Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Very disturbing, yes. What's IDF's rationale for using these weapons?

I suspect lack of penetration and thus reduction of colateral damage.
They will absolutely shred the target you aim them at, but the people on the other side of the wall should be safe.
Also a good way to stop an infantry rush at your tank (not that I know these happen now, but still).

Machineguns would work as well, but those penetrate more.
 
Last edited:
And this makes Israel, the US and all the people who do not want to see this point guilty of war crimes

Everyone who disagrees with your bigoted views are guilty of war crimes? That's a good one. You must be the king of war crimes.
 
1. LETTER FROM YASSER ARAFAT TO PRIME MINISTER RABIN:

September 9, 1993

Yitzhak Rabin
Prime Minister of Israel

Mr. Prime Minister,

The signing of the Declaration of Principles marks a new era in the history of the Middle East. In firm conviction thereof, I would like to confirm the following PLO commitments:

The PLO recognizes the right of the State of Israel to exist in peace and security.

- See more at: http://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/36917473237100E285257028006C0BC5#sthash.QN2f4bc0.dpuf

Isreal could have replied to Arafat: "Yes, we accept this agreement. We also recognize the State of Palestine based on the 1967 borders"

Brazil did
http://www.ndtv.com/article/world/brazil-recognises-palestinian-state-on-1967-borders-70566

Many other countries did
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_recognition_of_the_State_of_Palestine

But Israel do not
The Israeli government has accepted in general the idea that a Palestinian state is to be established, but has refused to accept the 1967 borders either as compulsory or as a basis for final border negotiations, due to security concerns. Israeli military experts have argued that the 1967 borders are strategically indefensiblehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_recognition_of_the_State_of_Palestine

This is the point of discussion
Nothing, nor Hamas, nor anyone else, would prevent Israel to recognize Palestine on 1967 borders

And this makes Israel, the US and all the people who do not want to see this point guilty of war crimes

You seem to be new to the idea of negotiations.

This means that Israel has some issues with those borders. Those can be alleviated in several different means. You negotiate different borders which are acceptable to both sides. You negotiate an other solution which would make these borders in question more defensible in the eyes of Israel.
And those are only two options off the top of my head, that I can think of.

That is what negotiations mean. giving and taking by both parties which result in an end situation acceptable to both.
 
Last edited:
Very disturbing, yes. What's IDF's rationale for using these weapons?

The IDF uses these weapons because they maximize civilian casualties and strike terror into the Palestinian populace. Of course, the IDF only uses these weapons when no one is looking...but sometimes ya' catch them doing it.

Well...I hear the IDF finally went up against someone who could fight back and despite their tanks, death drones, killer helicopters and fighter jets they lost 20+ guys. What the hell kind of soldiers does the IDF have nowadays...or is the "Donkey Bomb" really that effective? Yeah...I can just imagine IDF Generals right now talking to the heads of the American Defense-Industrial Complex about how to counter the mighty "Donkey Bomb"

Is it no wonder Hezbollah spanked the IDF in 2006? I mean, considering how inept the IDF has become, it does not surprise me that any well-trained force with adequate weapons could stoop it....even though they were greatly outnumbered. And that's just what Hezbollah did. But...Never fear. The IDF can always "Showboat" against the trapped Palestinians in order to look good.

Gawd...the IDF are an arrogant bunch of pricks who wouldn't last 5 minutes on an Asian or European battlefield. Fricken' Mama's Boys with Uzis shooting up a bunch of encircled peasants and claiming to be Ultimate Zionist Warriors! I'd like to ship a few platoons of these ********* to the Ukraine to get a lesson in humility. Better yet...let's send a few of the to Vietnam - that would knock cockiness right out of them!
 
I am generally pro-Israeli, but even I cannot explain why they're using flechettes. Clearly the current Israeli administration doesn't give a crap about peace or not hurting civilians. Disgusting.

Your own source contradicts your hysterical claims. Look at the picture of the flechettes stuck in the wall. Notice something about that photo? They're stuck in the wall! They don't penetrate! The photo is itself proof that these munitions do exactly the opposite of what you claim: they make it safer for civilians.
 
The IDF uses these weapons because they maximize civilian casualties and strike terror into the Palestinian populace.

Except, of course, there are no masses of civilian casualties from these weapons. There's reports of one woman injured from six shells fired. That's hardly maximized civilian casualties, is it?
 
Very disturbing, yes. What's IDF's rationale for using these weapons?

Anti-personnell.

The advantage of flechette over conventional HE is that flechette darts do not penetrate building materials, nor will they cause structural damage to buildings. Essentially if you are looking to minimize civilian casualties flechette rounds are a better choice:

a. there is no explosive overpressure;
b. persons behind walls are very unlikely to be hit;
c. They will no cause structural to buildings.

Of course, if a person is hit by a flechette round the wounds are frankly, really nasty to look at, but then again so are wounds caused by metal fragments from HE rounds, or chunks of the building you are hiding behind.

The rounds are legal under the Hague Conventions as the projectiles do not fragment or expand on impact to increase the severity of the wound.
 
Of course, if a person is hit by a flechette round the wounds are frankly, really nasty to look at, but then again so are wounds caused by metal fragments from HE rounds, or chunks of the building you are hiding behind.

If you get hit by a tank round of pretty much any kind, you're gonna have a bad day.
 
Anti-personnell.

The advantage of flechette over conventional HE is that flechette darts do not penetrate building materials, nor will they cause structural damage to buildings. Essentially if you are looking to minimize civilian casualties flechette rounds are a better choice:

a. there is no explosive overpressure;
b. persons behind walls are very unlikely to be hit;
c. They will no cause structural to buildings.

Of course, if a person is hit by a flechette round the wounds are frankly, really nasty to look at, but then again so are wounds caused by metal fragments from HE rounds, or chunks of the building you are hiding behind.

The rounds are legal under the Hague Conventions as the projectiles do not fragment or expand on impact to increase the severity of the wound.

And 5.56mm bullets can do nasty looking things as well.
I can understand the protest against some weapons, but flechetts are not one of them.
 
Flechettes are obviously a good choice of weapon for the Israelis.. The comments by posters who are obviously ignorant are based on biased political views as opposed to weapons effects. Another advantage of flechettes is that they are a pin point weapon that only go in one direction (forward trajectory) as opposed to anything with HE which has a blast radius in all directions.

We used them in South East Asia for several purposes, i.e. troops in the open and on Search and Rescue (SAR) missions. Escort aircraft on SAR nearly always carried flechette rockets to prevent the bad guys from coming to the survivor on the ground without endangering the survivor.
 
Yeah, the "Independent" story on Flechetts as a hit piece on Israel, pure and simple.
It also displays a true ignorance of the weapon and how it is used, but I am used to that from the mainstream media. I am not one of these people who hate the mainstream media but,god, they get it wrong so often when discussing military affairs. And I talking simple technical ignorance here. Sometimes it is "deliberte ignorance" to make a political point, but a lot of the time it is "honest" ignorance and just plain sloppiness.
 
Last edited:
You seem to be new to the idea of negotiations.

This means that Israel has some issues with those borders. Those can be alleviated in several different means. You negotiate different borders which are acceptable to both sides. You negotiate an other solution which would make these borders in question more defensible in the eyes of Israel.
And those are only two options off the top of my head, that I can think of.

That is what negotiations mean. giving and taking by both parties which result in an end situation acceptable to both.

You seem even newer than me at negotiations
When one side (the Palestinian) has a gun pointed at their heads and another side wants basically all the land and the Palestinians to migrate somewhere else, possibly without making too much fuss
Palestinians has suffered and endured many occupations, the Ottomans, etc.
They were all defeated
The Jews will be defeated as well
 
The IDF uses these weapons because they maximize civilian casualties and strike terror into the Palestinian populace. Of course, the IDF only uses these weapons when no one is looking...but sometimes ya' catch them doing it.

Well...I hear the IDF finally went up against someone who could fight back and despite their tanks, death drones, killer helicopters and fighter jets they lost 20+ guys. What the hell kind of soldiers does the IDF have nowadays...or is the "Donkey Bomb" really that effective? Yeah...I can just imagine IDF Generals right now talking to the heads of the American Defense-Industrial Complex about how to counter the mighty "Donkey Bomb"

Is it no wonder Hezbollah spanked the IDF in 2006? I mean, considering how inept the IDF has become, it does not surprise me that any well-trained force with adequate weapons could stoop it....even though they were greatly outnumbered. And that's just what Hezbollah did. But...Never fear. The IDF can always "Showboat" against the trapped Palestinians in order to look good.

Gawd...the IDF are an arrogant bunch of pricks who wouldn't last 5 minutes on an Asian or European battlefield. Fricken' Mama's Boys with Uzis shooting up a bunch of encircled peasants and claiming to be Ultimate Zionist Warriors! I'd like to ship a few platoons of these ********* to the Ukraine to get a lesson in humility. Better yet...let's send a few of the to Vietnam - that would knock cockiness right out of them!

So, You're basically a troll, then?
 
Yeah...like this piece where a Palestinian Civilian is shown being brutally murdered by an Israeli Sniper.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sBakqLUBWP0&bpctr=1406065383

Yeah...Zionism!

Regardless of what you may believe, Israel is not all "goodness and light". The Israelis are a hard-hearted bunch of land thieves and killers.

All the marks of a classic Pallywood movie. No actual blood on either the supposed murder victim or the guy on the stretcher at the beginning. This isn't evidence of anything.
 
Flechettes are obviously a good choice of weapon for the Israelis.. The comments by posters who are obviously ignorant are based on biased political views as opposed to weapons effects.
Well... some of us suffer from biased news media that refuses to give us an objective picture, as is the case here in Norway. Then again, I get the feeling you weren't referring to me;).
 
Last edited:
So, You're basically a troll, then?

Well given the fact that he has offered nothing but over the top rants, lots of snark,and total ignorance of the Palestinian/Israeli situation in general and Military factors in particular,I would say the choice lies between Troll and Brainless Fanatic.

As to his latest post wanting to send the Israeli Army to be sent to the Ukraine to be taught a lesson,I think the Isrealis would go through the Ukrainian Seperatists like a hot knife through butter.
 
Well... some of us suffer from biased news media that refuses to give us an objective picture, as is the case here in Norway. Then again, I get the feeling you weren't referring to me;).

No, not at all. Flechetts are simply a sharpened finishing nail that is flattened at the rear to stabilize the trajectory. They are like a hive of bees when in flight. They are only effective against people in the open. They will not penetrate virtually any sort of cover at all. Of course a hit is gory, but any HE weapon is worse. It is an excellent choice of weapon by the Israelis to minimize collateral damage. I have fired them from a rocket and have seen them fired from the same, many times over.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom