God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

Further we bring to the attention of readers that the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending is a one for all fact that everything in the universe has a beginning and an ending.

The two dimensional surface of a sphere has no boundaries. Since it can no longer be said that everything in the universe has a beginning and an ending, your entire argument falls apart. I'm sorry, I know that you really wanted to make your coup de grâce by declaring that your god is as plain as the noses on our faces, but obviously it is not.
 
Look at it this way: If we can imagine a thing though it does not exist in actual reality, then it does exist in potential reality which potential reality is a realm of existence independent of our mind, but we need our mind to get to know them.

So, the realm of potential reality is greater than the representatives of this realm which our mind has acquaintance of.
I can imagine a troll. The troll's name is Olaf. Olaf is quite opaque and is fairly large. Olaf lives in the realm of potential reality.

But Olaf doesn't like it there (by definition, because if Olaf does like it in potential reality, then it is not the troll I am imagining). Olaf wants to be in the actually real realm instead.

Olaf has an amazing power to move from the potentially real realm to the actually real realm, and wants to appear before you in front of your keyboard right now, before you read the rest of this sentence.

If you were able to read the entire sentence without seeing Olaf, I'd be interested in knowing how that could possibly be possible.
 
Last edited:
You say, "You are, however, incorrect that the universe includes all things that we can imagine or conceive of."


Look at it this way: If we can imagine a thing though it does not exist in actual reality, then it does exist in potential reality which potential reality is a realm of existence independent of our mind, but we need our mind to get to know them.

So, the realm of potential reality is greater than the representatives of this realm which our mind has acquaintance of.
so what you're saying, in a nutshell, is that every thing we can imagine, no matter how silly, is at least as real as your God!
 
I won't make such demands. Not ever.

The universe is not evidence for the existence of god. Nothing you say will make it so. You might as well put your "argument" on a shelf and admire it. That's all it will ever be good for.
Unfortunately, he also believes his god gives him the right to treat women, servants, atheists and buddhists like second-class citizens. (I'm sure that's only a partial list....)
 
Thank you for answering my question and telling me that this particular argument is only about the existence of a god rather than the Christian god in particular. That makes it a lot simpler for me since the Christian god definitely has a bunch of traits above and beyond just "creator of he universe".

I don't get the bit about noses though. Noses don't really have a beginning and and end unless you draw an arbitrary line. How do you decide where the beginning and end are? The nose moves smoothly into the forehead at one point, curves into the cheeks at another, and comes to a point before swooping down to the mouth with a delightful little dimple. We arbitrarily call this formation the nose but really we could include more or less of the face as we feel appropriate.

If you mean that a nose has a beginning and end in temporal space then I'm not so sure about that either. When do we start to call it a nose? When it is a few unidentifiable cells in a splitting egg? When it starts to form cartilage? Is it still a nose when all that is left is a skull and the ragged socket which once contained flesh and cartilage? We declare it to be a nose by our own standards and those may differ from person to person.
 
Thank you for answering my question and telling me that this particular argument is only about the existence of a god rather than the Christian god in particular. That makes it a lot simpler for me since the Christian god definitely has a bunch of traits above and beyond just "creator of he universe".

I don't get the bit about noses though. Noses don't really have a beginning and and end unless you draw an arbitrary line. How do you decide where the beginning and end are? The nose moves smoothly into the forehead at one point, curves into the cheeks at another, and comes to a point before swooping down to the mouth with a delightful little dimple. We arbitrarily call this formation the nose but really we could include more or less of the face as we feel appropriate.

If you mean that a nose has a beginning and end in temporal space then I'm not so sure about that either. When do we start to call it a nose? When it is a few unidentifiable cells in a splitting egg? When it starts to form cartilage? Is it still a nose when all that is left is a skull and the ragged socket which once contained flesh and cartilage? We declare it to be a nose by our own standards and those may differ from person to person.
I think this might be part of his point.

In what you're saying, you could say that the nose is attached to the entire universe. The end of the nose is the edge of the universe. Take away the arbitrary points we usually use to say "this is where it begins and ends" and that would be the end and the beginning of it.

And where did that "nose" come from ? The possibilities of where everything else came from .... where the cells came from, and the egg, and the atomic structure, yada yada.

And since we can recognize the nose, and even recreate it ... (maybe one day grow one on the back of a mouse ?) ... then it's evidence that the nose was possible, we can imagine it, and recreate it, and thus that is how the nose came into existence in the first place perhaps ... it was created from possibility.

So I think what yrreg is saying, is that since we can imagine a possible being who is a creator of things, like noses for example .... and we can create noses, then the possible being we can imagine must exist as we imagine. The evidence being the existence of something like the nose. Because the only way it exists in the form of us creating it, is that we recognize it from the sea of possibilities, find the pattern, and replicate it. So to must there have been a god who did the same thing ... since we can imagine it, and "mimic" what god does.

I think it's just another way of trying to "prove" that an entity created everything. I still don't see what the practical application of it is, or why it matters. Is that God still creating, is it dead, or is it detached ? What's the practical use of this ?
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, he also believes his god gives him the right to treat women, servants, atheists and buddhists like second-class citizens. (I'm sure that's only a partial list....)

All very good reasons why I not only don't believe, I don't even want to believe.

Boy, he's going to have a field day with that. :D
 
Gerry, that is one of the dumbest things I've ever heard. Where did you learn to think? I've talked to 1000's of people over the years, and not one can not-think as deeply as you can.

Tell me, does anyone around you - where you live- pay any attention to what you say??

<apologies for the near ad hom....gerry brings out the worst in, well - everyone>
 
Is that a flippant question or you are a dummy?

Originally Posted by yrreg
The thesis I am pursuing is that the universe is the evidence for God's existence.



But what is the practical application of this ?


We have first to agree on what is a practical application of a fact and/or a truth to humans.

Tell me as you are the one asking what is the practical application of something like the universe is the evidence for God's existence, what do you mean by a practical application of anything at all?

Enumerate all the kinds of practical applications of anything at all which to you has practical applications.

In this manner we will know what is your concept of practical application and what are the limitations of your heart and mind in terms of practical applications of things that you do have practical application for.


Then you might come to more practical applications of things about which you did not know or did not have any consciousness before.


Okay?


Edited to remove breaches. Please, cut out the personalization and insults and remember to address the argument rather than attacking the arguer.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL


Yrreg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Will you just get off your useless syllogistic perch and specialize on evidence?

How can you not recognise the illogic in your sequence of statements?

Statement 1 is an opinion statement of belief
Statemens 2, 3 and 4 are digressions
Statement 7 is not supported by the previous statements. Even the way you express it is a giveaway - you are stating an opinion, not a logical conclusion.

I suspect you recognise the hole in your argument but have too much ego invested in your position.



Will you just get off your useless syllogistic perch and specialize on evidence?


There are more things to the achievement of certainty than your toy Lego of carpetbagger syllogisms which are useless for anything except for you to feel so smug with over-worn baggage when it comes to the real world in the ascertainment of facts and truths.


Go and specialize on evidence.

If you are an atheist who do clamor for evidence like a mantra, then as no atheists at all have produced a comprehensive manual on evidence, I challenge you to take that mission in life for the advancement of your barren atheists' worldview, so that you can hope to succeed in turning everything into a barren desert.




Yrreg
 
You have no discipline for concentration on fundamentals.

Originally Posted by yrreg
You still have not shown why my concept of God is impossible or nonsensical.



I already did. You have not yet defined the concept 'god' that has the ability to express secondary characteristics such as 'maker'.

'Maker' says nothing of the god-concept itself which is what I'm saying you're missing and until you provide this, then there can be no coherent arguments made.



You already did nothing if you cannot repeat it here in your next post whatever you did previously: do as I do, I repeat my important texts again and again and again and again and again and again and again...



You have no discipline for concentration on fundamentals.

Read again this concept of God from yours truly, and concentrate on fundamentals, otherwise I give up on you.

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.
​


If you are not married yet and plan on marrying tell your girlfriend to see me, I wil tell her that before anything and everything else, make sure the guy has the fundamental component of a male human in the context of marriage in relation to you a woman.


Get the idea?

Or you will insist with your prospective bride and the whole world that you have secondary characteristics even though you don't have the fundamental component of a human male in the matter of marriage in relation to a human female your prospective bride.



On the other hand I really don't get what you are driving at with this thing about secondary characteristics as distinct to what? the fundamental credit of God as maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself, by the absence of which credit God for all your insisted on secondary characteristics is worth zilch.


Or for you God being the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself is only a secondary characteristic of God?

Oh please, then tell me what are the primary characteristics of God in His relation to the universe.



By the way if you want to know, I always tell men and women planning to get married to have a very thorough physico-medical check-up, in particular on their sexual-reproductive potentials, these characteristic potentials are very fundamental to each partner in marriage.




Yrreg
 
Will you just get off your useless syllogistic perch and specialize on evidence?


There are more things to the achievement of certainty than your toy Lego of carpetbagger syllogisms which are useless for anything except for you to feel so smug with over-worn baggage when it comes to the real world in the ascertainment of facts and truths.


Go and specialize on evidence.

If you are an atheist who do clamor for evidence like a mantra, then as no atheists at all have produced a comprehensive manual on evidence, I challenge you to take that mission in life for the advancement of your barren atheists' worldview, so that you can hope to succeed in turning everything into a barren desert.




Yrreg

So, what you're saying is that your logic is indeed flawed, but you have nothing better?

I had thought that you may have been capable of learning but alas, no.

You again seek refuge in prose that I suspect is meant to be a stinging insult, but is actually quite amusing word salad and totally misses the point.

It's terribly awkward for you to press for evidence, as that's what you're totally bereft of - which is why you've had to resort to logic puzzles. Unfortunately, you lack the intellect to execute them successfully.

I will be responding no further. Your posts and attitude are ignorant, lazy, deluded and unworthy of further notice.
 
That is very good, sir, now just tell me what are the differences between your...

Originally Posted by yrreg
Suppose you serious atheists who don't go for mockery, parody, and evasions, you get together and come up with a common statement of your concepts of God and of the universe.


God: An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior.

Universe: Everything that we can observe directly or indirectly.



That is very good(?), sir, now just tell me what are the differences between your concepts of God and universe compared to mine.


Read my concepts of God and the universe:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.​

Now read your concepts:
God: An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior.

Universe: Everything that we can observe directly or indirectly.​


Remember that my thesis is to establish that
the universe is the evidence for God's existence.​




Don't go away!





Yrreg
 
By the way if you want to know, I always tell men and women planning to get married to have a very thorough physico-medical check-up, in particular on their sexual-reproductive potentials, these characteristic potentials are very fundamental to each partner in marriage.
And we're back to penises again. I knew they couldn't be too far from the tip of yrreg's nose....

By the way if you want to know, when I was planning to get married I didn't need my husband-to-be to get a very thorough physico-medical checkup to check for the fundamental existence or functionality of his sexual-reproductive potentials. I had actual evidence that he had a working penis.

Frankly, I prefer physical evidence to ridiculous arguments and tergiversation.
 
Dear old Yrreg, you're losing it again, descending into nothing but vitriol and personal attacks. Usually it takes a few weeks for you to descend to this level, but you're being very insulting to people already and you've just been back a few days.

Don't take the fact that people disagree with you so personally, and don't lash out with insults. If you keep this up, you'll be kicked off the forum again.

Maybe you could learn some of that Buddhist calm and serenity, eh? ;)
 
What is your point in stating the the universe does not require noses?

The thesis I am pursuing is that the universe is the evidence for God's existence.


Here are my concepts of God and of the universe:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​


Suppose you serious atheists who don't go for mockery, parody, and evasions, you get together and come up with a common statement of your concepts of God and of the universe.


Now, we have also to work on the concept of what is evidence, because someone here is saying that the evidence for the universe existing is the evidence for the universe existing, and not for God existing.

So I am asking him for his concept of evidence because he needs evidence to know that the universe is existing and that on the evidence of the universe existing.

There must be more to the concept of evidence than just repeating the statement which is supposed to be established from evidence.

So, in effect the man is saying that:

The evidence that the universe exists
is the evidence that the universe exists.
​

Something is wrong here or he is into a kind of logic of his own devising.


Better we now all put our heads together to work on a concept of evidence by which no one will say that

the evidence that the universe exists
is the evidence that the universe exists.
​


By the way does anyone need evidence to know that the universe exists?




For those who are always repeatedly abusing me that I have not presented my argument for the thesis that the universe is the evidence for God's existence, here it is:

1. First we agree on the concepts of God and the universe as:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​

2. Then we present
the fact of the nose existing in the universe so it is a part and parcel of the universe.​

3. Next we inform readers of
the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending.​

4. Further we bring to the attention of readers that
the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending is a one for all fact that everything in the universe has a beginning and an ending.​

5. Wherefore
everything in the universe has need of an agent to bring them to the beginning of their existence.​

6. And this fact that everything in the universe has a need of an agent to bring them to existence and the fact that they do exist,
that double fact is the evidence that:​

7. There is an agent which I call
God, who is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


Thus, from the realm of concepts we arrive at the realm of real actualities in
the existence of God as the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​
​



That is what I call proof from evidence by way of ratiocination i.e. reasoning on facts which facts make up evidence.



The crux of the argument is to work with posters here who are serious on the common thought acceptable to everyone on what is the concept of evidence.


Aside from working together to come to common concepts on God and on the universe.

No need to come to common concept on the nose, unless you are overly doubtful you have a nose in your face because you have taken a vow of doubting everything -- in which case please leave at your earliest convenience from this thread.




[ Pretty soon, some people will be demanding again and again and again into infinite silly ingress: when I am going to give my argument on the proposition that the universe is the evidence for the existence of God. ]





Yrreg




Point # 2: misuse of "part and parcel." The universe does not require noses.

Point #4: unsupported assumption. There is no reason to assume that the attributes of a single object in the universe apply to others, or to the universe itself.

Point #5: non sequitur. Nothing in the previous points relates in any way to the necessity of an agent. You can't just toss this in.

Point # 7: unsupported assumption. Even if you could demonstrate the need for an agent, you have not established what agent is responsible for what. There is no logical necessity that the creator of the universe be the agent responsible for its details. The fact that you have defined a conceptual God who is responsible does not limit the possibilities to that one concept.




Okay, let us just one by one take first your comment to my step No. 2.
2. Then we present
the fact of the nose existing in the universe so it is a part and parcel of the universe.​

Point # 2: misuse of "part and parcel." The universe does not require noses.

​


My point is that the nose is a part of the universe, what is your point that the universe does not require noses?


That point of yours is an irrelevant point, it does not serve any purpose in advancement or in defeat of my thesis:
The universe is the evidence for God's existence.​

You want for us to dispute about whether the universe requires noses or not, when the fact is that noses exist and they make up therefore parts and parcels of the universe.

That is a useless dispute, but you must acknowledge that noses do exist in the universe, and therefore in actual reality they are parts and parcels of the universe.

How they the noses serve in the support of my thesis, "The universe is the evidence for God's existence," see my Steps Nos. 3. and 4.

3. Next we inform readers of
the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending.​

4. Further we bring to the attention of readers that
the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending is a one for all fact that everything in the universe has a beginning and an ending.​

​


So, your point #2 is a useless point for being irrelevant.

When you accept that your point #2 is useless for being irrelevant, then we can proceed to your next point, and your point #2 can be deleted without any adverse effect on your opposition to my thesis.


While my Step No. 2 stays.





Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom