Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I wonder how long Israel will last.

With 1.4 billion Muslims getting angry and even more angry by the day, with Iran getting nukes and the Islamic State expanding..
 
You cannot understand the current events without the context. Pretending that history started yesterday (or in this case with the killing of the three teenagers) is not a way to seriously digest the situation.

If you want to include all of recent history, we could include Arabs being driven off their land by Zionist forces on several occasions.
The term for that is ethnic cleansing. Not genocide.
We apply a different term, because it is a different thing.
 
If you want to include all of recent history, we could include Arabs being driven off their land by Zionist forces on several occasions.
The term for that is ethnic cleansing. Not genocide.
We apply a different term, because it is a different thing.

considering that Ethic Cleansing (as well as its lesser known cousin Kebab Removal) were serbian euphemisms for genocide, that doesn't work well.
 
One thing I don't get. Assad is still massacring Syrians, ISIS are operating genocidal policies, Ukraine is in civil war, likewise with Colombia, yet ISRAEL is marked out as a naziesque horror?
 
One thing I don't get. Assad is still massacring Syrians, ISIS are operating genocidal policies, Ukraine is in civil war, likewise with Colombia, yet ISRAEL is marked out as a naziesque horror?

Well, it's a matter of identifying the allies of Russia and marking everyone else as a Nazi. That's why - for instance - the actual fascist Assad (the neo-Baathism is sort of an amalgamation of extreme left and extreme right, and has been labeled Arab fascism) is not accused of being a Nazi or fascist, while the legitimate Kiev government of Ukraine is, despite there being just as many, if not more, fascists fighting on the pro-Russian side.

Why supporting allies of Russia is so important to some people, I couldn't tell you. My guess is severe stupidity.
 
One thing I don't get. Assad is still massacring Syrians, ISIS are operating genocidal policies, Ukraine is in civil war, likewise with Colombia, yet ISRAEL is marked out as a naziesque horror?

I looked up the Syrian casualty figures the other day. In a 3 year war:
The death toll in Syria's three-year conflict has climbed past 160,000, an activist group said...

Civilians comprised about a third, or 53,978, of the Observatory's new toll. Those deaths include 8,607 children and 5,586 women.

But no Jews to blame so who cares.
 
At least a) to c) are fulfilled. Genocide is the correct term, just like "concentration camp" for Gaza and increasingly the West Bank, and "Apartheid state" or "colonial settler state" for Israel.

Not really, unless you're twisting things quite a bit and stretching "part" well beyond the normal usage for the term.

You cannot understand the current events without the context. Pretending that history started yesterday (or in this case with the killing of the three teenagers) is not a way to seriously digest the situation.

Indeed. And both in context and out of context, "genocide" doesn't even remotely apply, much as Palestinians have frequently proclaimed that they would commit genocide against the Israelis if they could.

For contrast: I believe the total death toll of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict (1948-present) is somewhere around 20.000

It is a slow-burning, low casualty conflict. Accusations of genocide not withstanding.

Also for context, ISIS has killed more than 5500 civilians so far this year. This can make one mildly curious about the people in this thread who condemn the killing of civilians when it happens at Israel's hands it for any reason and condemn them horribly... and then turn around and defend ISIS and happily fantasize about them overrunning Israel.
 
Genocide?

More than 133,000 people were killed, the majority of which civilians, in attacks by forces loyal to Syrian President Bashar al-Assad against areas held by opposition forces since the beginning of the conflict in March 2011, according to a London-based rights group.
 
CE is breaking out the "You're a Jew" accusations, I see. At least she's showing her racism plainly.
 
I looked up the Syrian casualty figures the other day. In a 3 year war:


Good job. Usually the numbers are quoted without detailing who the dead are, at least they used to be and when the details came, most outlets stopped quoting them. Because they don't fit the narrative:

SOHR via HuffPo said:
The uprising also has killed 26,858 rebel fighters and 37,685 Syrian soldiers, the Observatory said. It said 25,147 pro-government fighters also have died on the battlefield, including 438 Hezbollah militants, and 1,224 Shiite foreign fighters and Palestinian militants.
 
Last edited:
CE is breaking out the "You're a Jew" accusations, I see. At least she's showing her racism plainly.

Antisemitism has infected the left for decades now. It's hard to find someone on the hard left who isn't antisemitic.
 
Antisemitism has infected the left for decades now. It's hard to find someone on the hard left who isn't antisemitic.

I don't think it is anti-Semitism.

More a case of letting white people* who are in a land dispute with brown people atone for the colonial crimes of European white people. Or something.





*70% of these white people are actually brown people
 
There is an odious segment of the conspiratorial left that has embraced anti-Jewish racism (thinly veiled, usually), especially during the last two decades.
 
I keep checking this thread but it has massively degenerated (not that it was ever great) thanks to people like CE, JG and KS who frankly should be embarrassed by their level of debate (and the other side including me have their share of blame for not simply using the ignore function on what is basically trolling)

This is the problem I have with this debate, I'm sure Israel does its share of bad and questionable **** like any other nation made up of human beings, but those on the anti-Israel side tend to be so ridiculous in their argumentation and wilful in their ignorance of the history and context (and I consider my knowledge shallow at best) that it just makes me disgusted with their side and more pro-Israeli. Maybe some of the less extreme pro-Israeli's in this thread could, for my benefit sum up the things they thing are most 'wrong' done by Israel and what changes to its current policy Israel should make

also while scouring the internet following this debate I hadn't come across this quote before but I love it:

http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/m/martinluth101536.html
 
Last edited:
Anyone who claims that anti-Zionist (using this term broadly for criticism of Israel) sentiments have nothing to do with antisemitism are in denial or deluded. It's quite clear that they are connected, if you investigate the development of attitudes (for anyone fluent in Swedish, this is an interesting article about the situation in Germany: http://skma.se/blogg/2014/06/antise...kland-problem-stridsfragor-och-laroprocesser/ about Peter Ullrich's research). Antisemitic rhetoric is prevalent in anti-Zionist arguments, conspiracy theories abound, and I suspect antisemitism is at least part of the reason for why the conflict is such a hot topic.

That's not to say all or most anti-Zionists are antisemites, but they may be doing the antisemites quite a favour.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom