HIV/AIDS, Facts, Myths, what is true?

I checked the figures on that. They don't add up.

Prove it. For a population of over 9 million they are far from unreasonable (assumeing a fartility rate of about 2).
 
If somebody makes a claim, it is up to them to provide evidence, facts, figures, show how they came to believe what they claimed. I checked the statistics, and the story doesn't hold water.

If you don't believe it, look at the figures for yourself. Don't try and switch the goalpost, and ask me to prove somebodies else's claim. It doesn't work that way.
 
If somebody makes a claim, it is up to them to provide evidence, facts, figures, show how they came to believe what they claimed. I checked the statistics, and the story doesn't hold water.

If you don't believe it, look at the figures for yourself. Don't try and switch the goalpost, and ask me to prove somebodies else's claim. It doesn't work that way.
I guess you mean my estimate of 40 thousand infants infected by MTCT each year? I used to have a reference somewhere for this but have lost it just now, so let's work it out shall we?

SA has a population of 47 million, with a birth rate of 23/1000.
This is around 1 million births each year.
25% of pregnant mothers are HIV positive.
So 250 thousand kids are born to HIV positive mothers each year.
Here
Of these we would expect between 15% and 30% to transmit HIV to their infants at birth (lets say 20%, or 50000 babies born with HIV each year)

We know that giving nevirapine alone to mothers in labour will reduce the transmission rates to between 5 and 13%.
Here and here also here

Without Nevirapine, between 24000 and 40000 babies will be born with HIV. So my 40000 estimate is at the top of this range.

But let's not forget that monotherapy with Nevirapine was recommended as the less favoured option - the ideal therapy to prevent MTC Transmission in resource poor settings is combination therapy (eg AZT plus other drugs) which if started as short course treatment in the last trimester will reduce the transmission rate to less than 10%, so employing this strategy would have averted 45 thousand transmissions each year. This was well within the capabilities of SA which is a curious mix of 1st world infrastructure and 3rd world problems, but has an excellent medical care system.

Thanks to Mbeki and Thabalala-Msimang, neither of these preventitive strategies was possible. Essentially they have commited genocide on their own population, condemming over a hundred thousand children to die protracted and painful deaths without even the quick release of Zyklon B.

HIV denialists like Dabljuh are perfectly comfortable with this nasty vignette from the annals of HIV denial. I am not.
 
Last edited:
Because it may be morally acceptable, depending on the circumstances.

I did't say your view has cost lives (please pay attention). I said the view that HIV does not cause AIDS has cost lives and that you find this view morally acceptable. Here it is again for good measure: "you find the exploitation of vulnerable people by chiropractic quacks, the dishonest promotion of both an antivaccination agenda and the view that HIV does not cause AIDS (all strategies that have demonstrably cost many lives) quite morally acceptable."
You are confusing two separate issues there. Is it moral to lie to people even if your goal is to help them? I don't think so. The other issue is one of science. Is the criticism on the HIV-AIDS hypothesis scientifically legitimate? Yes it is.

Lets evaluate the basic argument of what you're posted.
Assume HIV causes AIDS. Propose antiretroviral treatment prevents HIV from causing AIDS. (even to a degree!) Then, denial of antiretroviral treatment to people diagnosed with AIDS is a moral outrage.

But notice there's a whole lot of assumptions for this outrage. It should become apparent that the insistence on these assumptions, and indifference to legitimate scientific complaint, is not motivated by scientific interests. That's a scientific outrage, not a moral one.

Much rather, economical interest. A country that stops providing ART to its people means millions and billions of lost income opportunity. You better do something about that, jack.

Further: What if SA couldn't have afforded the medication anyways? The WIPO and WTO are still lobbied by big pharma to prevent third world countries from making their own, license-cost free anti-HIV treatment.

Now that is a moral outrage, not a scientific one.

And people like Bill Gates donate billions to third world countries for no other reason than guilt: Microsoft is one of the most adamant supporters of stringent WIPO regulations, and Gates himself can be made personally responsible for millions of africans not getting their precious ART. And that's all ignoring the scientific issues.

You need to learn to keep Moral issues and Scientific issues properly apart.

Well there is a book out by a famous scientist Peter Deusenberg called "Inventing the Aids Virus". He said that the HIV virus is harmless and he theorizes that the drug lifestyle causes Aids and he also says that certain Aids drugs do more harm than good.

http://www.netwatchcentral.com/articles/archive/07280401/index.php?reset=true
I'm aware of Duesberg, he is the leading scientist of the AIDS dissidents. I haven't read his book, but a number of papers and publications by him on the subject. Currently he seems more engaged in cancer research.
 
Last edited:
You are confusing two separate issues there.
No I'm not. You are the one who typically raises multiple issues so as to avoid dealing with questions you cannot answer.

Is it moral to lie to people even if your goal is to help them? I don't think so.
Many think it is. I think it may be depending upon the situation.
Can deceiving patients be morally acceptable?

The other issue is one of science. Is the criticism on the HIV-AIDS hypothesis scientifically legitimate? Yes it is.

Criticism of any hypothesis is legitimate. Has anyone said different? How you criticise it is another matter, and we all are aware of your skilfully honed debating techniques and reliance on solid scientific evidence.;)

Further: What if SA couldn't have afforded the medication anyways?

There has never been a question of South Africa having to pay through the nose for treatments such as nevirapine. It is very affordable, and preventing infection can save hundreds of million$ in the long run.
Here and here (PS: the cost of a dose of nevirapine for a mother in labour is about US $3)
 
Further: What if SA couldn't have afforded the medication anyways?

GDP of $570.2 billion. It could. GDP per capita is higher than say brazil

The WIPO and WTO are still lobbied by big pharma to prevent third world countries from making their own, license-cost free anti-HIV treatment.

AZT is patent free these days.

And people like Bill Gates donate billions to third world countries for no other reason than guilt: Microsoft is one of the most adamant supporters of stringent WIPO regulations, and Gates himself can be made personally responsible for millions of africans not getting their precious ART. And that's all ignoring the scientific issues.

Not really. I don't think Microsoft have really tried to enforce patents outside the US.
 
Not really. I don't think Microsoft have really tried to enforce patents outside the US.
I remember the chinese being outraged by Bill or that other lunatic reportedly saying something to the end, that they wanted MS products to be widespread before they'd start cashing in, and that was why the rights weren't enforced in china in particular.

the chinese were outraged because they said something like "addict them", and the chinese have a long history of being addicted to western monopolies (e.g. opium) and reacted harshly.

Copyrights were enforced in europe and patents were used to keep other countries' fledgling software industry down. Microsoft is loathed by lots of IT folks for a reason.
 
W:

And generally speaking, the fact that they are serious about protecting their intellectual property is NOT one of those reasons. Those reasons have more to do with the character and quality of product support and their reaction to security issues.

Now, that may be one of the reasons for the various hacker and cracker wannabes who think that paying for software is some sort of communist plot...but I assume by "IT folks" you meant professionals, not the script kiddie legions.

You really just say whatever comes to mind, without bothering whether it's related to the truth at all, don't you? Anything to support your argument, facts are irrelevent, I suppose.
 
What are we talking about here?

Microsoft enforces patents and copyrights, supports the WIPO, not because they want to increase their profits (and their potential profits), but because they "worry about security holes and the quality of support" ?

All IT professionals think that paying for software licenses is the only model that allows for software developers to make an income?

Go away.
 
What are we talking about here?
No, Dabljuh. I was pointing out the error in your implication that IT professionals disliking Microsoft was related to the fact that they enforce their intellectual property rights.

Again, you simply state this because it reinforces your point, but you have no clue as to the truth of the statement.
Microsoft enforces patents and copyrights, supports the WIPO, not because they want to increase their profits (and their potential profits), but because they "worry about security holes and the quality of support" ?

You have trouble with reading comprehension, don't you? I was speaking of IT professionals. A group of people you, from your statements, seem to have little contact with.

All IT professionals think that paying for software licenses is the only model that allows for software developers to make an income?
This, ladies and gentlemen, is what we call a "Strawman Argument". These are actually quite common in threads where Dubljuh participates.

No, W, I never said nor implied that. That is simply your fantasy position you wished to assign to me in a futile, juvenile attempt to discredit me instead of looking at the actual statements I made.

I said that IT professionals don't have a problem with Microsoft expecting people to pay for software licenses. It's an accepted and very common business model. And it's not as if it's something they sneak in on you, it's clearly stated up front. That's how they work. There are other business models that are used by other companies and products, but MS does not (generally speaking) take advantage of those. FOr that matter the vast amjority of commercial software uses a licensing model.

Now, I'll go away when you get your head out of your fourth point of contact long enough that your breath doesn't smell like excrement. When you talk about IT professionals, you're in my ballpark, and I'll have no problems looking you in the (metaphroical) eye and telling you you have no idea what you're talking about.
 
Damnation, extreme topic drift!

Not that there is anything wrong with that.

Of course all kinds of interesting stuff has shown up here and in the current scary Vaccination topic, just when I took on a huge contract and have little time to spare, damn you troll, for you provide the lattice for growth of ideas, much like dried pig bladder on an open wound, sometimes the most off the wall ideas, concepts and solutions turn out to have legs, maybe even wings, and I would venture, much like a hundred years ago, in 1907, many believe science knows almost everything about science, when in fact, we might, in a collective sense, know maybe 10% at best, about things that matter.

Of course the vast majority of wild claims turn out to be either huge errors in logic, lack of science, scams, fraud, or religious nonsense. While some may enjoy the shooting of a fish in a barrel, attacking and exposing the obvious crapolla that still hangs on, in our enlightened times, what is woo is a cultural bias, OMNSHO of course.

I prefer the more difficult task of going after scientific fraud, current medical woo, and other arenas of knowledge where new discoveries are greeted by the current power elite, with disdain, dismissal, censorship and scorn, because the real interesting stuff almost always shows up there.

I don't expect much, but receive far less.
 
This, ladies and gentlemen, is what we call a "Strawman Argument". These are actually quite common in threads where Dubljuh participates.

No, W, I never said nor implied that. That is simply your fantasy position you wished to assign to me in a futile, juvenile attempt to discredit me instead of looking at the actual statements I made.
Oh. Um... wait... what? You said:
Now, that may be one of the reasons for the various hacker and cracker wannabes who think that paying for software is some sort of communist plot...but I assume by "IT folks" you meant professionals, not the script kiddie legions.
Now that's what I call a straw man argument. You imply no "IT Professionals" would disagree with software patents, copyright software licenses (which was what I was talking about) and imply only script kiddies would.
All IT professionals think that paying for software licenses is the only model that allows for software developers to make an income?
Just what you said. And when I expose your straw man argument, you attack me for "using a straw man"?
This, ladies and gentlemen, is what we call a "Strawman Argument". These are actually quite common in threads where Dubljuh participates.
It appears so.

One more thing:

FOr that matter the vast amjority of commercial software uses a licensing model.
What you nublet probably call "commercial software" is, almost by definition, software that is sold via licensing. Hence your argument is... retarded. The vast majority of programmers don't produce for the market, but custom-design for the industry.

Go Away. Start a new thread or something. This oughta be about HIV/AIDS.

I prefer the more difficult task of going after scientific fraud, current medical woo, and other arenas of knowledge where new discoveries are greeted by the current power elite, with disdain, dismissal, censorship and scorn, because the real interesting stuff almost always shows up there.
Precisely what I'm looking for. It's much more interesting to debunk what everybody thinks is true and right, than to debunk stuff that nobody has even heard of.
 
Oh. Um... wait... what? You said: Now that's what I call a straw man argument. You imply no "IT Professionals" would disagree with software patents, copyright software licenses (which was what I was talking about) and imply only script kiddies would.

You don't understand hyperbole either, it seems. My apologies for not spelling out exactly what I thought anyone with two functional brain cells would understand. I didn't say IT professionals all loved licensing. I said very few consider it some sort of evil plot, as you do. Yes, I exaggerated for effect. I'm sorry, I expected you to be at least averagely intelligent.
What you nublet probably call "commercial software" is, almost by definition, software that is sold via licensing. Hence your argument is... retarded. The vast majority of programmers don't produce for the market, but custom-design for the industry.

*sigh*

You are an idiot.

Commercial software is software used by commercial entitites, as opposed to personal or private. In other words, what companies use...you know, the same places that hire IT professionals to maintain their systems? Let me make it clearer. The licensing model is the expected model for any non-custom software used by businesses. There is nothing "sinister" or "unethical" about MS using this model, and enforcing its rights in regards to its software. Additionally, your argument was about IT professionals (in other words, those who work in IT as a living). Not just programmers. Even among programmers, most are fine with the license idea (they may not like it, bit very few view it as a reason to dislike a company or some sort of "plot" as you implied). This is what's called "Moving the Goalposts (from IT professionals to programmers).

Even then, the type of programmers you're talking about generally don't produce software anyone else would have access to, period. They produce in-house solutions, and these are typically small programs, applets, and scripts (with the exception of mainframe systems). I don;t see how this is relevant to your arugment in any way.

Again, you simnply show how you are more than willing to spout nonsense as if you had a clue.

Go Away. Start a new thread or something. This oughta be about HIV/AIDS.
Yes, it outta be, but some idiot keeps spouting nonsense about subjects he knows nothing about in a vain attempt to support his arguments. You brought up the computer angle, I'm simply correcting your ignorance. Well, let's not take on an impossible task here...I'm trying to make sure your ignorance doesn't spread.


Just reminding you of your Membership Agreement, Huntsman. Please attack the argument & not the arguer. Thanks.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Katana
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just reminding you of your Membership Agreement, Huntsman. Please attack the argument & not the arguer. Thanks.
Posted By:Katana​
You mean I can't do both? ;)

I'm sorry, Katana, JREF mods, and other JREFers. Certain people get under my skin, especially those who post in ignorance (dictionary meaning) for no other reason than to support an agenda. I'll restrict my personal comments in the future, regardles of how accurate they may be :)
 
It is dumb to substitute personal insults for rational conversation. Most of us learn as we grow up to debate the issue, not attack the man. Except in Politics, where that seems to be OK still.

:D
 
You mean I can't do both? ;)

I'm sorry, Katana, JREF mods, and other JREFers. Certain people get under my skin, especially those who post in ignorance (dictionary meaning) for no other reason than to support an agenda. I'll restrict my personal comments in the future, regardles of how accurate they may be :)


No prob, Huntsman.

:)
 
It is dumb to substitute personal insults for rational conversation. Most of us learn as we grow up to debate the issue, not attack the man. Except in Politics, where that seems to be OK still.

:D
I agree.

But substituting is one thing. I just throw them in as additonal filler and to express my utter contempt. Really, you could take out all the insults in my previosu post, and still have a rebuttal. I didn't substitute anything:

Oh. Um... wait... what? You said: Now that's what I call a straw man argument. You imply no "IT Professionals" would disagree with software patents, copyright software licenses (which was what I was talking about) and imply only script kiddies would.

You don't understand hyperbole, it seems. My apologies for not spelling out exactly what I thought was obvious. I didn't say IT professionals all loved licensing. I said very few consider it some sort of evil plot, as you do. Yes, I exaggerated for effect.
What you nublet probably call "commercial software" is, almost by definition, software that is sold via licensing. Hence your argument is... retarded. The vast majority of programmers don't produce for the market, but custom-design for the industry.

Commercial software is software used by commercial entitites, as opposed to personal or private. In other words, what companies use. The licensing model is the expected model for any non-custom software used by businesses. There is nothing "sinister" or "unethical" about MS using this model, and enforcing its rights in regards to its software. Additionally, your argument was about IT professionals (in other words, those who work in IT as a living). Not just programmers. Even among programmers, most are fine with the license idea (they may not like it, bit very few view it as a reason to dislike a company or some sort of "plot" as you implied). This is what's called "Moving the Goalposts (from IT professionals to programmers).

Even then, the type of programmers you're talking about generally don't produce software anyone else would have access to, period. They produce in-house solutions, and these are typically small programs, applets, and scripts (with the exception of mainframe systems). I don't see how this is relevant to your arugment in any way.

Go Away. Start a new thread or something. This oughta be about HIV/AIDS.
Yes, it outta be, but some one keeps talking incorrectly about other subjects in an attempt to support his arguments. You brought up the computer angle, I'm simply correcting your ignorance.

See? No substitution,. just flavoring :)
 
Not really, You've gotten beyond my research on the subject at this point. I'm interested, but not enough to stop other things I'm doing and research allthis on my own. I'm just monitoring the topic to learn new things now; enjoying the fruits of others labors :) (and correcting the odd mistake in an area I do know about).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom