Has anyone ever heard of a thing called COINTELPRO?

Wasn't meant to, was meant to demonstrate it's not nice.
Ba-Bam - back of the head - not nice.
You were fondly reminiscing about something unrelated?

No I wasn't reminiscing about somthing unrelated, I was pointing out that surveillance is not COINTELPRO and is to be expected if you're a political activist. I was bringing it up because your only example of post-1970s COINTELPRO is a policeman attending meetings undercover.

Also, that murder is not proven as part of COINTELPRO operation - so using it as an example doesn;t make sense. Or are you saying that there is a government plan to murder 9/11 activists now?

And I'll ask again, why aren't the ACLU making a fuss?

Also, what evidence is there for COINTELPRO within the 9/11 Truth Movement? What activities and publications are discrediting it?

As usual, you're big on attitude and short on evidence.
 
Ah the ultimate logical fallacy - portraying an essentially political and civic issue as an exercise in logic.

Do you believe we should abandon logical reasoning in these circumstance? Why?
 
Second Request

Instead of making up shadow enemies, how about you just present some of that "fine work?" Y'know, like an alternate theory that won't make me instantly bust out laughing?

I shouldn't have to tell you this.

Again, scooby, if you're claiming the "COINTELPRO" is obscuring legitimate arguments with fake ones, then please, help us all, and take this opportunity to restate the real ones.

Why won't you do this? Don't you realize this will thwart the "COINTELPRO" agents?

Scooby Doo, where are you??
 
The question is - could I pay you not to - name your price?

And that's why it's not a logical issue.

So you think that because you are speculating that I can be paid to abandon logic that logic should be abandoned.

How is that an argument?

If it's not a logical issue, how do we get to the bottom of it? Do we trust your gut instinct? Why?

If you went as far as to accuse specific individuals of COINTELPRO, how should those individuals be able to defend themselves against you accusations? What rights to they have? Are you serious denying the right of an idnividual to be innocent until proven guilty?
 
So you think that because you are speculating that I can be paid to abandon logic that logic should be abandoned.

How is that an argument?

If it's not a logical issue, how do we get to the bottom of it? Do we trust your gut instinct? Why?

If you went as far as to accuse specific individuals of COINTELPRO, how should those individuals be able to defend themselves against you accusations? What rights to they have? Are you serious denying the right of an idnividual to be innocent until proven guilty?

I'm not speculating, I know that for the right price I could have you crying over my posts like they were Anna Nicole's coffin. The same thing has happened with the official story. Plenty of vested interests weeping over that one, teary eyes firmly on the pot.
 
I'm not speculating, I know that for the right price I could have you crying over my posts like they were Anna Nicole's coffin.

I can honestly state that I have shed exactly the same number of tears over your posts as I did about the death of Anna Nicole Smith, and shall continue to do so. Scooby, the fake coy drip-feed "I'll actually say something in a few posts' time, or will I?" thing got very boring around your third post in this thread. Post some actual evidence of something, anything, please.

Dave
 
I can honestly state that I have shed exactly the same number of tears over your posts as I did about the death of Anna Nicole Smith, and shall continue to do so. Scooby, the fake coy drip-feed "I'll actually say something in a few posts' time, or will I?" thing got very boring around your third post in this thread. Post some actual evidence of something, anything, please.

Dave

Where've you been?

I've described the methods and purpose of COINTELPRO, and demonstrated it's current use to infiltrate peace groups. Here's another example ...

Outlawing dissent
28-May-04
Michelle Goldberg
Salon.com


The undercover cop introduced herself to the activists from the Colorado Coalition Against the War in Iraq as Chris Hoffman, but her real name was Chris Hurley. Last March, she arrived at a nonviolence training session in Denver, along with another undercover officer, Brad Wanchisen, whom she introduced as her boyfriend. The session, held at the Escuela Tlatelolco, a Denver private school, was organized to prepare activists for a sit-in at the Buckley Air National Guard Base the next day, March 15. Hurley said she wanted to participate. She said she was willing to get arrested for the cause of peace. In fact, she did get arrested. She was just never charged. The activists she protested with wouldn't find out why for months.

Chris Hurley was just one of many cops all over the country who went undercover to spy on antiwar protesters last year ...
http://www.adcaustin.org/index.cfm/mod/news/ID/17/SubMod/NewsView/NewsID/232.cfm
 
Where've you been?

I've described the methods and purpose of COINTELPRO, and demonstrated it's current use to infiltrate peace groups. Here's another example ...

You have done no such thing all you have given us is stuff like this:

Outlawing dissent
28-May-04
Michelle Goldberg
Salon.com


The undercover cop introduced herself to the activists from the Colorado Coalition Against the War in Iraq as Chris Hoffman, but her real name was Chris Hurley. Last March, she arrived at a nonviolence training session in Denver, along with another undercover officer, Brad Wanchisen, whom she introduced as her boyfriend. The session, held at the Escuela Tlatelolco, a Denver private school, was organized to prepare activists for a sit-in at the Buckley Air National Guard Base the next day, March 15. Hurley said she wanted to participate. She said she was willing to get arrested for the cause of peace. In fact, she did get arrested. She was just never charged. The activists she protested with wouldn't find out why for months.

Chris Hurley was just one of many cops all over the country who went undercover to spy on antiwar protesters last year ...
http://www.adcaustin.org/index.cfm/mod/news/ID/17/SubMod/NewsView/NewsID/232.cfm


Which is a story about undercover cops doing surveillance of protest groups. She wasn't spreading disinfo. She wasn't organising the protests or inciting violence. She wasn't trying to factionalise anyone. She was there to see if people were breaking the law.

It's a bit sneaky, I'll admit, but not the kind of thing I would describe as Cointelpro.
 
Scooby,

You're either trolling or you're too stupid to understand what COINTELPRO actually is.

Which is it?
 
Scooby,

You're either trolling or you're too stupid to understand what COINTELPRO actually is.

Which is it?

What's to understand ...

COINTELPRO (Counter Intelligence Program) was a program of the United States Federal Bureau of Investigation aimed at investigating and disrupting dissident political organizations within the United States. Although covert operations have been employed throughout FBI history, the formal COINTELPRO operations of 1956-1971 were broadly targeted against organizations that were (at the time) considered to have politically radical elements, ranging from those whose stated goal was the violent overthrow of the U.S. government (such as the Weathermen); non-violent civil rights groups such as Martin Luther King Jr.'s Southern Christian Leadership Conference; and violent groups like the Ku Klux Klan and the American Nazi Party. The founding document of COINTELPRO directed FBI agents to "expose, disrupt, misdirect, discredit, or otherwise neutralize" the activities of these movements and their leaders.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cointelpro

And it's 'was' - don't give the game away.

Some items on this last list are particularly interesting - to disrupt, to discredit.

You see strangely enough there's been some famous examples of disruption and discrediting going on lately in a couple of groups between various factions that have formed. It's very strange. It's made me skeptical. It's enough to make the impartial observer conclude that COINTELPRO is being used again.

This is where agent provocateurs come in, these are the people they use to disrupt and discredit a target organisation ...

"Agents provocateurs typically represent the interests of another group, or are agents directly assigned to provoke unrest, violence, debate, or argument by or within a group while acting as a member of the group.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent_provocateur

Directly assigned to provoke unrest, violence, debate or argument.
So that's how it's done.
 
This is where agent provocateurs come in, these are the people they use to disrupt and discredit a target organisation ...

Directly assigned to provoke unrest, violence, debate or argument.
So that's how it's done.
(boldface added)

And here you are, in the forums of an organization with the avowed political agenda of promoting critical thinking and skepticism, attempting (successfully) to provoke debate and argument.

Are you a COINTELPRO agent provocateur?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, c'mon, call yourself a critical thinker? For the love of Sagan!
This, and you didn't realise we're at war - do yourself a favour - don't hold your breath till you've followed what I post, ok?
Babbylonian did not say, "There is no evidence of it happening, therefore it's not happening. Babbylonian did, indirectly, ask you to provide evidence supporting your claim that it is happening.
 
(boldface added)

And here you are, in the forums of an organization with the avowed political agenda of promoting critical thinking and skepticism, attempting (successfully) to provoke debate and argument.

Are you a COINTELPRO agent provocateur?

Respectfully,
Myriad

I see no consensus here.
Whats to disrupt?
 
Ah the ultimate logical fallacy - portraying an essentially political and civic issue as an exercise in logic. I believe I have yet again, successfully avoided that trap. Unlucky.
We are not discussing possible outcomes of policy changes. We are discussing your claims about what has, and is, happening. Your claims must be factually accurate, and logically sound in order for them to be convincing. Logical fallacies in your presentation undermine the latter.
 
I'm not speculating, I know that for the right price I could have you crying over my posts like they were Anna Nicole's coffin. The same thing has happened with the official story. Plenty of vested interests weeping over that one, teary eyes firmly on the pot.
Stop applying your, apparently very limited, morals to other people.
 
Scooby,

You're either trolling or you're too stupid to understand what COINTELPRO actually is.

Which is it?
There does appear to be great confusion on scooby's part as to the difference between undercover work and COINTELPRO.
 
What's to understand ...

COINTELPRO (Counter Intelligence Program) was a program of the United States Federal Bureau of Investigation aimed at investigating and disrupting dissident political organizations within the United States. Although covert operations have been employed throughout FBI history, the formal COINTELPRO operations of 1956-1971 were broadly targeted against organizations that were (at the time) considered to have politically radical elements, ranging from those whose stated goal was the violent overthrow of the U.S. government (such as the Weathermen); non-violent civil rights groups such as Martin Luther King Jr.'s Southern Christian Leadership Conference; and violent groups like the Ku Klux Klan and the American Nazi Party. The founding document of COINTELPRO directed FBI agents to "expose, disrupt, misdirect, discredit, or otherwise neutralize" the activities of these movements and their leaders.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cointelpro

And it's 'was' - don't give the game away.
Oops! Maccy, you slipped. Gravy should dock your pay for that.

Some items on this last list are particularly interesting - to disrupt, to discredit.

You see strangely enough there's been some famous examples of disruption and discrediting going on lately in a couple of groups between various factions that have formed. It's very strange. It's made me skeptical. It's enough to make the impartial observer conclude that COINTELPRO is being used again.

This is where agent provocateurs come in, these are the people they use to disrupt and discredit a target organisation ...

"Agents provocateurs typically represent the interests of another group, or are agents directly assigned to provoke unrest, violence, debate, or argument by or within a group while acting as a member of the group.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent_provocateur

Directly assigned to provoke unrest, violence, debate or argument.
So that's how it's done.
Except none of the examples you've given as evidence that COINTELPRO is an active program fit the description you've given of what COINTELPRO is. COINTELPRO relies on infiltration and surveillance, but infiltration and surveillance are not COINTELPRO.

To repeat what has been asked by others: How do you distinguish between an agent provocateur and a run-of-the-mill nutjob?
 
Scooby, who or what in the Truth movement is COINTELPRO in your opinion?

Do you have anything specific?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom