant usage also increases dramatically with promiscuity.

Perhaps you missed the bit where "Base-line anti-LANA [HHV-8]seropositivity preceded and was independently associated with subsequent Kaposi's sarcoma, even after adjustment for CD4 cell counts and the number of homosexual partners."

BTW - Fun Fact #2: Contraceptive coil usage increases with promiscuity. So when do we get to hear your "Kaposi is caused by the Copper 7" hypothesis?

Regression Of KS coincides with restoration of immunity from HAART:
The findings indicate that antiretroviral therapy with protease inhibitors is effective for AIDS-related KS; the clinical response was correlated with a decrease in plasma HIV-1 RNA levels and an increase in CD4(+) lymphocytes, whereas antibody levels to the lytic-phase HHV8 protein were influenced by the extent of tumor involvement
What the truck, 30% of AIDS deaths are caused by KS? Plus, with one sample, this is at the very best an anecdote. Can't imagine that "Mayo Clin Proc" is a very reknown journal. Bunk.

You read almost right - aggressive, visceral KS were a contributing factor in 30% of deaths. You've never seen a case of KS, have you? You see, in AIDS it's not quite like the benign, indolent skin tumour you would have us believe (see the studies above to learn the difference between types).

I posted this case report for Robinson, since it was the first record of severe pulmonary KS regressing with HIV therapy. Here it is again, since you weren't paying attention first time around:

"This report represents the first documented case of pulmonary KS regression after the initiation of HAART. Although this finding is preliminary, if confirmed by other clinicians, the effect of potent antiretrovirals on KS growth and development will have important implications on the manner in which KS is staged and treated."

Guess what? - It has been confirmed, like all good science, and it is now well established that HIV therapy alone to restore immunfunction is the best way to treat KS.

The Mayo Clinic is a world famous institution with a very prestgious journal. The fact that you have not heard of it merely speaks of your gross ignorance in all things medical. It's impact factor is 4. This is higher than journals such as the American Journal of Medicine, the British Journal of Cancer, to name only two.

Another paper on this - EuroSIDA study
CONCLUSIONS: The current incidence of KS among patients with HIV is less than 10% of the incidence reported in 1994; the proportion of AIDS diagnoses made on the basis of KS diagnoses remains near 6%.
And this uncontrolled, population based study attributes this to HAART which was introduced in 1997, when KS incidence was already going way down in 1993 (source) , and HAART is not usually supplied to people who haven't developed KS AIDS yet. As such it is pretty much impossible for HAART to be the causal agent that reduced the KS incidence - The whole paper is complete and utter bunk.

So after complaining about one "anecdote" you now have trouble accepting a cohort of 10 thousand cases? You stated below that you were "willing to believe that HHV-8 is the cause of KS, and that it does not usually cause KS in people that are not immunosuppressed".

I present a 10 thousand strong cohort, who with HIV therapy actually restore their immunity and become less immunosuppressed. By your own admission this should lessen the chance of KS, yet you still call the paper bunk???
If you are going to talk rubbish, at least let it be consisitent rubbish and stop contradicting yourself.

I'm willing to believe the following statements:
- HHV8 is the cause for KS
- HHV8 is an infectious agent, that can be spread through sex
- HHV8 does not usually develop KS in people that are not immunosuppressed

I'm willing to discuss the following statements:
- HIV *may* cause immunosuppression in *some* people, although there have never been any good studies on that
:D :D :D (my bold)

I'd like you to take a position this hypothesis:
- Amyl nitrites cause general immunosuppression when inhaled, and damage the skin's immunological defense, facilitating the developement of KS in an HHV8-infected host. This may explain the high KS incidence in homosexual men, not only in relation to population, but also in relation to HHV8 infections and in relation to HIV infections.

As a hypothesis, I'd like to see some (any?) supporting evidence. The competing hypothesis of HIV/HHV-8 is well supported however. It also explains the KS epidemic in Africa, which nitrites cannot explain (unless you are now willing to reveal the gay sauna address in Lusaka where all these thousands of people are meant to have gone to sniff poppers).

Your hypothesis is pretty vague. Substitute the words "anal lube" for "amyl nitrites" and I can generate another hypothesis that is of equal merit to yours. Now, as an intellectual exercise, why don't you prove to me that my anal lube hypothesis is incorrect.
 
Dubya, the HHV-8/KS hypothesis would be supported by studies showing that immune restoration from HIV therapy helped cure the KS or make it regress. There are many such studies. hese findings are inconsistent with a popper-induced KS theory.

Cattelan AM, Calabro ML, Gasperini P, Aversa SM, Zanchetta M, Meneghetti F, De Rossi A, Chieco-Bianchi L.
Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome-related Kaposi's sarcoma regression after highly active antiretroviral therapy: biologic correlates of clinical outcome.
J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr. 2001;(28):44-9.

Cattelan AM, Calabro ML, Aversa SM, Zanchetta M, Meneghetti F, De Rossi A, Chieco-Bianchi L.
Regression of AIDS-related Kaposi's sarcoma following antiretroviral therapy with protease inhibitors: biological correlates of clinical outcome.
Eur J Cancer. 1999 Dec;35(13):1809-15.

Dupin N, Rubin De Cervens V, Gorin I, Calvez V, Pessis E, Grandadam M, Rabian C, Viard JP, Huraux JM, Escande JP.
The influence of highly active antiretroviral therapy on AIDS-associated Kaposi's sarcoma.
Br J Dermatol. 1999 May;140(5):875-81

Cattelan AM, Calabro ML, De Rossi A, Aversa SM, Barbierato M, Trevenzoli M, Gasperini P, Zanchetta M, Cadrobbi P, Monfardini S, Chieco-Bianchi L.
Long-term clinical outcome of AIDS-related Kaposi's sarcoma during highly active antiretroviral therapy.
Int J Oncol. 2005 Sep;27(3):779-85.

Lebbe C, Blum L, Pellet C, Blanchard G, Verola O, Morel P, Danne O, Calvo F.
Clinical and biological impact of antiretroviral therapy with protease inhibitors on HIV-related Kaposi's sarcoma.
AIDS. 1998 May 7;12(7):F45-9.

Pellet C, Chevret S, Blum L, Gauville C, Hurault M, Blanchard G, Agbalika F, Lascoux C, Ponscarme D, Morel P, Calvo F, Lebbe C.
Virologic and immunologic parameters that predict clinical response of AIDS-associated Kaposi's sarcoma to highly active antiretroviral therapy.
J Invest Dermatol. 2001 Oct;117(4):858-63. Erratum in: J Invest Dermatol 2002 Apr;118(4):741.

Dupont C, Vasseur E, Beauchet A, Aegerter P, Berthe H, de Truchis P, Zucman D, Rouveix E, Saiag P.
Long-term efficacy on Kaposi's sarcoma of highly active antiretroviral therapy in a cohort of HIV-positive patients. CISIH 92. Centre d'information et de soins de l'immunodeficience humaine.
AIDS. 2000 May 26;14(8):987-93.

Gill J, Bourboulia D, Wilkinson J, Hayes P, Cope A, Marcelin AG, Calvez V, Gotch F, Boshoff C, Gazzard B.
Prospective study of the effects of antiretroviral therapy on Kaposi sarcoma--associated herpesvirus infection in patients with and without Kaposi sarcoma.
J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2002 Dec 1;31(4):384-90.

De Milito A, Catucci M, Venturi G, Romano L, Incandela L, Valensin PE, Zazzi M.
Antiretroviral therapy with protease inhibitors in human immunodeficiency virus type 1- and human herpesvirus 8-coinfected patients.
J Med Virol. 1999 Feb;57(2):140-4.
 
Last edited:
Deetee, you think the study of a single case is meaningful, and that HAART must obviously have caused the decline of KS incidence, since HAART was introduced in 1997 and KS began to decline rapidly in 1993.

You believe the Mayo clinic's pamphlet has an "impact factor of 4" (WOW!)

You believe an "adjustment" in a study proves anything, and aren't curious why nitrite inhalant usage wasn't recorded

Now, as an intellectual exercise, why don't you prove to me that my anal lube hypothesis is incorrect.
Anal Lube usage is not usually recorded in KS studies, hence there are no studies on the subject. Therefore your assertion that anal lube would/would not cause KS is scientifically unfounded. I hypothesize you would find a strong correlation between the amount of AL used in gays, and their KS incidence, and a weak correlation between heterosexuals that use AL and their KS incidence. Pretty much like HIV, huh?

Dubya, the HHV-8/KS hypothesis would be supported by studies showing that immune restoration from HIV therapy helped cure the KS or make it regress. There are many such studies. hese findings are inconsistent with a popper-induced KS theory.
Wrong, and wrong. Studies that claim an effect on KS by ART do not affect the HHV-8/KS hypothesis. HHV-8 is not a retrovirus. HAART does not restore the immune system, it merely and supposedly slows down the progress HIV infection. These findings are consistent with poppers usage: KS occurs more frequently in HIV-negative HHV-8 positive male homosexuals than in HIV-negative HHV-8 positive heterosexuals, and amyl nitrates are a risk factor. (link)
 
Deetee, you think the study of a single case is meaningful, and that HAART must obviously have caused the decline of KS incidence, since HAART was introduced in 1997 and KS began to decline rapidly in 1993.

Dubya, you are the one who quotes single case anectdotes ("I got ill after my flu jab therefore all vaccinations are harmful") I referred you to the first described case of a problem then linked you to studies with thousands more.

Reasons for the decline in KS are 2 fold - firstly, as safer sex messages took hold in the gay population, transmission rates for STIs (including HHV-8) fell. Then in the early 1990s, dual HIV therapy was introduced, to be followed in 1996 by triple therapy. You may not like the facts, but dual therapy has been shown to be effective in restoring CD4 counts, though not as effectively as triple HAART drugs.

You believe the Mayo clinic's pamphlet has an "impact factor of 4" (WOW!)
.
I don't believe it, I know it, and gave the link to prove it. Don't try and cover your ignorance about the existence of one of the most prestigious medical centres in the US by resorting to poorly judged sarcasm.

You believe an "adjustment" in a study proves anything, and aren't curious why nitrite inhalant usage wasn't recorded
Aren't you curious why anal lube wasn't recorded?

Anal Lube usage is not usually recorded in KS studies, hence there are no studies on the subject. Therefore your assertion that anal lube would/would not cause KS is scientifically unfounded.
Let's rephrase for you, substituting nitrites for anal lube again:
Dubya: "Nitrite usage is not usually recorded in KS studies, hence there are no studies on the subject. Therefore my assertion that nitrites would/would not cause KS is scientifically unfounded."
There, that sounds so much better, no?

Wrong, and wrong. Studies that claim an effect on KS by ART do not affect the HHV-8/KS hypothesis. HHV-8 is not a retrovirus. HAART does not restore the immune system, it merely and supposedly slows down the progress HIV infection.
You seriously think HIV therapy does not lead to immune restoration??
It does and you know it, which is where your whole argument crumbles into dust.

These findings are consistent with poppers usage: KS occurs more frequently in HIV-negative HHV-8 positive male homosexuals than in HIV-negative HHV-8 positive heterosexuals, and amyl nitrates are a risk factor. (link)
I will never cease to be amazed when HIV denialists link to studies that actually refute all their misconceptions about the subject, just because they find a small sentence buried somewhere that they can cherry-pick to support a nebulous claim.
 
You seriously think HIV therapy does not lead to immune restoration??
It does and you know it, which is where your whole argument crumbles into dust.
That actually made me laugh. I mean, I could probably surf the web for hours and not find this hilarious technique used anywhere in the history of debate.

