Heiwa Challenge to be Explained at NMSR


I think some of that is you simply not understanding Newton's Third Law. The rest is him just yanking your chain or being sloppy. Some of what you think he's saying seems to be this person's own interpretation. The language difference means things are a little fuzzier and you are misinterpreting where he might actually be joking with you. For example, I don't think he was actually trying to argue that the building materials were like cheese. The fact that you don't get that is funny.

As for the no plane stuff, well, everyone is entitled to their own... etc.

Interesting to see the same ridiculous, over-the-top examples being trotted out every time in some desperate attempt to find exceptions to Newtonian laws.
 
Last edited:
I think some of that is you simply not understanding Newton's Third Law. The rest is him just yanking your chain or being sloppy. Some of what you think he's saying seems to be this person's own interpretation. The language difference means things are a little fuzzier and you are misinterpreting where he might actually be joking with you. For example, I don't think he was actually trying to argue that the building materials were like cheese. The fact that you don't get that is funny.

As for the no plane stuff, well, everyone is entitled to their own... etc.

Interesting to see the same ridiculous, over-the-top examples being trotted out every time in some desperate attempt to find exceptions to Newtonian laws.


Let me make this perfectly clear to you
We understand Newton's Third Law.
You have failed to show how it applies to the wtc and was violated.
What you are attempting to do is use an example of a closed system and apply it to an event with that had an external force acting upon it.
You have failed.
 
I watched Heiwa consistently wipe the floor with the poor best that the debunkers here had to offer. A shudder of relief ran through the forum when he was banned.

I'm sorry, but that's demonstrably incorrect.
 
I think some of that is you simply not understanding Newton's Third Law.

Please explain to this uninformed professional physicist with a PhD and over 25 years' experience, exactly what Newton's Third Law states, and describe mathematically how this results in the conclusion that verinage demolitions are impossible.

Dave
 
Please explain to this uninformed professional physicist with a PhD and over 25 years' experience, exactly what Newton's Third Law states, and describe mathematically how this results in the conclusion that verinage demolitions are impossible.

Dave

It's certainly a strange suggestion given that he's not pushed the point over in the Physics vs Structural Engineering thready of late.
 
In any case, you don't seem to be recognizing that verinage does not meet his challenge.




But only because he changed his challenge after we showed him Verinage.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4561353#post4561353

The Heiwa Challenge


It is assumed at JREF 9/11 Conspiracy Theories Forum that a structure will be crushed, if you drop a piece (1/10th) of the same structure on it and that it is quite normal - no conspiracy. So here is the challenge: Prove it!

Conditions:

1. The structure is supposed to have a certain cross area A and height h and is fixed on the ground. The structure is an assembly of various elements of any type. It can be any size!
2. The structure should be more or less identical from h = 0 to h = h, e.g. uniform density, layout of internal elements, etc. Horizontal elements in structure should be identical. Vertical, load carrying elements should be similar and be uniformly stressed due to gravity, i.e. bottom vertical elements may be reinforced or made a little stronger, if required. Connections between elements should be similar throughout.
3. It is recognized that the structure may be a little higher stressed at h=0 than h=h due to uniform density, elements, etc.
4. Before drop test the structure shall be stable, i.e. carry itself and withstand a small lateral impact at top without falling apart. Connections between elements cannot rely solely on friction.
5. Before test 1/10th of the structure is disconnected at the top at h = 0.9 h without damaging the structure.
6. The lower structure, 0.9 h high is then called part A. The top part, 0.1 h high, is called part C.
7. Mass of part C should be <1/9th of mass of part A.
8. Now drop part C on part A and crush part A (if you can! That's the test).
9. In order to easily repeat the test/challenge drop height should be <1.1 h, i.e. C can only be dropped from 2h above ground on A that is 0.9 h high.
10. Structure is only considered crushed, when >70% of the elements in part A are disconnected from each other after test, i.e. drop by part C on A.

Have a try! I look forward to your structures!

Heiwa


The only limit here not demonstrated by every Verinage example we've seen is the 1/10 portion requirement, and even that is shown by at least one Verinage example.

His adding the "one-way crush up" part is a classic example of goalpost moving. If you look at his posting history here, it's clear that he refuses to believe that any upper part of any structure can crush the lower part, and Verinage demolishes that position completely.
 
It's certainly a strange suggestion given that he's not pushed the point over in the Physics vs Structural Engineering thready of late.

I didn't know that Dave was unemployed..

Oops...strike that. It's just that his post read something like a pitch...


''Please explain to this uninformed professional physicist with a PhD and over 25 years' experience...''
 
Last edited:
But only because he changed his challenge after we showed him Verinage.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4561353#post4561353




The only limit here not demonstrated by every Verinage example we've seen is the 1/10 portion requirement, and even that is shown by at least one Verinage example.

His adding the "one-way crush up" part is a classic example of goalpost moving. If you look at his posting history here, it's clear that he refuses to believe that any upper part of any structure can crush the lower part, and Verinage demolishes that position completely.

He's going easy on you Horatius in only asking for 70% of the connections to be broken. PPersonally I would insist on the whole 9 yards with 100% disconnection as in WTC1.

Who will take the challenge ? Remember the top one-tenth of the building must obliterate the lower nine-tenths of the building from a small drop.


PS:
Obliterate,v.....def...[mark for deletion or rule out]
obliterate,adj...def...[reduce to nothingness]
 
Last edited:
He's going easy on you Horatius in only asking for 70% of the connections to be broken. PPersonally I would insist on the whole 9 yards with 100% disconnection as in WTC1.

Who will take the challenge ? Remember the top one-tenth of the building must obliterate the lower nine-tenths of the building from a small drop.


PS:
Obliterate,v.....def...[mark for deletion or rule out]
obliterate,adj...def...[reduce to nothingness]



Thanks to bs for this real-time recreation of the Heiwa Goalpost Getaway Shuffle.
 
When did this bit get added? After he "left" JREF?

Every time he got challenged he moved the goalposts so it's hard to say what his challenge is/was/or will be.
 
I think some of that is you simply not understanding Newton's Third Law. The rest is him just yanking your chain or being sloppy. Some of what you think he's saying seems to be this person's own interpretation. The language difference means things are a little fuzzier and you are misinterpreting where he might actually be joking with you. For example, I don't think he was actually trying to argue that the building materials were like cheese. The fact that you don't get that is funny.

As for the no plane stuff, well, everyone is entitled to their own... etc.

Interesting to see the same ridiculous, over-the-top examples being trotted out every time in some desperate attempt to find exceptions to Newtonian laws.

I think its funny that you think he is "janking [our] chain" about all that other stuff, but you think its fine that your "expert" believes the plane would have bounced off the WTC and all the footage of planes were faked.

Its like... all that other stuff is way too crazy for anyone to believe but CGI planes and planes bouncing off buildings is a perfectly valid opinion to have.

Why arent you even a little embarrassed to be represented by him? I guess that very fact is why you lot are such a joke.
 
Last edited:
See post Number 88.

Still incorrect. Heiwa hand-waved away every single piece of technical evidence and calculation that was put to him.

I re-read the "Amazing Fireproof Steel" thread recently because Dusty seemed to be taking a similar line and I can assure you that the phrase "got his arse kicked" sprang to mind frequently.
 
Let's see you take a pratfall while walking on 12 foot stilts. Hey, it's only a 'small drop'.

Yes, hey Bill jump off a 12 foot high wall onto a scale and tell us how hard you land. (the Heiwa challenge).
 
I think some of that is you simply not understanding Newton's Third Law. The rest is him just yanking your chain or being sloppy. Some of what you think he's saying seems to be this person's own interpretation. The language difference means things are a little fuzzier and you are misinterpreting where he might actually be joking with you. For example, I don't think he was actually trying to argue that the building materials were like cheese. The fact that you don't get that is funny.

As for the no plane stuff, well, everyone is entitled to their own... etc.

Interesting to see the same ridiculous, over-the-top examples being trotted out every time in some desperate attempt to find exceptions to Newtonian laws.

You and Newton need to come to a better understanding.
 
call to perfection / moving the goalposts logical fallacy noted. All three floors crushed everything below them. Just because it wasn't in "a central part" or there was a wing of the building beyond the scope of demolition remaining you hand wave it off.
Your handwaving off the fact that your example isn't a complete structure being brought down that the challenge calls for, along with three floors dropping on ten being over double the 1/10 ratio specified in the challenge. While the 3.7 meter max drop height was added later, the rest is where the goalposts have been from the start, you're just ignoring them because you can't get anywhere close.
 
Your handwaving off the fact that your example isn't a complete structure being brought down that the challenge calls for, along with three floors dropping on ten being over double the 1/10 ratio specified in the challenge. While the 3.7 meter max drop height was added later, the rest is where the goalposts have been from the start, you're just ignoring them because you can't get anywhere close.

So 1/10 is impossible while 3/10 is fine?
 
Your handwaving off the fact that your example isn't a complete structure being brought down that the challenge calls for, along with three floors dropping on ten being over double the 1/10 ratio specified in the challenge. While the 3.7 meter max drop height was added later, the rest is where the goalposts have been from the start, you're just ignoring them because you can't get anywhere close.

Heiwa also claimed (IIRC) that it would have been dropped from 1000 meters up, and it would do nothing.

Yeah, do you agree?
 
So 1/10 is impossible while 3/10 is fine?
Even 1/10 is possible when just sheering floors off a building rather than bringing down the structure as a whole, and given a high enough drop.

Heiwa also claimed (IIRC) that it would have been dropped from 1000 meters up, and it would do nothing.

Yeah, do you agree?
No, that's absurd, and so are his TV fakery arguments.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom