But you have not shown my concept of God is an impossible concept like a 4-sided...
Before anything else, I have the pleasure of saluting you for not wallowing in flippancy thinking that you are saying anything useful with mockery, parody, and evasions.
You say: "I can indeed show that the concept is intrinsically impossible the same way I can show that a 4-sided triangle is intrinsically impossible."
But you have not shown my concept of God is an impossible concept like a 4-sided triangle.
Rewrite your post so that after that statement from you of your capacity to show my concept of God, namely:
Yrreg
Originally Posted by yrreg
So, you get the idea or the concept of God as a concept is not intrinsically impossible except to a truncated brain.
I know this thread has gone on for some time, and I'm jumping in medias res, but. . . .
Depending on the definition of God, I can indeed show that the concept is intrinsically impossible the same way I can show that a 4-sided triangle is intrinsically impossible.
So there are two responses to this: either you can refuse to define the concept of God (and since we're talking about deductive logic, I'm speaking of a formal logical definition which is a list of all characteristics such that you include in the class "God" what you mean to include and that you exclude from the class everything else), or you can offer a definition that is logically consistent.
If you do the former, there's no point in continuing the discussion, because without a formal definition of a concept, we cannot do any logic with it.
I certainly invite you to try the latter, but in my experience when anyone has succeeded, they have defined "God" in a way that conflicts with conventional usage of the term (such as the Deist notion of "God"). It would exclude characteristics that most theists do indeed mean to include, such as something you can have a personal relationship with, something that can listen sympathetically to human prayer, something that intervenes in the physical world at least on occasion, etc. You could win the argument with this alternatively defined concept of "God", but anytime you sought to extend that conclusion (i.e. that its existence is possible, or that it is not internally inconsistent) to the conventional usage of the term "God" you will be committing the fallacy of equivocation.
Before anything else, I have the pleasure of saluting you for not wallowing in flippancy thinking that you are saying anything useful with mockery, parody, and evasions.
You say: "I can indeed show that the concept is intrinsically impossible the same way I can show that a 4-sided triangle is intrinsically impossible."
But you have not shown my concept of God is an impossible concept like a 4-sided triangle.
Rewrite your post so that after that statement from you of your capacity to show my concept of God, namely:
maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself,
is an intrinsically impossible concept no different from the concept of a 4-sided triangle, insert your explanation and proof that my concept of God is an intrinsically impossible concept.Yrreg