"HIV therapy" does not lead to immune restoration any more than other active placebos. Possibly because "HIV therapy" is utterly ineffective at treating "HIV", and "HIV" isn't even the cause for a "lack of immune restoration" - You KNOW it! ADMIT IT! YOUR ENTIRE ARGUMENT CRUMBLES INTO DUST!!1!

P.S. does that link actually work for anyone? I click it and I get a error, if I copy & paste it manually, it works. Referral error? Google helps
 
Last edited:
That actually made me laugh. I mean, I could probably surf the web for hours and not find this hilarious technique used anywhere in the history of debate.


Ding Ding Ding!

We have a reductio ad Hitlerum! I knew it was coming. Could feel it from a mile away...
 
That actually made me laugh. I mean, I could probably surf the web for hours and not find this hilarious technique used anywhere in the history of debate.

"HIV therapy" does not lead to immune restoration any more than other active placebos. Possibly because "HIV therapy" is utterly ineffective at treating "HIV", and "HIV" isn't even the cause for a "lack of immune restoration" - You KNOW it! ADMIT IT! YOUR ENTIRE ARGUMENT CRUMBLES INTO DUST!!1!

Sigh......

HIV therapy, by suppressing HIV replication, results in immunerestoration. Not necessarily complete, that is true, but restoration nevertheless.

This is seen both functionally, with a dramatic reduction in the incidence of new opportunistic infections, and also in laboratory parameters where numeric CD4 counts are normalised and functional T cell responses improve. There are so many hundreds of references in the published literature to these phenomena that I am stumped to cite them all.

In fact, immune restoration can be so dramatic with HIV therapy that it has earnered itself an entirely new syndrome which goes under the moniker of IRIS. I won't bother taxing your brain with the hundreds of articles there are on Pubmed about just this one intriguing part of HAART's immunerestorative effect, so I'll let you Wiki for it.

In fact, because IRIS can damage the host (as all vigorous immune reactions can do) mainstream denialists consequently spend a lot of time slagging off HAART. "See, it harms patients!" they cry.

Your concept (that HAART never causes immune restoration) is a novel take, I must admit.

ETA: I see now where you get your debating techniques from. Spend a lot of time honing those skills, do you?
 
Last edited:
Ding Ding Ding!

We have a reductio ad Hitlerum! I knew it was coming. Could feel it from a mile away...
No, it really wasn't. I said its a completely new technique, not described anywhere, which is what makes it so ingenious.

In fact, immune restoration can be so dramatic with HIV therapy that it has earnered itself an entirely new syndrome which goes under the moniker of IRIS. I won't bother taxing your brain with the hundreds of articles there are on Pubmed about just this one intriguing part of HAART's immunerestorative effect, so I'll let you Wiki for it.

In fact, because IRIS can damage the host (as all vigorous immune reactions can do) mainstream denialists consequently spend a lot of time slagging off HAART. "See, it harms patients!" they cry.
You are really funny. So what essentially happens is, they give the "treatment" to the sick folks, and they get worse.

And then this is interpreted as proof that the treatment works?

And you believe that? You serious? Where's your skepticism, your Bullpoop-detector that goes "Waaaaait a second, that is total BS"

I mean seriously, how freaking deluded are you?
 
You are really funny. So what essentially happens is, they give the "treatment" to the sick folks, and they get worse.?

Yes, this can very occasionally happen. It also happens following bone marrow transplants for diseases like leukemia too. So do you want to come up with some theory that BMTransplants are a load of BS as well? (remember you have to be consistent - if you dismiss one, you dismiss them both)

And then this is interpreted as proof that the treatment works??

It is interpreted as proof that the treatment leads to IMMUNE RESTORATION. (You know, that thing you said did NOT happen with HIV treatment??

With a newly-invigorated and better functioning immune system the host can develop an inflammatory reaction to infections that have been lying dormant and which are untreated. So if there is latent TB, for instance, this can flare up when HIV treatment is commenced (because it is doing exactly what you refuse to believe - I.E: Restore immunity)

And you believe that? You serious? Where's your skepticism, your Bullpoop-detector that goes "Waaaaait a second, that is total BS"?

Sorry to say, this is all completely logical and comprehensible by anyone with a modicum of common sense and a smattering of medical understanding.

Yet again, you confirm you have neither.

I mean seriously, how freaking deluded are you?

Only as deluded as the tens of thousands of scientists and doctors who work with this virus and with AIDS patients day in and day out.
Of course, you, who have freely admitted having no medical knowledge or background, are not at all deluded - every one of your ignorant utterances is clearly cast iron evidence of whatever nonsense you have chosen to believe/promote today.
 
I had a conversation last night about HIV and related stuff. The person I was talking to doesn't do internet, so I got a sense of what an average person thinks about HIV, based on TV and newspaper reporting.

According to the major News reporting, (and this is just hearsay, from someone who watchesNetwork News and stuff), AIDS is a huge problem in the United States, the number of new cases is rising every year, and millions are going to die from the AIDS virus.

The AIDS VIRUS has been around since the fifties, and millions of people died from it back in the sixties, they just didn't call it AIDS then.

(I swear I am not making this up). The AIDS VIRUS is spread by sex, if you have unprotected sex with someone who has the AIDS VIRUS, you will get AIDS and die.
 
Thanks to the commentary/debate over HHV-8 I did some checking on that, and found some very interesting stuff about HHV-8.
 
I had a conversation last night about HIV and related stuff. /snip/
(I swear I am not making this up). The AIDS VIRUS is spread by sex, if you have unprotected sex with someone who has the AIDS VIRUS, you will get AIDS and die.

The public perception of many things is rather suspect. I guess many people think if you smoke you will get lung cancer, or if you live in the Bronx you will get mugged, or that any man talking to a child is a pedophile.

At least your friend realises the AIDS virus IS spread sexually....;)
The reality is that if you have unprotected sex with someone who has the AIDS VIRUS, you MAY get AIDS and die. It's very unlikely, but quite possible.

Think about how one gets a message across to someone they wish to "protect". You are a parent, and your child is stretching the boundaries of his independence and tends to run out into the street at every opportunity. You wish to discourage this potentially lethal behaviour. You have to promise reward for good behaviour, and/or make the child concerned that if they continue, some dire consequence may arise. This must be real and believable. You try and be as unequivocal as possible - the message that "A car could run you down and kill you" is hopefully immediately understandable (but statistically unlikely). Your child doesn't have the luxury of trying this one out for size - one hit and he could well be history, so you make the possibility seem as real as you can, explain how awful the consequenses will be, and how once is all it may take, and you not unnaturally tend to exaggerate somewhat for added effect.

People trying to promote safe sexual health and avoid transmission of HIV may use the same methods in their arguments. Unless someone is sufficiently scared about the consequences of their behaviour, they are unlikely to change it.

With HIV, many authorities have overplayed their hands, understandably I guess (The ethics of this policy could spawn another thread). But you still need to get the right balance. The message: "If you have unprotected sex with someone, there may only be a 0.2% chance that person has HIV, and even if they did have HIV there is only a 0.2% chance you would catch it, and even if you did catch it there is a reasonable chance it would not do a great deal of immediate harm, and oh by the way the treatment is so good now that someone with HIV is expected to live for 35 years" is not a very useful one if you are trying to make people have safer sex. If you are entirely accurate, then many people might take the view that HIV is not something to be concerned about and your message has failed.

Your conversational friend seems has picked up exactly the type of message that some in authority have tried to promote. There is a further dimension - what those in authority say is always misrepresented by the media to create the biggest scoop story or the most terrifying sound bite. Doom and apocalyptic gloom always sell well.

Conversely, I encounter some people who are actually the ones most at risk from HIV (as opposed to the usual low-risk heterosexual WASPs), and they have decided HIV is not worth worrying about, because they have seen that it is actually quite hard to catch, or not immediately lethal. Tell someone that he will catch HIV if he does X, and the person may say: "Hang on a minute, I've actually been doing X for 10 years now and not got HIV yet, so why should I listen to you?" Also the availability of "post exposure prophylaxis" has made people careless - a bit like the morning after pill. Again, people are now surviviing with HIV for 25 years plus, so others (such as younger men on the gay scene) may say - "I thought you died when you got HIV, yet these old guys are going strong 25 years later - so why should I worry?"
 
Last edited:
If you are entirely accurate, then many people might take the view that HIV is not something to be concerned about and your message has failed.
You believe that deception and scaremongering are superior to a honest explanation. That's just disgusting.

You'd also tell teenagers that kissing leads to pregnancy to keep them from having premarital sex, right?
 
You believe that deception and scaremongering are superior to a honest explanation. That's just disgusting.

You'd also tell teenagers that kissing leads to pregnancy to keep them from having premarital sex, right?
I said you need to get the balance right. I never said what I would tell people, I'm just explaining why some people do what they do. And yes, giving precise detail where it is not needed can lessen the impact of the preventative message sometimes, so one might need to be economical with the truth.

I find it odd that this "disgusts" you, but you find the exploitation of vulnerable people by chiropractic quacks, the dishonest promotion of both an antivaccination agenda and the view that HIV does not cause AIDS (all strategies that have demonstrably cost many lives) quite morally acceptable.
 
You believe that deception and scaremongering are superior to a honest explanation. That's just disgusting.

You'd also tell teenagers that kissing leads to pregnancy to keep them from having premarital sex, right?

No but I would tell them that unprotected sex will result in either an STD or pregnancy even though it is not a complete, statistical certainty.
 
I said you need to get the balance right. I never said what I would tell people, I'm just explaining why some people do what they do. And yes, giving precise detail where it is not needed can lessen the impact of the preventative message sometimes, so one might need to be economical with the truth.
I still do not notice any sort of moral condemnation for this type of behaviour.
I find it odd that this "disgusts" you, but you find the exploitation of vulnerable people by chiropractic quacks, the dishonest promotion of both an antivaccination agenda and the view that HIV does not cause AIDS (all strategies that have demonstrably cost many lives) quite morally acceptable.
Demonstrate how my view of HIV/AIDS has cost many lives. Do you believe people in africa wouldn't die if they believed in HIV/AIDS strongly enough? Or do just I have to believe so?

I've demonstrated that smallpox vaccinations have cost many lives, I've demonstrated that gruesome smallpox epidemics occur very well in 100% smallpox vaccinated populations instead of protecting against it, I've demonstrated that the incidence of smallpox increased with increasing vaccination, such that the vaccination itself caused smallpox.

I have never endorsed chiropractice. I've endorsed the opinion on non-chiropractic issues from a person who amongst many other things is also a chiropractic.
 
I still do not notice any sort of moral condemnation for this type of behaviour.
Because it may be morally acceptable, depending on the circumstances.

Demonstrate how my view of HIV/AIDS has cost many lives. Do you believe people in africa wouldn't die if they believed in HIV/AIDS strongly enough? Or do just I have to believe so?

I did't say your view has cost lives (please pay attention). I said the view that HIV does not cause AIDS has cost lives and that you find this view morally acceptable. Here it is again for good measure: "you find the exploitation of vulnerable people by chiropractic quacks, the dishonest promotion of both an antivaccination agenda and the view that HIV does not cause AIDS (all strategies that have demonstrably cost many lives) quite morally acceptable."

If you want Africa, I'll give you Africa.

A little history lesson...
In 1998, Thabo Mbeki, President of the country with the highest number of HIV cases in the world, developed doubts that HIV caused AIDS. So he and his Health Minister obstructed the roll out of HIV therapies nationally and also stopped the internationally accepted practice of offering HIV drug therapy to mothers in labour to prevent their infants becoming infected. Over the three years this took place, around 40 thousand babies became HIV infected per year, with the majority of these going on to get sick and have agonising deaths spun out over several years.

Nice, huh? You feel this is morally acceptable? Presumably. I think its sickening.

So how did Mbeki come to take this stance over HIV drugs?
Read on:
In October 1998 then Deputy President Thabo Mbeki and the then Minister of Health, Nkosazana Zuma, put a stop to the health department's piloting of anti-retroviral treatment for the prevention of mother-to-child transmission - for reasons which remain inexplicable.
It was only the following year that (now President) Mbeki was first introduced to the "alternative viewpoint" on HIV/AIDS, through the writings of Advocate Anthony Brink. According to the best available evidence Mbeki only really began taking a serious interest in the ‘dissident' literature in late October 1999 - although he proceeded to immerse himself in the subject thereafter.
The initial attraction of Brink's writings to Mbeki lay in his emphasis on the toxicity of AZT. This provided a new rationalisation for his (by then) already longstanding refusal to allow the provision of this drug through the public healthcare system.
Mbeki's other guide into this alternative view was the journalist Anita Allen. They met in November 1999 after Mbeki responded to earlier efforts of hers to contact him. The two worked closely together over the following few years on the HIV/AIDS issue.
In late January 2000 David Rasnick, a leading proponent of the ‘dissident' theory on AIDS, was contacted by President Mbeki's Office. He was sent eight questions which Mbeki had asked of the Minister of Health, Manto Tshabalala-Msimang - with her answers attached.Rasnick, and a colleague, Dr Charles Geshekter replied at length by fax the following day.
They stated that while the minister's answers "faithfully reflect the views of many in the medical establishment, nevertheless, her responses expose many of the problems and contradictions inherent in trying to understand AIDS in Africa." They suggested instead that five even more fundamental questions be asked, including "Does HIV cause AIDS?"
Elsewhere in their response they stated that the "real causes of AIDS in Africa" were "socio-economic status, poverty, malnutrition, tuberculosis, diarrhea, respiratory infections, malaria and other parasitic infections."

So Mbeki, who had been equivocal about whether HIV caused AIDS, had his requests for more information on the subject turned into a propaganda coup by these prominent HIV denialists. Mbeki had found his answer - HIV did not cause AIDS. The drugs were toxic and should be denied to his people. It was all downhill from then.

The World AIDS conference was held in SA in 2000. The world's scientific community was shocked at the stance taken in SA by Mbeki. Still he refused to admit HIV caused AIDS, and he steadfastly refused to let any drugs be given (though mysteriously, members of the ruling ANC party who had AIDS were able to get the drugs). Mbeki even went off to address a dissident conference in Uganda. On his return the press reported:
Mbeki also "told ANC MPs that it was their duty to inform themselves so that they could counter the huge propaganda offensive that was being mounted to say that HIV caused AIDS."
He also, "repeated his view that if one agrees that HIV causes AIDS, then it must be treated with drugs, and those drugs are produced by the big Western drug companies; these drug companies therefore need HIV to cause AIDS, so they promote the thesis that HIV causes AIDS."
He also, "said the CIA had become involved in covertly promoting the view that HIV causes AIDS; as part of the same effort, the US government was ignoring what the dissidents' conference in Uganda had demonstrated...."
By 2002 the stubborn refusal to allow anti-retroviral drugs through the public health care system had resulted in the opening up of deep divisions within the ANC. In early February former President Nelson Mandela voiced veiled criticisms of the continuing refusal of the government to allow for the provision of anti-retroviral treatment for the prevention of mother-to-child transmission.
Unfortunately for S Africans, the legacy of this period continues to the present day: All Africa.com, 29th July 2007
Despite a number of hospitals being ready to implement 'dual therapy' to prevent mother-to-child HIV infection, the national Department of Health has not yet made it national policy
The Department of Health is stalling the introduction of treatment that can prevent over 90% of pregnant HIV positive women from infecting their babies.
Currently, up to 30 000 babies are being infected with HIV by their mothers in KwaZulu-Natal alone each year.
A leading paediatrician has described the delay as "shameful", while the Treatment Action Campaign (TAC) says it is considering court action to force government to expand its programme.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom