Gimlin's Yakima Bigfoot Party

I think he baises it on all of his years of experience. Let's see he's all of 20 yrs old, you know. :rolleyes:





I Am He
 
My very first post on JREF :) I've been meaning to do this for a very long time.


Considering the issue at hand is whether or not "certain" questions should be allowed or not being all the huh ub, I would be more appreciative of the stance if he hadn't been to quick to get touchy about percieving folks as attacking Dr Meldrum last summer when it was merely a qustion of why some PHDs and like educated folks can be questioned; Farenbach, Bindernagle, davis among others but Meldrum is untouchable.

Just saying....

What exactly did I say last summer that gave you the impression that I was 'touchy' about people questioning Meldrum as opposed to other speakers? Please provide a link.

I'm not aware that I got 'touchy' - I think Meldrum is as answerable to questions as the next speaker. His PHD does not elevate him to some special status as far as I'm concerned - I thought I'd always been clear on that.

If you got the wrong impression about how I feel on the subject, I sincerly and unreservedly apologise, but I would still like a link please.


---


That aside, I think its a damn shame that Tom and Bobo acted the way they did (and I'm sure some are saying the same about me), but it is understandable, they are truly committed Gimlin groupies who have elevated him to a God-like status - frankly, I find Tom's infatuation with Gimlin nothing short of creepy.

The real problem as I see it is that there are people who seek to use Gimlin's reputation as a solid, dependable, "good Christian man" (as if that is more trustworthy than a good person of another religion or a good atheist) as evidence that the PGF is authentic, but they are looking at Gimlin in the 21st century, not the 1960s Gimlin, when, according to Tom Yamarone himself (as he relayed the story to me in 2004), Gimlin hung out with Bob Kneivel, a known bank robber and poacher at the time, although I accept that Tom may be have been bs'ing in an attempt to elevate Gimlin as a 'cool dude' even further.

It is the 1960s Gimlin that was involved with the PGF, a man who by all accounts was found with stolen property, had an arrest warrant issued (that doesn't mean he was actually arrested, and I still feel to this day that Long asked the wrong questions) had dodgy friends and didn't think twice about wearing a silly 'indian' wig to help Patterson appear authentic. I suspect Gimlin wasn't whiter than white, and according to his 'friend' James 'Bobo' Fay, he still has a tendancy to beat up on people who don't agree with him.

Now don't get me wrong, I met Gimlin in 2003 and thought he was a very nice old man. He was polite, respectful and funny, but unless someone can vouch for his character in the 1960s, his character should not be used to support the validity of the PGF - apart from anything else it is thoroughly unscientific, and anyone claiming to be a scientist who uses Gimlin as 'evidence' should be thoroughly ashamed of themselves.

When I'm in my late 70s, I'm going to be polite, respectful, charming and funny, but I'm now two years older than Gimlin was in 1967, I am not the same person that I was twenty years ago, and I'm not the same person I will be in another forty years time. Anyone who in 2049 claims that I was always charming and respectful will an out-and-out liar. ;)
 
Last edited:
Welcome Paul..

I would like to say that I have never found Paul to be anything but fair and respectful when it comes to dealing with controversy at BFF ..

I'm sure I've tested his patience a time or two, but I have never managed to get myself banned or even supended .. I understand and respect where he has drawn the line.

If anything he is too forgiving at times, but never in favor of one faction over the other .. ( IMO )
 
Welcome Paul..

I would like to say that I have never found Paul to be anything but fair and respectful when it comes to dealing with controversy at BFF ..

I'm sure I've tested his patience a time or two, but I have never managed to get myself banned or even supended .. I understand and respect where he has drawn the line.

If anything he is too forgiving at times, but never in favor of one faction over the other .. ( IMO )

I wholeheartedly agree
 
Welcome aboard Paul.

I don't post on BFF since I'm certain bigfoot is a mythological creature. I do lurk there since I find bigfoot hoaxes, and the people who believe them, to be interesting.
 
My very first post on JREF :) I've been meaning to do this for a very long time.




What exactly did I say last summer that gave you the impression that I was 'touchy' about people questioning Meldrum as opposed to other speakers? Please provide a link.

I'm not aware that I got 'touchy' - I think Meldrum is as answerable to questions as the next speaker. His PHD does not elevate him to some special status as far as I'm concerned - I thought I'd always been clear on that.

If you got the wrong impression about how I feel on the subject, I sincerly and unreservedly apologise, but I would still like a link please.


---

this was in the wake of the GA debacle, and I will look for it, amidst the many GA threads, you know what I mean, but i regard to the apology, accepted and appreciated, thanks. I'll find the relevant post and if you want to discuss we can, but the tone of my post was not meant be against you as much as it seems to me that the whole conference thing of late seems to be the hotbed of politics. Its gotten old.
 
Last edited:
That's fine Mikeyx - I'm just genuinely suprised to hear that I wrote such a thing. I mean, I know I write some real rubbish sometimes, so I wouldn't put it past me, but I genuinely don't remember doing so, and if I did, I am am thoroughly ashamed of myself, because it isn't what I think.

I suspect the conversation might have been along the lines of me saying that I see no reason why he shouldn't be allowed to sell casts at conferences just because he has a PHD. I think it is a little tacky, I know I wouldn't do it, and it depends on whether he is selling them as 'bigfoot casts' or 'alleged bigfoot casts', but in principal, I don't have a problem with it, but I don't think I have ever said that he shouldn't be subjected to questioning about his assertions.
 
Last edited:
My very first post on JREF :) I've been meaning to do this for a very long time.

Prince Paul! Welcome to hell! Enjoy your stay. Good move on Cult Freak Tom and Fanatic Chimp Bobo. Hey, I have a question. When members of your forum have threads on infrasound, or tree breaks, or what kind of pets Bigfoot keeps, etc do you find it funny good or funny bad?
 
That's fine Mikeyx - I'm just genuinely suprised to hear that I wrote such a thing. I mean, I know I write some real rubbish sometimes, so I wouldn't put it past me, but I genuinely don't remember doing so, and if I did, I am am thoroughly ashamed of myself, because it isn't what I think.

I suspect the conversation might have been along the lines of me saying that I see no reason why he shouldn't be allowed to sell casts at conferences just because he has a PHD. I think it is a little tacky, I know I wouldn't do it, and it depends on whether he is selling them as 'bigfoot casts' or 'alleged bigfoot casts', but in principal, I don't have a problem with it, but I don't think I have ever said that he shouldn't be subjected to questioning about his assertions.

time has passed, we;re good.
 
Welcome, Paul.

I reviewed your Sept. 2007 lecture on the PGF and found a number of unique "factoids" which I had never heard before. For this, your account of the PGF is unlike any other.

I can't seem to find your actual transcript (I thought it was on the web) now, but I did find several blogger reviews of your lecture. This one quotes you as saying Gimlin was "paid-off" by Pat Patterson for $10K. Do you have a reference for this information?

Bob Gimlin is still alive, works in a garage in Yakima, Washington State, and if drunk will tell you about his work with stunt motorcyclist ‘Evil’ Kenevel. He made very little money from the film, just a $10,000 pay-off from Mrs Patterson.

There are other curiousities in your lecture, but I'm just asking about this one now.
 
Anyone hear anything about any of the other speakers and all this other "new" stuff?

Meldrum probably claimed to have found a corn impression in one of the casts taken at the film site that no one without an advanced knowledge of foot morphology and podiatry could have hoaxed.

He left the stage to a smattering of applause and some wondering what in last night's BBQ gave them diarrhea.
 
:D

I wish I could find a link - but isn't it the case that during a frightening situation, our biology makes us assess the situation by estimating the maximum threat* we are likely to have to deal with?

So - when encountering a 'creature' no bigger than* seven feet (it may have actually been 6 ft) after the emotional needle settles, it can leave the impression that the encounter was actually with a seven foot individual.

That is certainly my experience - when I was a kid we encountered a huge spider in the house. My memory of that event puts the spider's size at way beyond what a British House Spider is capable of growing to - I'd like to say that it is just me exaggerating, but my memory of it is vivid and I have remembered that spider as being almost supernatural proportions. I can see it as clearly in my mind as I (thought I) did three decades ago, and it is obviously a false memory.
 
Prince Paul! Welcome to hell! Enjoy your stay. Good move on Cult Freak Tom and Fanatic Chimp Bobo. Hey, I have a question. When members of your forum have threads on infrasound, or tree breaks, or what kind of pets Bigfoot keeps, etc do you find it funny good or funny bad?

Those are three different questions.

Infrasound - I'll be honest, I tune out and don't read the threads - I think I got involved in one thread once about an article written about a BFRO expedition and thought "oh brother", it seems like something that can't be proved, so some people will hang on it as a reality knowing that sensible people can't disprove it as bigfoot-related activity.

Tree breaks (and stick formations) - I think it is people reading far too much into a natural occurance. I have often posted that I see the same tree breaks and stick formations occuring in the forest behind my house in England, so if they aren't bigfoot related here, what makes them bigfoot related in America? I think its bogus and I think people are reading what they want into naturally occuring situations.

Bigfoot Pets (and other assorted garbage) - I try not to read the threads - I don't have enough time on this planet to read that much garbage. It is a tough call deciding whether these sorts of threads should be pulled or not - we put our faith in the members that the threads will pull around to a sane opinion, so we usually let them live out their natural life cycle.
 
This one quotes you as saying Gimlin was "paid-off" by Pat Patterson for $10K. Do you have a reference for this information?

I'd have to dig that out - it was a figure I read some time ago. I don't think 'paid off' is the correct expression, my understanding is that it was an out-of-court settlement regarding the copyright. Its possible I used the phrase 'paid off', I can't remember, but I was referring to this settlement about the copyright, nothing else.

The Evel Kneivel reference is something told to me by Tom Yamarone himself, which is part of my argument about Gimlin's character. In the 1960s when Yamarone says Gimlin was hanging out with Kneivel, Kneivel was a known thief and poacher, which at the very least, makes 1960s Gimlin a poor judge of character. I don't have a problem with that, but as I've said, his 80 year old character shouldn't be held up as proof that the PGF must be genuine because he is such a nice guy (which of course he is). I didn't meet Gimlin in the 1960s, so I don't what he was like then.
 
Last edited:
Anyone hear anything about any of the other speakers and all this other "new" stuff?

Brian, Scott, myself and Jerry (Tugboatwa) have just finished recording a 'Bigfoot Show' where Jerry discusses some of the stuff presented at Yakima this weekend - it should be available via iTunes later today.

I can't post links yet, but I'll post a download link on 'thebigfootshow' website as soon as Brian uploads it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom