gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
Who are these powerful players, and how have they 'rigged' the market?

Mainly the big banks and some of the commodity exchanges like COMEX. As for how they do it, it isn't as much of a conspiracy as you would think.

Many of these gold/silver trades are paper, as in a piece of paper saying "I am selling you this amount of gold", however they don't have the actual physical to trade. In other words, a good portion of the trades are mainly on IOUs and not actual inventory. This doesn't apply to just commodities, but stocks as well.

So how does the actual 'manipulation' work? Quite simple. They mainly do naked short selling, or create put options, thus creating leverage. In order for a price to go down in the market, there needs to be more sellers than buyers. This is easily done via selling silver/gold that these firms do not possess, but still manage to push the price down. If someone buys 100 oz of physical silver, and someone sells 1,000 oz of paper silver, price is still going down.

Furthermore, margin hikes are a type of manipulation as well. Many of the PMs are constantly getting margin hikes but commodities like oil remain free of this. If stocks received as many margin hikes as PMs, they would go down further than the past few weeks.
 
Last edited:
....Compare these two graphs. One shows a bubble, the other one doesn't?
I understand your point, but there's a serious flaw in the logic. To make the comparison between two items, the same time scale should be used.

Also, internal variability in the data series, relating to "beta" of stocks. But that's figured over a cross section of time, so again, we need the same time base to make comparisons.
 
I don't recall that you were going to short gold. If you made money on silver, congratulations! You don't need any encouragement, your brokerage account should be encouragement enough.

Heh... I gave a price. The last thing I need is encouragement from anyone on this forum.

I'm in the market and do what I do for the money, not to score points on a board or convince myself that the crusade I'm on is correct. Honesty and reality is elusive here.

Just read this entire thread.... It is laughable and this forum section has been reduced to mostly conspiracy theorists and wannabes.

The days of learning anything here about economics -- which by the way is all but useless for trading markets -- have been gone for months now.

As I said before... back to your regularly scheduled program. I'm outta here!


.
 
.....The days of learning anything here about economics -- which by the way is all but useless for trading markets -- have been gone for months now........

There's still the nights.
 
Update:-

If you bought Gold right when this thread started, and just cashed it in today, how much would you have made?

That's right, Nothing!
 

Attachments

  • Gold Aug 5th to Dec 13th.gif
    Gold Aug 5th to Dec 13th.gif
    9.9 KB · Views: 4
Update:-

If you bought Gold right when this thread started, and just cashed it in today, how much would you have made?

That's right, Nothing!

uh huh. so are you trading it then? because why else would you be buying and selling a just few months later? :rolleyes:

if you were trading it, just look at that lovely roller coaster ride.

if you are buying gold for protection against systemic risk and /or money debasement and decided to sell it again today then you are stupid and got what you deserve, NOBODY ever said to buy gold if you want to sell it again a few months later.

lets come back to this thread in another 6 months, and another year, and another 18 months and we can all laugh at *one* of us, ok? ;)
 
Last edited:
I think Roger makes a good point that gold is too volatile to be a store of wealth, particularly given the lack of dividends.

Edited to say what I really meant.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
you could say the same about many if not most stocks and investments, especially in the last 3 years.

and not that many others have performed as well over that time

edit Citibank are bullish, predicting $3400 in next couple of years - chart

Which is why stocks give dividends. The only thing keeping up the "hopes" of gold is the fear of inflation, which by any widely accepted objective measure, is nowhere to be found.

Then you have to cope with the fact that at $1500/oz, you bet people are going to dig up a whole lot of it out of the ground. A single oz of gold is 2 weeks of pay for the average US based gold digger. 6 months of pay in some other countries.
 
HA ha ha ha!

*wipes tears from eyes*

I love it when gold investors lose money.
 
HA ha ha ha!

*wipes tears from eyes*

I love it when gold investors lose money.

lol, you and that numpty Roubini.

even deflationist Mish understands how dumb this is though

http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2011/12/dear-nouriel-roubini-fundamental-case.html

All anyone can really say is the fundamentals for gold are strong because the fundamentals for credit stress and central bank printing are strong.

When I perceive those fundamentals have changed, my position will change. In the meantime, we have had a relatively trivial drop in the price of gold to which many gold bugs threw in the towel in disgust.

Clearly, gold is not the fantastic bargain it was six years ago, but it is still a relative bargain as long as the fundamentals hold, no matter how the US dollar meanders over time. Maybe this correction steepens, and maybe it doesn't, but the fundamental case for gold has not changed one bit.

Gold has only fallen because central bankers ignored (for the time being), your foolish recommendations to print and spend more money.
 
Last edited:
good post from Greshams law on the (non) bubble

Why you, they, hell even I might buy the coming parabolic move in gold

Consider the musings of the gold top callers — after a decade of popping bubbles they’ve made a note to themselves and said ‘ Aha! I know how this works now! All I have to do is call a bubble whenever the price of a financial asset rises!’. I would argue that they have no idea about the environment that characterises a bubble-like top in an asset like gold. With the usual irony that is witnessed in the speculative arenas of life; they seek signals that do not correspond to the reality that they deal with (or so I presume).

As I mentioned above – the future is not obvious. One implication of this is that it is never ’easy’ as such to accurately call the top of a bubble! To call a bubble top right now really has few consequences – prices today aren’t wildly different from yesterday and all you might miss out on is opportunity. This kind of thinking may make a little sense when you’re shuffling paper titles to assets – but I would argue that it doesn’t apply so strongly to gold. Try calling a bubble when the implication could be that you lose virtually everything just by owning the ‘risk free’ asset; cash!
 

Funny how many people say "This time it's not a bubble" or "This time it still has a long way to go." It's also funny how many people say - after the bubble bursts - "I knew it was going to burst."

Similar to the way brokers always recommend you buy a stock but rarely tell you to sell a stock.

HA ha ha ha!

*wipes tears from eyes*

I love it when gold investors lose money.

Every bubble market is full of people betting there always be a bigger fool than they.
 
Funny how many people say "This time it's not a bubble" or "This time it still has a long way to go." It's also funny how many people say - after the bubble bursts - "I knew it was going to burst."

Similar to the way brokers always recommend you buy a stock but rarely tell you to sell a stock.

Every bubble market is full of people betting there always be a bigger fool than they.

this is why you have to look at the fundamentals of ownership and money flows, it has nothing to do with price, and everything to do with ownership levels.
 
Funny how many people say "This time it's not a bubble" or "This time it still has a long way to go." It's also funny how many people say - after the bubble bursts - "I knew it was going to burst."

I still wouldn't consider it a bubble considering the fundamentals.

China and India are buying a crap load of them, the premium on the metal dealers is absurd (I got quoted on 42 dollars for 1oz of silver!) and there is shortage in a few areas.

Usually a sign of a bubble is when people are buying a crapload of them when the prices are skyrocketing, up to the point where there are huge lineups and everyone is talking about on TV. Instead, you see plenty of people either slamming silver/gold and there isn't exactly high traffic for the metal dealers.

So...bubble? Doubtful. Just a shift of money to some place else.
 
I still wouldn't consider it a bubble considering the fundamentals.

China and India are buying a crap load of them, the premium on the metal dealers is absurd (I got quoted on 42 dollars for 1oz of silver!) and there is shortage in a few areas.

Usually a sign of a bubble is when people are buying a crapload of them when the prices are skyrocketing, up to the point where there are huge lineups and everyone is talking about on TV. Instead, you see plenty of people either slamming silver/gold and there isn't exactly high traffic for the metal dealers.

So...bubble? Doubtful. Just a shift of money to some place else.


$42 for an oz of silver? Check out the premium on Chinese Pandas:

http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fro...13&_nkw=china+panda&_sacat=See-All-Categories

What happens when you combine limited mintages (well, up until recently) and a (potentially) immense market.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom