Gold will go $1,500/oz

I've owned Intel, and it has performed well in the past (though not in the time frame I owned it*).

But Intel could be eclipsed, either suddenly or gradually, by other semiconductor manufacturers, and the price could plummet. Not saying that will happen or is probable, but there is certainly a non-zero probability of it happening - its happened again and again to companies that seemed inviolate.


*speaking of splits, my escapade with INTC began in late '99, bought at about $70. In 2000 there was a 2 for 1 split, lowering my basis to about $35. I gave up on it in late 2002, selling my shares for about $16.50 (I needed some losses to offset some gains, and was unhappy with the direction Intel was going). My timing sucked on that one, but just goes to show that just owning Intel is no guarantee of anything.

This is a pretty good example of what you are getting wrong. Your only basis for deciding what looks like a good investment is its performance over the last few years. At best this really isn’t all that different from random, at worst you are buying into the bubbles.

With a business you can learn about it and make somewhat objective decisions about what its worth based on its earnings, and the likelihood of those increasing or decreasing. If you decide it’s really worth more then it’s current value you buy and if your assessment was right you will beat the market, unless the whole market was similarly undervalued. With gold you can’t do this so you are back to throwing darts, or buying into bubbles.
 
With a business you can learn about it and make somewhat objective decisions about what its worth based on its earnings, and the likelihood of those increasing or decreasing.

... or even based on other assessments for the business, if the business doesn't have earnings. For example, I might decide that my hometown needs another Chinese restaurant, and I'm just the person to supply it. Yes, my business doesn't have any earnings yet, but you can still look at my business plan and the business environment I'd be opening into before you decide to go halvesies with me.

E.g.,
* How many Chinese restaurants are there in town already? If there's only one and it's always packed, then that's better than if there's one at every other lamppost.
* How much experience do I have in the restaurant industry? If my previous job was an Anglican bishop, maybe you want to stay away.
* How's my location? A hot retail location downtown across from the main hotel is better than an industrial park ten miles out of town.
* Et cetera

With gold, you get none of that. You can't even look at "competitors" because gold doesn't do anything. Your only hope is that you can find a greater fool than yourself to buy the gold from you when you need/want to use the money you're pouring into it. And since you have no idea where and when you'll find fools,.... you're really at the mercy of Lady Luck.

I'm afraid that my lottery ticket analogy is a better one than Eddie likes. Like a lottery ticket, gold generates no revenue stream. Like a lottery ticket, gold costs you money to get into and to stay in. And like a lottery ticket, whether or not you can turn it in for the big prize depends almost entirely on luck.
 
I like gold where it belongs... on my wrist.

Hey DrK, my BZ and CAT are both money makers, so thanks for that!
 
... or even based on other assessments for the business, if the business doesn't have earnings. For example, I might decide that my hometown needs another Chinese restaurant, and I'm just the person to supply it. Yes, my business doesn't have any earnings yet, but you can still look at my business plan and the business environment I'd be opening into before you decide to go halvesies with me.

E.g.,
* How many Chinese restaurants are there in town already? If there's only one and it's always packed, then that's better than if there's one at every other lamppost.
* How much experience do I have in the restaurant industry? If my previous job was an Anglican bishop, maybe you want to stay away.
* How's my location? A hot retail location downtown across from the main hotel is better than an industrial park ten miles out of town.
* Et cetera

With gold, you get none of that. You can't even look at "competitors" because gold doesn't do anything. Your only hope is that you can find a greater fool than yourself to buy the gold from you when you need/want to use the money you're pouring into it. And since you have no idea where and when you'll find fools,.... you're really at the mercy of Lady Luck.

Yes, that’s an even better way to put it. Buffet may be able to have accountants and relevant exports look at the business with a fine tooth comb before he buys, but most of us won’t have that level of access.

I'm afraid that my lottery ticket analogy is a better one than Eddie likes. Like a lottery ticket, gold generates no revenue stream. Like a lottery ticket, gold costs you money to get into and to stay in. And like a lottery ticket, whether or not you can turn it in for the big prize depends almost entirely on luck.
In his case, he may do better with the lottery ticket. As I pointed out, he only seems to look at the last few years performance. This means he won’t even buy until prices have already gone up. At best he’s already lost most of the random upside and there is a good chance he will buy at the top of the bubble. (buy high, sell low!)

We can even see this in his stock preferences. Apple has roared back from near zero in the last 5 years, if there is a way for them to repeat that over the next 5 I can’t see it. Google’s earnings have done well, but unless you have a good understanding of the market for advertising dollars (I don’t) I don’t see how you can predict if this will continue. Maybe he just knows more than I do, but I haven’t seen evidence, rather he seems like he is looking to buy what’s hot.
 
We can even see this in his stock preferences. Apple has roared back from near zero in the last 5 years, if there is a way for them to repeat that over the next 5 I can’t see it. Google’s earnings have done well, but unless you have a good understanding of the market for advertising dollars (I don’t) I don’t see how you can predict if this will continue. Maybe he just knows more than I do, but I haven’t seen evidence, rather he seems like he is looking to buy what’s hot.

Well, "momentum investing" is a popular form of technical investing; there's a reason that IBD publishes its relative strength ratings (or whatever the hell they're called). And it's sort of intellectually justifiable in an armchair "don't show me the data" way -- if people like this stock today, they'll probably like this stock tomorrow, which gives me the "greater fool" I need to unload this turkey at a profit.

The single greatest weakness of Buffett,... which he cheerfully admits to, although it's surprising how many of his disciples and camp-followers disagree -- is that his investment strategy can't be used for target-date investing. If I have $20,000 now and I need $50,000 to pay for Smaller Kitten's college fund in ten years, what's the best stock investment to buy? If I'm five years from retirement, which companies should I buy to preserve capital while maintaining growth?
 
Ah, goody. So you buy into tech at the peak of the tech bubble, and now you're telling us to buy gold at the peak of the gold bubble. And you wonder why your advice is ridiculed.

I wasn't going to say anything.

:bunnyface
 
Love that silver!
I'm a lucky lotto winner!
Just as lucky as if I had bought some lotto tickets!
 
Wow! I got really lucky! Just like spinnin' the wheel on a roulette table! Silver at $40! Will they announce QE3? Bernanke's mind is saying no, but his heart is saying yes, yes YES!
 
Maybe you'll understand it once the air goes out of the bubble.

Understand what exactly? Seems to me you are making rather large assumptions on my position.

The simple fact is that what Skeptic-PK asked can be applied to non-dividend paying stocks or long/short futures positions in any given market or many other investment vehicles.

Maybe you should put some more thought into the question or please explain why you think it is relevant.
 
I figured if UW could be a smartarse then so could I :)

But here's some fun graphs monitoring gold returns over the last 4 decades compared to dividend-paying stocks.

S%2526P_Gold_2000.JPG


S%2526P_Gold_1990.JPG


S%2526P_Golg_1980.JPG


S%2526_Gold_1970.JPG
 
Maybe you'll understand it once the air goes out of the bubble.

There is no bubble in precious metals. Until people are levered to the hilt in the metals, and until people like you capitulate, there won't be. The bubble is in the US dollar, and the US bond market, gold is just the impartial scorekeeper (despite it's manipulation).

But please, by all means, post here when you decide you're buying. You will be doing some of us, especially me, a favor.
 
Skeptic-PK,

It's easy to pick date ranges to paint whatever picture one likes. It goes both ways and when some gold lover picks 1999 - 2011, it's cherry picking just the same.

What's clear is that there are times to be in different markets / sectors and people have opinions on what those positions should look like. Money is made or lost based on those opinions. So when certain individuals here say they are short US T-bonds or the US$, or long certain stocks, or whatever, it's no different than someone being long gold or silver or oil or wheat.

I'm not against taking stabs at people who are perpetual gold bugs or who have absurd CT views or who are radical anti-banker types. I guess what I'm saying is that you have to distinguish between the two, and those who have been long metals over the last decade have been correct. Where they get out, what their other investments look like and what they do next is always up for review.

Fair enough on being a smartass if that was your intent. It's just that the point of lack of dividends seemed to be a weak one to me I apologize if I mistook your intent. :D
 
The simple fact is that what Skeptic-PK asked can be applied to non-dividend paying stocks or long/short futures positions in any given market or many other investment vehicles.

Wrong. Retained earnings have value as well, and in cases where there is growth opportunities they can have significantly more value then if those earnings had been paid out in dividends.

Now, if you had said it can be applied to companies which expect to pay no dividend and have no retained earnings and do not have assets in excess of their liabilities then you may have had a point. In this case such a company would indeed be comparable to gold, but companies like there generally have almost no value whatsoever.
 
Skeptic-PK,

It's easy to pick date ranges to paint whatever picture one likes. It goes both ways and when some gold lover picks 1999 - 2011, it's cherry picking just the same.

What's clear is that there are times to be in different markets / sectors and people have opinions on what those positions should look like. Money is made or lost based on those opinions. So when certain individuals here say they are short US T-bonds or the US$, or long certain stocks, or whatever, it's no different than someone being long gold or silver or oil or wheat.

I'm not against taking stabs at people who are perpetual gold bugs or who have absurd CT views or who are radical anti-banker types. I guess what I'm saying is that you have to distinguish between the two, and those who have been long metals over the last decade have been correct. Where they get out, what their other investments look like and what they do next is always up for review.

Fair enough on being a smartass if that was your intent. It's just that the point of lack of dividends seemed to be a weak one to me I apologize if I mistook your intent. :D

All fair points.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom