General questions from a new member...

now that doesn't make sense. what the xpert says should be backed up his evidence and has been reviewed by his peers.

why would you ignore what an expert says, and rather believe what a theologian would say on the subject of structural engineering?

I meet "experts" all the time. Some of them are stupid. Simple fact.

I am sitting next to one right now.... 20 years experience with an engineering degree.... cant fix ****. I make more than him.
 
Last edited:
I don't think I said I wasn't going to believe anything you were going to say. If I did, I didn't mean it and Im sorry.


Well, you did say that, but apology accepted.

I just said that if you tell me an "expert" says something, I am not necessarily going to believe him.


Here is the thing, there is a difference between expert testimony that can be verified, and that which cannot be verified. The trouble is, a layperson cannot always tell the difference. There was a thread on this very topic earlier this year.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2448404#post2448404

If you would do me a favor, can you please read through that thread (it isn't very long), and tell me if there is anything you disagree with in there? By narrowing down what defines an expert, there may be sources that you would accept that would clear up any confusion.
 
i notice that you put experts in quotes. that tells me that you aren't meeting experts at all, but those who claim to be experts but aren't.

Again, your dancing around the term isn't funny nor impressive.

Why did you avoid my question?

what would you believe an expert in structural engineering, and rather believe a theologians belief on structural engineering?
 
Well, you did say that, but apology accepted.




Here is the thing, there is a difference between expert testimony that can be verified, and that which cannot be verified. The trouble is, a layperson cannot always tell the difference. There was a thread on this very topic earlier this year.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2448404#post2448404

If you would do me a favor, can you please read through that thread (it isn't very long), and tell me if there is anything you disagree with in there? By narrowing down what defines an expert, there may be sources that you would accept that would clear up any confusion.

Ok, reading. I think this is a big part of my problem I agree. I think I have seen to many people come into my work that are suppose to be "defining" experts that don't know a damn thing compared to what I do (in my field).

On the other hand, I work with an englishman that is pure genius. He is MY expert.

Ill let you know when I am done reading.
 
i notice that you put experts in quotes. that tells me that you aren't meeting experts at all, but those who claim to be experts but aren't.

Again, your dancing around the term isn't funny nor impressive.

Why did you avoid my question?

what would you believe an expert in structural engineering, and rather believe a theologians belief on structural engineering?

Im sorry if I am not answering your question. I am not meaning to dodge it. Maybe I don't understant the question.

I put the term "expert" in quotes because these people, and the people around them, claim they are.

Plus they have all the credentials to back it up. But, 3 out of 4 times, I am not that impressed.
 
Ok, reading. I think this is a big part of my problem I agree. I think I have seen to many people come into my work that are suppose to be "defining" experts that don't know a damn thing compared to what I do (in my field).

On the other hand, I work with an englishman that is pure genius. He is MY expert.

Ill let you know when I am done reading.


Cool, but I have to toddle off to bed now. I will try to get back to you tomorrow (if 50 different posters haven't beaten me to it by then).
 
now that doesn't make sense. what the xpert says should be backed up his evidence and has been reviewed by his peers.

why would you ignore what an expert says, and rather believe what a theologian would say on the subject of structural engineering?

I never said I fully believe what a theologian would say. And I don't ignore completly what an expert says. I just realize that the term "expert" can be givin to people who are not very smart. I have witnesses first hand.
 
Allot of people seem to be very intelligent here. I was just afraid of posting for the very things that have happened.

I know that if I ask a question, that puts a target on my back. I am looking for people to make sense of some things I have heard. But in a selfesh way because you got to convince ME, and by doing so, I will only accept answers that make sense to my way of thinking.

But what if it's your way of thinking that is the problem? What is your way of thinking? Stuff like common sense and gut feeling work in everyday life, but if you're like me in that your everyday life is not that of a demolitions expert, our common sense and gut feelings are totally irrelevant to 9/11. It's not that common sense isn't useful in life, it's just that here it's called upon to do a job it's unprepared for.
 
But what if it's your way of thinking that is the problem? What is your way of thinking? Stuff like common sense and gut feeling work in everyday life, but if you're like me in that your everyday life is not that of a demolitions expert, our common sense and gut feelings are totally irrelevant to 9/11. It's not that common sense isn't useful in life, it's just that here it's called upon to do a job it's unprepared for.

Good point.

I think I get confused when I hear two different experts saying different things. It DOES happen.
If you want to know more about why I am leary of "experts" you would have to understand some of the medical issues I have been through and how many "experts" have almost killed me. Thats honestly when I started realizing that I can't believe anyone just on their credentials alone.
 
Last edited:
Everybody, stop it now, please. This thread has become far too personalised.

Please address the arguments, and do not attack the arguer. If this continues, the thread may be split, or just moved, to Abandon All Hope.

lee5, there is a thread in this section identifying all the qualifications of members here, which you may find interesting.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
oh gees... more bashing.

No, I don't have a degree. I didn't finish college.

I think anybody is qualified to have a credible opinion, afterall, its just an opinion right?!? :boggled:

No, I don't know your education level... what is it? :boggled:

SO are you a mechanical engineer or not?

TAM:)
 
Good point.

I think I get confused when I hear two different experts saying different things. It DOES happen.
If you want to know more about why I am leary of "experts" you would have to understand some of the medical issues I have been through and how many "experts" have almost killed me. Thats honestly when I started realizing that I can't believe anyone just on their credentials alone.

Oh Boy...Well, I guess you better stay away from me then...

TAM:)
 
So this is a closed-minded site that only accepts one view point

Even if that were true, did you notice we don't ban people for having another view point ?

Are you joking?

So you don't think there is a single hole in the Official Narrative of 9/11?

Not a single hole?

Depends if you can name one that stands up to scrutiny.

But for starters how about the commission even admitted that NORAD gave them a false account.

How is that a "hole" if it's admitted ?

So not only is the official narrative accurate but there are no legitimate anomalies surrounding the event.

Still waiting.

Obviously it's circumstantial evidence but most criminal cases have to rely on circumstantial evidence.

This is not a criminal case.

It's more than enough to suggest that we have had people in key positions who have demonstrated more actions to allow the attacks to happen than prevent them.

Non sequitur.

The world is a much easier place to live in when the bad guys and good guys aren't on the same side

Appeal to emotion.

The reason I don't get into speculation like LC is because it's pointless. It only diffuses the situation.

And it means you can always claim that you never accused anyone of anything. How convenient.
 
I think those terrorists wouldn't have had the means and opportunity to pull it off without some help on the other side.

Argument from incredulity.

The problem lies within all the coincidences that are documented that ALLOWED them to get away with it.

Same.

Found a lot I can't quote about banking conspiracy because of that

You can't quote it because it'll make you less credible ? Big surprise, there.
 
I am still very leary of the CIA and its operations. I still believe there is involvment in the JFK assisanation.

I mentioned to you earlier. Read "Reclaiming History" by Vincent Bugliosi. You'll never believe in a JFK conspiracy again.
(BTW, "Helter Skelter", also by Bugliosi, remains one of the most fascinating books I have ever read.)
I don't understand the Jonestown massacre. How were 900 people dead (most of whom shot in the head) and the "leader" had CIA ties.

False. They were poisoned. A few were shot in the head probably by Jones or his henchmen because they wouldn't drink it.

Where do you get this stuff?
 
Then that is not my problem. If you didn't graduate or have a degree in engineering, and your 'boss' fell for your lie, then that is not our problem.

Suffice to say, by your questions and of course you replies here, its very apparent that you are not an "engineer" or that of a "mechanical" one either.

I am going to disagree with you and say that he very well could be working as an engineer and not be degreed. I have known many "engineers" who were way better than degreed ones because they took the time to get experience on the job. Do not resort to truther tactics and try to discredit someone because they do not have a degree. Am I discredited because my degree is EET, while I have been doing mechanical work for the past 9 years?

However, I agree that he should be taken to task for relying on "gut" feeling for something as complex as the collapses. He should also be questioned about how his experience as an ME would mean he has expertise on the collapse, especially in relation to structural engineers and architects.
 
These buildings were not as strong as I thought they were. I think the general public has been mislead that these great feats of mankind are indestructible.

Who ever said they were ?

Maybe its the people who designed them that played this up. Reminds me of the Titanic and how people thought nothing like what happened could happen.. but it did.

Nobody ever said the trade center was invincible.

So, I think I am now at the possible LIHOP stage for a select few. I think if anything, they knew something was being planned but they didn't know when and where.

Which makes it very difficult to stop someone, doesn't it ?

So, im my conclusion about 9/11, I think at best, our government failed at letting us know the real threat we faced.

And not because of incompetence.

I also think that SOME people did know about it. It would be impossible for some key government officials to not hear anything at all. I won't buy it

Aside from sheer incredulity, why the hell not ?

I am still very leary of the CIA and its operations. I still believe there is involvment in the JFK assisanation.

For no other reason than... what, already ?

I am still leary of the Rockefellers and the Rothschilds having to much influience with our governent. I believe these people have bad intentions/interests.

Suit yourself. I prefer not to judge people I don't know.
 
Guys hold on a moment here,

Lee5 came here with doubts about 9/11. Some of those doubts have been addressed. Lee5 has taken our responses on board and has accepted that the buildings collapsed due to impact damage and fires, not some sort of demolition.

Lee5 is quite obviously not a "truther" as a "truther" is incapable of doing that. Give them a chance. No one should ever be punished for being ignorant - especially when they're actively trying to seek information.

-Gumboot
 
Guys hold on a moment here,

Lee5 came here with doubts about 9/11. Some of those doubts have been addressed. Lee5 has taken our responses on board and has accepted that the buildings collapsed due to impact damage and fires, not some sort of demolition.

Lee5 is quite obviously not a "truther" as a "truther" is incapable of doing that. Give them a chance. No one should ever be punished for being ignorant - especially when they're actively trying to seek information.

-Gumboot
Agreed!

Lee5;
In the future don't try to tip toe around your questions. If you have a concern come right out with it. No one here should give you grief for honesty.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom