Gimlin's Yakima Bigfoot Party

Has anyone heard what other new bigfoot revelations came out of this event?
 
Cruising the BFF conferences subforum last nite I found pictures of the Gimlin luv-in. Kathy Strain apparently gave a presentation that equates Native American stone carvings of what appear to be ape heads to bigfoot. Anyone have the skinny on these carved ape heads? My google-fu is weak so a link or a hint in what direction to go would be appreciated.
 
Cruising the BFF conferences subforum last nite I found pictures of the Gimlin luv-in. Kathy Strain apparently gave a presentation that equates Native American stone carvings of what appear to be ape heads to bigfoot. Anyone have the skinny on these carved ape heads? My google-fu is weak so a link or a hint in what direction to go would be appreciated.

that is the kind of thing that started my interest in things squatchy, but they are likely totems open to interpretation
 
Carvings of mythical beasties does not constitute evidence for those beasties' (former or current) existence. If it were, we'd have to seriously consider the that gargoyles, unicorns, hippogriffs, bull-men, lion-men, etc. once populated the earth.
 
Carvings of mythical beasties does not constitute evidence for those beasties' (former or current) existence. If it were, we'd have to seriously consider the that gargoyles, unicorns, hippogriffs, bull-men, lion-men, etc. once populated the earth.

Not to disagree on that, but there were also carvings of animals that turned out to be real, so we can not rule out anything, unless they are biological impossibilities.
 
Not to disagree on that, but there were also carvings of animals that turned out to be real, so we can not rule out anything, unless they are biological impossibilities.

Which, in the grand scheme of things, is meaningless. Just because someone makes a carving of a bird doesn't mean their carving of a fire breathing dragon represents a real creature, nor should both carvings be considered equally.

Here's an idea: how about we rule out the carvings of the extraordinary animals they(and no one else for that matter) can't find, and accept as real the carvings of animals they can find? You know, the common-sense approach?
 
Which, in the grand scheme of things, is meaningless. Just because someone makes a carving of a bird doesn't mean their carving of a fire breathing dragon represents a real creature, nor should both carvings be considered equally.

Here's an idea: how about we rule out the carvings of the extraordinary animals they(and no one else for that matter) can't find, and accept as real the carvings of animals they can find? You know, the common-sense approach?

I like your second approach Xblade, however, such things as the Thunderbird and Underwater Panther were real animals, only with magical powers. They both resembled the Condor, and a regular Panther. This does not, however, even support squatch's existence, due to the complete lack of fossils of a giant ape in NA.
 
I understand that various Native American tribes have historically made carvings of real animals such as bears, crows, eagles, wolves, foxes, etc. They have also made carvings of mythical animals such as the great underwater panther and the thunderbird.

http://www.petroglyphs.us/article_sanilac_petroglyphs.html

So, which category do you think North American ape-men fall into?

Sasquatch does not even have to be considered a Mythical animal, but rather represent a symbol of a certain Indian tribe. Sasquatch was thought to be Large, naked, Indians.
 
Didn't Rene Dahinden pay Gimlin around $10 (in 70's dollars) for his portion of the PGF rights?

I need to post a good quality scan of the copyright filing from the Library of Congress, but the Gimlins sold the rights to Dahinden for $10. The agreement of sale is dated March 25, 1981 in Yakima County, Washington. The Gimlins retained one copy of the film for personal use which can only be shown privately to groups of less than 10 people for no monetary or other compensation.
 
I like your second approach Xblade, however, such things as the Thunderbird and Underwater Panther were real animals only with magical powers.

They were far from being or resembling real animals:

"The underwater panther was an amalgam of features from many animals: the horns of deer or bison; snake scales; bird feathers; the body and tail of a mountain lion; and parts from other animals as well, depending on the particular myth."

http://wapedia.mobi/en/Underwater_panther

It's not like the underwater panther was a regular panther that someone saw swimming one day and assumed it was due to magic.
 
They were far from being or resembling real animals:

"The underwater panther was an amalgam of features from many animals: the horns of deer or bison; snake scales; bird feathers; the body and tail of a mountain lion; and parts from other animals as well, depending on the particular myth."

http://wapedia.mobi/en/Underwater_panther

It's not like the underwater panther was a regular panther that someone saw swimming one day and assumed it was due to magic.

My mistake, thanks for correcting me on that Xblade. :D

The Thunderbird resembled the Condor in many ways.
 
Kathy Strain I forgot she was on Monster Quest.

The "Babes in the Woods" episode. Out looking for BF in the deepest, darkest area of the PNW. I loved it when one of their camera traps snapped a passing car!

Back to the Gilmlin luv-in.

No one can point me to anything on the carved heads? Maybe I'll have time to do some searching this weekend.

I wonder if Ole SOE Bob doesn't spill the beans on the PGF hoax because he doesn't want to hurt the feelings of all these folks or is he a cynical old ******* who is privately thinks "boy, have I put one over on all these numbskulls"?
 
The "Babes in the Woods" episode. Out looking for BF in the deepest, darkest area of the PNW. I loved it when one of their camera traps snapped a passing car!

Back to the Gilmlin luv-in.

No one can point me to anything on the carved heads? Maybe I'll have time to do some searching this weekend.

I wonder if Ole SOE Bob doesn't spill the beans on the PGF hoax because he doesn't want to hurt the feelings of all these folks or is he a cynical old ******* who is privately thinks "boy, have I put one over on all these numbskulls"?


There's an anthropological treatment of them in the volume: "Manlike Monsters on Trial". Authored by Roderick Sprague. He points out that some of the heads resemble bighorn sheep. Others could very well represent New World monkeys. These were well known to the natives in Central and SOuth America, so it wouldn't be surprising if the North Americans learned of them as well after a bit of travel.
 
Any anthropologist that specializes in NA Indian studies should know that trade routes from the far north to south existed long before Columbus arrived.
Trying to pretend that tribes lived in isolation and did not swap stories while engaged in trade is pretty silly.

 
Well, you don't actually need to be a specialist. You just have to stick your head outside highly biased and misinformation-ridden bigfootery-related texts. A quick look at Native American myths will show that there was cultural exchange. Take the trickster myths, for example. The animals who plays the trickster change but the essence of the tale is the same.

Read Campbell.

No, I still haven't read Strain's book, so I can't actually comment on it.
 
DY,

Thanks! Bighorn sheep or monkeys. I'll definitely do some searching this weekend if I can find the time.

My first thought was these carved heads post dated European contact. But if they are older, then the sheep/monkey explanation makes sense.

I am still amazed that people defend the Skookum elk lay so I guess Kathy Strain will always believe these carved heads represent BF.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom