Gimlin's Yakima Bigfoot Party

The funny thing is Bobo's post was wrought with errors.

Gimlin didn't say Patty was 7 1/2", Krantz wrote that Gimlin gave an estimate of 6'1" or 2".

And Bob Heironimus isn't 5'10", according to Long's Book he is.... 6'2"

I thought Gimlin thought the "Creature" was around 6ft 5? Do you have any quotes from Gimlin.
 
1st article. 6.5-7 feet. Not very giant...

Patterson said the creature stood upright the entire time, reaching a height of about six and a half to seven feet and an estimated weight of between 350 and 400 pounds.

Nov 67 interview. It was like a giant man. Estimated at 6'9"... Not very giant. :D

R: Yes, it seemed to be, to me, more like a giant man except it had breasts.

B: They did on the height, measuring by the soles of those feet, in the picture, and they estimated the height to be approximately six foot, nine inches.
 
Sanderson interview, 7' and only 350 pounds.

On the other side of the creek, back up against the trees, there was a sort of man-creature that we estimated later, by measuring some logs that appear in the film, to have been about seven feet tall. Both Bob and I estimate--and this pretty well matched what others told us from examination of the depth to which her tracks sank into hard sand--that she would weigh about three hundred and fifty pounds.

BTW, I just realized that Patterson must be lying here. Who went to the site and examined the depth of the tracks to determine Patty's weight? What others? Did Laverty do an analysis? Titmus doesn't get there until the tracks are many days old and not useful for such an analysis. We can see that this is the case from his casts. So who examined the track depth to come up with a weight for Patty?

This interview was not too long after the incident and published in the Feb 68 magazine.
 
Last edited:
I left out a relevant bit. Roger chimed in and said the 6'9" estimate was based on a 14" foot, and Patty's foot was actually 14.5", so she must be a lot taller than 6'9".

But who didn't know that the casts were 14.5" long and used 14" to estimate?

B: They did on the height, measuring by the soles of those feet, in the picture, and they estimated the height to be approximately six foot, nine inches.

W: What was the length of the stride?

R: Just pardon me, this was estimated on a fourteen and a half inch, excuse me a fourteen inch track and these tracks were fourteen and a half inches, which would, would add quite a considerable bit
 
Im sorry, but 7ft 300 lbs isnt exactly giant, its quite thin. Perhaps the Policeman's vision was not accurate?

You seem to be missing the point: People can goof in their descriptions by overestimating things. The details for the "Bigfoot" seen by the police officer did not match the actual dimensions of the teenager in the suit. If a police officer (who tend to be trained to be careful observers) can make such a goof, it hardly stretches the imagination to have others make similar (or worse) mistakes.

vortigern99 said:
I would just like to thank AMM for his fine, scathing, face-palming rebuttal to Bobo's reprehensible drivel.

I'd like to thank Vortigern99 for both his compliment and for also explaining things to makaya. However, I facepalmed myself for not realizing the facts relayed by wolftrax:

wolftrax said:
The funny thing is Bobo's post was wrought with errors.

Gimlin didn't say Patty was 7 1/2", Krantz wrote that Gimlin gave an estimate of 6'1" or 2".

And Bob Heironimus isn't 5'10", according to Long's Book he is.... 6'2"
 
Grover Krantz said:
In sharp contrast, Patterson thought his subject was 7 feet 4 inches tall, while Gimlin estimated it at 6 feet 1 or 2 inches (223.5 vs. 184 cm.).

Then you have Green's interview with Gimlin:

I thought is[sic] was about six and a half feet tall and I would have guessed it's weight at 250 to 300 punds.
http://www.bigfootencounters.com/interviews/john.htm

So you have some variation of a few inches, but quite a ways from 7 1/2 feet tall.

No need for face palming, Atomic, there have been so many wildly variable estimates of Patty's size that it is hard to keep track.
 
I thought Gimlin thought the "Creature" was around 6ft 5? Do you have any quotes from Gimlin.

In addition to Krantz, Byrne (The Search for Bigfoot, 1975, page 140), also indicated that Gimlin thought the subject was 6' 1" or 6' 2".

Both Green (see previous link from wolftrax) and Meldrum (Sasquatch: Legend Meets Science, 2007, page 141) have Gimlin's estimate at 6'6".

Meldrum however, shrugs off Gimlin's estimates, and instead favors the 7-foot+ guesstimates arrived at by Murphy and Glickman.

RayG
 
To me the idea of giving estimates down to the nearest inch is just plain absurd. It is almost is if the witness knew the height before hand. If you saw somebody on the street, you would not guess their height at 6'1" or 6'2". You would probably say he was about 6-foot or maybe between 6 foot and 6-1/2 foot. You also might hint that he was just over 6-foot. I don't know many people who give such precise estimates on a persons height unless they are standing near them.
 
In addition to Krantz, Byrne (The Search for Bigfoot, 1975, page 140), also indicated that Gimlin thought the subject was 6' 1" or 6' 2".

Both Green (see previous link from wolftrax) and Meldrum (Sasquatch: Legend Meets Science, 2007, page 141) have Gimlin's estimate at 6'6".

Meldrum however, shrugs off Gimlin's estimates, and instead favors the 7-foot+ guesstimates arrived at by Murphy and Glickman.

RayG

I hope all of us get to know Bob's real estimate
 
It is almost is if the witness knew the height before hand.
:D

I wish I could find a link - but isn't it the case that during a frightening situation, our biology makes us assess the situation by estimating the maximum threat* we are likely to have to deal with?

So - when encountering a 'creature' no bigger than* seven feet (it may have actually been 6 ft) after the emotional needle settles, it can leave the impression that the encounter was actually with a seven foot individual.
 
As I mentioned before, I'm 6'7" -- which means I get a lot of people (usually women, LOL) remarking "Wow! You're tall"" and/or asking me how tall I am*. For the last few years, my usual response has been: "Can you guess?" I then straighten to my full height, inviting the questioner, and anyone with them, to offer their best estimate.

Anecdotally (that is, without recording their responses on the spot), I can report that with the first try, most people get within 2 inches of my actual height; that is, they estimate 6'5" to 6'9". Sometimes I get a really ridiculous guess, like "7 feet?", but for the most part, people are fairly accurate in their estimation.

That said, this generally occurs with people who are 1 - 3 feet away from me at the time, so perhaps this example does not make the best analogy with the on-site estimation of Patty's height... especially from two men who may have been faking the entire thing from the start.

*I met my wife this way, so I can't really complain, though it does get old after awhile.
 
That said, this generally occurs with people who are 1 - 3 feet away from me at the time, so perhaps this example does not make the best analogy with the on-site estimation of Patty's height... especially from two men who may have been faking the entire thing from the start.

I have a similar problem being 6'4" (a runt compared to you). People close to me recognize the rough height. However, if I were standing in a field over a hundred feet away, I think people would give a more average value of 6 to 6-1/2 foot. When people are close they compare you to their own height or a reference. Far away in a field, is much more difficult.
 
I have a similar problem being 6'4" (a runt compared to you). People close to me recognize the rough height. However, if I were standing in a field over a hundred feet away, I think people would give a more average value of 6 to 6-1/2 foot. When people are close they compare you to their own height or a reference. Far away in a field, is much more difficult.

People can not judge size at all. I am starting to think that even other species are better witnesses than us.
 
Vortigern.Off topic but as a Welshman I would rather see Gwrtheyrn (guhweerth eye ren).Vortigern was his English name.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom