General questions from a new member...

We're at the point where Swing Dangler will now seek to play games with semantics and endless questions in the hope of uncovering a massive government conspiracy.

Really, I don't think he's going to seriously attempt to prove much of anything.

-Sporanox
 
Don't you just hate it when a truther uses a debunker to debunk a fellow debunker? :big:

Not really. Unlike truthers I am delighted to be shown I am wrong. My point still stands, however. Gumboot did not debunk it, he gave much more detail than I could provide.

But go ahead an laugh at your own jokes. As Abby once said, troofers don't care about facts, its all about some kind of pwnage, no matter how desperate, mitpicky and pathetic they have to be to try and get it.
 
You left out Tripod II.


Tripod II was not scheduled to start until the day after 9/11. It also wasn't a military exercise, and finally, it wasn't listed on the webpage he linked to, which is what I was responding to.


----
9/11 Flight Controller: "Is this real world or exercise?"
----
"First thing that went through my mind was, 'Is this part of the exercise? Is this some kind of a screw-up?'" said Air Force Maj. Gen. Larry Arnold, who was at a command center at the Tyndall Air Force Base in Florida. [ABC News]
Sgt. Jeremy W. Powell of North American Aerospace Defense Command's (Norad) Northeast Air Defense Sector (NEADS) in Rome, N.Y., took the first call from Boston Center. He notified NEADS commander Col. Robert K. Marr, Jr., of a possible hijacked airliner, American Airlines Flight 11. "Part of the exercise?" the colonel wondered. No; this is a real-world event, he was told. [Aviation Week]
-----
At 8:40, Deskins noticed senior technician Jeremy Powell waving his hand. Boston Center was on the line, he said. It had a hijacked airplane. "It must be part of the exercise," Deskins thought. At first, everybody did. [Newhouse]

----
As you know through previous testimony from Gen. Eberhart to Congress, ...we were in the middle of a NORAD exercise at that particular time. Which means, that basically our entire staff was focused on being able to do the air operations center mission, which was our job to do. We had just come out of a video teleconference with the NORAD staff and with our folks at that particular time when I was handed note that we had a possible hijacking in Boston Center. And it had come from the Northeast Air Defense Commander Col. Bob Meyer (phonetic) who is commander up there and he had requested that I call him immediately. And I was upstairs in our facility. I immediately went downstairs and picked up the phone, asking on the way to my staff, is this part of the exercise? Because quite honestly and frankly, we do do hijacking scenarios as we go through these exercises from time-to-time. But I realized that it was not – that this was real-life. [9/11 Commission]
------
And Gumboot can debunk you as well Kookbreaker...


So, Kook, you are wrong in your statement that the exercises made little to no difference.


As has been explained repeatedly by people who refuse to listen, there was no confusion in NORAD. After the initial question "exercise or real world?" no one had any doubt about the nature of the threat. Yes, it took a couple of minutes as the information filtered through the various positions, and each person naturally asked if they meant real world or exercise. But once they had been told it was real world, that confusion came abruptly to an end. So technically Kookbreaker is wrong - it did make a difference - a difference of about thirty seconds.

The exercise did not slow NORAD's response - indeed, it enhanced it.

-Gumboot
 
As has been explained repeatedly by people who refuse to listen, there was no confusion in NORAD. After the initial question "exercise or real world?" no one had any doubt about the nature of the threat. Yes, it took a couple of minutes as the information filtered through the various positions, and each person naturally asked if they meant real world or exercise. But once they had been told it was real world, that confusion came abruptly to an end. So technically Kookbreaker is wrong - it did make a difference - a difference of about thirty seconds.

The exercise did not slow NORAD's response - indeed, it enhanced it.

-Gumboot

If D. Berry had a clue or listened, he would realize that all military units exercise repeatedly throughout the year. Virtually all of the units have a real world ongoing mission that continues even during an exercise. I can not recall a single exercise in which that question - "Is this real world or exercise" was not asked. It is very, very common and might involve anything from a traffic accident to an aircraft emergency that is not exercise related.

To continue to bring up this issue repeatedly after being told it's irrelevance is the epitome of an obtuse and ignorant person.

He's wasting your time Gumboot. It's well beyond the obvious that he's just trolling to harass folks here.
 
Last edited:
I can't be arsed (as they say in the nasally-elevated English-speaking countries) to read this thread in its entirety, but I would like to know from the poster of the OP whether I can reasonably expect to be able to purchase T-MAX and TRI-X film in 35mm and 120 for the forseeable future. I am also concerned about being able to procure D-76 developer. I can MacGuyver stop bath and fixers, but I don't know how to improvise developer.

Shortly after I discovered the joys of darkroom chemistry, the friggin computer nerds hijacked photography and gave us digital cameras. Phooey upon them and all their minions who hold their little snapshot boxes at arm's length. HATE HATE!
 
No. That's not what we are saying at all. But feel free to make up what you want to hear in place of what was said.

There were drills being held that day. The thing is, they made little to not difference in the events of that day. Having planes not in Alaska would not make a difference, other drills merely meant that folks were in their seats rather than in some meeting at the HR department.IT MADE LITTLE TO NO DIFFERENCE.

Now, in troother world, drills being held the day of the attack is always considered a sign of the conspiracy. Their little brains think "OMG!!! 365 DAYS A YEAR AND THEY RAN A DRILL ON 9/11 OMG!!!!ITS TEH CONSPIRACY!!!"

But the fact of the matter is that agencies run drills. The run them a lot. Short of actual events, it is all they can do to try and keep things sharp and test protocols. There are many, many agencies and almost all of them run drills of one kind or another. If these two weren't running drills, then the Army would have been, or the Navy, or the City of New York's emergency forces, or the FBI, the BATF.

It is ludicrous, in analyzing the events of that day, to suggest there was anything odd about the drills, or that they had any real effect on events.

Except in trootherland.


You can dismiss the drills as coincidence but to say they had no affect is absurd


They clearly made the air defense confused to the point where they asked "is this real world or exercise"

The drills put extra blips on the screen causing all sorts of confusion and created a situation where there were less fighter jets in the northeastern region of the US

Whether if it was intentional or not, those drills certainly alleviated the attacks.
 
Shortly after I discovered the joys of darkroom chemistry, the friggin computer nerds hijacked photography and gave us digital cameras. Phooey upon them and all their minions who hold their little snapshot boxes at arm's length. HATE HATE!

Amen.

-Gumboot
 
You can dismiss the drills as coincidence but to say they had no affect is absurd


They didn't have no effect. They enhanced response times. Got it? They made NORAD better.


They clearly made the air defense confused to the point where they asked "is this real world or exercise"

The standard question in any real world incident. I've listened to hours upon hours of recordings from NEADS, and beyond that first brief clarification at 08:37, there is absolutely no point in the entire recording at which any one in that room was confused as to whether the attacks were real or an exercise.

It's time to stop your unsupported claims and put up or shut up. Either provide a single scrap of evidence that NORAD staff were confused as to whether the hijackings were real or not, or stop with this nonsense.



The drills put extra blips on the screen causing all sorts of confusion

This is false.


created a situation where there were less fighter jets in the northeastern region of the US

This is also false.


Whether if it was intentional or not, those drills certainly alleviated the attacks.

And this is false.

Got any more false information to spread, or are you done?

-Gumboot
 
You can dismiss the drills as coincidence but to say they had no affect is absurd


They clearly made the air defense confused to the point where they asked "is this real world or exercise"

The drills put extra blips on the screen causing all sorts of confusion and created a situation where there were less fighter jets in the northeastern region of the US

Whether if it was intentional or not, those drills certainly alleviated the attacks.

Please show me, from a reliable MILITARY source, which drills were running WHILE THE 9/11 ATTACKS were ongoing. I don't mean before, or the same day, but during. I don't want some obscure reference from someone who postulates they were ongoing, give me a quote from a general, or a colonel, who was involved in one that day, who says it is the fact.

Then tell me what kind of wargame. Were there aircraft involved, if so how man, where....

Like I said, you gotta bring the REAL PROOF, not some pp article, etc...

TAM:)
 
Ok, good link. I visited this site a few times but left rather quick because I didn't agree with some things.

I think the video of the firefighter is the best piece of evidence to me so far that the building was doomed.

Thanks.

I think you just admitted that you ignore that with which you do not agree, no?
 
Alright let's take a look at the list:

Operation Northern Vigilance
As the name suggests, this was not a war game or exercise, but an operation. Since the early days of the cold war, it was standard protocol if either side conducted a large scale exercise, for the other side to shadow the exercise with an operation. This was done to avoid being caught by a surprise attack concealed as an exercise.

Northern Vigilance was in response to a large scale Russian long-range bomber exercise being conducted in northern Siberia. In order to monitor the exercise units stationed in Canada, Alaska, and Iceland were raised to operational status. This operation did not affect the seven Contiguous USA Alert Stations.


Global Guardian/Vigilant Guardian
Once a year the US military components responsible for repelling a full scale nuclear attack conduct a major Command Post Exercise called "Guardian". Components include US Strategic Command (Global), NORAD (Vigilant), and US Space Command (Apollo).

Vigilant Guardian was the only aspect of this exercise which involved air defense assets. It's what's called a "Vigilant Overview" exercise. According to NORAD Order 11-33 "Code Words, Nicknames, and Exercise terms", "Vigilant" denotes a NORAD-wide CPX or Command Post Exercise. This means an exercise that involves operations centre staff at computer and radar terminals, but not operational units such as fighter squadrons. Every NORAD command centre has two independent computer systems so that one can be maintaining operational status while the other is used to run system checks and for exercises. This insures that training does not interfere with NORAD's day-to-day operations, and avoids any confusion between exercises and real-world events.

"Overview" is the nickname for a specific exercise type, from a list of NORAD exercise nicknames:

ANGEL - Sector-coordinated Unit Level FIX (ROCC/SOCC Controlled Intercepts)
ARIZONA - Cheyenne Mountain Air Force Base Internal System Training Mission (STM)
BRAVE - Region-sponsored System FIX
CHIEF - JCS-approved, CINCNORAD-sponsored FIX
DOLLY - HQ NORAD Battle Staff Exercise
GAIN - Region/sector-sponsored Internal ROCC/SOCC CPX
GOLD - Sector-coordinated Unit Level FIX (autonomous intercept procedures)
INDIAN - Region-sponsored System CPX
KEYNOTE - Region-coordinated, Sector-sponsored FIX
LEADER - Recall of Airborne Forces (FIX)
LIBEL - Region-coordinated, Sector-sponsored System CPX
MUTE - NORAD IG Evaluation
OVERVIEW - JCS-approved, CINCNORAD-sponsored CPX
PIPE - Region-sponsored Nuclear, Biological, Chemical (NBC) Warning and Reporting System (WRS) Training Exercise
RICE - SOCC-sponsored Internal CPX (Battle Staff/BSSC/Crew training)
SPADE - Region/sector No-Notice AST
UNION - Cheyenne Mountain Air Force Base SPACC Training
VANTAGE - Sector-coordinated/scheduled Interoperability FIX with US Navy Units
VIRGO - Special Exercise or Test (FIX)
WARRIOR - JCS-approved, CINCNORAD-sponsored FIX
YELL - FE14A Exercise

As we can see "Overview" is a Joint Chiefs of Staff-approved, Commander in Chief NORAD-sponsored Command Post Exercise.

Now, Vigilant Guardian started on Monday 10th September, and was to continue through the week. However each day the exercise began at 0900hrs. When the first call came in to NEADS about the hijacking, staff were mingling about or in a pre-exercise briefing in the Battle Cab. Major Nasypany - the Mission Crew Commander, for example, was getting coffee. The ID Technicians were talking about furniture.

Of course that exercise never started, because 23 minutes before it was scheduled to start the call came from Boston ARTCC about a hijacking in progress. The exercise was quickly called off and stations were manned to respond to the hijacking.

What's most important to note is normally the Air Defense Sector, Regional HQ, and NORAD HQ is manned by a skeleton crew. In the event of a major crisis it can take several hours to bring in all of the necessary staff (don't forget most of the staff who manned NORAD command centres were only part time military personnel - they had regular jobs as well).

But because Vigilant Guardian was about to start, NEADS was fully staffed, CONUS Region was fully staffed, and Cheyenne Mountain was fully staffed. This allowed NORAD to respond much more rapidly to the situation that they would have been able to normally.


VIGILANT WARRIOR
We have only Richard Clarke's recollection of an off hand comment made by Richard Myers to reference this particular "exercise". But Myers, when directly asked about it, claimed NORAD was only involved in the CPX I've discussed above. Clarke postulates that Vigilant Warrior was a life-fly (field exercise) element of Vigilant Guardian.

There's some problems with this theory. As we already know, "Vigilant" is reserved for NORAD-wide Command Post Exercises. But from the list I posted we can see that "Warrior" is a Joint Chiefs of Staff-approved, Command-in-Chief NORAD-sponsored Field Exercise. So "Vigilant" and "Warrior" can't go together. In fact the correct first word is "Amalgam" which denotes a NORAD-wide Field Exercise. Amalgam Warrior is NORAD's major field exercise, and involves many operational units.

Amalgam Warrior is held twice a year - in the Spring for the West Coast and in the Fall for the East Coast. Amalgam Warrior was held in June 2001, with the second typically scheduled in October.


NRO Drill
The NRO is entirely independent of NORAD, providing maintainence and operation of the USA's surveillance satellites. On 9/11 their head office was conducting a local evacuation exercise. This had no bearing on NRO operational sites, and as NRO does not interact directly with NORAD, had no bearing on NORAD response times on 9/11. Once the attacks started the exercise was called off and most staff were sent home (a testiment to how little their task had to do with air defense).

Okay. Got any more?

-Gumboot

Which one of those is Amalgam Virgo?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amalgam_Virgo

Too bad that the whitewashopedia says that this was a "cruise missile" drill, when in fact Gen. McKinley himself admitted that they also drilled this for hijacked planes.

http://www.9-11commission.gov/archive/hearing2/9-11Commission_Hearing_2003-05-23.htm
 
Last edited:
Guess what, Stickman. The world isn't the same. It changed greatly as of 8:50am, Sept 11-2001

That's right, and now we're in this Glorious War on Terror, killing brown people, and imprisoning dissidents, while brownshirts are turning the blind eye to the constant revelations of overwhelming corruption before, on and after 9/11.
 
That's right, and now we're in this Glorious War on Terror, killing brown people, and imprisoning dissidents, while brownshirts are turning the blind eye to the constant revelations of overwhelming corruption before, on and after 9/11.
No facts yet? Darn, you are still batting zero.
 
Which one of those is Amalgam Virgo?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amalgam_Virgo

Too bad that the whitewashopedia says that this was a "cruise missile" drill, when in fact Gen. McKinley himself admitted that they also drilled this for hijacked planes.

http://www.9-11commission.gov/archive/hearing2/9-11Commission_Hearing_2003-05-23.htm


What point are you making here, Zlaya? Going by the second link you provided, these are 2 different operations. Amalgam Virgo 01 was the cruise missile exercise:

MR. SCOTT: Yes, sir. Specifically Operation Amalgam Virgo, which I was involved in before I retired, was a scenario using a Third World united -- not united -- uninhabited aerial vehicle launched off a rogue freighter in the Gulf of Mexico. General Arnold can back me up -- at the time one of our greatest concerns was the proliferation of cruise missile technology and the ability for terrorist groups to get that technology, get it close enough to our shores to launch it. In fact, this exercise -- in this exercise we used actual drone -- NQM-107 drones, which are about the size of a cruise missile, to exercise our fighters and our radars in a Gulf of Mexico scenario.

MR. BEN-VENISTE: You are referring to Amalgam 01, are you not?

MR. SCOTT: Yes, sir, Amalgam 01.


Amalgam Virgo 02 was in the planning stages on 9/11:

GEN. MCKINLEY: Amalgam Virgo in general, 02, was an exercise created to focus on peacetime and contingency NORAD missions. One of the peacetime scenarios that is and has been a NORAD mission for years is support to other government departments. Within this mission falls hijackings. Creativity of the designer aside, prior to 9/11, hijack motivations were based on political objectives -- i.e., asylum or release of captured prisoners or political figures. Threats of killing hostages or crashing were left to the script writers to invoke creativity and broaden the required response for players.


How are these relevant to what happened on 9/11?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom