Has anyone ever heard of a thing called COINTELPRO?

Scooby,

Can you point to any COINTELPRO activity occurring after the Church report? With evidence and links, please.

Also, wouldn't you agree that the very existence of the Church report shows that the systems is policed by congress?

Lastly, in reference to the FBI opening mail, does it not make sense for the FBI to keep tabs on any group that might threaten lives, or engage in other criminal activity? Or are you just referring to the quantity of mail?
 
Scooby,

Can you point to any COINTELPRO activity occurring after the Church report? With evidence and links, please.

Also, wouldn't you agree that the very existence of the Church report shows that the systems is policed by congress?

Lastly, in reference to the FBI opening mail, does it not make sense for the FBI to keep tabs on any group that might threaten lives, or engage in other criminal activity? Or are you just referring to the quantity of mail?

Ah it runs strong in you doesn't it? That old chestnut.
Congress didn't catch them remember, 'left wing radicals' did, in 1971.
Congress didn't get involved until 1976 - this is all on the wiki page at the start.

"The program was secret until 1971, when an FBI field office in Media, PA was burglarized by a group of left-wing radicals calling themselves the Citizens' Commission to Investigate the FBI. Several dossiers of files were taken and the information passed to news agencies, many of which initially refused to publish the information. Within the year, Director Hoover declared that the centralized COINTELPRO was over, and that all future counterintelligence operations would be handled on a case-by-case basis.

Further documents were revealed in the course of separate lawsuits filed against the FBI by NBC correspondent Carl Stern, the SWP, and a number of other groups. A major investigation was launched in 1976 by the Select Committee to Study Governmental Operations with Respect to Intelligence Activities of the United States Senate, commonly referred to as the "Church Committee" for its chairman, Senator Frank Church of Idaho. However, millions of pages of documents remain unreleased, and many released documents are entirely censored."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cointelpro

As for COINTELPRO being used now - you've not heard of Aaron Kilner then?
 
Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, c'mon, call yourself a critical thinker? For the love of Sagan!
Absence of evidence, however, does indicate absence of evidence. Said absence is thus unconvincing of extraordinary (and ridiculous) claims. Should I also believe in Santa Claus despite an absence of evidence that he doesn't exist? I could easily find more believers in Santa Claus than in 9/11 conspiracy theories, and I could probably find more evidence of his existence, too.

Here's what critical thinking tells me about the idea that the government is trying to fracture the 9/11 "Truth" Movement from within:

a) Said "Movement" is based on nothing but conjecture and preconceptions regarding powerful conspiracies involving the governments of the world and the wealthy.
b) Every attempt of said "Movement" to provide evidence of their claims ends in failure.
c) Said "Movement" has failed to demonstrate significant support from a statistically significant portion of the population.
d) Even the participants in said "Movement" can't agree on the nature of the proposed conspiracy, nor which "facts" support their views.
e) Said "Movement" has, so far, apparently, committed no crimes, particularly ones which would endanger lives or property. They're "all talk."
f) Thus, said "Movement" is no threat to either the government or the postulated "conspiracy" which supposedly caused the events of 9/11/2001.
g) J. Edgar Hoover is dead, and so obviously does not run the FBI.
h) Having determined that no real threat exists, there is no reason for the government to expend resources to deal with said "Movement."

Now, I suppose b, c and d could be entirely due to the government infiltration, of which there is no evidence, but that constitutes a circular argument which is not a substitute for that evidence. One could as easily blame Internet gremlins which are actually responsible for the "disinformation" and such amongst CTers. Both theories are as credible to me since I believe in neither gremlins nor FBI "Truth Movement" infiltrators...

This, and you didn't realise we're at war - do yourself a favour - don't hold your breath till you've followed what I post, ok?
I do realize it. I wasn't specifically concerned with your use of the word "peacetime" but your use of the present tense. My apologies if I was unclear.
 
Ah it runs strong in you doesn't it? That old chestnut.
Congress didn't catch them remember, 'left wing radicals' did, in 1971.
Congress didn't get involved until 1976 - this is all on the wiki page at the start.

But Congress still took action.

As for COINTELPRO being used now - you've not heard of Aaron Kilner then?
Here's a quote from members of the group he infiltrated:

Ken Hudson, a long time activist with Peace Fresno, said that Kilner played a very quiet role in the group. Other Peace Fresno activists also remembered him as being quiet and added that he did not actively engage in political, tactical, or other discussions while attending the meetings.
source: http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2003/10/04/16505501.php

Doesn't exactly amount to counter-intelligence or propaganda does it?

I've been involved with peace movements in the UK 1983 onwards. It used to be a running joke in CND that all the mail took twice as long to arrive, because it was being opened by the secret services. Personally, I have no problems with this, if you engage in political activism you have to expect the security services to take an interest.

ETA: Also, Kilner was a member of the local police force, not the FBI.
 
Last edited:
Gas chambers in German camps kept lice infestation under control. Cremation of bodies also was a way to keep diseases from spreading.

You need to visit Germany! This would get you a prison term.

Are you a pure NAZI nut case dolt. You spread NAZI lies and post like a fool. Yet you have proven you are a pure NAZI and lack any credible facts on any subject.
 
Last edited:
I know you desperately want to believe the guv is out to break up the twoofers. Sure beats admitting that your movement is a magnet for kooks and morons of all stripes.
Heh. At least Tom Cruise had the balls to come out and say there's "no such thing as a chemical imbalance". scooby seems to not even consider its possibility.

It's like the elephant in their room...
 
But Congress still took action.

Here's a quote from members of the group he infiltrated:

source: http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2003/10/04/16505501.php

Doesn't exactly amount to counter-intelligence or propaganda does it?

No it amounts to surveillance and confirms COINTELPRO is being used today. It also proves specifically that groups are being infiltrated. But in case anyone is unfamiliar with the story ...

Fresno peace group infiltrated by government agent
Mike Rhodes
Independant Media Center
October 4, 2003


Peace Fresno was infiltrated by an agent working for the Fresno Sheriff’s Department. Aaron Kilner, known by Peace Fresno activists as Aaron Stokes, attended several Peace Fresno meetings. Peace Fresno activist Nicholas DeGraff remembers him taking voluminous notes and several members say they saw him at peace vilgils held at Shaw and Blackstone.

http://www.notinourname.net/graphics/kilner.gif
"Voluminous note taker."

http://www.notinourname.net/restrictions/peace-fresno.htm

And once we know that COINTELPRO is being used then it is logical to conclude that it's complete arsenal of methods is available to it's operatives. We don't know what else is going on, but we have established that anything could be. And due to it's secretive nature, our only guide is it's history.

I've been involved with peace movements in the UK 1983 onwards. It used to be a running joke in CND that all the mail took twice as long to arrive, because it was being opened by the secret services. Personally, I have no problems with this, if you engage in political activism you have to expect the security services to take an interest.

ETA: Also, Kilner was a member of the local police force, not the FBI.

You ever heard of a guy called Fred Hampton?
He was pulled out of bed and shot in the back of the head, that was COINTELPRO.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/4/40/FredHamptonDead.jpg

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Hampton

Anything like that go down at Greenham Common?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Magz:

You send me to a "hollocaust is a Hoax" site as a solid reference...jhc.

The photos in the piece show me (1) an orchestra somewhere, playing for some people, and (2) what looks to be more like a water pool youd find in a garden, rather than a swimming pool.

Gonna have to do better.

TAM:)
 
No it amounts to surveillance and confirms COINTELPRO is being used today. It also proves specifically that groups are being infiltrated.

It shows that one group was infiltrated by one police department. No attempt was made by the inflitrator to disrupt meetings or suggest actions for the group. There is no evidence that anybody produced propaganda to discredot the group. Surveillance is not COINTELPRO.

You'll have to find a better example, this proves nothing.

I'm looking at your other example now.
 
No it amounts to surveillance and confirms COINTELPRO is being used today. It also proves specifically that groups are being infiltrated.
No, it doesn't. What it "proves" is that a local sheriff's department decided to send a guy to observe some meetings of an activist group. Unless such an organization is trying to stay secret, what would be the harm? It would be like being upset that an FBI agent is browsing the Loose Change forum.

Further, you keep using the term "COINTELPRO" to describe activities conducted after that specific program was defunct. It seems like your only reason for doing so is to lump even potentially legitimate surveillance with the activities of a defunct program that people considered wrong when its full scope was revealed. This would be like lumping all military activities into a group with the My Lai Massacre.
 
It shows that one group was infiltrated by one police department. No attempt was made by the inflitrator to disrupt meetings or suggest actions for the group. There is no evidence that anybody produced propaganda to discredot the group. Surveillance is not COINTELPRO.

You'll have to find a better example, this proves nothing.

I'm looking at your other example now.

Yeah you're rushing a bit and introducing the term 'agent provocateur', nobody is accusing Mr Kilner of being an agent provocateur.

But agent provocateurs are interesting, here's a good definition ...

An agent provocateur (plural: agents provocateurs, French language, "inciting agent") is a person who secretly disrupts a group's activities from within the group. Agents provocateurs typically represent the interests of another group, or are agents directly assigned to provoke unrest, violence, debate, or argument by or within a group while acting as a member of the group.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent_provocateur

Again, all we can safely conclude at this point, is that COINTELPRO is being used today, and therefore any of its methods might also be in use. I've become particularly interested lately in 'Factionalization' and the use of 'agent provocateurs'.
 
Last edited:
You ever heard of a guy called Fred Hampton?
He was pulled out of bed and shot in the back of the head, that was COINTELPRO.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/4/40/FredHamptonDead.jpg

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Hampton

Anything like that go down at Greenham Common?

This occurred in 1969, it does not prove that COINTELPRO is still happenening today.

In the immediate aftermath of 9/11 the ACLU recounted the history of COINTELPRO and issued this warning:

In light of the September 11th attacks, the lessons of these historical examples of inappropriate and unconstitutional domestic surveillance are all the more relevant. The current administration would do well to remember its predecessors' breaches of the public trust. We cannot let the FBI engage again in a COINTELPRO-like operation against law-abiding American citizens. We cannot let the CIA step outside its own charter and begin surveillance inside American borders as it has in the past. And, we cannot let the military again engage in domestic espionage
http://www.aclu.org/natsec/emergpowers/14360prs20011010.html

From this it is clear that the ACLU believed at the time that COINTELPRO activities ceased in the 70s and hadn't occurred since then. I can't see them making any accusations of COINTELPRO between that article (10 October 2001) and now. They obviously take the whole issue seriously, have the dropped the ball between then and now? Why isn't the ACLU making a fuss?
 
Last edited:
Yeah you're rushing a bit and introducing the term 'agent provocateur', nobody is accusing Mr Kilner of being an agent provocateur.

But agent provocateurs are interesting, here's a good definition ...

An agent provocateur (plural: agents provocateurs, French language, "inciting agent") is a person who secretly disrupts a group's activities from within the group. Agents provocateurs typically represent the interests of another group, or are agents directly assigned to provoke unrest, violence, debate, or argument by or within a group while acting as a member of the group.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent_provocateur

Again, all we can safely conclude at this point, is that COINTELPRO is being used today, and therefore any of its methods might also be in use. I've become particularly interested lately in 'Factionalization' and the use of 'agent provocateurs'.

Because you can point to a definition of the term, you think this proves that Agent provocateurs are being used?

Where's your evidence?
 
I'd be interested to see just who amongst the Truthers Scooby thinks are the CoIntelPro agents.

Come on Scoobs, name names...

Fetzer? A.Jones? S.Jones? Woods? Avery? Bermas? Griffin? Haupt? Jamieson? Ryan? Killtown? Doherty? Chit? MaGZ? D.J.Jordan? Jack Blood? RoxDog? Lyte Trip? Merc? Pickering? Conner? etc etc...

If some or all of these people are trying to split and discredit the Truth Movement for government paychecks, how would you be able to tell the difference from them just being kooks or conmen?

Is it just the ones with totally stupid theories, or the ones who appear to be at least partially rational?

With kooks like them, who needs spooks?
 
Scooby, you seem to have fallen into a logical trap that's one of the conspiracy theorist's most common mistakes: affirming the consequent.

You appear to be reasoning thus: the FBI's COINTELPRO program sought, with some success, to divide political movements they didn't like into squabbling factions that hated each others' guts. The 9/11 "Truth Movement" is divided into squabbling factions that hate each others' guts. Therefore a COINTELPRO-like program is operating against the "Truth Movement".

This amounts to reasoning: A implies B, B is true, therefore A is true. That inference can't be valid unless you also show that no C exists such that C also implies B and that B cannot have the value "true" independent of the value of A.

For example, I could reason: When it rains the sidewalk outside my building gets wet. The sidewalk outside my building is wet. Therefore it's raining. This is an invalid inference because a C exists which implies B irrespective of A: when the sprinkler system is operating the sidewalk outside my building gets wet; consequently I can't deduce that it is raining based on the fact that the sidewalk is wet.

There's a related form which is valid, denying the consequent, which amounts to A implies B, B is not true, therefore A is not true. For example, when it rains the sidewalk outside my building gets wet. The sidewalk outside my building is not wet. Therefore it isn't raining. That isn't the type of argument you're trying to make, though.

For the inference you're trying to draw to be valid, you have to show that COINTELPRO is a necessary cause of factionalization, i.e. that B can be true only if A is true, while the evidence we have only indicates that COINTELPRO is a sufficient cause of factionalization, i.e., that if A is true, B will be true. Given the tendency to schism and conflict over dogma we can see through the whole history of political and religious movements, I don't expect proving that first proposition to be easy, or even possible.

Of course, this doesn't prove that no COINTELPRO-like program is operating against the "Truth Movement". It does prove that your argument is nowhere near as convincing as you seem to believe; in fact it shows that it isn't convincing at all.
 


This occurred in 1969, it does not prove that COINTELPRO is still happenening today.

Wasn't meant to, was meant to demonstrate it's not nice.
Ba-Bam - back of the head - not nice.
You were fondly reminiscing about something unrelated?
 
Scooby, you seem to have fallen into a logical trap that's one of the conspiracy theorist's most common mistakes:.

Ah the ultimate logical fallacy - portraying an essentially political and civic issue as an exercise in logic. I believe I have yet again, successfully avoided that trap. Unlucky.
 
Scooby, who or what in the Truth movement is COINTELPRO in your opinion?

Do you have anything specific?
 
Ah the ultimate logical fallacy - portraying an essentially political and civic issue as an exercise in logic. I believe I have yet again, successfully avoided that trap. Unlucky.

Horse patooties. You're just looking for an excuse to substitute ideologically-based prejudice for sound reasoning. Your argument consists of invalid inferences and all the handwaving in the world can't change that.

OTOH, it's kind of nice to know that if the conclusion-jump is ever added as an Olympic event, we'll be able to field quite a strong team.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom