General questions from a new member...

Um, honestly, WTC 7 was the only thing that has left a funny taste in my mouth. I think I am starting to understand how one side of the building failed first, thus causing the rest to fall. This just leaves me with the conclusion that I was not willing to accept before...

Gravy has an excellent paper on WTC7, which includes the hundreds of quotes from FDNY personnel about the intensity of fires in the building and extensiveness of the structural damage it suffered. I'd recommend reading it - after looking at those quotes you can only really conclude one of two things - either WTC7 collapsed from structural damage and fires, or hundreds of members of the FDNY are liars.


These buildings were not as strong as I thought they were. I think the general public has been mislead that these great feats of mankind are indestructible.

Maybe its the people who designed them that played this up. Reminds me of the Titanic and how people thought nothing like what happened could happen.. but it did.

There's an element of this which is just basic human behaviour. We build these enormous structures that defy our own insignificance, and we like to think these things will last forever. Great feats of human engineering and so forth. But the reality is of course in the great scheme of things even our greatest structures are pretty feeble. Tall buildings in particular, are not structurally robust. Just making the things stand up is a feat of engineering in itself. Once the structure is shifted out of harmony things can go very wrong.

It's also important to note that the forces these buildings were exposed to were far outside the realm of "normal" they were designed for. Massive impact forces, enormous fires, and staggering structural damage. Nothing can sustain that sort of force and be guaranteed to survive.


So, I think I am now at the possible LIHOP stage for a select few. I think if anything, they knew something was being planned but they didn't know when and where. They were obviously scared because of the security measures they took for themselves leading up to 9/11.

What would this be in reference to?


But honestly, if I were to recieve a death threat today, I really wouldn't know when or how it would happen.. I could only guess.

What if you received two hundred death threats every day from dozens of different people, and had been receiving them for the last twenty years?


So, im my conclusion about 9/11, I think at best, our government failed at letting us know the real threat we faced.

I think all of Western Civilisation failed to appreciate the level of threat - despite how evident it was. Indeed, I think most of Western Civilisation still doesn't appreciate the seriousness of the threat. I hardly think it's fair to overly criticise the US Government for having a position that reflected the view of the rest of the world.


That might have taken the shock value out from the people in the towers who didn't get out because they didn't understand the threat.

This is highly unlikely. Of course knowing the threat of Radical Islam and knowing the towers were going to collapse are totally unrelated. The reality is virtually everyone who could leave the towers did get out in time.


I also think that SOME people did know about it. It would be impossible for some key government officials to not hear anything at all. I won't buy it (flame me if you will).

I think you've got it backwards, and perhaps this is why Conspiracy Theorists can believe LIHOP. Information is not top down, it's bottom up. It's the people at the bottom - field agents in the CIA and FBI, operators in the NSA, informers, and lower level managers that first pick up the information. Key government officials know nothing until the information has passed up the chain to them.

So if "some key government officials" know something, that means hundreds upon hundreds of regular men and women working in various government agencies also have to know - and know more. This is why LIHOP can't work. It requires hundreds of plain ordinary people, who are working poorly paid high stress jobs with the sole task of protecting their nation, of committing treason.

People like John O'Neill (FBI) and Michael Scheuer (CIA) were the ones who knew more than anyone else about Al Qaeda. Either they knew, and did nothing to stop the people they had dedicated their lives to stopping, or no one knew as much as you think they did.

-Gumboot
 
Yes, I do apologize, but we have been bitten here many times by the juvenile tactics of trutherclan exhibiting the "Mark of Woo"..

TAM:)
 
Guys hold on a moment here,

Lee5 came here with doubts about 9/11. Some of those doubts have been addressed. Lee5 has taken our responses on board and has accepted that the buildings collapsed due to impact damage and fires, not some sort of demolition.

Lee5 is quite obviously not a "truther" as a "truther" is incapable of doing that. Give them a chance. No one should ever be punished for being ignorant - especially when they're actively trying to seek information.

-Gumboot

Err, lee5, excuseth me whilst I jam my foot into my mouth repeatedly.

:footinmou:footinmou:footinmou:footinmou:footinmou:footinmou:footinmou:footinmou:footinmou:footinmou

There is no excuse for me being so skeptical of the motives of every single person who comes in here. Please accept my apologies.
 
Last edited:
Meh.... what's that saying?... 6 years after 9/11 and if you claim to have not made up your mind you're either too lazy to pay attention or you're a closet 'truther'...something like that.

But, whatever...
 
And, that is my fear, that I will have gonnen sucked into something stupid and have wasted time to only come to the conclusion that our government is good.

Youve gotabe kidding me?
 
These buildings were not as strong as I thought they were. I think the general public has been mislead that these great feats of mankind are indestructible.

Are you guy's buying this?
 
Well, my common sense has served me well as a mechanical engineer so far. It never fails.
:rolleyes:

Im trying to put together a question but first I need to know the answer to this question...

Did any of the building fall at free fall speed?

If no, how far was the time off from being what would be called "free" fall speed?
:eek:

OK this is just TOO MUCH.
 
So according to the shi... posters on this site, War games didn't even exist on 9/11


Hilarious
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_games_in_progress_on_September_11,_2001

No. That's not what we are saying at all. But feel free to make up what you want to hear in place of what was said.

There were drills being held that day. The thing is, they made little to not difference in the events of that day. Having planes not in Alaska would not make a difference, other drills merely meant that folks were in their seats rather than in some meeting at the HR department.IT MADE LITTLE TO NO DIFFERENCE.

Now, in troother world, drills being held the day of the attack is always considered a sign of the conspiracy. Their little brains think "OMG!!! 365 DAYS A YEAR AND THEY RAN A DRILL ON 9/11 OMG!!!!ITS TEH CONSPIRACY!!!"

But the fact of the matter is that agencies run drills. The run them a lot. Short of actual events, it is all they can do to try and keep things sharp and test protocols. There are many, many agencies and almost all of them run drills of one kind or another. If these two weren't running drills, then the Army would have been, or the Navy, or the City of New York's emergency forces, or the FBI, the BATF.

It is ludicrous, in analyzing the events of that day, to suggest there was anything odd about the drills, or that they had any real effect on events.

Except in trootherland.
 
There must be some scientific formula to explain the scientific term of "global collapse".

I'm just on page 4 now folks so forgive me if this piss-puller has already been outed. But Jeeze you guys have mucho more patience than I do.
 
You really believe that gum?

Guys hold on a moment here,

Lee5 came here with doubts about 9/11. Some of those doubts have been addressed. Lee5 has taken our responses on board and has accepted that the buildings collapsed due to impact damage and fires, not some sort of demolition.

Lee5 is quite obviously not a "truther" as a "truther" is incapable of doing that. Give them a chance. No one should ever be punished for being ignorant - especially when they're actively trying to seek information.

-Gumboot

He is after all...just asking questions.

would just like to note...

I came here to ask questions... I didn't say I have facts for you to look at. Im not trying to convince anyone of a conspiracy. I am simply asking about them.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I am not insisting on any conspiracy!! Thats why I continue to get upset. You guys assume, because I ask questions that I am some kind of nut.

Its not crazy to question things that don't make sense to the naked eye. Its not crazy to question the conspiracy theory's that you hear. Its not crazy to NOT accept EVERYONES evidence as fact.

That my friend, would make a crazy world.

Of course it is a crazy world we live in lee5, it is so crazy that 19 guys would jump onboard four planes and slam three of them into landmark buildings inside the US. How crazy is that lee5? It is utterly absurd that anybody would do such a thing, it beyond ones wildest imagination that anybody could be driven to do such a thing isn't it?

Its goes beyond ones wildest imagination that the US, a super power could be brought to her knees by such reckless wild actions and to ones naked eye it makes no sense whatsoever. It beggars believe that individuals who come from a long, proud culture would in anyway be able to strike back at the perceived injustices they felt had been dealt out to their fellow countrymen. It simply defies believe that individuals who were so incensed by such injustices would broad planes , kill all in their paths, take control and slam them into buildings full of innocent men ,women and children, killing citizens from over 70 countries. This world is so crazy that some loonies actually believe that the entire planet would stand idly by while Islamic terrorists murder their citizens and do nothing. It is so crazy that rather than join the rest of the planet in expressing utter revulsion at this dreadful crime against humanity some dudes would try to blame anybody, including their own countrymen of being involved in mass murder, rather than those who have repeatedly claimed responsibility.

Yes Lee5, it is a crazy world , it is made all the more crazier by loonies, ghouls and fools who bury their heads in the sand , pretend that it was all one big hoax, and pretend a small percentage of people within the US managed to fool the entire planet. A tiny silly group would have you believes that there is no such thing as Islamic fundamentalism, that it would be impossible for cavemen to do such a dreadful thing and that global terrorism is all made up, one big false flag. They would have you believe that the " offical story" is all one big lie, it was all made up, just so we could go and steel oil, start a NWO, and kill people from the middle East.In this same crazy world those that push and profit from these insane theories will also tell you that anybody who does not subscribe to their line of thinking are simply US Goverment shills who lap all up all they are told by the US Govn, they are blissfully unaware of all the worlds injuctices, blind sheep who simply tow the line.

Of course in the real world, the world not full of craziness, there is no such thing, no "official story", just mountains of evidence, testimony and statements from those unfortunate enough to be caught up in the worse, single terrorist attack this century. Those who have to live day in and day would with dreadful memories of that dreadful day. Equally so there is the same festering resentment that drove these 19 individuals to comment such a wicked act. It still lingers and will not go away; Al Qaeda is the real deal Lee5. If you wish to point fingers or ask questions maybe you should ponder the biggest question of all “Why?". Why would anybody wish to hurt us so much?

Maybe it is better you and your fellow conspirators don't ask such a question, the answer is far more horrific than anything you guys could dream up.

Does that make sense?
 
Last edited:
Gravy has an excellent paper on WTC7, which includes the hundreds of quotes from FDNY personnel about the intensity of fires in the building and extensiveness of the structural damage it suffered. I'd recommend reading it - after looking at those quotes you can only really conclude one of two things - either WTC7 collapsed from structural damage and fires, or hundreds of members of the FDNY are liars.




There's an element of this which is just basic human behaviour. We build these enormous structures that defy our own insignificance, and we like to think these things will last forever. Great feats of human engineering and so forth. But the reality is of course in the great scheme of things even our greatest structures are pretty feeble. Tall buildings in particular, are not structurally robust. Just making the things stand up is a feat of engineering in itself. Once the structure is shifted out of harmony things can go very wrong.

It's also important to note that the forces these buildings were exposed to were far outside the realm of "normal" they were designed for. Massive impact forces, enormous fires, and staggering structural damage. Nothing can sustain that sort of force and be guaranteed to survive.




What would this be in reference to?




What if you received two hundred death threats every day from dozens of different people, and had been receiving them for the last twenty years?




I think all of Western Civilisation failed to appreciate the level of threat - despite how evident it was. Indeed, I think most of Western Civilisation still doesn't appreciate the seriousness of the threat. I hardly think it's fair to overly criticise the US Government for having a position that reflected the view of the rest of the world.




This is highly unlikely. Of course knowing the threat of Radical Islam and knowing the towers were going to collapse are totally unrelated. The reality is virtually everyone who could leave the towers did get out in time.




I think you've got it backwards, and perhaps this is why Conspiracy Theorists can believe LIHOP. Information is not top down, it's bottom up. It's the people at the bottom - field agents in the CIA and FBI, operators in the NSA, informers, and lower level managers that first pick up the information. Key government officials know nothing until the information has passed up the chain to them.

So if "some key government officials" know something, that means hundreds upon hundreds of regular men and women working in various government agencies also have to know - and know more. This is why LIHOP can't work. It requires hundreds of plain ordinary people, who are working poorly paid high stress jobs with the sole task of protecting their nation, of committing treason.

People like John O'Neill (FBI) and Michael Scheuer (CIA) were the ones who knew more than anyone else about Al Qaeda. Either they knew, and did nothing to stop the people they had dedicated their lives to stopping, or no one knew as much as you think they did.

-Gumboot

Thanks Gumboot. More points for me to consider.

The the others that are still continue to flame me go ahead. I won't be online for the next 4 days anyway.

And honestly, I got mostly what I came for. Gumboot and a couple others (I forgot their names off the top of my head) have answered most of my questions. I don't believe that the government was behind 9/11. I wasn't so sure before and that's why I came hear... to ask questions. Sure I have other questions but I will have a better way of thinking as I investigate these further.

Some of you insist on your methods of "handling truthers". If you think that is working for you to show people the real truth then fine. Good luck to that.
 
Of course it is a crazy world we live in lee5, it is so crazy that 19 guys would jump onboard four planes and slam three of them into landmark buildings inside the US. How crazy is that lee5? It is utterly absurd that anybody would do such a thing, it beyond ones wildest imagination that anybody could be driven to do such a thing isn't it?

Its goes beyond ones wildest imagination that the US, a super power could be brought to her knees by such reckless wild actions and to ones naked eye it makes no sense whatsoever. It beggars believe that individuals who come from a long, proud culture would in anyway be able to strike back at the perceived injustices they felt had been dealt out to their fellow countrymen. It simply defies believe that individuals who were so incensed by such injustices would broad planes , kill all in their paths, take control and slam them into buildings full of innocent men ,women and children, killing citizens from over 70 countries. This world is so crazy that some loonies actually believe that the entire planet would stand idly by while Islamic terrorists murder their citizens and do nothing. It is so crazy that rather than join the rest of the planet in expressing utter revulsion at this dreadful crime against humanity some dudes would try to blame anybody, including their own countrymen of being involved in mass murder, rather than those who have repeatedly claimed responsibility.

Yes Lee5, it is a crazy world , it is made all the more crazier by loonies, ghouls and fools who bury their heads in the sand , pretend that it was all one big hoax, and pretend a small percentage of people within the US managed to fool the entire planet. A tiny silly group would have you believes that there is no such thing as Islamic fundamentalism, that it would be impossible for cavemen to do such a dreadful thing and that global terrorism is all made up, one big false flag. They would have you believe that the " offical story" is all one big lie, it was all made up, just so we could go and steel oil, start a NWO, and kill people from the middle East.In this same crazy world those that push and profit from these insane theories will also tell you that anybody who does not subscribe to their line of thinking are simply US Goverment shills who lap all up all they are told by the US Govn, they are blissfully unaware of all the worlds injuctices, blind sheep who simply tow the line.

Of course in the real world, the world not full of craziness, there is no such thing, no "official story", just mountains of evidence, testimony and statements from those unfortunate enough to be caught up in the worse, single terrorist attack this century. Those who have to live day in and day would with dreadful memories of that dreadful day. Equally so there is the same festering resentment that drove these 19 individuals to comment such a wicked act. It still lingers and will not go away; Al Qaeda is the real deal Lee5. If you wish to point fingers or ask questions maybe you should ponder the biggest question of all “Why?". Why would anybody wish to hurt us so much?

Maybe it is better you and your fellow conspirators don't ask such a question, the answer is far more horrific than anything you guys could dream up.

Does that make sense?

I think you totaly missed the point of my post. That is evident by calling me a "conspirator". Oh well. Thanks for your time.
 
I'm just on page 4 now folks so forgive me if this piss-puller has already been outed. But Jeeze you guys have mucho more patience than I do.

You seem to have allot to say about my posts. Would you care to give me a conclusion about who I am and what I am trying to accomplish by this thread? You obviously think I have some sort of evil agenda. May I hear it?

Some of you guys are just plain jerks. But, what else would I expect from people on the internet?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom