God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

The rest of you who don't agree with me, there can be no logical exchange with you because you are talking about other things.

So there is no sense with me giving you any attention whatsoever.

"I'll only talk to people who agree with me".

So much for open debate.
 
Okay, you tell me then what is your concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.

In the Christian faith, God spoke the universe into existence, created the first man from dust and the first woman from the man's rib, exiled them from a paradise for eating a forbidden fruit, destroyed all but a handful of humanity with a global flood, freed the Hebrews from Egyptian bondage through a series of plagues and other miracles, caused an engaged Hebrew virgin teenaged girl to become pregnant, incarnated in the form of his own son, who preached and performed miracles, got crucified by the Romans, resurrected and appeared to many people, ascended into heaven, and will return to judge the world.

You don't want to talk about the Christian God?

I'll talk about any god you like, but the definition you gave isn't distinctively Christian, and if you change the definition to be specific to Yahweh/Jehovah/Jesus, you have to do a lot more than just establish that the universe was created by someone: you have to also establish that the someone was the Christian god. Taking on 'there's a creator' before 'and it's 'the god of Christianity' is advisable, but you don't have to take my well-meant advice.

But that is what I am concerned with, or you want to talk about the gods of other religions?

I'm just responding to your posts. If you want to put the cart before the horse, knock yourself out. The 'maker of the universe' definition covers a broad class of deities, of which yours is only one. The smart thing to do would be to put off talk of any specific god until after you've made the case for a creator god at all, but you are more than welcome to go your own way.

In which case I must ask of you to depart from this thread because all my concern is with the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe, and I have defined my concept of the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe as:

God = Maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.


And my definition of the concept of the universe is:

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

Must you, really?

I fear that you are in the wrong thread, please leave at your earliest convenience.

I fear that any thread begun by you is the wrong thread in which to be, but I'll soldier on somehow. Please understand that I truly do take your requests and recommendations as seriously as you do mine.

Otherwise I will seriously suspect that you are into mockery, parody, and evasions, more in particular, evasions.

Yrreg

Naturally, I'm quite alarmed that you might suspect me of such things, especially seriously, but I'm deficient in my capacity to be concerned about what you suspect.
 
Last edited:
Alright, so we are discussing the Catholic version of the Christian god here, right? I'm assuming Orthodox Catholicism since that makes it easier, we don't have to ask which bits are not considered valid.

Ok, so what now? I have what I think your god is like in mind and as several other posters have pointed out there are a lot of details to that god beyond just "creator of the universe". It is not difficult to envision a being who created this universe but all of the extra details of it being the Catholic Christian god muddy the matter considerably.

So, why the Catholic Christian god? What make that particular being more likely than the Deist version of a creator god? How does it compare to Brahma or Amon? Note that I have no hostility towards any deistic world view, I just want to understand why you hold this view and what it means to you.
 
Why don't you just post your argument, premise to conclusion?
It would give you a chance to actually state it (a position I honestly cannot recall you ever having reached before), and it would not give the "wastrels" time to distract you with their banter.

Yes, but it would spoil his dream of being able to lure unsuspecting atheists into his "clever" trap, exclaim "HAHA GOTCHA" and then watch them drop to their knees and beg Jesus for forgiveness. Basically, yrreg thinks life is a Chick Tract, and he's frustrated that we don't all parrot our assigned dialogue.
 
this thread, like so many of its ilk, grows so fast that it's hard to follow, so forgive me if I repeat something, but I think a fundamental flaw in Yrreg's definition of God is that it includes the creation story itself.

Yrreg, I propose a compromise definition of God, which should be satisfactory as far as it goes, though perhaps incomplete relative to yours. But this defnition would not require accepting the creation story in order to accept the concept of God.

Consider stipulating that the concept of "God" is a supreme being with the ability to create universes. By definition outside the universe, the powers and attributes of such a god would be outside of understanding or explanation.

The universe is everything that exists that is not God.

Now all you have to do is prove that such a god exists, and that, if such a god exists, it created the universe.
 
Things imaginable are those entities that do not actually exist in reality but their concepts are possible, so that they are called potential beings, and they are real entities though not actual entities.


That is the point I take great efforts to explain to posters here but they are not receptive to the idea, namely, that the universe also houses potential beings, and that actual beings could not have attained actual status of reality in the universe: unless they were possible concepts or potential beings in the universe antecedent to their transit to the status of actual real existence.


Can you comprehend what I am saying?

Yes, I understand it and no, I don't agree with it.
 
You joining in the expedition? If so, then get in the bus.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Here again are my concepts of God and the universe:


God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.


For those who accept them for the purpose of this thread, that the universe is the evidence for the existence of God, we are now into effecting an agreement on whether in nose in our face has a beginning and an ending.



I have to make a list of such posters who agree with me on my concepts of God and the universe.


The rest of you who don't agree with me, there can be no logical exchange with you because you are talking about other things.

So there is no sense with me giving you any attention whatsoever.


Yrreg



I'm not sure what being on the list means but I'm pretty sure I agree with you but I'm not 100% clear on what the thread is about. I would simplify your equations by saying:

God = Existence
Universe = Everything caused by God

I think the "man made concepts" part has to do with negative theology. That is, you start from things and work your way up to God. If you take every affirmation and denial, apply them to God, and remove the ones that are less like God. As you get closer to accurately describing him, you will have less terms to use and will ultimately run out before you get to the level of God. So we are forced to use human concepts/words to give a very rough approximation of what He truly is.

None of this means that you can't talk about whether or not He exists. Thomas Aquinas showed that God's existence isn't self evident and also provided demonstrations that he does exist (I'm staying away from the word 'proof' deliberately). You seem to be saying that his existence is self evident and you shouldn't try to demonstrate it (unless I misunderstand). I can't say anything about the nose except that it was made for smelling



You joining in the expedition? If so, then get in the bus.


Do your serious reading and thinking and come to the gist of this thread, namely:
The universe is the evidence for God's existence.​


Do I put you in the list of passengers in my bus of an expedition to seek in the universe the evidence for God's existence?


Let me know.




Yrreg
 
You joining in the expedition? If so, then get in the bus.


Do your serious reading and thinking and come to the gist of this thread, namely:
The universe is the evidence for God's existence.​


Do I put you in the list of passengers in my bus of an expedition to seek in the universe the evidence for God's existence?


Let me know.




Yrreg

It's the short bus, isn't it.
 
Beware of the self-truncated mind that can't access the reality of potential beings.

Originally Posted by yrreg
*Do you, Robert Oz, have some question about the universe containing also things imaginable and at least can be the subject of man's discourse?


Things imaginable are those entities that do not actually exist in reality but their concepts are possible, so that they are called potential beings, and they are real entities though not actual entities.


That is the point I take great efforts to explain to posters here but they are not receptive to the idea, namely, that the universe also houses potential beings, and that actual beings could not have attained actual status of reality in the universe: unless they were possible concepts or potential beings in the universe antecedent to their transit to the status of actual real existence.


Can you comprehend what I am saying?





Yes, we can imagine beings that later turn out to be real, as in to actually exist independent of our imagination. It is possible to conceive of something before discovering its existence.

However, the imagined thing may or may not actually exist in the universe. So, I would agree that the universe contains undiscovered realities. Even realities that we could possibly imagine without having observed.

You are, however, incorrect that the universe includes all things that we can imagine or conceive of. It may include some, but certainly not all, and I would argue that whenever we imagine something, the less evidence there is to support it, the less likely it is for that imagined thing to turn out to actually exist. I would also argue that where there is no evidence, the imagined thing is highly unlikely to exist and if it happens to exist, our conception of it is unrelated to the actual being and was simply a lucky guess.

I am happy for your definition of the universe to be all things that exist, including as yet undiscovered things, some of which are possible for us to imagine. I do not accept your definition including all things we can imagine.



RO, this is a side discussion on the reality of imaginable or possible entities, we will resume the main subject afterwards, at least for the present we are agreed on our concepts of God and the universe, on the existence of the universe and on the fact of the nose being a part of the universe and that the nose has a beginning and an ending.



You say, "You are, however, incorrect that the universe includes all things that we can imagine or conceive of."


Look at it this way: If we can imagine a thing though it does not exist in actual reality, then it does exist in potential reality which potential reality is a realm of existence independent of our mind, but we need our mind to get to know them.

So, the realm of potential reality is greater than the representatives of this realm which our mind has acquaintance of.


That is why I say that the universe is
the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.​


Not all human minds have the capability and productive thinking prowess to come to more and more exquisite concepts of potential entities, ordinary people do not possess that creative gift.

But that innate gift can be and is suppressed by a self-inured truncated worldview.

You can notice such a self-truncated worldview that suppresses the creative gift which I might even call genius, in the way the subject of such a truncated worldview talks, they use flippant language and engage in mockery, parody, and evasions when faced with truly creative ideas which reach into the vast realm of potential entities in the universe of the totality of existence.

And then they have this self-mind-truncating dictum,
we cannot know therefore we must not ask anything about what we cannot know, period.​


But since such self-mind-truncating folks have already a self-lobotomized brain, they cannot even just suspect why they should judge that there are things they cannot know therefore period for them -- wherefore their mind is a period.




Yrreg
 
We are not in concepts here talking about beliefs, but about possibilities.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Here, I have two posters who agree to accept my concepts of God and of the universe.


1. Poster X:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php...&postcount=317

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php...&postcount=322

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php...&postcount=326



2. Poster Robert Oz:





===================


So, to enumerate the points of agreement:

1. On the concept of God: God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

2. On the concept of the universe: Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

3. On the fact of the nose being a part of the universe.

4. On the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending.


Now, I just want to assure you two, X and Robert Oz, that we are into concepts with God and universe.

The existence of God is the reality to be established that corresponds to the concept of God above propounded, to be established namely on the basis on the universe as the evidence pointing to the existence of God.

Now, the universe is also a fact of existence that corresponds to the concept of the universe above propounded.

The nose is a fact of existence in the universe.

The nose having a beginning and an ending is also a fact in the universe.


*Do you, Robert Oz, have some question about the universe containing also things imaginable and at least can be the subject of man's discourse?


Things imaginable are those entities that do not actually exist in reality but their concepts are possible, so that they are called potential beings, and they are real entities though not actual entities.


That is the point I take great efforts to explain to posters here but they are not receptive to the idea, namely, that the universe also houses potential beings, and that actual beings could not have attained actual status of reality in the universe: unless they were possible concepts or potential beings in the universe antecedent to their transit to the status of actual real existence.


Can you comprehend what I am saying?



Tell you what, we all three of us: X, and Robert OZ, and myself, should do a lot of thinking about imaginable beings which are potential beings which are also components of the universe the one where we live in and are part and parcel of.


In the meantime, what do you say, can we already continue to work together to the disquisition of the universe as evidence for God's existence, on the agreed on concepts of God and the universe as namely:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.


Yrreg





You are saying that God is the being that birthed the universe into existence (actuality) from concept (imagination) … and that man is able to comprehend concepts and thus we are able to comprehend God as a concept through what God has birthed into actuality.

In other words, actuality is the language of concepts … and the conduit through which "God" speaks to "us" … concept to concept. Our physical nature is the actual part, the part we use to understand imaginable beings is the concept part. All of the universe and everything within it is the telephone line through which the communication takes place, with God on one end and us on the other, separated by that barrier you are calling actuality.

Is this a good summary ?

If so … prove that it's true to someone that doesn't believe that it's true.



First, before anything else, I have the privilege of saluting you for not going into mockery, parody, and evasions with a heart and mind polluted with flippancy and zilch in place of real thinking and speaking as to communicate viably and civilly.


Belief has got nothing to do when we talk about concepts, we are dealing with possibilities when we talk concepts while prescinding (yes, there is a word, to prescind) from actual realities.

So, let us imagine that we never know about airplanes, then one of us who does have a gift for imagination and comes up with the idea of a ship that sails in the air instead of in the water.

Belief in an air cruising ship is not the case here with the idea of this creative thinker with a good imagination, it has to do with the possibility of such a ship.

Now, people who have the discipline of genuine thinking will examine his idea of an air-cruising-ship, they analyze the concept of any components that cannot be compatible among themselves so that the concept cannot be imagined at all, it is an impossible concept.

It takes a genius of a mind to imagine an air-cruising-ship, and it takes a self-truncated brain to not see the intrinsic possibility of such a concept, because his brain is self-truncated to limit possible motion to only on water or on land, but not in the air or in non-water and non-land space.

You see, self-brain-truncated folks are not only mind-blind, but they don't even see with their eyes what is before their eyes, namely, that birds fly, so why should it not be possible that a vessel can be fabricated to move from one point in space to another outside of water and land, as birds do.


So, you get the idea or the concept of God as a concept is not intrinsically impossible except to a truncated brain.


That concept of God, namely:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


I know of people who are into the livelihood and make a good living as home renovators, they are operating as one-man worker but with power tools and machinery.

This guy contracted to remodel my brother's home comes with a big van carrying all his hand tools, power tools, and craft machinery.

He does everything in the house to renovate it so that when you see it again it looks new and different outside and inside.

You ask but answer your own question yes: That guy does everything in the house? Yes!


So, I have a proposition to search in the universe for evidence that there is an agent who made everything in the universe so that everything in the universe that is not himself is made by him.

You cannot grasp that? you have a self-truncated brain?



Yrreg
 
But since such self-mind-truncating folks have already a self-lobotomized brain, they cannot even just suspect why they should judge that there are things they cannot know therefore period for them -- wherefore their mind is a period.




Yrreg

Is your mind a period or can you imagine a god who says men should be subservient to their wives?

In your next message, title it thus: "I, yrreg, do not have mind like a period because I am subservient to my wife as god commands."

Only in this way will we know that your mind is not like a period.
 
So, you get the idea or the concept of God as a concept is not intrinsically impossible except to a truncated brain.

I know this thread has gone on for some time, and I'm jumping in medias res, but. . . .

Depending on the definition of God, I can indeed show that the concept is intrinsically impossible the same way I can show that a 4-sided triangle is intrinsically impossible.

So there are two responses to this: either you can refuse to define the concept of God (and since we're talking about deductive logic, I'm speaking of a formal logical definition which is a list of all characteristics such that you include in the class "God" what you mean to include and that you exclude from the class everything else), or you can offer a definition that is logically consistent.

If you do the former, there's no point in continuing the discussion, because without a formal definition of a concept, we cannot do any logic with it.

I certainly invite you to try the latter, but in my experience when anyone has succeeded, they have defined "God" in a way that conflicts with conventional usage of the term (such as the Deist notion of "God"). It would exclude characteristics that most theists do indeed mean to include, such as something you can have a personal relationship with, something that can listen sympathetically to human prayer, something that intervenes in the physical world at least on occasion, etc. You could win the argument with this alternatively defined concept of "God", but anytime you sought to extend that conclusion (i.e. that its existence is possible, or that it is not internally inconsistent) to the conventional usage of the term "God" you will be committing the fallacy of equivocation.
 
And a comment on the thread title: all concepts (that we know of) and all words (that we know of) are man-made. If you're going to start an argument about the existence of God that assumes the existence of God (as in assuming words or concepts exist in the mind of God), then you are merely begging the question.
 
Okay, you tell me what to you is the distinctively Christian God in His...

In the Christian faith, God spoke the universe into existence, created the first man from dust and the first woman from the man's rib, exiled them from a paradise for eating a forbidden fruit, destroyed all but a handful of humanity with a global flood, freed the Hebrews from Egyptian bondage through a series of plagues and other miracles, caused an engaged Hebrew virgin teenaged girl to become pregnant, incarnated in the form of his own son, who preached and performed miracles, got crucified by the Romans, resurrected and appeared to many people, ascended into heaven, and will return to judge the world.



I'll talk about any god you like, but the definition you gave isn't distinctively Christian, and if you change the definition to be specific to Yahweh/Jehovah/Jesus, you have to do a lot more than just establish that the universe was created by someone: you have to also establish that the someone was the Christian god. Taking on 'there's a creator' before 'and it's 'the god of Christianity' is advisable, but you don't have to take my well-meant advice.



I'm just responding to your posts. If you want to put the cart before the horse, knock yourself out. The 'maker of the universe' definition covers a broad class of deities, of which yours is only one. The smart thing to do would be to put off talk of any specific god until after you've made the case for a creator god at all, but you are more than welcome to go your own way.



Must you, really?



I fear that any thread begun by you is the wrong thread in which to be, but I'll soldier on somehow. Please understand that I truly do take your requests and recommendations as seriously as you do mine.



Naturally, I'm quite alarmed that you might suspect me of such things, especially seriously, but I'm deficient in my capacity to be concerned about what you suspect.



You say: "I'll talk about any god you like, but the definition you gave isn't distinctively Christian."

Here is my concept of God that is distinctively Christian in His fundamental relation to the universe:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself. ​


You know better, okay, you tell me what to you is the distinctively Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe, but not in more than ten words.


We are back to concepts, I have to put on abeyance my presentation of the universe as the evidence for God's existence.


You know, dear readers, all reasoning is about the concepts involved, once people get to comprehend correctly the concepts involved, they will understand and accept a proposition that is immediately true on the concepts involved once comprehended correctly.

The task therefore facing everyone is to collaborate to come to the correct comprehension of the concepts involved.





Dear Mister Agenda, I like to ask you whether you know the difference between something that is distinctive of a person and something that is peculiar or particular of a person.

What is the point of insisting on the fact that other religions also have a God that is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself, namely, that therefore God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe is not the right God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe?

Much ado about nothing unless you want to insist that in the Christian faith God in concept is not the maker of everything in the universe that is not God, which is absolutely being mis-informed.

Before anything and everything else, on concept in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe,
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God himself.​


If you don't know that concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, then you are ignorant of the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.


And therefore you are in the wrong thread.



Yrreg
 
Well, if you want to talk about the God of Deists, start your own thread.

Alright, so we are discussing the Catholic version of the Christian god here, right? I'm assuming Orthodox Catholicism since that makes it easier, we don't have to ask which bits are not considered valid.

Ok, so what now? I have what I think your god is like in mind and as several other posters have pointed out there are a lot of details to that god beyond just "creator of the universe". It is not difficult to envision a being who created this universe but all of the extra details of it being the Catholic Christian god muddy the matter considerably.

So, why the Catholic Christian god? What make that particular being more likely than the Deist version of a creator god? How does it compare to Brahma or Amon? Note that I have no hostility towards any deistic world view, I just want to understand why you hold this view and what it means to you.



Well, if you want to talk about the God of Deists, start your own thread.


Now, if you are interested in the Christian God Who in His fundamental concept in the Christian faith in again His fundamental (mark that word, fundamental, very very very important) relation to the universe, and you are impatient to read my presentation of the universe as evidence for God's existence, the Romans tell us that "sapienti pauca," meaning to the wise few words, here is the synopsis of my presentation:

We first agree on the concepts:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​

Then we agree on the fact that
the nose is a part of the universe and that the nose has a beginning and an ending.​


From those few statements, according to the Romans who tell us that "sapienti pauca," you should already come to the light that the universe is the evidence for God's existence.



Yrreg
 
You say: "I'll talk about any god you like, but the definition you gave isn't distinctively Christian."

Here is my concept of God that is distinctively Christian in His fundamental relation to the universe:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself. ​


You know better, okay, you tell me what to you is the distinctively Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe, but not in more than ten words.


We are back to concepts, I have to put on abeyance my presentation of the universe as the evidence for God's existence.


You know, dear readers, all reasoning is about the concepts involved, once people get to comprehend correctly the concepts involved, they will understand and accept a proposition that is immediately true on the concepts involved once comprehended correctly.

The task therefore facing everyone is to collaborate to come to the correct comprehension of the concepts involved.





Dear Mister Agenda, I like to ask you whether you know the difference between something that is distinctive of a person and something that is peculiar or particular of a person.

What is the point of insisting on the fact that other religions also have a God that is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself, namely, that therefore God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe is not the right God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe?

Much ado about nothing unless you want to insist that in the Christian faith God in concept is not the maker of everything in the universe that is not God, which is absolutely being mis-informed.

Before anything and everything else, on concept in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe,
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God himself.[/b]​



If you don't know that concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, then you are ignorant of the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.


And therefore you are in the wrong thread.



Yrreg
Be careful there. I don't think you can place God within the universe and have a god at all. You need to think very carefully about the implications of a god that can be considered a part of the universe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom