gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
Another buyback and they absolutely take 2% of your money. It says so right there in black and white. They're also selling you gold at £1,100 per oz while the spot price now is about £1050.

Can you yet see anything at all wrong with your investment strategy?

Not really, no. You are worrying about 2% when gold is going up at 2% every day?

I am not speculating. All I'm doing is turning unstable money into stable money. If I have to pay 2% to exchange it, then so be it.

And small people like me can never get gold at spot price. This is all irrelevant, anyway, if gold is heading towards $5000.
 
Last edited:
It was this



No worries. I've been long metals for over 10 years and I have disagreed with many people here when they have bashed being invested in gold / silver. Even though I unloaded 90% of my investments in this sector over a year ago, I still have my physical (it's not as easy to sell) and I still think the 3-5 year outlook is positive. So, in respect to precious metals we're not as far apart as you might have imagined.

That's interesting. I would call you a weak hand, but if you've held on for ten years through all the idiots and their ridicule, that isn't true. I'm not sure that justifies a short position into a form of money that is going to skyrocket, but I could be wrong. So what are you invested in now?
Well, I'm not interested in going into my analysis in detail. I don't want to have to argue against a peanut gallery (I'm not directing this at anyone in particular, but a forum like this is full of them).

That's too bad. I'm open-minded, I'd like to hear it.

Suffice it to say the metals have met my targets for this move (and then some in gold), the sentiment is too bullish, I'm not a believer in hyper-inflation -- at this point anyway -- I believe the US$ will also strengthen for a while, so I can envision lower prices for a year or so.

You think the sentiment is bullish? Discount gold buyers are doing record business, and most households don't own any. Did you see the poll that was the OP? Anecdotally, I have a fried who is a dot-com millionaire. He has a good understanding of the macro picture and we agree on virtually everything. I found out recently that despite all of his talk, he's severely underweight metals. I've been buying for the last ten years, and he has been talking. This is the smartest person I know, he scored a perfect 1600 on his SAT, back when it was a challenge, and yet the cognitive dissonance is astounding. Granted, gold has been in the news, mostly because it keeps breaking all-time highs, but I would hardly agree the sentiment is bullish. I guess we'll see.
 
That's interesting. I would call you a weak hand, but if you've held on for ten years through all the idiots and their ridicule, that isn't true.

It’s only been the last few years that I’ve really been exposed to a lot of the ridicule that you speak of – most of it here on JREF – and it wasn’t really directed at me.

My other participation in this sector was mostly in precious metals funds, ETF’s and some futures positions. I got out early on most of it and left a chunk of money on the table (as always), with the only exception being the funds as they have underperformed the base metal, but I made a lot of money having been long for that time. I hope I get another bite at the apple -- it’s just going to have to be at a lower price with a different set of "circumstances".

I'm not sure that justifies a short position into a form of money that is going to skyrocket, but I could be wrong. So what are you invested in now?

It’s a trade. Not very many people here (none that I can recall) were thinking bonds would continue to rally either. In any event, it can only be justified if it turns out to be correct. :-)

My general portfolio make up is of positions consistent to what I've posted I think will happen, and a large amount of liquidity that I maintain in short-term Treasuries.

That's too bad. I'm open-minded, I'd like to hear it.

My methodology is complicated, unconventional and based on 25 years of trading and investing. It’s based only in part on fundamentals. It will just invite more questions and ridicule than I care to deal with.

Some background -- I owned a NASD broker dealer (institutional bond trading) and a commodity futures broker. I do some advising for some friends that run a small hedge fund.

You think the sentiment is bullish? Discount gold buyers are doing record business, and most households don't own any. Did you see the poll that was the OP? Anecdotally, I have a fried who is a dot-com millionaire. He has a good understanding of the macro picture and we agree on virtually everything. I found out recently that despite all of his talk, he's severely underweight metals. I've been buying for the last ten years, and he has been talking. This is the smartest person I know, he scored a perfect 1600 on his SAT, back when it was a challenge, and yet the cognitive dissonance is astounding. Granted, gold has been in the news, mostly because it keeps breaking all-time highs, but I would hardly agree the sentiment is bullish. I guess we'll see.

I’m talking trader sentiment and professional investor sentiment.


.
 
You think the sentiment is bullish? Discount gold buyers are doing record business, and most households don't own any. Did you see the poll that was the OP?

Roughly 25% are bulls, apparently, with over 60% thinking gold is overpriced.

My personal opinion is that we are at the beginning of a new phase of the bull market. I think the rate of increase is going to get faster now.
 
No. But if Scrut didn't sell anything today, he didn't "lose" any money.

Everyone at work today was moaning about "the hit" that their 401(k)'s took. I finally asked one of them, "Did you cash out of your plan today?" They said no. "So," I asked them, "What exactly did you lose?"

They couldn't answer. They didn't seem to understand that while their 401(k) might not be worth what it was yesterday, they haven't "lost" any money unless they cash it in when it is worth less than they put into it. And only a pea-brain would do that. If you have $1000 worth of stock and the price drops to where it's only worth $500 you don't sell it then, you hang onto it until the price is somewhere above $1000. If you aren't ready to roll with the changes (and possibly get shafted in the deal, it happens), bury your money in a mason jar in the backyard.

Aw somebody beat me to it. I always :rolleyes: when someone goes "I lost $XXX in the market today."

So what are y'alss short- and long-term plans investing-wise, generally speaking? My lack of activity has actually saved me money. :boggled: I have a large chunk just sitting in a money market at a pathetic rate, but at least it's not losing.
 
Not really, no. You are worrying about 2% when gold is going up at 2% every day?

I am not speculating. All I'm doing is turning unstable money into stable money. If I have to pay 2% to exchange it, then so be it.

And small people like me can never get gold at spot price. This is all irrelevant, anyway, if gold is heading towards $5000.

not necessarily true www.bullionvault.com

Originally Posted by kevsta
..like getting gang rogered by the elephant & 500lb gorilla in the room at the moment I expect

Time will tell. 1/2 a day seems a bit premature to offer anything -- especially since silver is flat on the day -- but thanks for showing you don't really have any idea where the markets opened and when it trades.

I didnt realise you weren't already positioned, and assumed the $2 spike at Au / Asian opening might have smarted a little.

Roughly 25% are bulls, apparently, with over 60% thinking gold is overpriced.

My personal opinion is that we are at the beginning of a new phase of the bull market. I think the rate of increase is going to get faster now.

"the foothills of the mania" that's my opinion too.
 
Last edited:
I didnt realise you weren't already positioned, and assumed the $2 spike at Au / Asian opening might have smarted a little.

As it turns out I wasn't. I put them on today. I may sell more if it goes higher, but I would not want to see it close above last weeks high.

Of course, for all you knew based on your assumption, I could have been short from last week and much higher.

Probably just fond of the idea that someone who doesn't share your outlook on silver suffers. Whatever makes your boat float. :cool:


.
 
It’s a trade. Not very many people here (none that I can recall) were thinking bonds would continue to rally either. In any event, it can only be justified if it turns out to be correct. :-)

Most people still perceive US bonds as a "save haven". They're jumping out of the equity frying pan, into the bond fryer. Bonds will go up and yields will go down in the short term, that's a very temporary condition.

My general portfolio make up is of positions consistent to what I've posted I think will happen, and a large amount of liquidity that I maintain in short-term Treasuries.


My methodology is complicated, unconventional and based on 25 years of trading and investing. It’s based only in part on fundamentals. It will just invite more questions and ridicule than I care to deal with.

Fair enough. If it isn't based on fundamentals, I wouldn't be interested in anway. I'm not smart enough to time the market.

Some background -- I owned a NASD broker dealer (institutional bond trading) and a commodity futures broker. I do some advising for some friends that run a small hedge fund.



I’m talking trader sentiment and professional investor sentiment.


.

I would be hesitant to use "smart money" sentiment as a contrarian indicator. I guess you're using the Bernard Baruch school of thought, "you'll never go broke taking a profit." I'd like to think I am smart enough to spot a secular top in monetary metals before hand, even though I don't know what will happen in the short term. We will probably either need to see double digit rates that are in decline, or a total collapse of the US dollar before I will turn into a bear. That, or proof that "The Central Scrutinizer" is a buyer.
 
Not really, no. You are worrying about 2% when gold is going up at 2% every day?

I am not speculating. All I'm doing is turning unstable money into stable money. If I have to pay 2% to exchange it, then so be it.

And small people like me can never get gold at spot price. This is all irrelevant, anyway, if gold is heading towards $5000.

No, they are only buying back gold from you that you bought from them at a 4.7% premium. So you go in there with £10,000 and get £9,500 worth of gold. You return your £9,500 worth of gold and they give you back £9,350. You just profited -6.5%. All you're really doing is buying gold futures from them and not gold itself. They're booking revenue with each transaction while you're assuming all their risk.
 
Suppose you had some money to save for later. What is a better place than gold regarding the criteria you mentioned ?

I don't know many investments that you could have bought in the time of the pharaohs, and still sell for a decent return today.

Real estate.
 
Gold isn't strictly a counterbalance to "fiat currency", much like T-Bills gold can rise simply because investors can't find anything less frightening to invest in. Look at today (Monday), gold and treasuries both soaring.

Then look at the dollar index.. not much going on. When money flees the stock market it has to end up somewhere, and the mattress is a much less popular investment vehicle than it used to be.
 
All you're really doing is buying gold futures from them and not gold itself.

This is without doubt the most idiotic thing that has been posted in this thread. I'm not buying gold itself? Funny that....I could have sworn I actually own some gold...

They're booking revenue with each transaction while you're assuming all their risk.

They aren't taking any risk because they are gold retailers. They make their money by selling people gold for more than they pay for it. If they did not make any money in this manner, what would be the point in them being gold retailers?

You do understand the difference between a retailer and a speculator, right?

You are desperately trying to convince me I'm being ripped off, but the fact of the matter is that if I were to sell the gold I've bought it would be at a handsome profit already, and the value is going up daily and shows no signs of stopping. Had I left that money in a bank account or invested it in the stock market, it would have lost value.

What a foolish person I have been!

Right now, gold is a one-way bet. It can only go up. The only question is how far, and how fast.
 
Last edited:
Right now, gold is a one-way bet. It can only go up. The only question is how far, and how fast.

although I am a massive bull, I wouldn't necessarily agree with this unless you mean over intermediate (or longer) term.

if Paulson (or anyone else of size) has to liquidate his GLD holdings to pay margin calls on all his insolvent bank stocks, we can expect a pretty good smashdown for a little while.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/bank-america-just-start-paulsons-problems-behold-citigroup

even Im tempted to park half of it in cash at these record levels and buy back in lower because this is a definite possibility IMO. if it just kept going up I could always buy silver at these lower levels instead and swap back once the ratio closes down to 30:1 again.

who knows though, demand might be so strong currently that it may not even drop $50, but if it drops 20 or 30% in a day that would be nice if I was ready to be buying back in. decisions decisions.
 
Last edited:
although I am a massive bull, I wouldn't necessarily agree with this unless you mean over intermediate (or longer) term.

if Paulson (or anyone else of size) has to liquidate his GLD holdings to pay margin calls on all his insolvent bank stocks, we can expect a pretty good smashdown for a little while.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/bank-america-just-start-paulsons-problems-behold-citigroup

even Im tempted to park half of it in cash at these record levels and buy back in lower because this is a definite possibility IMO. if it just kept going up I could always buy silver at these lower levels instead and swap back once the ratio closes down to 30:1 again.

who knows though, demand might be so strong currently that it may not even drop $50, but if it drops 20 or 30% in a day that would be nice if I was ready to be buying back in. decisions decisions.

It would be nice if you are right...
 
re the Poll results, I would also like to ask any of the people who voted "bear" what circumstances they envision driving the price down again?

ie massive deflationary crash (or grind) downwards dragging the price down

or slow recessionary pressure and people realising that it is just yellow metal that you cant eat after all?

or what exactly?

does anybody think we're (global economy) going to recover and pull back to relative economic health without too much major drama, and that will be the cause?
 
Last edited:
Just for the record....

http://www.taxfreegold.co.uk is now saying that there is a three month waiting period for orders to be filled, and http://www.bullionbypost.co.uk/ has (this morning) stopped taking orders with no information about if/when they are going to start again.

I predict it is going to get harder and harder to actually get hold of physical gold, not that this requires me to be a genius...
 
Most people still perceive US bonds as a "save haven".

Yeah, I'd say that's pretty obvious -- especially in hindsight.

They're jumping out of the equity frying pan, into the bond fryer. Bonds will go up and yields will go down in the short term, that's a very temporary condition.

And people have been saying this for a while now. "Temporary" doesn't really mean anything unless one puts an actual time period to it.

Fair enough. If it isn't based on fundamentals, I wouldn't be interested in anway. I'm not smart enough to time the market.

That's not what I said, of course.

I would be hesitant to use "smart money" sentiment as a contrarian indicator.

Thanks for the advice. I do what works for me. I've thrown out more methodology over 25 years than I've kept, and that goes for all types.

I guess you're using the Bernard Baruch school of thought, "you'll never go broke taking a profit."

Actually, I think it is some of the worst advice given.

I'll use your dot com friend as an example of what I do think is important to understand. There are two basic skills at play... Perception and Execution.

Most people concentrate on trying to figure out where the market(s) are going. They spend the time, the money and the resources in an attempt to decide on the correct "perception" (ie; market direction).

Unfortunately, they don't spend much time thinking about "execution". Thus, they are weak at executing their trades / investments and most importantly exhibit even poorer Money Management on the positions they do enter.

I'd like to think I am smart enough to spot a secular top in monetary metals before hand, even though I don't know what will happen in the short term.

So in my view you do think you can time the market. You just think that by being more "long-term" that somehow precludes any timing. I don't see it that way.

I'm not a day trader. My analysis is also what I consider long-term. Nevertheless, every day a new piece of the puzzle is turned over that may help to confirm or negate this analysis. I try not to get convinced on anything.

.... That, or proof that "The Central Scrutinizer" is a buyer.

Funny. :D


.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom