Has anyone ever heard of a thing called COINTELPRO?

I tried to read it for school, I really did, but the attraction of reading about another religion of the absurd when I was already trying to make sense of Catholicism was too much. Joseph Heller was much better, Catch 22 made perfect sense.

If you didn't read it for that reason, I urge you to read it. The end may interest you.

Or at least rent the movie, if you don't want to commit that much time to it.
 
This may surprise you Kiwi...the ‘Holocaust’ really doesn’t interest me. I have read one book on the subject, and it answered all the questions I had.
The Hoax of the Twentieth Century
http://www.vho.org/GB/Books/thottc/
Thanks for reminding us how a true believer functions.

Read only books that confirm your bias, close your mind to anything that contradicts it.

You do it for the holocaust, you do it for your "missile at ground zero". Never mind that the pilot contradicts you, that there is no evidence for the missile, that the damage in WTC 7 and on the parking doesn't fit with damage done by a missile, that we have video-evidence that the parking was undamaged after the second plane hit: you've read an article on some website, and that's it for you, case closed.

What you don't seem to get is that this only works for you.
After you started to post on your "missile at ground zero"-theory, it didn't take long for posters here to rip it to shreds. The one source you used fails to withstand even the slightest scrutiny.

The same would happen if you started to discuss the holocaust. Butz' book would also fail to withstand even the slightest intellectual scrutiny.
Most people know it, because they read more than one book on the subject. You never will. Your loss.
 
You sure it isn't a case of the Truth Movement discrediting itself?

No it's a case of them playing a documentary about COINTELPRO that you can listen to. It's a very interesting one, many interviews with former FBI informants and agent provocateurs - all straight from the horses mouth.
 
I am frankly surprised and a bit amused you actually believe the soap bar story in regard to the ‘Holocaust’.

Is there anything about the tales told about the ‘Holocaust’ that you don’t believe?

Perhaps you have your doubts about Jews being made into lampshades?


Magz, does this mean you do not believe that the Nazis gassed millions of Jews ?

If that is the case, I find that perspective somewhat worrying.
 
Of course!

An entire peoples were being systematically butchered for no reason other than hatred. It is only natural that certain urban legends would arise.

The only sort of person who would think an error of minor detail (such as human skin lampshades or specific dimensions of a gas chamber) thus disproves the entire event would be...well...frankly they'd be a neo-nazi.

-Gumboot
Thanks for the correction. I was certain that was fact, but what you say makes sense.
Now, about the rest of your claims, MaGZ...
Get a clue!
 
I just thought I'd point out that some of the more extreme Holocaust stories - such as using human skin to make lampshades and soap made from humans, were nothing more than products of urban legend circulating amongst the prisoners.

At the Nuremberg War Crimes Trials pieces of evidence presented were tested, and it was found they were not made from human beings.

-Gumboot

Michael Shermer, in his book "Why people believe weird things" have a chapter (no. 14) dedicated to "How we know that holocaust happend". I recommend it , especially because its an exellent guide to how we (and historians) know about, and research, historical events.

Shermer also emphasises how important it is to know about "urban legends" like the human soap story, because if you are debating a Holocaust-denier, they will use stories like this to and/or:
- so you didn't know the soap story was phony. Seems that you don't know much about Hololcaust at all mr. expert! Ha! Got you there!
- claim (trough some mysterious logic) that since the soap story was false, every other story about Holocaust is also false.
 
No it's a case of them playing a documentary about COINTELPRO that you can listen to. It's a very interesting one, many interviews with former FBI informants and agent provocateurs - all straight from the horses mouth.

I was actually referring to your insistance that the "Truth Movement" was subject to these kinds of operations.

Like I said the vid doesn't work on my computer, so can I ask you if any of the experts in the video say that COINTELPRO is being used against Truthers?

You seem to think that the Truth Movement is some kind of big important radical network which threatens the US Government (or at least you think that's what the FBI thinks), when it is in fact just a handful of paranoid kooks and arrogant teens trying to pretend that they are clever.

Like I said before the "Truth Movement" is about as much of a threat to the Government as The Kiss Army (maybe less).
 
I was actually referring to your insistance that the "Truth Movement" was subject to these kinds of operations.

Like I said the vid doesn't work on my computer, so can I ask you if any of the experts in the video say that COINTELPRO is being used against Truthers?

You seem to think that the Truth Movement is some kind of big important radical network which threatens the US Government (or at least you think that's what the FBI thinks), when it is in fact just a handful of paranoid kooks and arrogant teens trying to pretend that they are clever.

Like I said before the "Truth Movement" is about as much of a threat to the Government as The Kiss Army (maybe less).

See you're jumping ahead a little - there seems to be plenty of Holocaust chat going on, which is only to be expected - maybe you could participate in that while you're waiting?
 
No, Hitler had immense disdain for much of the white race, and was perfectly happy to kill them or see them die. What actually interested him most was destruction...he was fascinated and obsessed by it, to the point of ordering Speer to ensure that the buildings planned for postwar Berlin did not have steel or concrete, so that their ruins in a thousand years would look more impressive. Hitler drew sketches of the Third Reich's buildings in ruins, centuries later.

He cared little for his own people, as further evidenced by his draconian orders late in the war.

And Nazism was very anti-religion. It sought to replace all forms of Christianity with an Odinistic religion. Himmler put that into practice to some degree.

You need to read other things than "Stormfront" and "National Vanguard."

Was this from one of Speer’s books that he wrote after serving 20 years in prison?

If so, then there is no reason to believe anything Speer has written. Speer has always been a self-serving opportunist. He joined the NSDAP only after the party came to power.

As to Odinism, I think this was largely a post-war phenomenon and did not have anything to do with Hitler. However, in time, the plan was to wean the German people away from Christianity and create a new race-based Germanic religion. You know, something ethnio-centric and racist like Judaism.
 
Ah, that's right, I forgot they were actually day spas, set up for their enjoyment!
Silly me!
That's sarcasm, figured I have to tell you, since you're dain bramaged!

Well not quite day spays, but the Nazi concentration camps did have swimming pools and orchestras for the prisoners recreation and enjoyment. This is actually true.
 
Well not quite day spays, but the Nazi concentration camps did have swimming pools and orchestras for the prisoners recreation and enjoyment. This is actually true.

Reference please, as I would be most interested in reading about swimming pools and orchestras placed there for the PRISONERS enjoyment.

Thanks

TAM:)
 
You seem to get everything wrong to a degree that is bordering on hate speech. If you would avoid NeoNAZI web sites you may have a better chance of finding some facts. This is the dumbest post I have seen on WWII. It not worth even talking about it.

You just keep bringing up NAZI propaganda.


Here is a link to the history of American run concentration camps. Some of these were American citizens. Many were German and Italian families kidnaped by the American government in South America and taken to a concentration camp in Crystal City, Texas.
This is secret history you are not suppose to know about.

http://www.foitimes.com/
 
I just thought I'd point out that some of the more extreme Holocaust stories - such as using human skin to make lampshades and soap made from humans, were nothing more than products of urban legend circulating amongst the prisoners.

At the Nuremberg War Crimes Trials pieces of evidence presented were tested, and it was found they were not made from human beings.

-Gumboot

Sadly Gumboot, there are still those who will believe anything and everything negative about Hitler and the Third Reich. These type of people fail in the critical thinking department. I can think of only two historians I trust to read concerning this era: John Toland and David Irving.
 
Both John Toland and David Irving are revisionist historians who are heavily discredited. The holocaust happened, they gassed defenceless people.

Holocaust revisionists and holocaust deniers are effectively accomplices to mass murder.

Sadly there are people who will believe that the nazis weren't that bad. Well they were. There are men who helped liberate Belsen who still have nightmares about what they saw.
 
Once again, this conversation is making my stomach turn....Seeya
 
Thanks for reminding us how a true believer functions.

Read only books that confirm your bias, close your mind to anything that contradicts it.

You do it for the holocaust, you do it for your "missile at ground zero". Never mind that the pilot contradicts you, that there is no evidence for the missile, that the damage in WTC 7 and on the parking doesn't fit with damage done by a missile, that we have video-evidence that the parking was undamaged after the second plane hit: you've read an article on some website, and that's it for you, case closed.

What you don't seem to get is that this only works for you.
After you started to post on your "missile at ground zero"-theory, it didn't take long for posters here to rip it to shreds. The one source you used fails to withstand even the slightest scrutiny.

The same would happen if you started to discuss the holocaust. Butz' book would also fail to withstand even the slightest intellectual scrutiny.
Most people know it, because they read more than one book on the subject. You never will. Your loss.

Arthur Butz’ book is the final answer to the question of the ‘Holocaust.’ I challenge everyone with an open mind to read it.
 
Arthur Butz’ book is the final answer to the question of the ‘Holocaust.’ I challenge everyone with an open mind to read it.
I have read parts of it. It's BS.

No real historian takes your holocaust-denial BS seriously.
Almost no one here cares for hate-speach. Get over it.
 
Magz, does this mean you do not believe that the Nazis gassed millions of Jews ?

If that is the case, I find that perspective somewhat worrying.

From what I understand on the subject, the Final Solution to the Jewish problem was the removal of the Jews from Europe and after the war, their resettlement east of Europe. Gas chambers were to control lice infestation.
Jews died from disease and starvation in the camps. Butz estimates their total losses, if I remember correctly, a few hundred thousand.
 
Michael Shermer, in his book "Why people believe weird things" have a chapter (no. 14) dedicated to "How we know that holocaust happend". I recommend it , especially because its an exellent guide to how we (and historians) know about, and research, historical events.

Shermer also emphasises how important it is to know about "urban legends" like the human soap story, because if you are debating a Holocaust-denier, they will use stories like this to and/or:
- so you didn't know the soap story was phony. Seems that you don't know much about Hololcaust at all mr. expert! Ha! Got you there!
- claim (trough some mysterious logic) that since the soap story was false, every other story about Holocaust is also false.

Could you give us a summation on that chapter, "How we know the holocaust happened?" I would like to know.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom