Gold will go $1,500/oz

every house is not going to get robbed. Yes there is a chance, but it would have to be straight Mad Max for every house to get robbed, or even 1 out of 5.

I don't think you answered my question, unless you're implying that you believe the chances of economic/societal meltdown are 1 in 5 or greater.

Some people have defending holding gold as a rational hedge against a remote, "Black Swan" event. I'm just pointing out that physically possessing gold exposes you to a not-so-remote risk of robbery.
 
.....
Some people have defending holding gold as a rational hedge against a remote, "Black Swan" event. I'm just pointing out that physically possessing gold exposes you to a not-so-remote risk of robbery.

In the event of that economic/societal meltdown then the risk of being robbed for a loaf of bread, or a box of Twinkies would be the greater threat. But these total meltdown scenarios are on the silly side considering the OP.
 
In the event of that economic/societal meltdown then the risk of being robbed for a loaf of bread, or a box of Twinkies would be the greater threat. But these total meltdown scenarios are on the silly side considering the OP.

Of course, but those fantasies are what's building the gold bubble.

It's Glenn Beck and Alex Jones and seed gardens and hyperinflation in the 30's...bunch of nutty stuff.

Several posters are just noting that should the reason many of these people are buying gold come to pass, that gold won't do a hell of a lot.

If you don't think the Apocalypse is coming, aren't paying some shady Beck-advertiser ridiculous commission fees, and just think you're making an investment, then it's not that big of a deal (although expect to lose some money if you're still in when the bubble bursts).
 
Just to be clear, I was talking about the risk of being robbed of your gold now, while you're waiting for the apocalypse to hit. (Obviously, in a post-apocalypse world in which only gold has value, it's better to have gold and risk being robbed of it than to not have it at all.)
 
Yeah, I wouldn't rob every house. I'd just look for the ones with gold in them.

How would you know?

If there was mass looting, then yes, even gold would be worth less (not worthless). But hyperinflation does not necessarily imply mass looting. it means shortages and fights in grocery stores and such, but not widespread mad max anarchy. (although frankly, I think Americans would be worse than Zaire, Zimbabwe or Germans, because of their current every man is a king attitude)

Just to be clear, I was talking about the risk of being robbed of your gold now, while you're waiting for the apocalypse to hit. (Obviously, in a post-apocalypse world in which only gold has value, it's better to have gold and risk being robbed of it than to not have it at all.)

You are probably more likely to be robbed by your financial investment company. ;)

If we're in full-on apocalypse, it'd probably get you a gallon of water or some bread for a day or two.

yeah, because.... ... why? Because people will be trading what instead?
 
Last edited:
So you're of the position that I was serious?

All your posts on this topic are quite ridiculous. I am pretty sure your statement about gold only being able to buy bread and water was a serious attempt at dismissing gold. So it is hard to tell when you are being serious or not.

I don't think you answered my question, unless you're implying that you believe the chances of economic/societal meltdown are 1 in 5 or greater.

I was implying, even in a mad max kind of world, your chances of your house getting robbed would still only be about 1/5. It's a total out of my donkey number.
 
Last edited:
I have a question for you Sceptic. Do you see George Soros as a harmless crank with no power to devalue a currency?

I honestly don't care either way. There will always be much bigger fish out there than me, regardless of my investment methods. I don't live in perpetual fear of currency devaluation. If my currency devalues, it's good for my country's exporters and miners. If it values, it's good for my shopping tendencies. These fanciful doomsday scenarios do not enter my mind when planning longterm investment strategies. I find them rather childish.
 
I honestly don't care either way. There will always be much bigger fish out there than me, regardless of my investment methods. I don't live in perpetual fear of currency devaluation. If my currency devalues, it's good for my country's exporters and miners. If it values, it's good for my shopping tendencies. These fanciful doomsday scenarios do not enter my mind when planning longterm investment strategies. I find them rather childish.

Childish to be aware of threats to our economy? You remain ignorant by intention yet you feel informed enough to post your opinions in this thread.
 
commodities-vs-dollar-feb08.gif




You buy what you want and I'll buy what I want and we'll let "fate" sort it out.







Of course at this time , "fate" means Bernanke and QE2 and QE3 and QE4 and ...
 
Childish to be aware of threats to our economy? You remain ignorant by intention yet you feel informed enough to post your opinions in this thread.

No, childish to focus intently upon it (doomsday) to the exclusion of everything else, and base an investment strategy upon extreme situations, that do not represent normal, regular market activities or outcomes. This thread is a perfect example, in order to justify investment in gold the most unlikely scenarios are being used as evidence/examples. Childish.
 
No, childish to focus intently upon it (doomsday) to the exclusion of everything else, and base an investment strategy upon extreme situations, that do not represent normal, regular market activities or outcomes. This thread is a perfect example, in order to justify investment in gold the most unlikely scenarios are being used as evidence/examples. Childish.

You say unlikely. History says otherwise. Take George Soros' history for example.

You seem unable to answer this simple question.

Is George Soros a harmless crank with no power to devalue a currency?

For those who know the answer to that question there is a follow up for extra credit. Has George Soros said that he favors the devaluation of the UD$?
 
You say unlikely. History says otherwise.

Please note we are talking about doomsdays, not devaluations. We've just experienced the most severe economic calamity we're likely to see in a long time, yet where's the revolution? Where's the end of civilisation as we know it?

Is George Soros a harmless crank with no power to devalue a currency?

I really don't understand the question. Of course there are extremely rich people/businesses who have the ability to influence all kinds of economic outcomes, including currency. What does Soros' history of currency speculation have to do with whether gold is a sensible investment in longterm investment strategy? What do market/currency crashes have to do with doomsdays? Why would I care if my currency devalues as long as the businesses I invested in remain profitable (not even touching on the fact that certain businesses make substantial gains with a weaker currency)?

It is silly to invest as if calamity is around every corner. Calamity is not the norm.
 
No, childish to focus intently upon it (doomsday) to the exclusion of everything else...

Straw Man.

No one has said to exclude everything else.

In fact, most here have said that at the most, some gold could/should be part of a diversified portfolio.
 
These are not normal times.

I like this quote, from Jim Rogers book, "Investment Biker":

"We [specifically Americans] think we are exempt from universal laws but we are not. People who think they are exempt from universal laws have a moral disease called, hubris, frequently fail. I am not trying to be clever or outrageous; this is simply history, the way the world has been ever since we've been recording it. Seperatism is a fact of history at all times of economic distress. Most people will maneuver to maximize their economic lives, always have and always will, and in the process new societies and structures will be established. Sooner or later political structures around them must shift to deal with the change.
Americans find it hard to believe that such laws apple to their country that even their borders can change. They shouldn't. Borders and governments move to follow economic interests, which shift constantly, as Adam Smith, Marx and Keynes all noted; then come religious, ethnic, and linguistic reasons. There is no border in the world that has lasted centuries, much less forever. With our short-term myopia, we think it's different this time.......Well, in the laws of economics, in the laws of history, in the laws of politics, and in the laws of society its never different this time. The law of gravity isn't ever suspended for someone's convenience, and these laws are just as rigorous, though more subtle and complex. "Oh come on!" I hear all the time [ I heard it from Buffet last Thursday night], "This is American. It's different here." I wish it were, but unfortunately, its never different anywhere, never different anytime. Every piper has to be paid Fall of a cliff and no matter whether you're Spanish, Argentine, Chinese or American, gravity still operates, no different from any other time."

(bolded mine)
 
Last edited:
In the event of that economic/societal meltdown then the risk of being robbed for a loaf of bread, or a box of Twinkies would be the greater threat. But these total meltdown scenarios are on the silly side considering the OP.

One doesn't get to have it both ways.

If gold is valuable enough to have (over stock certificates or commercial real estate, for example, which represent shares in a productive and revenue-generating enterprise), then it's valuable enough to be worth stealing. In fact, it's an ideal thing to steal and people will steal it in preference to bread (because gold doesn't go stale or rot, it's dense enough that I can carry enough away with me for a truckload of bread, it can be melted down so it can't be traced, and so forth).

If gold isn't valuable enough to be worth stealing (with all of its advantages over stealing bread), then it's not valuable enough to be worth owning in the first place.

Similarly, one doesn't get to have it both ways about black swan events. If I need to take seriously the idea of hyperinflation and the possibility that the currency in my wallet might go to zero and take my shares in Caterpillar with it --- itself a ludicrous proposition, as farmers will still need to buy tractors and tractor parts regardless of the value of a dollar -- as I said, if I need to take seriously the idea of hyperinflation, goldbugs need to take serious the idea of a physical loss.

I'd suggest, in fact, that a physical loss like a burglary is much more likely than hyperinflation or a Mad Max crash. I've been burglarized twice in my life, and robbed once. I've never experienced hyperinflation. Simple statistics suggest that burglary is not particularly a black swan -- light gray at worst.

Basically, if the best argument for gold is hyperinflation (especially with inflation rates running at <2%, historically low rates, low enough to cause problems), I think the serious day-to-day practical concerns about gold (the fact that it doesn't pay dividends, for example) should totally damn it.
 
Re: theft of gold...

...there's no absolute protection against theft, but...

...one of these would certainly deter the average burglar:

fire-proof-gun-safe.jpg


Also, a safe deposit box is a viable option, barring a near-instantaneous doomsday scenario. Even when banks get shut down, the contents of the boxes are protected and available.
 
Re: theft of gold...

...there's no absolute protection against theft, but...

...one of these would certainly deter the average burglar:

[qimg]http://www.ammoland.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/fire-proof-gun-safe.jpg[/qimg]

Would it? Which is more likely, a hyperinflationary scenario, or an ordinary safecracking?

How many people have had their safes rifled in the past twenty-five years, vs. how many have experienced hyperinflation?

As I said, you don't get it both ways. If you get to say "well, my home safe provides reasonable protection for my gold stock," I can say, with much greater justification that the Fed provides much greater protection against hyperinflation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom