God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

But you have not shown my concept of God is an impossible concept like a 4-sided...

Originally Posted by yrreg
So, you get the idea or the concept of God as a concept is not intrinsically impossible except to a truncated brain.




I know this thread has gone on for some time, and I'm jumping in medias res, but. . . .

Depending on the definition of God, I can indeed show that the concept is intrinsically impossible the same way I can show that a 4-sided triangle is intrinsically impossible.

So there are two responses to this: either you can refuse to define the concept of God (and since we're talking about deductive logic, I'm speaking of a formal logical definition which is a list of all characteristics such that you include in the class "God" what you mean to include and that you exclude from the class everything else), or you can offer a definition that is logically consistent.

If you do the former, there's no point in continuing the discussion, because without a formal definition of a concept, we cannot do any logic with it.

I certainly invite you to try the latter, but in my experience when anyone has succeeded, they have defined "God" in a way that conflicts with conventional usage of the term (such as the Deist notion of "God"). It would exclude characteristics that most theists do indeed mean to include, such as something you can have a personal relationship with, something that can listen sympathetically to human prayer, something that intervenes in the physical world at least on occasion, etc. You could win the argument with this alternatively defined concept of "God", but anytime you sought to extend that conclusion (i.e. that its existence is possible, or that it is not internally inconsistent) to the conventional usage of the term "God" you will be committing the fallacy of equivocation.


Before anything else, I have the pleasure of saluting you for not wallowing in flippancy thinking that you are saying anything useful with mockery, parody, and evasions.


You say: "I can indeed show that the concept is intrinsically impossible the same way I can show that a 4-sided triangle is intrinsically impossible."

But you have not shown my concept of God is an impossible concept like a 4-sided triangle.

Rewrite your post so that after that statement from you of your capacity to show my concept of God, namely:
maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself,​
is an intrinsically impossible concept no different from the concept of a 4-sided triangle, insert your explanation and proof that my concept of God is an intrinsically impossible concept.



Yrreg
 
Well, if you want to talk about the God of Deists, start your own thread.


Now, if you are interested in the Christian God Who in His fundamental concept in the Christian faith in again His fundamental (mark that word, fundamental, very very very important) relation to the universe, and you are impatient to read my presentation of the universe as evidence for God's existence, the Romans tell us that "sapienti pauca," meaning to the wise few words, here is the synopsis of my presentation:

We first agree on the concepts:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​

Then we agree on the fact that
the nose is a part of the universe and that the nose has a beginning and an ending.​


From those few statements, according to the Romans who tell us that "sapienti pauca," you should already come to the light that the universe is the evidence for God's existence.



Yrreg

Gerry,
For somebody that went to such great pains to create a logical construct, it's somewhat surprising that you threw away the construct you created, in search of the punchline.

Let me show you:

1. You state that it's a *Christian* belief that God created the Universe etc

2. You define the Universe (in the context of statement 1), so the *true* statement is that "it is the Christian belief that the Universe..." etc

3. The nose is indeed part of the Universe, totally independent of any definitions stated at 1 and 2. This statement stands alone and does not require any other statements to be true. Neither does this statement flow as an outcome from statements 1 and 2.

4. You state that the Universe is the evidence for God's existence. Again, this is not the logical outcome of statements 1 and 2 or 3. The correct statement is "It is the Christian belief that the Universe is the evidence of God's existence."

The existence of any body part is irrelevant to the logic attempted.
 
Yrreg, you don't seem to really be reading my posts. Let me try to make this simple.

I do not object to the idea that there may be a being, who can be called god, who created this universe.

I just don't understand what makes this being specifically Christian.
 
Not to worry, my concept of God is really very versatile, He is in and also out.

Originally Posted by yrreg

You say: "I'll talk about any god you like, but the definition you gave isn't distinctively Christian."


Here is my concept of God that is distinctively Christian in His fundamental relation to the universe:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

You know better, okay, you tell me what to you is the distinctively Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe, but not in more than ten words.


We are back to concepts, I have to put on abeyance my presentation of the universe as the evidence for God's existence.


You know, dear readers, all reasoning is about the concepts involved, once people get to comprehend correctly the concepts involved, they will understand and accept a proposition that is immediately true on the concepts involved once comprehended correctly.

The task therefore facing everyone is to collaborate to come to the correct comprehension of the concepts involved.





Dear Mister Agenda, I like to ask you whether you know the difference between something that is distinctive of a person and something that is peculiar or particular of a person.

What is the point of insisting on the fact that other religions also have a God that is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself, namely, that therefore God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe is not the right God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe?

Much ado about nothing unless you want to insist that in the Christian faith God in concept is not the maker of everything in the universe that is not God, which is absolutely being mis-informed.

Before anything and everything else, on concept in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe,
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God himself.

If you don't know that concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, then you are ignorant of the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.


And therefore you are in the wrong thread.



Yrreg


Be careful there. I don't think you can place God within the universe and have a god at all. You need to think very carefully about the implications of a god that can be considered a part of the universe.


Not to worry, my concept of God is really very versatile, He is in and also out at the same time because He is really huge, He is in concept and in reality co-terminous with space and time and outside space and time.

Impossible?

To a self-truncated-brain without capability of imagination, of course.


You know the air you breathe everywhere, it is inside your car and outside.

God in concept and in reality is both inside the universe and part of the universe and also in all proper sense outside or without as opposed to within the universe of His creation.


How is that?

Meditate the way Descarte and Pascal meditate, not like the way Buddhists meditate all the way to non-existence of the self, on these themes:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​



Yrreg
 
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

This is unfortunately not a sentence. Did you instead mean to write

God = In the Christian faith, and in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


?
 
And you are in deep self-dungeoned freeze for not following the lead.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Well, if you want to talk about the God of Deists, start your own thread.


Now, if you are interested in the Christian God Who in His fundamental concept in the Christian faith in again His fundamental (mark that word, fundamental, very very very important) relation to the universe, and you are impatient to read my presentation of the universe as evidence for God's existence, the Romans tell us that "sapienti pauca," meaning to the wise few words, here is the synopsis of my presentation:

We first agree on the concepts:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

Then we agree on the fact that

the nose is a part of the universe and that the nose has a beginning and an ending.

From those few statements, according to the Romans who tell us that "sapienti pauca," you should already come to the light that the universe is the evidence for God's existence.



Yrreg







Gerry,
For somebody that went to such great pains to create a logical construct, it's somewhat surprising that you threw away the construct you created, in search of the punchline.

Let me show you:

1. You state that it's a *Christian* belief that God created the Universe etc

2. You define the Universe (in the context of statement 1), so the *true* statement is that "it is the Christian belief that the Universe..." etc

3. The nose is indeed part of the Universe, totally independent of any definitions stated at 1 and 2. This statement stands alone and does not require any other statements to be true. Neither does this statement flow as an outcome from statements 1 and 2.

4. You state that the Universe is the evidence for God's existence. Again, this is not the logical outcome of statements 1 and 2 or 3. The correct statement is "It is the Christian belief that the Universe is the evidence of God's existence."

The existence of any body part is irrelevant to the logic attempted.



Do you deny that the nose is a part of the universe, yes, no?


And you are in deep self-dungeoned freeze for not following the lead.



Again, the Romans tell us "sapienti pauca," meaning to the wise few words.



Are you acquainted with the concept of what is evidence, so that a part of a human found on the ground all by itself is the evidence of the existence of the whole man, and all the police investigator has to do is to look for the identity of the human with a missing nose or a human cadaver with a missing nose that has the same DNA.

Now, remember "sapienti pauca," to the wise few words, you see a nose in the vast universe which is a part of a human being or any creature with a nose in the face, which nose as with its owner has a begining and an ending, what can you reason out already?


Here, let me tell you how to prove something to be existing in reality:

1. By inspection, so you prove that there is a nose in your face by inspecting your face.

2. By investigation, so you want to prove that the severed nose belongs to someone, you do investigation to locate that someone with a missing nose or a cadaver with a missing nose but with the same identical DNA as the nose.

3. Suppose the thing or entity is very huge on the one hand and very subtle on the other hand, that is the end creator of a nose, you do ratiocination, i.e., reasoning from what you know for a fact to the ascertainment that it the nose comes from the entity that is so huge and so subtle that you cannot inspect it much less go about investigating it everywhere all the time, and that is what I call proof by evidence through ratiocination i.e. reasoning.

The nose and everything in the universe as also the whole universe is evidence of the creator God according to the concept of God = maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.



You are in deep self-dungeoned freeze for not following the lead.

Time for yo to thaw yourself out of your self-dungeoned deep freeze and learn to follow the lead, i.e. evidence.


You are entangled hopelessly with syllogistic reasoning neglecting to go to the evidence, to follow the lead.



Now, let me see how you react to my ratiocination, i.e. reasoning.




Yrreg
 
Well, the fact is that the concept of God as the maker of everything in the...

Yrreg, you don't seem to really be reading my posts. Let me try to make this simple.

I do not object to the idea that there may be a being, who can be called god, who created this universe.

I just don't understand what makes this being specifically Christian.



Well, if you don't feel that you should identify this God as the Christian God, then it is no trouble for me.

My purpose is to present the universe as the evidence for God's existence, which God is understood in His fundamental relation to the universe as maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


Then why do I specify that God in the Christian faith, etc.?

Because I am a Christian.

But before anything else I am a human being possessed of reason and free will, and if I were not a Christian but working from reason with an honest free will I would still come to the concept of God in His fundamental relation to the universe as the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


Well, the fact is that the concept of God as the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself is a conclusion of human reason without any need for any revelation found in the Bible or in the Koran or in the whatever Book of Mormon or whatever books of the Baha'i folks.



Your next question is why am I a Christian?

That is a personal choice which I think I have made in all honesty with the sincere and unblindered use of my reason and intelligence.


In other words my choice of a faith in Christianity is founded on my best judgment on consideration of the most rational and the most intelligent justification for doing so.


You will insist that there have been and are still bad Christians.

Correct.

But that does not render the Christian faith not as far as my honest reason and intelligence and exercise of free choice is concerned, that does not render the Christian faith less appealing to me: it however requires me to judiciously choose the right kinds of Christians to associate with.




Yrreg
 
But you have not shown my concept of God is an impossible concept like a 4-sided triangle.

Impossible? Perhaps; but your concept of God is most certainly nonsensical for the reasons I've already stated twice.

There are several others who wish to play your little game however, and that's cool. I'm just wishing that you'll get on with your main point.
 
Do you have a blind spot in your mind or brain?

Originally Posted by yrreg
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.



This is unfortunately not a sentence. Did you instead mean to write

God = In the Christian faith, and in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


?



Well, if you are a teacher of correct writing, you have a point there.

Now, if you are a teacher of effective communication, then I submit you should get my thought correctly, unless you want to be quarrelsome.


Tell me what you don't find comprehensible with my concept of God, as: The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.


Ah yes, a definition should not contain in the text of the definition the word to be defined.

Correct.


That is what someone pointed out to me and felt so very self-congratulatory, but I told him he has a blind spot in his mind or brain.


Do you want me to tell you why I told him he has a blind spot in his mind or brain?




Yrreg
 
First, before anything else, I have the privilege of saluting you for not going into mockery, parody, and evasions with a heart and mind polluted with flippancy and zilch in place of real thinking and speaking as to communicate viably and civilly.


Belief has got nothing to do when we talk about concepts, we are dealing with possibilities when we talk concepts while prescinding (yes, there is a word, to prescind) from actual realities.

So, let us imagine that we never know about airplanes, then one of us who does have a gift for imagination and comes up with the idea of a ship that sails in the air instead of in the water.

Belief in an air cruising ship is not the case here with the idea of this creative thinker with a good imagination, it has to do with the possibility of such a ship.

Now, people who have the discipline of genuine thinking will examine his idea of an air-cruising-ship, they analyze the concept of any components that cannot be compatible among themselves so that the concept cannot be imagined at all, it is an impossible concept.

It takes a genius of a mind to imagine an air-cruising-ship, and it takes a self-truncated brain to not see the intrinsic possibility of such a concept, because his brain is self-truncated to limit possible motion to only on water or on land, but not in the air or in non-water and non-land space.

You see, self-brain-truncated folks are not only mind-blind, but they don't even see with their eyes what is before their eyes, namely, that birds fly, so why should it not be possible that a vessel can be fabricated to move from one point in space to another outside of water and land, as birds do.


So, you get the idea or the concept of God as a concept is not intrinsically impossible except to a truncated brain.


That concept of God, namely:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


I know of people who are into the livelihood and make a good living as home renovators, they are operating as one-man worker but with power tools and machinery.

This guy contracted to remodel my brother's home comes with a big van carrying all his hand tools, power tools, and craft machinery.

He does everything in the house to renovate it so that when you see it again it looks new and different outside and inside.

You ask but answer your own question yes: That guy does everything in the house? Yes!


So, I have a proposition to search in the universe for evidence that there is an agent who made everything in the universe so that everything in the universe that is not himself is made by him.

You cannot grasp that? you have a self-truncated brain?



Yrreg
But you point out the issue here yourself ...

If you see a bird, and say to yourself, "I can create something that will allow me to fly as well," and I see the bird, and I say, "it can never be done ..." .... the evidence that it can be done is the resulting airplane.

So lets assume there is the possibility that the universe and everything in it was created by God, and the evidence being the universe itself. In your analogies, the key component that makes one thing stand out from another, is comparison to points of reference. Compare birds to themselves, and airplanes are impossible. Once we have airplanes though ... we have planes and birds, and more points of reference. It opens up a new paradigm so to speak. The same with the handyman. He comes in, fixes up a house to look completely different. Two points of reference so that we can see .... yes, aviation is reality, not just possibility. Yes, the existence of a handyman is reality, not just possibility.

What is the other point of reference here for the God who is everything else ? "Possibility" ? If raw possibility is the point of reference, you are back at square one because then I can say God is the FSM, because I can imagine it as a possibility.
 
You still have not shown why my concept of God is impossible or nonsensical.

Originally Posted by yrreg
But you have not shown my concept of God is an impossible concept like a 4-sided triangle.



Impossible? Perhaps; but your concept of God is most certainly nonsensical for the reasons I've already stated twice.

There are several others who wish to play your little game however, and that's cool. I'm just wishing that you'll get on with your main point.


You still have not shown why my concept of God is impossible or nonsensical.


You are into mockery, parody, and evasions, mostly into evasions moved by the spirit to be flippant and to dwell on mockery and parody.

You don't believe that?

Better not, otherwise you might feel the need to compensate for your confusion, with more of mockery, parody, evasions, and general flippancy.




Okay, just show how my concept of God as the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself is an impossible concept or a nonsensical concept.


Produce your reasons again, because you are one poster I have chosen to not give any attention to except today because you stirred up my curiosity, on what is your latest flippancy blowhard.



Yrreg
 
You still have not shown why my concept of God is impossible or nonsensical.


Yrreg

A female god who created the universe and was destroyed in its making and left us her final words, "Women are the masters of the household and men are to be subservient to them".

You've not shown why that concept of god is impossible or nonsensical. Are you saying that your brain is a period?
 
Please be clear what you are trying to say.

Originally Posted by yrreg
First, before anything else, I have the privilege of saluting you for not going into mockery, parody, and evasions with a heart and mind polluted with flippancy and zilch in place of real thinking and speaking as to communicate viably and civilly.


Belief has got nothing to do when we talk about concepts, we are dealing with possibilities when we talk concepts while prescinding (yes, there is a word, to prescind) from actual realities.

So, let us imagine that we never know about airplanes, then one of us who does have a gift for imagination and comes up with the idea of a ship that sails in the air instead of in the water.

Belief in an air cruising ship is not the case here with the idea of this creative thinker with a good imagination, it has to do with the possibility of such a ship.

Now, people who have the discipline of genuine thinking will examine his idea of an air-cruising-ship, they analyze the concept of any components that cannot be compatible among themselves so that the concept cannot be imagined at all, it is an impossible concept.

It takes a genius of a mind to imagine an air-cruising-ship, and it takes a self-truncated brain to not see the intrinsic possibility of such a concept, because his brain is self-truncated to limit possible motion to only on water or on land, but not in the air or in non-water and non-land space.

You see, self-brain-truncated folks are not only mind-blind, but they don't even see with their eyes what is before their eyes, namely, that birds fly, so why should it not be possible that a vessel can be fabricated to move from one point in space to another outside of water and land, as birds do.


So, you get the idea or the concept of God as a concept is not intrinsically impossible except to a truncated brain.


That concept of God, namely:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

I know of people who are into the livelihood and make a good living as home renovators, they are operating as one-man worker but with power tools and machinery.

This guy contracted to remodel my brother's home comes with a big van carrying all his hand tools, power tools, and craft machinery.

He does everything in the house to renovate it so that when you see it again it looks new and different outside and inside.

You ask but answer your own question yes: That guy does everything in the house? Yes!


So, I have a proposition to search in the universe for evidence that there is an agent who made everything in the universe so that everything in the universe that is not himself is made by him.

You cannot grasp that? you have a self-truncated brain?



Yrreg




But you point out the issue here yourself ...

If you see a bird, and say to yourself, "I can create something that will allow me to fly as well," and I see the bird, and I say, "it can never be done ..." .... the evidence that it can be done is the resulting airplane.

So lets assume there is the possibility that the universe and everything in it was created by God, and the evidence being the universe itself. In your analogies, the key component that makes one thing stand out from another, is comparison to points of reference. Compare birds to themselves, and airplanes are impossible. Once we have airplanes though ... we have planes and birds, and more points of reference. It opens up a new paradigm so to speak. The same with the handyman. He comes in, fixes up a house to look completely different. Two points of reference so that we can see .... yes, aviation is reality, not just possibility. Yes, the existence of a handyman is reality, not just possibility.

What is the other point of reference here for the God who is everything else ? "Possibility" ? If raw possibility is the point of reference, you are back at square one because then I can say God is the FSM, because I can imagine it as a possibility.



Please be clear what you are trying to say.


I say that there are potential beings in the universe which potential beings are accessible to man's mind so that man have concepts of these potential beings even though only as concepts but possible concepts, not impossible concepts like a square circle.

But man does not have all the potential concepts in the universe because he is not capable of getting acquainted with all the potential concepts which do exist in the universe.


If you comprehend what I am saying, tell me what you don't accept because I am not saying something that is comprehensible to you, for the reason that it is something that is patently irrational to you for being imposible in terms of your kind of rational conceptuality.


What I seem to get you is that you are of the conviction man knows about a possibility of something only afterwards when that something has been invented by man.

Is that your conviction?


Okay, then give me two examples of something that man knows afterwards to be possibilities, afterwards namely after when some man has already invented them.


I fear you are playing a self-dummy game.



You should acquire the discipline of working out your ideas before you put them to words, and also acquire the discipline of rational employment of words, otherwise you are saying things unclearly, and thus either betraying your limited mental resources or your lack of sincerity.




Yrreg
 
Not to worry, my concept of God is really very versatile, He is in and also out at the same time because He is really huge, He is in concept and in reality co-terminous with space and time and outside space and time.

Impossible?

To a self-truncated-brain without capability of imagination, of course.


You know the air you breathe everywhere, it is inside your car and outside.

God in concept and in reality is both inside the universe and part of the universe and also in all proper sense outside or without as opposed to within the universe of His creation.


How is that?

Meditate the way Descarte and Pascal meditate, not like the way Buddhists meditate all the way to non-existence of the self, on these themes:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​



Yrreg
If you're really trying to express the omnipresence of God by comparing it to the air inside and outside of my car, then I don't think you're thinking very carefully about the implications of divinity.

I still, anyway, cannot accept your definition of God as the maker of the universe, because that presupposes that the universe was made, and that god made it. That is a story, not a definition. I can easily accept as a working definition that God has the power to make universes and could do so in the way that christians and other theists assume was done. But the definition you propose has an illegal payload.
 
So, bruto, suppose you tell the readers and me what is your concept of God?

Originally Posted by yrreg
Not to worry, my concept of God is really very versatile, He is in and also out at the same time because He is really huge, He is in concept and in reality co-terminous with space and time and outside space and time.

Impossible?

To a self-truncated-brain without capability of imagination, of course.


You know the air you breathe everywhere, it is inside your car and outside.

God in concept and in reality is both inside the universe and part of the universe and also in all proper sense outside or without as opposed to within the universe of His creation.


How is that?

Meditate the way Descarte and Pascal meditate, not like the way Buddhists meditate all the way to non-existence of the self, on these themes:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.


Yrreg




If you're really trying to express the omnipresence of God by comparing it to the air inside and outside of my car, then I don't think you're thinking very carefully about the implications of divinity.

I still, anyway, cannot accept your definition of God as the maker of the universe, because that presupposes that the universe was made, and that god made it. That is a story, not a definition. I can easily accept as a working definition that God has the power to make universes and could do so in the way that Christians and other theists assume was done. But the definition you propose has an illegal payload.



You are worried for God.

Not to worry for God, He can take care of Himself.



Suppose you tell me and the readers here what is your concept of God?




Dear readers here:

I thought I had already two posters here who have agreed with me on the concepts of God and of the universe and on the fact that the nose is a part of the universe and the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending, and I also said that for the Romans who subscribe to "sapienti pauca," meaning for the wise few words, the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending is already clear evidence in the universe that God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


Well, I guess we are still in the concepts coordinating stage of this thread.


So, bruto, suppose you tell the readers and me what is your concept of God?




For latecomers, here are my concepts of God and of the universe, and I am asking for inputs from others to add to or by which to revise my concepts, in order to come to mutually accepted concepts, because without first coming to commonly accepted concepts it is illogical to talk at all together, because we will be speaking past each other's heads.

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​



And that is what I have seen all the time with atheists, they are notorious for talking past your heads, dwelling in and spewing forth mockery, parody, and evasions, indulging in flippancy including the mention of penis time and again, just to disrupt, derail, or sabotage the thread -- never really sincerely truly honestly rationally substantially patiently and productively above all cooperatively coming to the resolution of the issue God or no God.


Have you readers here noticed the volumes of flippant posts here which are into mockery, parody, and evasions, instead of sincere intelligent exchange of ideas?




Yrreg
 
Gerry,
For somebody that went to such great pains to create a logical construct, it's somewhat surprising that you threw away the construct you created, in search of the punchline.

Let me show you:

1. You state that it's a *Christian* belief that God created the Universe etc

2. You define the Universe (in the context of statement 1), so the *true* statement is that "it is the Christian belief that the Universe..." etc

3. The nose is indeed part of the Universe, totally independent of any definitions stated at 1 and 2. This statement stands alone and does not require any other statements to be true. Neither does this statement flow as an outcome from statements 1 and 2.

4. You state that the Universe is the evidence for God's existence. Again, this is not the logical outcome of statements 1 and 2 or 3. The correct statement is "It is the Christian belief that the Universe is the evidence of God's existence."

The existence of any body part is irrelevant to the logic attempted.

Do you deny that the nose is a part of the universe, yes, no?


And you are in deep self-dungeoned freeze for not following the lead.



Again, the Romans tell us "sapienti pauca," meaning to the wise few words.



Are you acquainted with the concept of what is evidence, so that a part of a human found on the ground all by itself is the evidence of the existence of the whole man, and all the police investigator has to do is to look for the identity of the human with a missing nose or a human cadaver with a missing nose that has the same DNA.

Now, remember "sapienti pauca," to the wise few words, you see a nose in the vast universe which is a part of a human being or any creature with a nose in the face, which nose as with its owner has a begining and an ending, what can you reason out already?


Here, let me tell you how to prove something to be existing in reality:

1. By inspection, so you prove that there is a nose in your face by inspecting your face.

2. By investigation, so you want to prove that the severed nose belongs to someone, you do investigation to locate that someone with a missing nose or a cadaver with a missing nose but with the same identical DNA as the nose.

3. Suppose the thing or entity is very huge on the one hand and very subtle on the other hand, that is the end creator of a nose, you do ratiocination, i.e., reasoning from what you know for a fact to the ascertainment that it the nose comes from the entity that is so huge and so subtle that you cannot inspect it much less go about investigating it everywhere all the time, and that is what I call proof by evidence through ratiocination i.e. reasoning.

The nose and everything in the universe as also the whole universe is evidence of the creator God according to the concept of God = maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.



You are in deep self-dungeoned freeze for not following the lead.

Time for yo to thaw yourself out of your self-dungeoned deep freeze and learn to follow the lead, i.e. evidence.


You are entangled hopelessly with syllogistic reasoning neglecting to go to the evidence, to follow the lead.



Now, let me see how you react to my ratiocination, i.e. reasoning.




Yrreg

Gerry,
I am trying to help you with your logic here, and all you can do is criticize and insult.

Let me make this perfectly clear: nothing in your posts has established evidence that god created the Universe, because you have not demonstrated any evidence for God. That the Universe exists is evidence that it exists, not that God created it.

Your attempt to use logic was and is flawed, because the conclusion is not based on the propositions - you draw a conclusion not in evidence by switching from stating a belief, to using that belief as if it is a fact.

Your. logic. does. not. work.

Feel free to repeat your logic statements in your response to this post. Look at them carefully.
 
Last edited:
Have you readers here noticed the volumes of flippant posts here which are into mockery, parody, and evasions, instead of sincere intelligent exchange of ideas?




Yrreg

You're the only one who hasn't noticed that it's because what you say is ridiculous. I told you to use logic. You should have listened to me.
 
Please be clear what you are trying to say.


I say that there are potential beings in the universe which potential beings are accessible to man's mind so that man have concepts of these potential beings even though only as concepts but possible concepts, not impossible concepts like a square circle.

But man does not have all the potential concepts in the universe because he is not capable of getting acquainted with all the potential concepts which do exist in the universe.


If you comprehend what I am saying, tell me what you don't accept because I am not saying something that is comprehensible to you, for the reason that it is something that is patently irrational to you for being imposible in terms of your kind of rational conceptuality.


What I seem to get you is that you are of the conviction man knows about a possibility of something only afterwards when that something has been invented by man.

Is that your conviction?


Okay, then give me two examples of something that man knows afterwards to be possibilities, afterwards namely after when some man has already invented them.


I fear you are playing a self-dummy game.



You should acquire the discipline of working out your ideas before you put them to words, and also acquire the discipline of rational employment of words, otherwise you are saying things unclearly, and thus either betraying your limited mental resources or your lack of sincerity.




Yrreg
Bolded part mine.

I'm not trying to understand my own convictions here, I am trying to summarize and understand your concept of God to see if it holds up apart from both my conviction, and your conviction. If God's existence is dependent upon one or both of our convictions, then the moment our convictions change so to does God, unless you continually move the goalposts of your convictions, or it can be shown that you are mentally deficient or confused for any variety of reasons, which can actually be quite normal reasons depending on what they are.

It seems to me that you keep finding God in your imagination and mind, and in those whom you identify with your same imagination (i.e. those who agree with you). Those who don't agree with you, you don't find God there and it must be because they are blind to it.

Where is this possible being outside of both your mind, and the mind of the one who doesn't agree with you ?

More importantly ... what I'd like to know from your idea, is what is the practical application of what you're saying ? Do you do something different with your life than you normally would ? Tell me how this plays out in the world around you with you in it, not just your mind. How does this effect those who don't agree with you ? Is it a matter of you pointing out who you find to be faulty and that's the extent of this God while you protect yourself from those who find you faulty ? It seems like a closed loop system dependent upon your ability to protect your idea .... so again, practical application.

If someone is experiencing a myocardial infarction in front of me, what are you going to do differently for them, to them, based on what you're saying about God and possible beings ?
 
Last edited:
You are worried for God.

Not to worry for God, He can take care of Himself.



Suppose you tell me and the readers here what is your concept of God?




Dear readers here:

I thought I had already two posters here who have agreed with me on the concepts of God and of the universe and on the fact that the nose is a part of the universe and the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending, and I also said that for the Romans who subscribe to "sapienti pauca," meaning for the wise few words, the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending is already clear evidence in the universe that God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


Well, I guess we are still in the concepts coordinating stage of this thread.


So, bruto, suppose you tell the readers and me what is your concept of God?


For latecomers, here are my concepts of God and of the universe, and I am asking for inputs from others to add to or by which to revise my concepts, in order to come to mutually accepted concepts, because without first coming to commonly accepted concepts it is illogical to talk at all together, because we will be speaking past each other's heads.

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​



And that is what I have seen all the time with atheists, they are notorious for talking past your heads, dwelling in and spewing forth mockery, parody, and evasions, indulging in flippancy including the mention of penis time and again, just to disrupt, derail, or sabotage the thread -- never really sincerely truly honestly rationally substantially patiently and productively above all cooperatively coming to the resolution of the issue God or no God.


Have you readers here noticed the volumes of flippant posts here which are into mockery, parody, and evasions, instead of sincere intelligent exchange of ideas?




Yrreg
I just did. You ignored it. My concept of God, or at least the working definition of that concept that I would be willing to discuss here, is a supreme being with the ability to create universes. I smell an ontological proof in your defnition. My defnition allows the concept of God without carrying the necessary assumption that this power has been exercised in the creation of the universe we inhabit.

I am not worried for God at all. If there's a god it can take care of itself, as it obviously must have done since the creation, having graciously stepped aside and let the universe do its own thing.

It is generally conceded that the range of possible numbers is infinite. Yet, I can find a range of numbers, for example, 1 to 10, and it is quite obviously finite, with a beginning and an end. Does this prove that the range of possible numbers is finite? Why does the finiteness of the nose prove anything about the universe it's in?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom