General questions from a new member...

By all means, impress us with your job responsibilities.

I think it is hard to impress those who think they are above everyone else.

What do you do for a living? Actually, scratch that, it really doesn't matter because I wouldn't hold it against you in the ability to have an intelligent discussion.

Well, unless you had a really silly job ;)
 
It is standard operating procedure to scramble jet figthers for any one of the following situations.

1)An aircraft goes off course
2)Radio contact with it is lost
3)The transponder is turned off.

On 9/11 the 4 hijacked aircraft met not just one, but all 3 of these criteria!

The air defense network had, on September 11th, predictable and effective procedures for dealing with just such an attack. Yet it failed to respond in a timely manner until after the attack was over, more than an hour and a half after it had started.

Why were these protocols not followed to prevent the attacks?

1. Who says this is the way it's handled?

2. Even if that is right, you've never been in the military have you?




CIA/National Reconnaissance Office exercise
Simulation of a plane crash into the NRO headquarters (near DUlles Airport, Virginia) -- Not a "terrorism" exercise, resulted in evacuation of most NRO employees just as the "real" 9/11 was taking place.
Effects: made it more difficult for a nation's spy sattelites to be used to track the hijacked planes.
How can a spy sat track a plane? Do you think that these sats just sit over a target?

Vigiliant Guardian: Simulated very closely the hijackings of 9/11
Effects: Top NORAD personnel were confused, not sure if the 9/11 hijackings were "real-world or exercise"
IIRC therse are the ones that hadn't started yet.

Northern Vigilance: Planned months in advance, involved deploying fighter jets to locations in Alaska and norther Canada
Effects: Ensured that there would be fewer fighter planes available to protect the East Coast on 9/11. Confusion from simulated information fed into radar screens.
So Planes from the east coast were over Alaska?

Vigilant Warrior [Richard Clark, "Against All Enemies"
NOrthern Guardian [Toronto Star, December 9, 2001]
Tripod II [Bio-Warfare exercise scheduled for 9/12/01]
Effects: FEMA was deployed to NYC area on 9/10/01 according to FEMA spokesman Tom Kenny [Dan Rather interview, 9/12/01][Gulliani 9/11 Commission May 2004]
[/quote]

And all of these were happening during the attacks?
 
Last edited:
Hi lee5,

I just wonder if there's any specific aspect of 9/11 that you'd like to discuss in detail - perhaps an area that you feel is suspicious, or the "official version" doesn't add up, or you just don't know much about it.

-Gumboot
 
OMG you guys are amazing...

I am in no way saying my job qualifies me as an expert. I never said that. Gees, whats your damn point your trying to make? I just told you my job title and you guys are stoping at nothing to make me look bad.

This is just an attempt to flog me. I said I don't have a damn degree Im just a damn MECHANICAL engineer and I understand that doesn't mean ****.

Are you happy yet?

You're the one who used the Jerry Springer tactic of "YA'LL DON'T KNOW ME! YA'LL DON'T KNOW ME!" and then when people tried to ask you about your history, you called it an "insult".

As I've tried to tell you, vague innuendo and speculation will get you nowhere on this forum. If you want to make bizarre accusations with no evidence, go to the Loose Change Forum. They'll love you. Here....not so much. If you want to make an extraordinary claim, you will need extraordinary evidence. If you continue to argue in favor of a conspiracy without evidence, ridicule is the inevitable conclusion.

If you continually insist on conspiracy with little evidence and little experience within the field, no one is going to take you seriously. It's not a deliberate insult, it's just the norm in the academic community. Deal with it!
 
Hi lee5,

I just wonder if there's any specific aspect of 9/11 that you'd like to discuss in detail - perhaps an area that you feel is suspicious, or the "official version" doesn't add up, or you just don't know much about it.

-Gumboot

Whew, a real post. Thanks.

Um, honestly, WTC 7 was the only thing that has left a funny taste in my mouth. I think I am starting to understand how one side of the building failed first, thus causing the rest to fall. This just leaves me with the conclusion that I was not willing to accept before...

These buildings were not as strong as I thought they were. I think the general public has been mislead that these great feats of mankind are indestructible.

Maybe its the people who designed them that played this up. Reminds me of the Titanic and how people thought nothing like what happened could happen.. but it did.

So, I think I am now at the possible LIHOP stage for a select few. I think if anything, they knew something was being planned but they didn't know when and where. They were obviously scared because of the security measures they took for themselves leading up to 9/11.

But honestly, if I were to recieve a death threat today, I really wouldn't know when or how it would happen.. I could only guess.

So, im my conclusion about 9/11, I think at best, our government failed at letting us know the real threat we faced. That might have taken the shock value out from the people in the towers who didn't get out because they didn't understand the threat.

I also think that SOME people did know about it. It would be impossible for some key government officials to not hear anything at all. I won't buy it (flame me if you will).

As far as bombs in buildings..... I am debunked.


Now... That doesn't mean I don't have other questions about other topics :)

I am still very leary of the CIA and its operations. I still believe there is involvment in the JFK assisanation.

I am still leary of the Rockefellers and the Rothschilds having to much influience with our governent. I believe these people have bad intentions/interests.

I don't understand a good reason for Builderburg (sp?) to take place under such secrecy.

I don't understand the Jonestown massacre. How were 900 people dead (most of whom shot in the head) and the "leader" had CIA ties.


I got more but theres a few.
 
Operation Cyclone: 1986-1992

The CIA and MI6 (British Intelligence) recruit and train more than 100,000 militants to help fight Afghan "jihad" against the Soviet Union.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Cyclone

Ok, First you said "1995, then you say "1992" above, and the article you quote says 1989. Which is it?





Please show me how I have been "corrected" on the admitted wire transfer.
As far as i know you haven't. i was wondering if you would answer a question without a cutnpaste.



Head US Consular Official was told to Issue Visas to mujihadeen terrorists.

Michael Springmann, head US consular official in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, claims that during this period he is "repeatedly told to issue visas to unqualified applicants." He turns them down, but is repeatedly overruled by superiors. Springmann loudly complains to numerous government officers, but no action is taken. He is fired and his files on these applicants are destroyed.

Springmann said "What I was doing was giving visas to terrorists recruited by the CIA and Osama bin Laden to come back to the United States for training to be used in the war in Afghanistan against the then Soviets." the Jeddah consulate was run by the CIA and staffed almost entirely by intelligence agents. This visa system may have continued at least through 9/11, and 15 of the 19 9/11 hijackers received their visas through Jeddah, possibly as part of this program. [BBC 11/6/2001; Associated Press, 7/17/2002; Fox News, 7/18/2002]

What Years was Springmann talking about?

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/events/newsnight/1645527.stm
http://www.cooperativeresearch.org/entity.jsp?entity=us_consulate,_jedda,_saudi_arabia_office
Odd, Why did you include Fox News but not the St Petersburg times?
 
You're the one who used the Jerry Springer tactic of "YA'LL DON'T KNOW ME! YA'LL DON'T KNOW ME!" and then when people tried to ask you about your history, you called it an "insult".

As I've tried to tell you, vague innuendo and speculation will get you nowhere on this forum. If you want to make bizarre accusations with no evidence, go to the Loose Change Forum. They'll love you. Here....not so much. If you want to make an extraordinary claim, you will need extraordinary evidence. If you continue to argue in favor of a conspiracy without evidence, ridicule is the inevitable conclusion.

If you continually insist on conspiracy with little evidence and little experience within the field, no one is going to take you seriously. It's not a deliberate insult, it's just the norm in the academic community. Deal with it!

I am not insisting on any conspiracy!! Thats why I continue to get upset. You guys assume, because I ask questions that I am some kind of nut.

Its not crazy to question things that don't make sense to the naked eye. Its not crazy to question the conspiracy theory's that you hear. Its not crazy to NOT accept EVERYONES evidence as fact.

That my friend, would make a crazy world.
 
I would just like to note...

I came here to ask questions... I didn't say I have facts for you to look at. Im not trying to convince anyone of a conspiracy. I am simply asking about them.

I think you all got upset when I tried to explain that I don't take every "experts" "facts" as real evidence. Sorry if I make you mad that your "experts" don't define my position. Thats just how I am. I think I am more skeptical than some of YOU are if anything and that bothers you.

Now, may we get back to a normal conversation about Conspiracy Theories? I am actually here to have mine debunked so I can think the world is a safer place and I can start looking at different topics on the web.... like porn. lol (j/k)
 
Last edited:
I am not insisting on any conspiracy!! Thats why I continue to get upset. You guys assume, because I ask questions that I am some kind of nut.

Its not crazy to question things that don't make sense to the naked eye. Its not crazy to question the conspiracy theory's that you hear. Its not crazy to NOT accept EVERYONES evidence as fact.

That my friend, would make a crazy world.

If you are not an actual 9/11truther, and you are really here for information, then I apologize. However, you have had all the markings of a truther by initially claiming to be new and a skeptic, then suddently knowing ALL THE (debunked) TRUTHER ARGUMENTS. This his led all of us to be suspicious of your story. Making long-winded and pointless rants about how close-minded we are after trying to address your issues does not help your case. Keep that in mind.

If I sound like a jerk, remember that tons of truthers have come on this board claiming to be new skeptics, only to show their colors after a few posts. It is a tactic that I don't understand, yet it exists for whatever reason.
 
Just curious, why did you choose the JREF forum to ask these questions?

Allot of people seem to be very intelligent here. I was just afraid of posting for the very things that have happened.

I know that if I ask a question, that puts a target on my back. I am looking for people to make sense of some things I have heard. But in a selfesh way because you got to convince ME, and by doing so, I will only accept answers that make sense to my way of thinking.

I know thats a unfair task to ask, but I am just being honest. Like I said, I don't take everything I hear as fact so if you tell me something, chances are I won't believe you ;)

But seriously, I respect most of you. You just don't understand my unique way of thinking.

Make any sense?
 
If you are not an actual 9/11truther, and you are really here for information, then I apologize. However, you have had all the markings of a truther by initially claiming to be new and a skeptic, then suddently knowing ALL THE (debunked) TRUTHER ARGUMENTS. This his led all of us to be suspicious of your story. Making long-winded and pointless rants about how close-minded we are after trying to address your issues does not help your case. Keep that in mind.

If I sound like a jerk, remember that tons of truthers have come on this board claiming to be new skeptics, only to show their colors after a few posts. It is a tactic that I don't understand, yet it exists for whatever reason.

I don't feel like a "truther" because I won't say I know the truth. But, when getting backed into a corner, I myself started to think I was sounding like one. In truth, I think I come off that way when I am on the deffensive. I have been know to argue about things just for the sake of defending myself. Just ask my parents.

But all in all, Im still glad I started this thread.
 
what;s are point? that you come in here claiming to be a "mechanical engineer" when thats far from the truth. we dont like liar,s and well, you just proved yourself to be one.
 
Allot of people seem to be very intelligent here. I was just afraid of posting for the very things that have happened.

I know that if I ask a question, that puts a target on my back. I am looking for people to make sense of some things I have heard. But in a selfesh way because you got to convince ME, and by doing so, I will only accept answers that make sense to my way of thinking.

I know thats a unfair task to ask, but I am just being honest. Like I said, I don't take everything I hear as fact so if you tell me something, chances are I won't believe you ;)

But seriously, I respect most of you. You just don't understand my unique way of thinking.

Make any sense?


Not really. By stating up front that you aren't going to believe anything I say, what is the point of my doing the legwork to find answers for you? Honestly, it just sounds like some kind of game to you, when to many dedicated people, including several on this forum, it is anything but. Sorry to sound so dismissive, but if it cannot be a dialog (or at least a compromise), there really is no point. I can save myself a world of time and frustration by just giving you several pages of links, then waiting until you have a valid question based on the information in the links.

Make any sense?
 
what;s are point? that you come in here claiming to be a "mechanical engineer" when thats far from the truth. we dont like liar,s and well, you just proved yourself to be one.

ok......

my job title says that. THATS ALL I SAID DAMMIT.

Do you want me to tell my boss and all of the other engineers that I work with that they are all liars and they are not engineers and I quit for tricking me into thinking I got a job as an engineer? Some of these dudes make $200,000 a year and I have the same damn title.

So sue me.
 
Then that is not my problem. If you didn't graduate or have a degree in engineering, and your 'boss' fell for your lie, then that is not our problem.

Suffice to say, by your questions and of course you replies here, its very apparent that you are not an "engineer" or that of a "mechanical" one either.
 
Not really. By stating up front that you aren't going to believe anything I say, what is the point of my doing the legwork to find answers for you? Honestly, it just sounds like some kind of game to you, when to many dedicated people, including several on this forum, it is anything but. Sorry to sound so dismissive, but if it cannot be a dialog (or at least a compromise), there really is no point. I can save myself a world of time and frustration by just giving you several pages of links, then waiting until you have a valid question based on the information in the links.

Make any sense?

I don't think I said I wasn't going to believe anything you were going to say. If I did, I didn't mean it and Im sorry.

I just said that if you tell me an "expert" says something, I am not necessarily going to believe him.
 
I don't feel like a "truther" because I won't say I know the truth. But, when getting backed into a corner, I myself started to think I was sounding like one. In truth, I think I come off that way when I am on the deffensive. I have been know to argue about things just for the sake of defending myself. Just ask my parents.

But all in all, Im still glad I started this thread.




Here's my point:
I don't have blind faith in my government as most of you do (it seems).
Ok, that makes sense but, it still doesn't justify a lie that ends up killing thousands of people does it?

And if its known to be a lie, then where is the line drawn on what is ok to lie about and what is not?
Its a fact that the "independant" investigation was leaded by somebody who had ties to the very people that are accused. That, for me, discredits 99% of that investigation.


These kinds of statements really make it look like you already had your mind made up before you ever came to this forum. Maybe you didn't! But it sure looks familiar to the rest of the posters here. Keep in mind most (if not all) of your criticisms have been addressed previously on this forum, so you could easily find them by using the search function. Some of the people here (notably Gravy) are getting sick and tired of addressing the same issues over and over again.
 
Last edited:
now that doesn't make sense. what the xpert says should be backed up his evidence and has been reviewed by his peers.

why would you ignore what an expert says, and rather believe what a theologian would say on the subject of structural engineering?
 
Then that is not my problem. If you didn't graduate or have a degree in engineering, and your 'boss' fell for your lie, then that is not our problem.

Suffice to say, by your questions and of course you replies here, its very apparent that you are not an "engineer" or that of a "mechanical" one either.


My boss didn't fall for anything. I never applied for the job, they offered it to me after seeing me work with their equipment and hearing about me from other engineers.

and thanks for telling me what I am, or better yet, what I am not.

Suffice to say, you are not a engineer of any kind.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom