Heiwa Challenge to be Explained at NMSR

once again I show you how ignorant you are. @ 3.19 top three stories demolish the lower ten

That's because they are only demolishing part of the building in that example. The top block isn't crushing the central wall that held it up, just sheering floors off of it and crushing the outer wall. Note how when they do full buildings they come at them from the middle. Also, in that example any every other I've seen, they push out well more than 3.7 meters.
 
Well done Dave,

I'll add to the Heiwa thing...

I directly asked him on TruTV's forums about Verinage and why that didnt qualify as fitting his challenge, he claimed that they destroy the bottom in Verinage first in order to bring the building down. I pointed out that he has absolutely no evidence that they do this and showed him the patent which specifically stated they do not do this and he completely ignored me even though I asked him over and over again.

So in future simply point to Verinage, since his claim that it doesnt match his challenge is based purely on his denial of how it works.

Not that he would listen to anyone, but people like ergo defending his insane ideas.
Forget verinage, he once claimed that the Ronan Point failure initiated near the base of the building, when it started at the 18th floor
 
I think this must be it here but the English portion does not cover the whole description.

https://data.epo.org/publication-server/getpdf.jsp?pn=1082505&ki=B1&cc=EP



You can get a machine translation of the text here:

http://v3.espacenet.com/publication...=A1&FT=D&date=20010314&DB=EPODOC&locale=en_EP


There's a box at the top right of the text that says "translate this text"; click that, and you'll get it. Since it's a machine translation, it usually reads a bit funny, but you can get the essential points.
 
Please tell me he says yes..........

If he does then he is quite right as he usually is. The plane should have hit the line of 33 14'' square steel BOX columns which would have crushed against the floor slabs at 12 foot intervals. This would have taken all the momentum out of the aluminium tin-can plane and the wreckage would just have fallen away.

The denser engines and landing gear MIGHT have penetrated but the aluminium airframe ?--Never..
 
Last edited:
That's because they are only demolishing part of the building in that example. The top block isn't crushing the central wall that held it up, just sheering floors off of it and crushing the outer wall. Note how when they do full buildings they come at them from the middle. Also, in that example any every other I've seen, they push out well more than 3.7 meters.
call to perfection / moving the goalposts logical fallacy noted. All three floors crushed everything below them. Just because it wasn't in "a central part" or there was a wing of the building beyond the scope of demolition remaining you hand wave it off.
 
If he does then he is quite right as he usually is. The plane should have hit the line of 33 14'' square steel BOX columns which would have crushed against the floor slabs at 12 foot intervals. This would have taken all the momentum out of the aluminium tin-can plane and the wreckage would just have fallen away.

The denser engines and landing gear MIGHT have penetrated but the aluminium airframe ?--Never..

Just like water can't cut steel......:rolleyes:
 
In all verinage videos I've seen, the top is simultaneously crushing up. I believe Bjorkman's assertion is that a smaller top of something cannot one-way crush down a larger bottom of something.

No, Heiwa's assertion is that in Verinage they destroy the building from the bottom despite proving no evidence for this and ignoring the patent

Heiwa claims with Verinage that they...

....suddenly remove primary supporting elements of the structure at the bottom, close to ground, so that the top part of the building drops down and contacts ground"... "The lower part is already partly destroyed (to initiate the controlled destruction)

It think TruTV deleted loads of threads so you'll have to deal with the cache:
http://preview.tinyurl.com/28uk6cv

I cant find the original post in google cache, but ask him directly again why Verinage doesnt count and Im sure he will give the same stupid answer.

I would really love to see the patent, though. Is there an online source for it?

Im sure someone has provided this but i cant be bothered to read the rest of this thread to find out while Im typing this so here it is again. You can also translate the French to English in google translate which doesnt do too badly:

https://data.epo.org/publication-server/getpdf.jsp?pn=1082505&ki=B1&cc=EP

Par ailleurs, ce procédé est également sans danger pour les opérateurs étant donné qu'il n'est pas nécessaire de fragiliser la structure de l'immeuble.
English:

Moreover, this method is also safe for operators because it is not necessary to weaken the structure of the building.

You will find absolutely no reason to think Verinage works the way Heiwa claims it works. But go please read it, maybe you'll realise why Bjorkman's "challenge" is idiotic... but then again I wont hold by breath.
 
Last edited:
No, Heiwa's assertion is that in Verinage they destroy the building from the bottom despite proving no evidence for this and ignoring the patent

I directly asked him on TruTV's forums about Verinage and why that didnt qualify as fitting his challenge,

Heiwa's challenge, as I understand it, is to find a structure in which its smaller upper portion can one-way crush its larger bottom portion. In verinage, the top portion is always seen crushing up simultaneously. So, no, you have not met the challenge. Whatever else he has said about it is irrelevant to his specific challenge.
 
Heiwa's challenge, as I understand it, is to find a structure in which its smaller upper portion can one-way crush its larger bottom portion.

When did this bit get added? After he "left" JREF?
 
Heiwa's challenge, as I understand it, is to find a structure in which its smaller upper portion can one-way crush its larger bottom portion. In verinage, the top portion is always seen crushing up simultaneously. So, no, you have not met the challenge. Whatever else he has said about it is irrelevant to his specific challenge.

Ergo, please pay attention.

I have asked Heiwa why Verinage doesnt count, he doesnt say that the reason you give above is why Verinage doesn't count.

He says that in Verinage they destroy the bottom part of the structure. Can you at least have the intellectual honesty to just admit he is wrong about that?

Feel free to pass my post onto him and ask him to clarify what he meant when he said that they "suddenly remove primary supporting elements of the structure at the bottom, close to ground, so that the top part of the building drops down and contacts ground"... "The lower part is already partly destroyed (to initiate the controlled destruction"

I asked him over and over to justify those remarks but he ignored me each time. Maybe because he has no evidence Verinage works the way he thinks it does and what he believes about it is directly contradicted by the patent.
 
I haven't seen where he has said this, so I wouldn't comment on it one way or another. I don't know him personally so I am not in communication with him. Why don't you just invite him back so he can respond to a number of things that are being said about him? Otherwise it's not really fair to be having these discussions if he can't respond. I'm sure the mods would consider it if a number of jref-ers requested it.

In any case, you don't seem to be recognizing that verinage does not meet his challenge.
 
I haven't seen where he has said this, so I wouldn't comment on it one way or another. I don't know him personally so I am not in communication with him. Why don't you just invite him back so he can respond to a number of things that are being said about him? Otherwise it's not really fair to be having these discussions if he can't respond. I'm sure the mods would consider it if a number of jref-ers requested it.

In any case, you don't seem to be recognizing that verinage does not meet his challenge.

He said it in that thread I referenced, unfortunately TruTV decided to delete a bunch of threads and it seems the cache hasnt been saved for that page.

I dont know why you think it sounds so stupid I must have made it up since this is coming from a guy that thinks the plane would have bounced off the WTC, that there were no planes on 911 at all and all the footage was faked along with various other crazy things he's said since he has been at the JREF (not at all exhaustive)


Small relevant examples:

The first failures would be arrested at once, which I clearly describe. No crush-down is possible. And that applies to all steel structures! You cannot destroy a steel structure by dropping a piece of it from above on itself!
- link

Well, if you have a nuke in your wardrobe and want to destroy a rigid structure with it, have a try. The rigid structure is indestructible (by definition) and thus remains intact.
- link


Björkman believes his house would survive an asteroid impact.

Björkman proposes experiments to prove that the structures of the Twin Towers were comparable to cheese, pizza boxes, match boxes, rubber balls, and sponges.

Also, you can contact him here:
http://heiwaco.tripod.com/index.html

Please do go ask him why he doesnt consider Verinage fit his challenge.

He claims that if a top part of a building can never crush the bottom part, thats why he denied Verinage even exists because that is exactly what we see happen. In those videos the most extreme case is about 3 floors easily crushing around 10 or so. Bjorkman has maintained over and over this is impossible since the bottom part has greater mass than the top. That is why he claims Verinage has to destroy the bottom supports in order for it to work. As I said, Verinage does not work that way and the only reason he says it works this way is because he is in denial.
 
Last edited:
I haven't seen where he has said this, so I wouldn't comment on it one way or another. I don't know him personally so I am not in communication with him. Why don't you just invite him back so he can respond to a number of things that are being said about him? Otherwise it's not really fair to be having these discussions if he can't respond. I'm sure the mods would consider it if a number of jref-ers requested it.

In any case, you don't seem to be recognizing that verinage does not meet his challenge.

I watched Heiwa consistently wipe the floor with the poor best that the debunkers here had to offer. A shudder of relief ran through the forum when he was banned.
 
I haven't seen where he has said this, so I wouldn't comment on it one way or another. I don't know him personally so I am not in communication with him. Why don't you just invite him back so he can respond to a number of things that are being said about him? Otherwise it's not really fair to be having these discussions if he can't respond. I'm sure the mods would consider it if a number of jref-ers requested it.In any case, you don't seem to be recognizing that verinage does not meet his challenge.

And I am sure that you would be wrong.
 
I watched Heiwa consistently wipe the floor with the poor best that the debunkers here had to offer. A shudder of relief ran through the forum when he was banned.

:dl:

​
We've seen the staggeringly ignorant and outright bizarre nonsense spewed by Gage and the "experts" whose opinions he promotes. Is Björkman's promotion by AE911Truth another fallacious appeal to authority, or has he done some sensible analysis of the events of 9/11? Bjorkman posts as "Heiwa" on the JREF forum:
​
Björkman claims that no planes hit the Twin Towers or the Pentagon or crashed near Shanksville, which makes him a rarity even among the most delusional "truthers": a quadruple no-planer.
Björkman claims that all evidence of the aircraft impacts is fake and all witness accounts are invalid
. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again.
Björkman claims that if 30 stories of one of the Twin Towers was dropped on the lower 80 stories from a height of two miles, it would bounce off without damaging the lower portion. And again.
Björkman says a Tower wouldn't be destroyed if a 60-million-pound block of ice was dropped on it, then denies making that claim.
Björkman claims that all photo and video evidence showing severe fires and structural failure in the WTC buildings is fake. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again.
Björkman claims that WTC 7 was demolished by a vacuum.
Björkman believes that the authors of the NIST WTC reports don't exist.
Björkman believes that steel structures are indestructible, even by nuclear weapons. And again. And again. However, Björkman also believes that 16,500-22,000 lbs of high explosives may have been used to demolish each Twin Tower...with no detectable detonations.
Björkman is an engineer who believes that weight = mass. No, really.
Björkman believes his house would survive an asteroid impact.
Björkman again attempts to revise the laws of physics.
Björkman says a bathroom scale will register the same weight whether you stand on it or jump on it.
Björkman says the Twin Tower fires were "minor office fires."
Björkman makes the egregiously false claim that the FDNY said it could handle the fires in the Towers.
Björkman believes that columns become stronger when their supports are removed.
Björkman believes that the structures of the Twin Towers were comparable to cheese, pizza boxes, match boxes, rubber balls, sponges, a bicycle running into a wall, a child jumping on a bed, a tower of sushi, and a tower of lemons.
Björkman has been nominated for the JREF forum "Stundie," an award for the looniest conspiracist statement of the month, far more times than anyone, and has been voted the "winner" several times. His avoidance of mountains of facts and expertise, his complete ignorance of the most basic engineering concepts, and his insistence that special laws of physics apply in his world, are perhaps surpassed only by the inimitable Judy "Star Wars Beams" Wood. Read about the errors he makes in his website paper here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom