Gold will go $1,500/oz

...and gold is starting to drop.

Starting to drop? You mean headed lower (prophecy fulfilled)?

Or just pausing in a temporary pullback before shooting to new heights?

Or seeking equilibrium at a new level?

Or?

Or?

The cool thing about free markets and random walks is that anyone can project any meaning on any movement - always after the fact, of course!
 
That means you bought silver some time between 1991 and 2003. Which year was it? Yet your post is in 2008 so there's no way to really verify it. It seems all your posts containing financial advice are always about half a decade late.

Is there a reason for this?

I've bought a lot of silver, gold, platinum, stocks, bonds, and even limited partnerships, over a long period of time, over a lot of transactions. My post in 2008 is relevant how? I wouldn't condescend to give you internet advice. Are you suggesting that I don't in fact own any silver? Uh oh! A random idiot on the internet is casting aspersions on my credibility. I guess I'd better provide the receipts from my bullion dealer, to "verify". Or not.
 
Starting to drop? You mean headed lower (prophecy fulfilled)?

Or just pausing in a temporary pullback before shooting to new heights?

Or seeking equilibrium at a new level?

Or?

Or?

The cool thing about free markets and random walks is that anyone can project any meaning on any movement - always after the fact, of course!

Nobody can predict, that's for sure. I've seen pundits say this is a temporary pullback. I'm inclined to believe it's going to stall and possibly drop if the economy keeps chugging. Then again I wouldn't be shocked if it kept rising either. ;)
 
I've bought a lot of silver, gold, platinum, stocks, bonds, and even limited partnerships, over a long period of time, over a lot of transactions. My post in 2008 is relevant how? I wouldn't condescend to give you internet advice. Are you suggesting that I don't in fact own any silver? Uh oh! A random idiot on the internet is casting aspersions on my credibility. I guess I'd better provide the receipts from my bullion dealer, to "verify". Or not.

Did you buy your silver in 1991 or 2003? Or some time in between? Did the $4 price include the transaction fees? Is it in metallic form or silver certificates?

Most importantly: Why are your precise numbers at least five years late while your current-year ball-gazing is so vague? For example, what is "huge manipulation"? I can sort of envision what that might be but it doesn't sound like proper dinner table conversation.
 
Did you buy your silver in 1991 or 2003? Or some time in between? Did the $4 price include the transaction fees? Is it in metallic form or silver certificates?

None of your business.

Most importantly: Why are your precise numbers at least five years late while your current-year ball-gazing is so vague? For example, what is "huge manipulation"? I can sort of envision what that might be but it doesn't sound like proper dinner table conversation.

You're not making any sense. Nothing about what I posted regarding my silver and gold holdings, or what I think is going to happen to the economy in the future is inconsistent in the least. Is accusing me of lying the best you can do? I guess that's par for the course for liars.

Given what I think about the Fed, and the US economy, it's not really a stretch that I would put my money where my mouth is.
 
stilicho,

Just one man's opinion, but I think you're being rather insulting towards Tippit.

We're an online community, and I think its best if we respect each other, and assume we're being truthful until given reason to believe otherwise.

I believe he has a basis of about $4 in silver. Its not that bizarre a claim. Do you have reason to believe otherwise?

Anecdote:

In 1964 I was about 15. The gov't had announced that dimes, quarters, halves and silver dollars would no longer contain .90 silver going forward. Prior to that (in my lifetime, remember) it was assumed that these coins had intrinsic value - the silver in them. In 1964, some people were going into banks and getting rolls of silver dollars for $20 to stash away (or other denominations for lesser amounts).

PeaceDollarRoll.jpg


My father thought they were insane.

Fast forward to today and those still alive have a "thirty-bagger" (in Peter Lynch's terminology). Each $20 roll of silver dollars is now worth about $600. Of course one could point to other investments that would have beaten that, but one can also point to investments that wouldn't have, or even have gone to zero - all in retrospect, of course.

If you're curious, I know my silver basis to the penny, transaction costs included*. it's well north of $4, but that's inconsequential. I'm not betting on silver increasing in price. I just have some of my worth in metals to maintain value. That's all.


*Its important to keep track. When you sell, its considered a capital gain (or loss). If a gain, taxes are owed and records may be requested if audited.
 
Last edited:
Starting to drop? You mean headed lower (prophecy fulfilled)?

Or just pausing in a temporary pullback before shooting to new heights?

Or seeking equilibrium at a new level?

Or?

Or?

The cool thing about free markets and random walks is that anyone can project any meaning on any movement - always after the fact, of course!
I think it's starting to drop. I predict this is the year that it will finish the year cheaper than it started.
 
Just one man's opinion, but I think you're being rather insulting towards Tippit.

We're an online community, and I think its best if we respect each other, and assume we're being truthful until given reason to believe otherwise.

I believe he has a basis of about $4 in silver. Its not that bizarre a claim. Do you have reason to believe otherwise?

Thanks. I'm not sure he understands what an average basis is. Mine has gone up since 2008 as I've bought more silver at higher prices.

Anecdote:

In 1964 I was about 15. The gov't had announced that dimes, quarters, halves and silver dollars would no longer contain .90 silver going forward. Prior to that (in my lifetime, remember) it was assumed that these coins had intrinsic value - the silver in them. In 1964, some people were going into banks and getting rolls of silver dollars for $20 to stash away (or other denominations for lesser amounts).

[qimg]http://www.amergold.com/vault/images/PeaceDollarRoll.jpg[/qimg]

My father thought they were insane.

Fast forward to today and those still alive have a "thirty-bagger" (in Peter Lynch's terminology). Each $20 roll of silver dollars is now worth about $600. Of course one could point to other investments that would have beaten that, but one can also point to investments that wouldn't have, or even have gone to zero - all in retrospect, of course.

If you're curious, I know my silver basis to the penny, transaction costs included*. it's well north of $4, but that's inconsequential. I'm not betting on silver increasing in price. I just have some of my worth in metals to maintain value. That's all.


*Its important to keep track. When you sell, its considered a capital gain (or loss). If a gain, taxes are owed and records may be requested if audited.

Junk silver is one of the most cost effective ways to own physical silver. I'm pretty sure I paid nearly a 50% premium over spot for my silver maples and kookaburras, but they certainly are pretty.
 
Junk silver is one of the most cost effective ways to own physical silver.

Yep. And I own a couple bags. (Google image)

junk-silver-coin-bag-pic.jpg


Kinda bulky but as you said, very little markup and in the doomsday scenario we all hope never happens, silver coins will be easier to buy small things with than gold coins.
 
stilicho,

Just one man's opinion, but I think you're being rather insulting towards Tippit.

We're an online community, and I think its best if we respect each other, and assume we're being truthful until given reason to believe otherwise.

I believe he has a basis of about $4 in silver. Its not that bizarre a claim. Do you have reason to believe otherwise?

I asked when he bought, in 1991, 2003, or at some point in between. His return so far has been exactly 0.0% by my calculation since he's still urging people to consider buying more, at more than seven times the price he said he paid for it. You don't realise a gain (or loss, for that matter) if you buy, hold, and never sell.

The claims for platinum investment are even harder to imagine as realistic. Platinum tends to sputter around worse than most metals and has in the past ten years looked awfully sensitive to the fluctuations in the USD. I think that's because most of the production is outside the US. I can't imagine anyone's seriously been investing in platinum as a hedge against anything.

My point is that Tippit is exactly wrong about metals investing. You're supposed to sell your investment when you can realise your 1,400% annual profit (or whatever his claim is this week). Unless he's suggesting that $200 an oz is a reasonable projection for silver in 2020, I can't understand why he'd be promoting it now or holding on to the substantial reserves he's been collecting.
 
My point is that Tippit is exactly wrong about metals investing. You're supposed to sell your investment when you can realise your 1,400% annual profit (or whatever his claim is this week)...I can't understand why he'd be promoting it now or holding on to the substantial reserves he's been collecting.

This has been covered so completely and repeatedly in this thread, its hard to know whether you're being purposely obtuse or if there really is some fundamental difference in the way people are able to view this topic. Perhaps you literally "can't understand".

There's a class of investor who has as their goal to diversify across many asset classes. One may decide, somewhat arbitrarily, that they'd like 10% of their portfolio in precious metals.

To use a concrete example, imagine someone who over a lifetime has amassed assets of $5m. Following the above guideline, they'd aim for about $500k in precious metals. Gold could go up 100% or 1,400% or a gazillion percent and they still wouldn't sell - they know better than to try to time markets. If the value of the gold begins to exceed 10% of their portfolio, some adjustments might be in order, which might or might not involve selling off some gold. Still, if they play their cards right, they may pass peacefully in their sleep one day with all that metal still in place - and passed on to their heirs.

So, one more time, some buy gold not as a short or long term speculative investment, but as insurance. That being the case, its irrational to say that they "should" sell at any given profit level.
 
Last edited:
There's a class of investor who has as their goal to diversify across many asset classes. One may decide, somewhat arbitrarily, that they'd like 10% of their portfolio in precious metals.

Perhaps there is, but as you've described them, the class is known as "idiots."

Or maybe "suckers."

And I'm (ahem) not entirely convinced that we should be encouraging people to model their investment behavior off of idiots who have never heard of rebalancing.

To use a concrete example, imagine someone who over a lifetime has amassed assets of $5m. Following the above guideline, they'd aim for about $500k in precious metals. Gold could go up 100% or 1,400% or a gazillion percent and they still wouldn't sell - they know better than to try to time markets. If the value of the gold begins to exceed 10% of their portfolio, some adjustments might be in order, which might or might not involve selling off some gold.

So, um, gold is supposed to go up 1400%, but not enough to raise their investment in gold above 10% of their portfolio. Interesting. I guess I want to know what the rest of their portfolio is supposed to be.

The whole point of diversification is to create offsetting profits against "expected" losses due to random fluctuations. I.e. if gold is doing well and stocks are doing badly, you sell gold (high) and buy stocks (low). Especially with a non income-producing investment like gold, the idea of buying it and not rebalancing periodically is daylight madness, as it essentially defeats the purpose.

But there's a further reason that buying gold is irrational. As you point out, the 10% diversification requirement you set above is "somewhat arbitrary." It's not just arbitrary, but it's stupid. If you look at the long-term profitability of gold, or even its long-term performance as an inflation hedge, gold is a worse commodity to invest in than, say, Twinkies or classic cars.

The people who actually do investment planning for a living have elaborate spreadsheets and calculations about how much you should put into each class of assets for a given risk/reward profile in order to maximize your expected return. And these calculations can be optimized -- there's an actual correct number, based on history.

The "correct" amount of gold to have in order to maximize risk/return appears, empirically, to be zero. Every percentage point of your portfolio you put into gold both increases your risk and decreases your reward, when measured against the optimal portfolio (which of course, historically, is heavily weighted towards equity stocks if you want reward, and heavily weighted towards cash investments and Treasuries if you want low risk).
 
Last edited:
drkitten,

Your post is so wrong, so many times and on so many levels I'm not going to attempt to respond.

Each and every point has been countered repeatedly in this thread.

Good luck - I think your investment choices are rational ones, but not the only rational ones.
 
drkitten,

Your post is so wrong, so many times and on so many levels I'm not going to attempt to respond.

That's good, because you can't actually respond rationally.

Each and every point has been countered repeatedly in this thread.

Repeatedly, yes. You and Tippit are great are typing repetitive gibberish.

None of my points, however, have been countered correctly. You can type "rabbits are a type of fish" as many times as you like, but that won't grant you credentials as a biologist.
 
To everyone except drkitten,

I think that a case has been made here that holding gold can be a rational decision.

I will not restate the arguments already presented in the prior posts, now approaching 500. To do so would be pointless, as some minds here really seem to be made up.

The opposing view is that only idiots own gold. If the arguments supporting that view seem more persuasive, then so be it.

I'll continue to monitor this thread in case something new comes up - until then, have fun!
 
The whole point of diversification is to create offsetting profits against "expected" losses due to random fluctuations. I.e. if gold is doing well and stocks are doing badly, you sell gold (high) and buy stocks (low). Especially with a non income-producing investment like gold, the idea of buying it and not rebalancing periodically is daylight madness, as it essentially defeats the purpose.

Exactly.

I don't blame people for wanting to use metals as an idiot asset class. The company I work for indeed has a metals inventory item because we buy gold and have it processed.

But, if you bought your metals at $4 (see cite above) and it's now $28 then you need to sell it or you really haven't done anything at all in terms of investing. Personal finance investment decisions have to include cashing in the winners.

Fast Eddie is working under the strange illusion that property becomes valuable only when passed on to heirs. Yet, just as Grandpa's house is liquidated and the cash used by the heirs, so will be his bags of junk silver. Unless the heirs are mendicants earning their living performing banjo solos on the city streets, they already have a place to live and would rather use the junk silver to buy something useful instead.

A much better investment, and one the heirs might actually treasure rather than sell especially if they have also acquired the genetic maladies handed on by Fast Eddie and Tippit, would be shotgun shells and lots of them. I would recommend hoarding them in the millions and cowering in the bomb shelter until the apocalypse arrives.
 
.. and gold is starting to drop. Plenty of people starting to take short positions now. If the economy keeps picking up speed I'm not sure gold is going to hit $1500.

Has gold been so out of sync with the broad market in the past 5 years?
 
Fast Eddie is working under the strange illusion that property becomes valuable only when passed on to heirs. Yet, just as Grandpa's house is liquidated and the cash used by the heirs, so will be his bags of junk silver. Unless the heirs are mendicants earning their living performing banjo solos on the city streets, they already have a place to live and would rather use the junk silver to buy something useful instead.

He also seems to be under the impression that only property is valuable when passed to heirs. The idea that Grandpa could leave five thousand shares of Google to his heirs seems foreign.

The simple fact is that he can leave whatever he possesses; if I have $600 that I want to leave to my heirs, I can buy twenty or so ounces of silver, or I can buy a share of GOOG. Or, for that matter, I can buy thirty shares of INTC. If I have $1800, I can do all three.

History suggests that, by the time I actually die, my shares of Intel and Google will be worth a hell of a lot more than the silver. So I'd -- and my heirs -- would be better off if I bought a share of Google and sixty shares of Intel instead.

My heirs will thank me that I didn't waste money on precious metals and instead invested in something with better risk/reward characteristics.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom