Gold will go $1,500/oz

Has gold been so out of sync with the broad market in the past 5 years?

Well, in the past five years, gold has gone from about $400 to about $1400.

In that same time, the S&P 500 stock market index has gone from a little below 1300 to.... a little below 1300. So I'd say, "yes, it has been so out of sync."
 
History suggests that, by the time I actually die, my shares of Intel and Google will be worth a hell of a lot more than the silver.

Maybe. Picking winners is trivially easy - after the fact.

How about Enron? Pets.com? Circuit City? Pan Am? Blockbuster? GM?

I am a huge supporter of common stocks. My winners far exceed my losers.

BTW, Intel is a stock I owned for quite some time and sold for about what I paid for it. I'm in Google (just 50 shares) at about 105. My biggest current gainers are Apple and Netflix (both with bases under 10).

But its not either/or - I think that's called a false dichotomy. The vast majority of my holdings are in common stocks and mutual funds.

But I also own some gold and silver- idiot that I am! ;)
 
Last edited:
Maybe. Picking winners is trivially easy - after the fact.

So Grandpa can buy an S&P 500 index fund, and still do better than he would buying gold.


But its not either/or - I think that's called a false dichotomy. The vast majority of my holdings are in common stocks and mutual funds.

No, it's not an either/or. It's an optimization problem. Given the historical record, what percentage of your investment portfolio should you put into precious metals to maximize return while minimizing risk. (Obviously, this needs to be formalized somewhat -- the usual formulation is " ... with no greater risk than X," with X being a choice of the investor/client.

When you do the math, the percentage is 0.0%. The Pareto-superior percentage is 0.0%.

Irrespective of the value of X. The percentage of the optimal portfolio is 0% in precious metals.

Now, you can "arbitrarily" decide to put a certain percentage of your portfolio into precious metals. In fact, that's the only way you can do it, because you can't do it for a reason that can be justified in terms of risk/reward. You can also "arbitrarily" decide to put a certain amount of your portfolio into rare baseball cards and then light them on fire.

The effects on your return in both cases will be the same; you will reduce your returns and increase your risk.
 
Perhaps there is, but as you've described them, the class is known as "idiots."

Or maybe "suckers."

And I'm (ahem) not entirely convinced that we should be encouraging people to model their investment behavior off of idiots who have never heard of rebalancing.



So, um, gold is supposed to go up 1400%, but not enough to raise their investment in gold above 10% of their portfolio. Interesting. I guess I want to know what the rest of their portfolio is supposed to be.

The whole point of diversification is to create offsetting profits against "expected" losses due to random fluctuations. I.e. if gold is doing well and stocks are doing badly, you sell gold (high) and buy stocks (low). Especially with a non income-producing investment like gold, the idea of buying it and not rebalancing periodically is daylight madness, as it essentially defeats the purpose.

But there's a further reason that buying gold is irrational. As you point out, the 10% diversification requirement you set above is "somewhat arbitrary." It's not just arbitrary, but it's stupid. If you look at the long-term profitability of gold, or even its long-term performance as an inflation hedge, gold is a worse commodity to invest in than, say, Twinkies or classic cars.

The people who actually do investment planning for a living have elaborate spreadsheets and calculations about how much you should put into each class of assets for a given risk/reward profile in order to maximize your expected return. And these calculations can be optimized -- there's an actual correct number, based on history.

The "correct" amount of gold to have in order to maximize risk/return appears, empirically, to be zero. Every percentage point of your portfolio you put into gold both increases your risk and decreases your reward, when measured against the optimal portfolio (which of course, historically, is heavily weighted towards equity stocks if you want reward, and heavily weighted towards cash investments and Treasuries if you want low risk).

this is all a long winded attempt to rationalize timing the market, which is a fail strategy.

Buy low, sell high. Wow... genius. Why didn't I think of that?

But, if you bought your metals at $4 (see cite above) and it's now $28 then you need to sell it or you really haven't done anything at all in terms of investing. Personal finance investment decisions have to include cashing in the winners.

Assuming you know when the top is, which you don't. I oft think about times I sold when I should have held, and held when I should have sold. Both sting in the same way really.

would be shotgun shells and lots of them. I would recommend hoarding them in the millions and cowering in the bomb shelter until the apocalypse arrives.

yooo sooo funny, funny man.
 
Last edited:
So Grandpa can buy an S&P 500 index fund, and still do better than he would buying gold...The percentage of the optimal portfolio is 0% in precious metals.

I'll keep my responses/inquiries brief.

From the above, given a finite time frame (for the sake of argument, let's say 20 years), are you saying there is a 0% chance that gold holdings would have outperformed the S&P?

I ask, because you invoke "history", and there are many historical periods where gold outperforms the S&P.

As long as there's a finite risk of financial meltdown (and I'll invoke history on that one), a case and me made for holding more that 0% precious metals.

And I've made it already, to those paying attention.
 
this is all a long winded attempt to rationalize timing the market, which is a fail strategy.

Buy low, sell high. Wow... genius. Why didn't I think of that?

Removed breach.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL


Assuming you know when the top is, which you don't.
Who said anything about "when the top is" except you? The point of diversification and rebalancing is that you will automatically buy low and sell high without worrying about "the top," because you automatically sell in proportion to the "height" of any individual investment. It's essentially the back end of a dollar-cost averaging investment strategy, one where you automatically buy more when things are cheap because you put a fixed number of dollars in at each point.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
From the above, given a finite time frame (for the sake of argument, let's say 20 years), are you saying there is a 0% chance that gold holdings would have outperformed the S&P?

No. Nor am I saying that there's a 0% chance that lottery tickets would have outperformed the S&P. But the chance that lottery tickets or gold would have outperformed the S&P are so dominated by the likelihood that they would have underperformed, and by so great a margin, that the optimum investment in both lottery tickets and gold is zero.

As long as there's a finite risk of financial meltdown (and I'll invoke history on that one), a case and me made for holding more that 0% precious metals.

"As long as there's a finite chance of a billion percent return in the state lottery (and I'll invoke history on that one), a case [can be] made for holding more [than] 0% lottery tickets."

The case is exactly the same. And equally flawed.
 
This is not directed to drkitten, who seems intransigent on the matter, but for anyone else who might be following this thread.

that the optimum investment in both lottery tickets and gold is zero.

He's equating gold with lottery tickets.

Here's what gold has done, looking back about 20 years (admittedly not adjusted for inflation).

USD_Line_20years_300x150.gif


If you go back to the 70's, with gold at $37, the chart looks just as good.

Gold as a holding has not performed too badly.

Is gold equivalent to lottery tickets? You decide.

I just glanced at the Wikipedia entry, and it seems pretty balanced at first blush.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_as_an_investment
 
This is not directed to drkitten, who seems intransigent on the matter, but for anyone else who might be following this thread.

He's equating gold with lottery tickets.

Here's what gold has done, looking back about 20 years (admittedly not adjusted for inflation).

http://www.galmarley.com/ChartApp/Images/USD_Line_20years_300x150.gif

If you go back to the 70's, with gold at $37, the chart looks just as good.

Gold as a holding has not performed too badly.

Is gold equivalent to lottery tickets? You decide.

I just glanced at the Wikipedia entry, and it seems pretty balanced at first blush.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_as_an_investment

No, it shows that selling the gold you bought 20 years ago wouldn't be a bad idea. Or the gold that Grandpa hoarded and passed on to you in his will. Throw in that junk silver you're collecting while you're at it.

UWdude said:
stilicho said:
Quote:
...would be shotgun shells and lots of them. I would recommend hoarding them in the millions and cowering in the bomb shelter until the apocalypse arrives.

yooo sooo funny, funny man.

Thanks, I'll be appearing every night through Thursday. Don't forget to tip your server.
 
No, it shows that selling the gold you bought 20 years ago wouldn't be a bad idea.

I think that's a distinction without a difference.

One could always say (all hypotheticals)...

...I'm up over 50% in Intel, or...

...my home's value is still up over 60% from where I bought it, or...

...my vacation home has lost nearly half its value since 2008, or...

...the gold I hold is worth about 3 times what I paid for it, or...

...my overall portfolio is up 13% year-to-date...

...and always add the words "IF I SOLD RIGHT NOW".

But that's silly, and redundant. The things you own can increase or decrease in value while you still hold them. Of course you don't realize the gain or loss until you actually sell, but that's totally irrelevant.

Unless you assert that holdings cannot increase in value - which I think would be silly.

Unless I'm misunderstanding you.
 
I think that's a distinction without a difference.

One could always say (all hypotheticals)...

...I'm up over 50% in Intel, or...

....

But that's silly, and redundant. The things you own can increase or decrease in value while you still hold them. Of course you don't realize the gain or loss until you actually sell, but that's totally irrelevant.

It's not me you're misunderstanding but rather your own examples. Have you ever invested in a good dividend/growth stock like INTC? Drkitten introduced that one for a reason. How many times did your gold split 2:1 and pay a quarterly dividend in the past 20 years?

If you're averse to technology then how about a less sexy stock like Coca-Cola? They pay out regularly too and split just like the growth stocks do. You can even drink their product if you're thirsty.

If you liked, you could always spend all that extra money on junk silver. It's your money, after all, and you didn't have to lift a finger. Coca-Cola and Intel just gave it to you. When was the last time your bag of silver did that for you?
 
It's not me you're misunderstanding but rather your own examples. Have you ever invested in a good dividend/growth stock like INTC?

Yes. As stated prior in this thread, I did own Intel for quite some time.

If you're averse to technology...

As stated prior in this thread, my biggest gains are in Apple and Netflix. Google is doing well, too. My IRA contains both Technology and Software & Computing funds, as well as other more mundane funds.

...then how about a less sexy stock like Coca-Cola?

Or even less sexy, like Dominion Resources, Potomac Electric, Nextera (was FPL), Washington Gas? Or even municipal bond funds? As stated prior in this thread, I'm diversified. And I agree, dividends are great, and as I get older I think about them more.

If you liked, you could always spend all that extra money on junk silver.

You seem to be still beating that same, dead, straw man. Some choose to put some portion of their portfolios in precious metals. Really, read that Wikipedia link to "Gold as an Investment" I posted before. It gives the pros and cons. Here's an excerpt:

The performance of gold bullion is often compared to stocks due to their fundamental differences. Gold is regarded by some as a store of value (without growth) whereas stocks are regarded as a return on value (i.e., growth from anticipated real price increase plus dividends). Stocks and bonds perform best in a stable political climate with strong property rights and little turmoil. The attached graph shows the value of Dow Jones Industrial Average divided by the price of an ounce of gold. Since 1800, stocks have consistently gained value in comparison to gold in part because of the stability of the American political system.[51] This appreciation has been cyclical with long periods of stock outperformance followed by long periods of gold outperformance. The Dow Industrials bottomed out a ratio of 1:1 with gold during 1980 (the end of the 1970s bear market) and proceeded to post gains throughout the 1980s and 1990s. The gold price peak of 1980 also coincided with the Soviet Union's invasion of Afghanistan and the threat of the global expansion of communism. The ratio peaked on January 14, 2000 a value of 41.3 and has fallen sharply since.
On November 30, 2005, Rick Munarriz of The Motley Fool posed the question of which represented a better investment: a share of Google or an ounce of gold. The specific comparison between these two very different investments seems to have captured the imagination of many in the investment community and is serving to crystallize the broader debate.[52][53] At the time of writing, a share of Google's stock was $405 and an ounce of gold was one day from breaking the $500 barrier, which it did December 1. On January 4, 2008 23:58 New York Time, it was reported that an ounce of gold outpaced the share price of Google by 30.77%, with gold closing at $859.19 per ounce and a share of Google closing at $657 on U.S. market exchanges. On January 24, 2008, the gold price broke the $900 mark per ounce for the first time. The price of gold topped $1,000 an ounce for the first time ever on March 13, 2008 amid recession fears in the United States.[54] Google closed 2008 at $307.65 while gold closed the year at $866. Leading into 2010, Google had doubled off that (100%), whereas gold had risen 40%.


As stated before its not a matter of stocks OR gold. I own both, heavily weighted towards stocks.
 
As stated before its not a matter of stocks OR gold. I own both, heavily weighted towards stocks.

No, it's not either/or. You can happily diversify your portfolio between stocks and rat turds if you like. But you've still been unable to provide a rational reason why putting 10% of your portfolio into rat turds is better than -- or even as good as -- putting it into almost any other investment on the planet.
 
One could always say (all hypotheticals)...

...I'm up over 50% in Intel, or...

Except I wouldn't be saying that; I'd be saying instead that I was up over 50% in Intel and had generated cumulative dividend return of over 20%.

That dividend stream is real money.

And I also own an equivalent percentage of a larger commercial enterprise; my thousandth of a percent of Intel represents a thousandth of a percent of two new fabrication lines, fifty new patents, a sales force ten percent larger, and so forth.

I don't need to sell to make money on Intel.

If I buy an ounce of gold, I have.... an ounce of gold. It's not going to turn into two ounces of gold, or write me a check every quarter, or buy a new factory in Singapore.
 
Are you absolutely sure about that last bit?!? :confused:

:confused: Absolutely. The ounce of gold is just going to sit there; it performs no economic activity at all. (As a matter of fact, if you analyze a little more deeply, its ultimate effect is negative economic activity since it forces me to secure and insure it, which costs me money.)

I might be able to secure enough money at the right time to buy that factory in Singapore, but only if I sell the gold and buy the factory.

By contrast, Intel, the corporation of which I hypothetically own a piece, is continuing to perform economic activity and to earn money, both for me directly (through dividends) as well as for itself directly (through retained earnings). These retained earnings could easily be a new factory in Singapore that produces more chips, resulting in more sales, and so forth.

Essentially, Intel is an active economic entity; gold is a shiny metal.

How did you expect gold to purchase a factory?
 
By contrast, Intel, the corporation of which I hypothetically own a piece, is continuing to perform economic activity and to earn money, both for me directly (through dividends) as well as for itself directly (through retained earnings). These retained earnings could easily be a new factory in Singapore that produces more chips, resulting in more sales, and so forth.

Essentially, Intel is an active economic entity...

I've owned Intel, and it has performed well in the past (though not in the time frame I owned it*).

But Intel could be eclipsed, either suddenly or gradually, by other semiconductor manufacturers, and the price could plummet. Not saying that will happen or is probable, but there is certainly a non-zero probability of it happening - its happened again and again to companies that seemed inviolate.


*speaking of splits, my escapade with INTC began in late '99, bought at about $70. In 2000 there was a 2 for 1 split, lowering my basis to about $35. I gave up on it in late 2002, selling my shares for about $16.50 (I needed some losses to offset some gains, and was unhappy with the direction Intel was going). My timing sucked on that one, but just goes to show that just owning Intel is no guarantee of anything.
 
I've owned Intel, and it has performed well in the past (though not in the time frame I owned it*).

But Intel could be eclipsed, either suddenly or gradually, by other semiconductor manufacturers, and the price could plummet. Not saying that will happen or is probable, but there is certainly a non-zero probability of it happening - its happened again and again to companies that seemed inviolate.

But, of course, the probability is zero that the price of gold could plummet, either from a discovery of new sources, or simply from a drop in speculative demand. :rolleyes: Gold is 100% safe, but INTC is just too risky.....

*speaking of splits, my escapade with INTC began in late '99, bought at about $70. In 2000 there was a 2 for 1 split, lowering my basis to about $35. I gave up on it in late 2002, selling my shares for about $16.50 (I needed some losses to offset some gains, and was unhappy with the direction Intel was going). My timing sucked on that one, but just goes to show that just owning Intel is no guarantee of anything.

Ah, goody. So you buy into tech at the peak of the tech bubble, and now you're telling us to buy gold at the peak of the gold bubble. And you wonder why your advice is ridiculed.
 
I am a huge supporter of common stocks. My winners far exceed my losers.

Lol, picking names at random will result in far more winners then losers...

BTW, Intel is a stock I owned for quite some time and sold for about what I paid for it. I'm in Google (just 50 shares) at about 105. My biggest current gainers are Apple and Netflix (both with bases under 10).
That tells me a lot about your investing style. IMO now is a good time to be selling both Apple and Google, or at least taking profits. TBH if you have been in them for 5 years you may have made money, but it was dumb luck. Both are good companies but it’s far from clear their earnings potential justify their current valuations; it was even less clear 5 years ago.
Netflix is interesting but I think the barrier to entry is too low to maintain margins, and if they get too big look for the content producers to begin funnelling their releases to their own distribution networks. Netflix only works as long as they are a low margin partner.

Of course I could prove to be mistake, but mistakes on companies you don’t buy doesn’t actually cost anything.

Intel on the other hand is well on its way to transitioning to a mature company. With the R&D, and construction costs involved with getting high performance low power processors approaching $20 billion no one else can realistically think about competing in either their PC/Server space which is still benefiting from growth in India/China, nor the rapidly growing market for the mobile/smart phone market which has a high bar for both performance and power consumption. Basically Intel will have these markets to themselves for the foreseeable future.

At the very least Intel is paying a 3% dividend and their current PE is just over 11, half of what it’s been for most of the last few decades, it’s margins remain strong and it’s still a relatively fast growing company. Selling INTC, just doesn’t look like a wise move atm, and it’s probably a good candidate to buy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom