Has anyone ever heard of a thing called COINTELPRO?

I think the person screaming "Cointelpro" the loudest is likely the instigator of such activities in the first place...heh scoob?

TAM:)

Yes, but I bring the solution to any problem that I might create - as does Michael Wolsey. He may be shouting "fire!" but only in the same context as a fireman would, essentially combining it with such platitudes as " ... this way please, walk don't run ..."

Maybe you are unfamiliar with the content of the thread?
 
But I was appealing on behalf of all 11,000 of us.
There's only 20 or so jerks in here who are muddying the issue.
There are about eleven thousand members of this forum. If you believe you can start a thread and convince us all to refrain from posting in it, give it a try.
 
I rest my case.

As usual, you don't have much of a case to rest. I've looked through all 77 of your posts in this thread to see what you propose as a solution to the problem you perceive of COINTELPRO agents operating within the truth movement, and came up with the following quotes (sorry, but I don't have links to the posts, but you're welcome to check I've quoted you correctly). These eight sentences seem to be your only contributions to a solution (as opposed to evidence and argument):

No, again you miss it's simplicity - what you do is act under the assumption that anyone who is embarrassing, disruptive, argumentative, unpredictable, etc is just that - disruptive.

Who cares what their speciality is? It's reason enough - you don't need them. This is normal in any organisation, it puts its house in order. Of course this does not protect against future attempts to disrupt, but each can be dealt with once it is recognised.

Of course I’d say people should give it all a once over and make their own minds up, I think it’s an interesting facet to watch, the emerging coherent position is to just let them speak and discredit themselves whatever their motives. I think it’s working well. I’d certainly recommend keeping tabs on the situation as there is sure to be more controversy to come.

In other words, you should treat anyone who appears disruptive as COINTELPRO whether they are or not, you should put your house in order, but you should also just let the disruptive elements speak and let them discredit themselves. Is that right? If so, it's too vague to be termed a solution - "put your house in order" is hardly a detailed plan of action.

Even as far as your "solution" goes, the problem is this: who is the disruptive element in a two-way feud? If truther A and truther B disagree, and truther A claims truther B is a disinfo agent and should be expelled from a truther organisation, whereas truther B makes the same claim about truther A, who is the one who's really being disruptive? Who is the one who is toeing the party line, especially when there's no party line to toe? And who determines the party line, if there is to be one, given that just about every leading member of the truth movement has been accused of being a disinfo agent by another member of the truth movement?

Your "solution" is a recipe for the whole movement degenerating into a series of inward-looking witch-hunts, with the survivors being rigidly bound to an ever-narrowing orthodoxy that none dare question for fear of expulsion. In many ways, it's a replica in miniature of the totalitarian, hegemonistic society so many truthers seem to fear. It seems you can't even see the big picture when you're the one painting it.

Dave
 
Actually, I hope there really are all manner of spooks and spies who have "infiltrated" the various 9/11 conspiracy factions.

Hopefully I'm wrong, but I think it's just a matter of time before some of the more astonishingly deranged Truthers out there decide they really believe their own fantasies and do something Really Stupid, ala Tim McVeigh or Mir Aimal Kasi.

I'd prefer any such incident be stopped ahead of time, rather than simply mopped up afterward.
 
[snip]
In other words, you should treat anyone who appears disruptive as COINTELPRO whether they are or not, you should put your house in order, but you should also just let the disruptive elements speak and let them discredit themselves. Is that right? If so, it's too vague to be termed a solution - "put your house in order" is hardly a detailed plan of action.

Even as far as your "solution" goes, the problem is this: who is the disruptive element in a two-way feud? If truther A and truther B disagree, and truther A claims truther B is a disinfo agent and should be expelled from a truther organisation, whereas truther B makes the same claim about truther A, who is the one who's really being disruptive? Who is the one who is toeing the party line, especially when there's no party line to toe? And who determines the party line, if there is to be one, given that just about every leading member of the truth movement has been accused of being a disinfo agent by another member of the truth movement?

Your "solution" is a recipe for the whole movement degenerating into a series of inward-looking witch-hunts, with the survivors being rigidly bound to an ever-narrowing orthodoxy that none dare question for fear of expulsion. In many ways, it's a replica in miniature of the totalitarian, hegemonistic society so many truthers seem to fear. It seems you can't even see the big picture when you're the one painting it.

Dave

Great post.
 
Yeah I've been reading some stuff lately, about this CointelPro thing they had going back in the 60's. I'm not sure if this is the right forum, it's all true, but it is also a 'Conspiracy Theory' - one where they got caught...

Not sure what you mean by "it is also a Conspiracy Theory". No it's not - do you actually have an idea of what "theory" means?

There is no "theory". Government counter intelligence agencies ran a program - it's what they are supposed to be doing. Counter intelligence is supposed to work against (counter) the intelligence operations of enemies.

The elected officials are supposed to exercise oversight, sometimes they are lax and sometimes they are just plain dumb but sometimes they also get it right.

They didn't get "caught" you moron.

Oh well, I guess this is going to prove to be one more of those pointless discussions with some developmentally challenged "twoofer" trying to connect the dots - without a pencil and without any dots.
 
Not sure what you mean by "it is also a Conspiracy Theory". No it's not - do you actually have an idea of what "theory" means?

There is no "theory". Government counter intelligence agencies ran a program - it's what they are supposed to be doing. Counter intelligence is supposed to work against (counter) the intelligence operations of enemies.

The elected officials are supposed to exercise oversight, sometimes they are lax and sometimes they are just plain dumb but sometimes they also get it right.

They didn't get "caught" you moron.

Oh well, I guess this is going to prove to be one more of those pointless discussions with some developmentally challenged "twoofer" trying to connect the dots - without a pencil and without any dots.

Yawn.

The phrase 'conspiracy theory' can be applied to so broad a range of subjects, that the distinction is effectively meaningless.

Nevertheless, it has become convention of late for anyone who holds a dissenting viewpoint in conflict with the establishment view - as represented by mainstream media - to be called a 'conspiracy theorist'.

Yes CointelPro was a fact, and its use now at least in part is also a fact. That its tactics may be in use to disrupt the 911 Truth movement, is a theory, and a very reasonable one to discuss ... in light of the facts.

But save it Deus, wait till I've done this summary Dave's after and we can go to it then if you like.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom