gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
I think 9/11 was a NWO job, and AGW, peak oil, and Malthusian overpopulation bunk are scams set up to implement a global carbon tax, and legitimize the future emergence of a tyrannical world government. There is probably a correlation between things that are either difficult to believe or difficult to accept, but the correlation doesn't make any one of these possibilities any more or less likely. There is plenty of room for diversity of opinion, but arguing that any one of these non-mainstream beliefs is wrong because of some correlation, as skeptic-pk has attempted to do, is a fallacy. It's just a way of attempting to dismiss any particular theory without argument, which explains why skeptic-pk would employ that tactic. His arguments repeatedly fail.

Whatever.

At what price do you revert from a hoarder of gold to an investor and decide to sell? I heard $10,000/oz wasn't enough but I know you are smarter than that.

What's your selling price?

Some people think you can't be a wingnut and a decent investor at the same time but I'm not one of those. I know you must have a good selling price for gold. Silver, too. You started buying that stuff in the single digits and I think you're waiting for some opportunity to dump it all and buy something worthwhile but you've been uncharacteristically coy about when that will be or at what price.
 
Whatever.

At what price do you revert from a hoarder of gold to an investor and decide to sell? I heard $10,000/oz wasn't enough but I know you are smarter than that.

What's your selling price?

This question has been repeatedly asked in this thread, and the answer is always the same: there is no fixed selling price, because there is no limit to the amount of fiat money which can be created. The decision to sell will be based on what happens in terms of political decisions and monetary reform, not a price level. If the price is $10,000 and there is still no sign of a resolution to the monetary/fiscal problems then there is no point in selling because the price is likely to continue rising. If the price is $5000 and we've gone back to metal-backed money then there is no point in holding on to the gold.

At the moment, a lot of people have not accepted the reality of what is happening to the world's fiat currencies. Until they do, precious metals are likely to remain the only non-short-term game in town that is actually worth playing. We haven't had the mania/bubble stage yet.
 
Last edited:
:boxedin:

The above shows perfectly how a pseudo-skeptic thinks. Notice Sceptic-PK you have above "fantastic or extreme viewpoints", but do not describe who they are fantastic or extreme relative to (perhaps yourself I am supposing), so that the indication is that such things must be 'objectively' extreme or fantastic.

It is hard being a real sceptic, you have to question your own beliefs all the time, listen to crazy ideas and work out the holes in them, or if you can not find holes, tentatively accept the new ideas. This is not what in general it seems to me is done on JREF by quite a few people. The psuedo-sceptic has a much easier job, just parrot whatever is the official line and name-call everything else as extreme or fantastic.

Bang on the money. "Pseudo-scepticism" - where scepticism becomes just another form of tribalism and the exact opposite of freethinking.
 
The above shows perfectly how a pseudo-skeptic thinks. Notice Sceptic-PK you have above "fantastic or extreme viewpoints", but do not describe who they are fantastic or extreme relative to (perhaps yourself I am supposing), so that the indication is that such things must be 'objectively' extreme or fantastic.

911 CTs are objectively extreme and fantastic. If someone believes in that kind of thing, then it is reasonably easy to predict which of the more popular CTs, doomsday events and other crazy fun they might be into. And some of that crazy fun might even be right on the money at some stage in the next million years, but remain non-mainstream views currently. In my wasted hours on the internet I have yet to meet a 911 woo member that did not rail against central banking or fiat/doom or fractional lending etc. Not one. Regardless of the veracity of the criticisms re any of those topics, subscription to said topics can be predicted based on knowing of their 911 love.

All I said in my original post was that of course the poster believed in the impending doom of fiat. They all do.

It is hard being a real sceptic, you have to question your own beliefs all the time, listen to crazy ideas and work out the holes in them, or if you can not find holes, tentatively accept the new ideas. This is not what in general it seems to me is done on JREF by quite a few people. The psuedo-sceptic has a much easier job, just parrot whatever is the official line and name-call everything else as extreme or fantastic.

I know what the PK stands for in your nickname Sceptic-PK (it's just a guess, so apologies ahead of time if I guessed incorrectly)

Sceptic - Pseudo Kind.

Haha. Giving people names is completely different!

I think anyone can testify to me questioning my beliefs in those stupid banking threads. At one stage you really had me thinking that banks didn't lend customer deposits. You really did. But you're right, I have found it increasingly harder to be honestly sceptical when people peddle confusing nonsense into the intertubes. It's just easier to ignore huge swathes of BS than sort through them looking for microscopic grains of insight. I'm sorry I can't be as truly objective.

Makes sense now.
Have a nice day Sceptic-PK.

;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;) ~ ;)

Passive aggressive is such a cop out. I'll just be honest and call you a wanker.
 
This question has been repeatedly asked in this thread, and the answer is always the same: there is no fixed selling price, because there is no limit to the amount of fiat money which can be created. The decision to sell will be based on what happens in terms of political decisions and monetary reform, not a price level. If the price is $10,000 and there is still no sign of a resolution to the monetary/fiscal problems then there is no point in selling because the price is likely to continue rising. If the price is $5000 and we've gone back to metal-backed money then there is no point in holding on to the gold.

And if there is a resolution to the problems? I know you don't think there will be and that's fine, but you accept the fact that IF crises are resolved then the price would normalise? I would accept the demise of fiat if and when I saw it, how long would fiat have to reign supreme for you to accept that the "impending" part of its demise was inaccurate?
 
And if there is a resolution to the problems?

Then either I (and anybody else who is paying attention) will see this coming quite a long time advance, or we won't see it coming at it will cause a sudden jump in the price of precious metals. Either way, that will be the time to think about selling.

I know you don't think there will be and that's fine, but you accept the fact that IF crises are resolved then the price would normalise?

What does "normalise" mean? If you mean "goes back to the price that seemed normal between 1971 and 2005 then there's not a cat's chance in hell of it happening. "Normal" is in the process of being redefined.

I would accept the demise of fiat if and when I saw it, how long would fiat have to reign supreme for you to accept that the "impending" part of its demise was inaccurate?

I don't believe that is going to happen and until/unless I see world politics/economics heading that way then I see no reason to believe that it will happen.
 
emoticon

:boxedin:

911 CTs are objectively extreme and fantastic. If someone believes in that kind of thing, then it is reasonably easy to predict which of the more popular CTs, doomsday events and other crazy fun they might be into. And some of that crazy fun might even be right on the money at some stage in the next million years, but remain non-mainstream views currently. In my wasted hours on the internet I have yet to meet a 911 woo member that did not rail against central banking or fiat/doom or fractional lending etc. Not one. Regardless of the veracity of the criticisms re any of those topics, subscription to said topics can be predicted based on knowing of their 911 love.

Fair enough and true, except there is no such thing as objectively extreme or fantastic. Maybe that is too much in the way of Anthropological thinking though. I also very much dislike the idea of intrinsic value.

All I said in my original post was that of course the poster believed in the impending doom of fiat. They all do.

By they I think you mean Austrian School / Gold Money Advocates? I myself have a hard time accepting the US government's official conspiracy theory on what happened on 9/11 (first responders are not going to be allowed at the upcoming 9/11 commemoration ceromony because I guess too many of them are having a hard time accepting it either). The air is safe to breath Sceptic-PK! Breath in that post 9/11 air! Breath!

Oh, and I am not a gold-money advocate. Maybe I am an outlier that breaks some pattern you have discovered.

Haha. Giving people names is completely different!

I must protest good sir! I was merely guessing at what the PK stood for, if that is it stood for anything (Skeptic Pakistan, Sceptic Proper Knowledge...). If you do not like my guess though, by all means let us know what the acronym really stands for. For my part I was merely trying to match it with what seemed reasonable.

I think anyone can testify to me questioning my beliefs in those stupid banking threads. At one stage you really had me thinking that banks didn't lend customer deposits. You really did. But you're right, I have found it increasingly harder to be honestly sceptical when people peddle confusing nonsense into the intertubes. It's just easier to ignore huge swathes of BS than sort through them looking for microscopic grains of insight. I'm sorry I can't be as truly objective.

I can not testify to this. I for instance did not see a lot of doubt troubling your posts (doubt, the sign of a true sceptic). I am glad I brought you some doubt of your position on banking vis-a-vis if they make money or not. Make sure and take that feeling and apply it liberally to everything else you might believe in, or don't... It probably doesn't really matter after all.

Passive aggressive is such a cop out. I'll just be honest and call you a wanker.

Hmmm, this term wanker really does not have any kind of punch to it here in the US (I think people here would make fun of people saying it by saying something dumb like "that sounds gay"). While I might skirt the line of Ad hom I think the above use of wanker is definitely going into the red zone. Maybe that is why they have so many emoticons here to relieve such emotional pressures?

Oh well, I never really cared for such silly social mores (although the JREF moderators certainly do!). The bad thing about Ad Hominem is it never adds to an argument; the good thing about Ad Hominem is it lets the other side know what you think of them, possibly even their emotional state.

This is interesting because emotions can certainly interfere with thinking. On the other hand, Antonio Damasio, if I remember correctly, has stated that emotion and critical thinking are not seperate. This kind of makes sense to me in a way as math to me will often either feel correct or not, even before I check if it is correct.

So, looking up wanker it seems in all likelyhood that you mean to say I am self-indulgent and egotistical (perhaps with some passive agressive in there, quite an odd mix). OK, I will look into that. Thanks for the advice.

As for gold / silver. The best estimate I have seen is that gold will go up to the inflation adjusted mark of a high set in the 80's. Silver is supposedly a severely artificially depressed commodity. Will the "Buy Silver, Crash JP Morgan" compaign make any difference? Another war? Who knows?

I have tried to pick the emoticon that best looks like what a wanker should look like Sceptic-PK for my line of emoticons. I hope it matches.

:o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o
All the best to you all!
:o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o ~ :o
 
The continued attempts to define VALUE in USD numbers defies repeated warnings against such practice. Whether the value discussed is gold or other, but with gold it is most apparent as a logical error.
 
I trust you'll let us know when you cover your silver fade?

Sure, I'll let you know. I don't take being long or short these commodities personal, and I don't root for or against anyone. This is strange around here, I know. :p

I've been kinda busy lately, traveling and whatnot, but I'll try and pop in from time to time just for you.

Tippit, just popping back in. How are you doing? Making any money?

I'm not covering yet... still see weakness into early next year at a minimum.

Just a reminder.

Now, back to your regularly scheduled program. :)




.
 
pop!

Obviously the price of gold can't continue to rise at its current exponential rate...
Has the bubble burst? Spot Gold price dropped 12% in the last 30 days - almost back to where it was 2 months ago.

Will it continue to slide, or will it bounce back? I bet a few Gold bugs are feeling nervous right now...
 

Attachments

  • gold_60_day_o_b_usd.png
    gold_60_day_o_b_usd.png
    6.2 KB · Views: 3
Tippit, just popping back in. How are you doing? Making any money?

I'm not covering yet... still see weakness into early next year at a minimum.

Just a reminder.

Now, back to your regularly scheduled program. :)




.

I'm doing fine. Gold is back to levels it was at a couple of months ago. Silver looks weak, but physical demand, by all accounts is strong, CME and central bank manipulation notwithstanding. If it tanks more, I'll buy more. I know how the story is ending, this is just a shakedown.
 
Has the bubble burst? Spot Gold price dropped 12% in the last 30 days - almost back to where it was 2 months ago.

Will it continue to slide, or will it bounce back? I bet a few Gold bugs are feeling nervous right now...

No bubble burst. In fact, if anything, I suspect some major inside trading.

CME raised the margin of gold, silver, and copper AFTER the market closed on Friday. It wouldn't surprise me at all if this massive sell-off wasn't on the gold longs, but the gold shorts to cover their position and get out.

At first I thought this was hit 1600 or below due to recession like 2008. But now...who knows.
 
Last edited:
Has the bubble burst? Spot Gold price dropped 12% in the last 30 days - almost back to where it was 2 months ago.

Will it continue to slide, or will it bounce back? I bet a few Gold bugs are feeling nervous right now...

I will start to feel nervous only when all of the following happen:

(a) The political/monetary future of the eurozone becomes clearer rather than more uncertain. In effect this means that the eurozone countries choose either closer political/fiscal integration, or they allow the PIIGS to leave, or Germany leaves. Even if Greece is allowed to default on 50% of its debts, there will still be no prospect of a long-term solution to this problem. It is important to understand that this really is a political problem, and that it is of immense proportions.

(b) The political/monetary future of the US becomes clearer rather than more uncertain. In effect this means that all the different parts of the US government find a way to agree how the US is going to deal with its own debt problems. This is further complicated by the fact that Obama is up for re-election next year, and that there is a powerful right-wing political force in the UK which is basically psychotic and insane (much of the "tea-party" movement is clinically detached from reality, at least that is the way it looks to me.)

So long as nobody knows how these two situations are going to play out in the long-term, it is not possible to make an informed prediction as to where the price of gold is likely to go. All I know is that both situations are very serious indeed and that almost nobody is publicly discussing the realistic outcomes, because they are too scary. It is also the case that whilst these two problems are taking centre stage at the moment, they do not represent the full extent of the global, systemic problems. These are to do with fundamental physical resource limitations and with an economic/political/monetary system which is not fit for purpose. It is physically impossible for the world to continue for much longer down the path it has been travelling since the end of WWII, it follows that the path must change, and whichever new path we end up on it is absolutely guaranteed to have major implications for the role/price of precious metals.
 
Last edited:
I will start to feel nervous only when all of the following happen:

(a) The political/monetary future of the eurozone becomes clearer rather than more uncertain. In effect this means that the eurozone countries choose either closer political/fiscal integration, or they allow the PIIGS to leave, or Germany leaves. Even if Greece is allowed to default on 50% of its debts, there will still be no prospect of a long-term solution to this problem. It is important to understand that this really is a political problem, and that it is of immense proportions.

If I had to make a prediction, I would predict fiscal integration. It conforms to the NWO plan of political regionalization. I think the PIGS will get bailed out ultimately at German and French taxpayer expense. However, I think gold will outperform regardless, if this doesn't happen. The only scenario where gold is likely to sell off is if there is widespread default followed by political, monetary, and banking reform.

(b) The political/monetary future of the US becomes clearer rather than more uncertain. In effect this means that all the different parts of the US government find a way to agree how the US is going to deal with its own debt problems. This is further complicated by the fact that Obama is up for re-election next year, and that there is a powerful right-wing political force in the UK which is basically psychotic and insane (much of the "tea-party" movement is clinically detached from reality, at least that is the way it looks to me.)

To the extent that the tea-party has been co-opted by neo-con republicans, as I predicted, I agree. To the extent that the tea-party was basically pioneered by Ron Paul with the express goal of monetary and tax reform, and now functions as a vehicle to marginalize and discredit any potential of real reform, I disagree. I suspect given your tone that since you implicate the "right-wing" while failing to implicate the "left-wing", you implicitly support the "left-wing", who, along with the "right wing" status quo, are responsible for the very mess we are in which has caused gold to reassert its historical role. Suffer from cognitive dissonance, much?

So long as nobody knows how these two situations are going to play out in the long-term, it is not possible to make an informed prediction as to where the price of gold is likely to go. All I know is that both situations are very serious indeed and that almost nobody is publicly discussing the realistic outcomes, because they are too scary. It is also the case that whilst these two problems are taking centre stage at the moment, they do not represent the full extent of the global, systemic problems. These are to do with fundamental physical resource limitations and with an economic/political/monetary system which is not fit for purpose. It is physically impossible for the world to continue for much longer down the path it has been travelling since the end of WWII, it follows that the path must change, and whichever new path we end up on it is absolutely guaranteed to have major implications for the role/price of precious metals.

I don't know for certain, but as long as fraud remains the business of the day for sovereigns and multinational banks, I'm pretty sure gold and silver are going up, long-term.
 
To the extent that the tea-party has been co-opted by neo-con republicans, as I predicted, I agree. To the extent that the tea-party was basically pioneered by Ron Paul with the express goal of monetary and tax reform, and now functions as a vehicle to marginalize and discredit any potential of real reform, I disagree. I suspect given your tone that since you implicate the "right-wing" while failing to implicate the "left-wing", you implicitly support the "left-wing", who, along with the "right wing" status quo, are responsible for the very mess we are in which has caused gold to reassert its historical role. Suffer from cognitive dissonance, much?

From my point of view, the "left wing" in the US hardly exists, when compared to the situation elsewhere in the developed world. I'm not really a left-winger. I'm a green, and not the idealistic leftie sort of green either. I didn't single out the right wing because I think the left wing has the answers (although I'd also disagree that it was the left which caused the mess we are in). I singled them out because, at least in the US, the far right is mainstream enough to wield real power, and the left is not, because it isn't big enough or left enough. There is no left wing equivalent of the tea-party movement.

I don't know for certain, but as long as fraud remains the business of the day for sovereigns and multinational banks, I'm pretty sure gold and silver are going up, long-term.

Fraud and de-facto dictatorship, yes. That won't change until the system collapses, we agree on that much.

In the US and the UK alike, it doesn't make much difference whether you vote for the left or for the right, because the world is actually run by the banks.
 
Last edited:
pop!
Originally Posted by Roger Ramjets
Obviously the price of gold can't continue to rise at its current exponential rate...

Has the bubble burst? Spot Gold price dropped 12% in the last 30 days - almost back to where it was 2 months ago.

Will it continue to slide, or will it bounce back? I bet a few Gold bugs are feeling nervous right now...

exponential? all depends on your viewpoint. looks pretty standard stuff to me.

http://aaronbasile.files.wordpress.com/2011/09/gold-wkly-9-23-11.png

the trend is unbroken, wake me up if we get below 1480, I will need to load up with more
 
Last edited:
From my point of view, the "left wing" in the US hardly exists, when compared to the situation elsewhere in the developed world. I'm not really a left-winger. I'm a green, and not the idealistic leftie sort of green either. I didn't single out the right wing because I think the left wing has the answers (although I'd also disagree that it was the left which caused the mess we are in). I singled them out because, at least in the US, the far right is mainstream enough to wield real power, and the left is not, because it isn't big enough or left enough. There is no left wing equivalent of the tea-party movement.

The green party is more or less the left-wing equivalent of the tea-party, other than the fact that it is currently out-of-favor. The "left-wing" certainly exists, it just may not be "left" enough for you, or others to qualify it as such, especially compared with statist Europe. As I see it, the left-wing exists to "justify" the relentless encroachment of the Federal Government in our lives and its correspondent taxation, with promises of welfare and the redistribution of wealth. In reality, it brings corporate welfare, and just enough ill-gotten table scraps used to buy the votes of the poor and disenfranchised. When the "right-wing" is in power the taxing power of the state is used to fund perpetual war, and its attendant fraud and corruption.

Fraud and de-facto dictatorship, yes. That won't change until the system collapses, we agree on that much.

Alan Greenspan, former Fed Chairman, wrote an essay entitled Gold and Economic Freedom , in 1966. In this essay he wrote:

"In the absence of the gold standard, there is no way to protect savings from confiscation through inflation There is no safe store of value. If there were, the government would have to make its holding illegal, as was done in the case of gold. If everyone decided, for example, to convert all his bank deposits to silver or copper or any other good, and thereafter declined to accept checks as payment for goods, bank deposits would lose their purchasing power and government-created bank credit would be worthless as a claim on goods. The financial policy of the welfare state requires that there be no way for the owners of wealth to protect themselves.

This is the shabby secret of the welfare statists' tirades against gold. Deficit spending is simply a scheme for the confiscation of wealth. Gold stands in the way of this insidious process. It stands as a protector of property rights. If one grasps this, one has no difficulty in understanding the statists' antagonism toward the gold standard.

​

Since you implied that the US Government is far to the right of Europe, and not "left" enough for your tastes, that makes you a statist. If Greenspan was correct when he wrote this, and I think he was, then you should be antagonistic towards gold because it prefents deficit spending, and the encroachment of the state which you apparently desire. Is it that you hate gold, but recognize the inevitability of the current situation? I can't really understand why you would promote gold as you do, and yet not seem to realize how its absence permits the encroachment of the state. That's why I suggested you suffer from cognitive dissonance. You want an all powerful government, but you recognize the inherent futility of the debt crisis, and how gold relates to this, and so you're opportunistic about it.

So we have you, the gold-liking statist, and psion the gold-disliking non-statist (as much as I can glean from his writing). I guess that's what makes the market of ideas what it is, even though sometimes it doesn't make sense to me. I'd like to point out that I hesitate to use labels like left and right wing on people, as I reject those labels personally. I think statist is appropriate for you, since you favor a powerful role for the state. I'm happy describing myself as a minarchist. I don't mean statist as a pejorative. I disagree with a lot of what you've said, but I think you are honest, respectful, and eloquent (that goes for psion too), so I hope you don't take this criticism the wrong way.

In the US and the UK alike, it doesn't make much difference whether you vote for the left or for the right, because the world is actually run by the banks.

I agree. Lets disempower the governments that keep bailing them out perpetually, and who keep the scam running. Eventually maybe we can get the government to do at least the minimum of what both of us likely believe is its role: to enact justice.
 
Last edited:
The green party is more or less the left-wing equivalent of the tea-party, other than the fact that it is currently out-of-favor.

While I accept that there is a certain sort of stereotypical "green leftie", the greens are a fundamentally different sort of political movement to the Marxist/Socialist left. The reason for this left-ward tinge to the green party (internationally) is that some people (still) believe that the only way to tackle the global ecological issues is to work for a fairer distribution of wealth, but this is by no means taken for granted within the green movement in the way it is taken for granted by the true socialists. For (some) greens it is a means to an end (ecological sustainability.) For all socialists, it is the end in itself. In a clash between the needs of humans and the needs of the ecosystem, of which there will be a great many in the coming years, the true left will always prioritise humans, but true greens will prioritise the ecosytem, regardless of the cost to humans.

So what you are saying rather supports my point - there is so little resembling a real left-wing political movement in the US that you are having to point to the green party as the closest thing you can see.

The "left-wing" certainly exists, it just may not be "left" enough for you, or others to qualify it as such, especially compared with statist Europe.

Again, this statement only sounds normal in the US. From our point of view, Europe is pretty much politically central and the US is ludicrously right-wing. That's why you are calling us "statist."

As I see it, the left-wing exists to "justify" the relentless encroachment of the Federal Government in our lives and its correspondent taxation, with promises of welfare and the redistribution of wealth. In reality, it brings corporate welfare, and just enough ill-gotten table scraps used to buy the votes of the poor and disenfranchised. When the "right-wing" is in power the taxing power of the state is used to fund perpetual war, and its attendant fraud and corruption.

All of which is a highly US-centric perspective.

Since you implied that the US Government is far to the right of Europe, and not "left" enough for your tastes, that makes you a statist.

It's not just the government. The same applies to most of the public, who are fed a daily dose of right-wing propaganda by the corporate/bank-controlled media like Fox News.

And as I keep saying...my tastes are GREEN. I'm not actually defending the left. All I am doing is pointing out the difference between US and Europe regarding what is considered left, right and centre. What you think of as centre, most people in Europe regard as right wing. Not just me.

If Greenspan was correct when he wrote this, and I think he was, then you should be antagonistic towards gold because it prefents deficit spending, and the encroachment of the state which you apparently desire.

But I have an entirely different agenda and reasoning process, which you aren't taking into account. I defend gold as money over fiat currencies for two reasons, neither of which has anything to do with left/right politics. The first is purely pragmatic - the fiat currency system is broken and cannot be fixed, so it has to be replaced with something else, and gold or commodity-backed money would appear to be the only serious contender. The second is ecological - I believe we are heading into an era of declining availability of physical resources and declining population and consumption levels, and this in turns means that there will be no economic growth and no need to increase the money supply. I believe a return to the gold standard would reflect this physical reality by linking the amount of money to a physical resource of which there is a finite supply.

Right-wingers think I'm a left-winger. Communists and socialists regularly accuse me of "eco-fascism." I'm not supporting the left. I'm a true and radical green who rejects the basic premise shared by both the left and the right that our number one priority should be raising the living standards of humans and expanding the human operation on Earth.

Is it that you hate gold, but recognize the inevitability of the current situation? I can't really understand why you would promote gold as you do, and yet not seem to realize how its absence permits the encroachment of the state. That's why I suggested you suffer from cognitive dissonance. You want an all powerful government, but you recognize the inherent futility of the debt crisis, and how gold relates to this, and so you're opportunistic about it.

I only want an all-powerful government if it is a radical green government, which is highly unlikely to ever happen.

So we have you, the gold-liking statist, and psion the gold-disliking non-statist (as much as I can glean from his writing). I guess that's what makes the market of ideas what it is, even though sometimes it doesn't make sense to me. I'd like to point out that I hesitate to use labels like left and right wing on people, as I reject those labels personally. I think statist is appropriate for you, since you favor a powerful role for the state. I'm happy describing myself as a minarchist. I don't mean statist as a pejorative. I disagree with a lot of what you've said, but I think you are honest, respectful, and eloquent (that goes for psion too), so I hope you don't take this criticism the wrong way.

I'm not taking any of this personally. This is not the first time that people who haven't spend much time yet finding out where I'm coming from have trouble figuring it out. I haven't just given up hope for our existing monetary system. I've given up hope for the whole of civilisation as we know it. I believe that whatever we do, we are heading towards what will prove to be the most traumatic period of transition in the whole of human history. I believe Thomas Malthus is about to be proven spectacularly right.

I agree. Lets disempower the governments that keep bailing them out perpetually, and who keep the scam running. Eventually maybe we can get the government to do at least the minimum of what both of us likely believe is its role: to enact justice.

That is just one of its proper roles.
 
Last edited:
Tippit,

Just to help you get a handle on my position, let's imagine I've been put in a position of benevolent dictator of the UK (the US is slightly different, but something similar would apply). That is - I am free to implement whatever policies I choose with no fear of what will happen at the next election.

One of the things I would do would be to replace fiat sterling with a tri-metallic monetary system based on gold, silver and copper. I would also nationalise all banks and confiscate most of the wealth of existing bankers. I would replace the existing free market system with an "unfree" market which used a tax system to heavily subsidise any business which is seriously working for local/regional/national sustainability and heavily penalises those which are least sustainable. I would put high import taxes on all goods which are coming from outside what is now the EU but could just as easily (though not as cheaply) be produced within Europe. Ultimately, as the situation detiorates further, this could become more nationalistic than European. I would impose a one-child policy with large tax penalties for those with two or more children and tax breaks for everyone who remains childless. I would pass laws ensuring that all products made in the UK are 100% recyclable. I would confiscate land from every large private landowner in the UK (including the CofE and the monarchy, which I would nevertheless leave in place as a monarchy) and use the best of it for the establishment of sustainable eco-communities - places to go for people who want to opt out of the modern, industrialised world and work the land using permaculture systems which maximise the amount of food produced with a minimal amount of industrial/technological input required rather than maximising the profit as existing industrial agriculture does. In other words I would enable and encourage the start of a transition which will eventually take over the whole of society - a process which will take many decades.

And that's just the start.

Is that statist? Is that left wing? I'd argue that it blows the traditional left/right debate out of the water. It makes the bickering between the traditional left and right seem rather irrelevant and out-dated, and I suspect that people from both the left and the right will be equally horrified by much of what I've said in this post. For me, it is not really the size of the state which matters, but the basic assumptions about where humanity is heading and what we need to do in order to protect ourselves from the Great Catastrophe that is coming and prepare for an increasingly uncertain and difficult future. Some of the most dearly-held beliefs and objectives of both the right and the left will be shattered during this process. We can't let the existing powers-that-be run the world any longer, but any dreams the left has of freeing the poor from their poverty and establishing some sort of global socialist state are also going to be shattered. We cannot save all of the poor for the simple reason that there are already far more humans living on this planet than can be supported in without an endless supply of cheap oil. The poor are doomed because there are too many of them, and socialism as we know it just makes that particular problem even worse. The only solution to that problem, as every student of mediaevil English history should already know, is for there to be considerably fewer people. What we need right now is a 21st century equivalent of The Black Death.
 
Last edited:
I'm doing fine. Gold is back to levels it was at a couple of months ago. Silver looks weak, but physical demand, by all accounts is strong, CME and central bank manipulation notwithstanding. If it tanks more, I'll buy more. I know how the story is ending, this is just a shakedown.

:jaw-dropp Wow... No, "nice call"? No, "you were right... silver went to $28 range as you projected and then saw a bounce"?

Or "Gold is $250 lower than where you sold it short and has fallen 20% (high to recent low)"??

Just "I'm going to be right in the end more so than I was two months ago" and "here's my justification and explanation"???

Too funny.


.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom