God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

There are posters here in this thread who are confirmed wastrels of my time and labor, so I do not read them anymore, it is a loss of time and labor from my part; I don't maintain an answering service to give them the attention they crave, for I am only one and they are legion.

I stop reading and proceed to the next post.


Sometimes I get mixed up with the identity of the poster I am replying to.

but that is unavoidable when there are a legion of you atheists, whose heart and mind is not truly sincerely attentively substantially seriously relevantly truth-seeking-ly into the issue of God or no God, but into mockery, parody, evasions, and now attempts at derail or sabotage, to stop the thread from taking off at all, or to obstruct its development.

Dear Gerry,

You waste much time and Bandwidth this way so why do you continue to prattle on? As usual, your arrogance shows up to belittle atheists in this forum. I most certainly expected this since you've done it in other threads. Stop wasting our time and get on with the discussion! Got it?
 
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


Yes, that is an acceptable definition of a god for the purposes of this discussion.


Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.


No, not everything that can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse. Man can imagine and discuss an infinite number of things that do not exist. It's called fiction.

You need to remove that part of your definition. Then we can continue.


By the way, I still agree that noses have beginnings and endings.
 
I honestly don't see why you can't just state your premises all in one post, like anyone else would.

For example, the first-cause argument for god:
Premise 1) Everything that begins to exist has a cause.
Premise 2) The Universe began to exist.
Conclusion 1) It follows from Premise 1 and Premise 2 that the Universe had a cause.
Definition 1) The cause of the universe is defined by some as "god".
Conclusion 2) Based on Conclusion 1 and Definition 1, god can be assumed to exist.


See? It isn't necessary to demand we agree with each and every sub-point in order. Just post up your argument, in it's entirety.
He thinks he's being Socratic, doncha know?
 
Here again are my concepts of God and the universe:


God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.


For those who accept them for the purpose of this thread, that the universe is the evidence for the existence of God, we are now into effecting an agreement on whether in nose in our face has a beginning and an ending.



I have to make a list of such posters who agree with me on my concepts of God and the universe.


The rest of you who don't agree with me, there can be no logical exchange with you because you are talking about other things.

So there is no sense with me giving you any attention whatsoever.




Yrreg

I'm not sure what being on the list means but I'm pretty sure I agree with you but I'm not 100% clear on what the thread is about. I would simplify your equations by saying:

God = Existence
Universe = Everything caused by God

I think the "man made concepts" part has to do with negative theology. That is, you start from things and work your way up to God. If you take every affirmation and denial, apply them to God, and remove the ones that are less like God. As you get closer to accurately describing him, you will have less terms to use and will ultimately run out before you get to the level of God. So we are forced to use human concepts/words to give a very rough approximation of what He truly is.

None of this means that you can't talk about whether or not He exists. Thomas Aquinas showed that God's existence isn't self evident and also provided demonstrations that he does exist (I'm staying away from the word 'proof' deliberately). You seem to be saying that his existence is self evident and you shouldn't try to demonstrate it (unless I misunderstand). I can't say anything about the nose except that it was made for smelling :p
 
I have to make a list of such posters who agree with me on my concepts of God and the universe.


The rest of you who don't agree with me, there can be no logical exchange with you because you are talking about other things.

So there is no sense with me giving you any attention whatsoever.
Narcissus: "Who's here?"
Echo: "Here."

Narcissus goes off to fall in love with his own reflection ...
 
Narcissus: "Who's here?"
Echo: "Here."

Narcissus goes off to fall in love with his own reflection ...

Okay, you are serious and relevant, then say your message again sans the mockery, parody, and evasions.

Put on top of your message this inscription in bold font: Yrreg, I am serious, no mockery, parody, and evasions here.

This works for parody.;)
 
Okay, you are serious and relevant, then say your message again sans the mockery, parody, and evasions.
Request denied.
Put on top of your message this inscription in bold font: Yrreg, I am serious, no mockery, parody, and evasions here.
Request denied.
Haven't you noticed the useless prattle going on here with people who do not think but regurgitate useless words with the idea in their naive disingenuous mind that they are saying clever things but actually prattle.
Not my problem. I'm only responsible for what I say.
I invite you to do relevant logical productive thinking and writing here, so that in the midst of useless prattle regurgitating wastrels here we can work on the issue God or no God sincerely to arrive at the fact.
You just told me that you do not take me for my word, that you confuse me with other people on the thread, and that you're both free and eager to interpret anything that I say as useless regurgitating prattle. So what are you inviting me to exactly?

No thanks.
 
Last edited:
Here, I have two posters who agree to accept my concepts of God and of the universe.

Here, I have two posters who agree to accept my concepts of God and of the universe.


1. Poster X:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7728769&postcount=317

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7728895&postcount=322

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7728963&postcount=326



2. Poster Robert Oz:

Robert Oz said:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7728936&postcount=324


Originally Posted by yrreg
...all my concern is with the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe, and I have defined my concept of the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe as:

God = Maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.

I agree, you have defined a god, specifically the kind of god you wish to discuss. You have also made a leap of faith that such a god exists and an even larger leap of faith that it is the Christian god as described in Biblical texts.

And even though your definition fits many gods that have been and are believed in, I accept your definition for the purposes of this discussion.


Originally Posted by yrreg
And my definition of the concept of the universe is:

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

I accept your definition of the universe* apart from the subject of man's imagination and discourse. Man imagined gods. That does not mean that gods are part of the universe or that they exist outside the universe.


So, essentially, I accept your definition of a god, but do not share your belief in one, and I accept your definition of the universe* with the exception of the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

What's next?
Robert Oz said:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7728947&postcount=325

Originally Posted by yrreg
Now, do you also agree that the nose has a beginning and an ending, the one in your face as also in everyone's face?


Yes, the nose has a beginning and an ending.


===================


So, to enumerate the points of agreement:

1. On the concept of God: God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

2. On the concept of the universe: Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

3. On the fact of the nose being a part of the universe.

4. On the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending.


Now, I just want to assure you two, X and Robert Oz, that we are into concepts with God and universe.

The existence of God is the reality to be established that corresponds to the concept of God above propounded, to be established namely on the basis on the universe as the evidence pointing to the existence of God.

Now, the universe is also a fact of existence that corresponds to the concept of the universe above propounded.

The nose is a fact of existence in the universe.

The nose having a beginning and an ending is also a fact in the universe.


*Do you, Robert Oz, have some question about the universe containing also things imaginable and at least can be the subject of man's discourse?


Things imaginable are those entities that do not actually exist in reality but their concepts are possible, so that they are called potential beings, and they are real entities though not actual entities.


That is the point I take great efforts to explain to posters here but they are not receptive to the idea, namely, that the universe also houses potential beings, and that actual beings could not have attained actual status of reality in the universe: unless they were possible concepts or potential beings in the universe antecedent to their transit to the status of actual real existence.


Can you comprehend what I am saying?



Tell you what, we all three of us: X, and Robert OZ, and myself, should do a lot of thinking about imaginable beings which are potential beings which are also components of the universe the one where we live in and are part and parcel of.


In the meantime, what do you say, can we already continue to work together to the disquisition of the universe as evidence for God's existence, on the agreed on concepts of God and the universe as namely:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.





Yrreg
 
Man-made concepts and words, they are the only concepts and words we human beings use to talk about God.

But they cannot ever describe to us exhaustively what is God in Himself.

So all our concepts and words used by theists as by atheists to argue for and against the existence of God, they are all short of if not totally missing what is God in Himself.

What then? Shall we all no longer talk for or against the existence of God?


Before I go further I just want everyone here theists -- of which I am one, a Christian theist more specifically -- and atheists, allow me to just remind everyone that God is not religion.


You can relate to God without religion. And you can have religion without God.


What do theists and atheists here think ( and you have to use man-made concepts and words to think and to communicate with each other here, that is the only way we can do so ), namely, should no longer talk and argue for God's existence as for His non-existence?



Yrreg
Am I hearing a motion to stop talking about god? Second.
 
I am signing off now, those of you who are serious instead of being flippant, you...

I am signing off now, those of you who just joined now who are serious instead of being flippant, you are welcome to contribute to the thesis I am advocating, namely, the universe is the evidence for God's existence.

And you can contribute constructively please to the attainment of agreed on concepts of God, universe, whatever else that comes up in the course of our common efforts to come to the resolution of the issue God or no God.


I just expect you to be cognizant of the logic of coming first to agree on concepts, unless you are just here to engage in the acrobatics of useless prattle, in order to impede the thesis by spewing words of mockery, parody, and evasions.



Yrreg
 
*Do you, Robert Oz, have some question about the universe containing also things imaginable and at least can be the subject of man's discourse?


Things imaginable are those entities that do not actually exist in reality but their concepts are possible, so that they are called potential beings, and they are real entities though not actual entities.


That is the point I take great efforts to explain to posters here but they are not receptive to the idea, namely, that the universe also houses potential beings, and that actual beings could not have attained actual status of reality in the universe: unless they were possible concepts or potential beings in the universe antecedent to their transit to the status of actual real existence.


Can you comprehend what I am saying?


Yes, we can imagine beings that later turn out to be real, as in to actually exist independent of our imagination. It is possible to conceive of something before discovering its existence.

However, the imagined thing may or may not actually exist in the universe. So, I would agree that the universe contains undiscovered realities. Even realities that we could possibly imagine without having observed.

You are, however, incorrect that the universe includes all things that we can imagine or conceive of. It may include some, but certainly not all, and I would argue that whenever we imagine something, the less evidence there is to support it, the less likely it is for that imagined thing to turn out to actually exist. I would also argue that where there is no evidence, the imagined thing is highly unlikely to exist and if it happens to exist, our conception of it is unrelated to the actual being and was simply a lucky guess.

I am happy for your definition of the universe to be all things that exist, including as yet undiscovered things, some of which are possible for us to imagine. I do not accept your definition including all things we can imagine.
 
Last edited:
I am signing off now, those of you who just joined now who are serious instead of being flippant, you are welcome to contribute to the thesis I am advocating, namely, the universe is the evidence for God's existence.

And you can contribute constructively please to the attainment of agreed on concepts of God, universe, whatever else that comes up in the course of our common efforts to come to the resolution of the issue God or no God.


I just expect you to be cognizant of the logic of coming first to agree on concepts, unless you are just here to engage in the acrobatics of useless prattle, in order to impede the thesis by spewing words of mockery, parody, and evasions.



Yrreg
We've been through this many times. Why do you think it will work this time? Stipulating your concepts has not led to the conclusions you would wish for so far. We can define God any way you like, but you have not been able yet to provide coherent arguments as to why the universe would be evidence of God's existence even if God exists.
 
Here, I have two posters who agree to accept my concepts of God and of the universe.


1. Poster X:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7728769&postcount=317

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7728895&postcount=322

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7728963&postcount=326



2. Poster Robert Oz:





===================


So, to enumerate the points of agreement:

1. On the concept of God: God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

2. On the concept of the universe: Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

3. On the fact of the nose being a part of the universe.

4. On the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending.


Now, I just want to assure you two, X and Robert Oz, that we are into concepts with God and universe.

The existence of God is the reality to be established that corresponds to the concept of God above propounded, to be established namely on the basis on the universe as the evidence pointing to the existence of God.

Now, the universe is also a fact of existence that corresponds to the concept of the universe above propounded.

The nose is a fact of existence in the universe.

The nose having a beginning and an ending is also a fact in the universe.


*Do you, Robert Oz, have some question about the universe containing also things imaginable and at least can be the subject of man's discourse?


Things imaginable are those entities that do not actually exist in reality but their concepts are possible, so that they are called potential beings, and they are real entities though not actual entities.


That is the point I take great efforts to explain to posters here but they are not receptive to the idea, namely, that the universe also houses potential beings, and that actual beings could not have attained actual status of reality in the universe: unless they were possible concepts or potential beings in the universe antecedent to their transit to the status of actual real existence.


Can you comprehend what I am saying?



Tell you what, we all three of us: X, and Robert OZ, and myself, should do a lot of thinking about imaginable beings which are potential beings which are also components of the universe the one where we live in and are part and parcel of.


In the meantime, what do you say, can we already continue to work together to the disquisition of the universe as evidence for God's existence, on the agreed on concepts of God and the universe as namely:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.





Yrreg
You are saying that God is the being that birthed the universe into existence (actuality) from concept (imagination) … and that man is able to comprehend concepts and thus we are able to comprehend God as a concept through what God has birthed into actuality.

In other words, actuality is the language of concepts … and the conduit through which "God" speaks to "us" … concept to concept. Our physical nature is the actual part, the part we use to understand imaginable beings is the concept part. All of the universe and everything within it is the telephone line through which the communication takes place, with God on one end and us on the other, separated by that barrier you are calling actuality.

Is this a good summary ?

If so … prove that it's true to someone that doesn't believe that it's true.
 
What have you read that is wrong?

I am saying that you have the wrong comprehension.

So, tell me what you have comprehended from my words, and don't neglect to reproduce my words faithfully.


Here are your words, reproduced faithfully with a link so that people can see them in their original context:
You see, reality is made up of two things: potential entities and actual entities.

An actual entity cannot come to existence unless there is a possible concept of it.


Here is what I wrote, explaining why you were wrong:
No. An actual entity exists whether or not anyone has a concept of it.

For example, the Galilean moons of Jupiter were first observed by Galileo in 1609 and 1610. Before this there was no concept of moons orbiting any planet other than the Earth. But the moons of Jupiter (and of Mars, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune) all existed long before this.


I suspect that you are quibbling over your use of the word "possible", but this is not really the point. Concepts are pretty much unlimited. There is "a possible concept" of pretty much anything, regardless of whether it is capable of existing, because people have this thing called imagination. There is no correspondence between having a concept of something (or that concept being "possible") and that something "com[ing] into existence".

And even if consciousnesses capable of having concepts had not evolved, the universe would still exist. It was here for a long time before we appeared.
 
Last edited:
Okay, it's been nearly two years, so let's sum up: God is the maker of everything in the universe except himself, and the nose has a beginning and an end.

Maybe in two years time, we'll get some further points.


Maybe yrreg will even provide a definition that goes some way towards distinguishing his god from all the others.
 
I am signing off now, those of you who just joined now who are serious instead of being flippant,
I think you mean "credulous instead of being skeptical"

you are welcome to contribute to the thesis I am advocating, namely, the universe is the evidence for God's existence.

I think you mean "Im going to ignore all the deconstructions of my arguments and push on regardless"

And you can contribute constructively please to the attainment of agreed on concepts of God, universe,

I think you mean "you can only contribute if you agree with me"

whatever else that comes up in the course of our common efforts to come to the resolution of the issue God or no God.

You will never resolve this Gerry, because there is no good evidence for the existence of god, and you wont ever accept the logical result of that.

You are stuck in an endless loop of hope and despair.


I just expect you to be cognizant of the logic of coming first to agree on concepts,

This is, again, "you can only contribute if you agree with me"

unless you are just here to engage in the acrobatics of useless prattle, in order to impede the thesis by spewing words of mockery, parody, and evasions.

And this is dismissing all evidence to the contrary with a mere wave of the hand.

Seriously Gerry, can you really not see this in yourself?
 
*Do you, Robert Oz, have some question about the universe containing also things imaginable and at least can be the subject of man's discourse?


Things imaginable are those entities that do not actually exist in reality but their concepts are possible, so that they are called potential beings, and they are real entities though not actual entities.


That is the point I take great efforts to explain to posters here but they are not receptive to the idea, namely, that the universe also houses potential beings, and that actual beings could not have attained actual status of reality in the universe: unless they were possible concepts or potential beings in the universe antecedent to their transit to the status of actual real existence.


Can you comprehend what I am saying?



Tell you what, we all three of us: X, and Robert OZ, and myself, should do a lot of thinking about imaginable beings which are potential beings which are also components of the universe the one where we live in and are part and parcel of.


Formally: Yes, I will, for the sake of argument, accept that it is possible the universe contains things we can only imagine at this time. Now will you please lay out your argument instead of doing everything piece-by-piece?

Informally: Yes, yes. Get on with it, man!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom